TopConsumerReviews.com
      October 22, 2017

Home  >  Seafood  >  Detailed Reviews

Best

Seafood Stores

  1. Catalina Offshore
  2. The Crab Place
  3. All Fresh Seafood
  4. Hancock Gourmet
  5. Chesapeake Bay
  6. Lobsters Online

Your Information Is Secure
Culinary Delights: 220 Recipes Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Baby Cribs

Credit Card Consolidation

Graduation Invitations

Gutter Guards

Hair Care Products

Installment Loans

Makeup

Reverse Mortgages

Tickets

Web Hosting

 

 

 

 

 

Lose Weight Today

 

 

 

 

Get Out Of Debt Today With Natinoal Debt Relief!

 

 

 

 

Protect Your Home with FrontPoint Security Today!

 

 

 

 

Get Your Next Gift Basket at Gift Tree Today!

 

 

 

 

Make Your Next Jewelry Purchase at Blue Nile!

 

 

 

 

Get Your Contact Lenses At Coast Contacts Today!

 

 

 

 

Protect Your Loved Ones With LifeStation Today!

Disclosure: We pay our reviewers for their reviews. We are not compensated by companies for their reviews, but we are compensated for links and advertisements on our website. Click here for details.

Seafood Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Get Your Seafood at Legal Seafoods Today! Many people love the idea of fresh seafood delivered right to their door and ready to cook. Unfortunately for most people, finding quality seafood isn't easy. The few grocery stores that offer fresh seafood don't have much variety, and often charge high prices for what they do carry.

However, a growing number of people have found fresh seafood - including lobster, fish, shrimp, oysters, and more - from online seafood stores. With the internet, fresh seafood is only one click away from anyone wanting the best seafood delivered direct to their doorstep. Plus, many of these seafood stores offer excellent gift packages that are sure to impress seafood lovers.

Continue reading below reviews

2017

Seafood Reviews

5 stars
Legal Seafoods

LEGAL SEAFOODS Visit Site

Gift Options:

Seafood selections, gourmet meals, gift cards

TopConsumerReviews.com Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Legal Sea Foods began in 1950 when George Berkowitz opened a fish market in Cambridge, Massachusetts. The business expanded in 1968 when the family opened their first seafood restaurant, right next store to the fish market. The early success of the restaurant led to further expansion and today has grown to several seafood restaurants, especially strong along the Eastern Seaboard.

The same family still owns the business and maintains that they are a fish company in the restaurant business. If you've ever eaten at a Legal Sea Foods restaurant, you know that delicious lobster, shrimp, fish and more is the only thing you'll find on your plate. Their seafood delivery business delivers the same top quality seafood to their online customers.

We found that Legal Sea Foods consistently received high praise from customers of their online seafood store. They also make seafood gift giving easy with several gift options ranging in price. You can purchase a wonderful box of seafood for your family, friend or business acquaintance - or, a gourmet gift combo including seafood and steak, or a gift certificate of your choosing. The website makes it easy to find exactly what you're looking for from start to finish.

When comparing prices between the Legal Sea Foods selection of shrimp, lobster, oysters and more, we found that they fall in the middle of the range. We were encouraged that you could find such wonderful, high quality seafoodat such affordable prices. We believe that has to do with the high quantity of seafood they purchase, and that they're able to pass some of those savings on to their customers. Most seafood orders are sent the next day in order to maintain freshness. Lobsters arrive live if desired, and are ready for boiling that night.

Legal Sea Foods provides excellent, customer friendly service. They offer a satisfaction guarantee should something go wrong with the order. They do their best to make the purchase right and maintain a satisfied customer.

Legal Sea Foods exceeded our expectations in selection, price and service. Because of their professional approach to delivering quality seafood at such affordable prices, Legal Sea Foods has earned our highest rating.

Visit Site

4.5 stars
Catalina Offshore Products

CATALINA OFFSHORE PRODUCTS Visit Site

Gift Options:

Gift cards, sushi samplers, unique items, seafood of the month club

After 25 years in business Catalina Offshore Products is one of the largest seafood import and export companies in California. The original founders of the company still oversee the day to day operations to maintain the level of quality and customer service that allowed them to grow so successfully.

Seafood selections come directly from reputable fishermen who catch seafood throughout the waters of Southern California and Baja California. Catalina Offshore Products maintain strict handling procedures to preserve the freshness and quality of the products they deliver. Most fishing is done with hand lines to save the environment and maintain the earths natural resources. Catalina Offshore Products offers a no frills website but it's packed with a lot of information including recipes, sushi making kits, vivid pictures, and more.

For those looking for fresh quality seafood at a great price, Catalina Offshore Products is the place to shop. You can enjoy lower priced selections of seafood such as live lobsters, sushi meat, fresh fish, and shrimp. You can also anticipate lower shipping costs at Catalina Offshore Products. While the selection and variety are a little lower, they hit the mark with value for your dollar. We think lower priced fresh quality seafood is exactly what many customers are looking for.

In the event you aren't happy with your purchase as a result of delivery delays or an error by the company, Catalina Offshore Products will refund your money back, or you can save it as a credit on any future orders.

Along with their seafood, Catalina Offshore Products also offers some unique gift ideas. In addition to sushi samplers and gift cards, they even offer a seafood of the month club for that seafood lover in your life.

For those looking for sushi, fish, or value-oriented seafood selections, Catalina Offshore Products is a great place to start. Their products are very affordable, and we appreciated their attention to the customer. They earn high marks for offering quality seafood at very affordable prices.

Visit Site

4 stars
The Crab Place

THE CRAB PLACE Visit Site

Gift Options:

Gift cards, gift messages allowed on any purchases

The Crab Place motto pretty much sums it up "Maryland Seafood Delivered from our dock to your door." Greg Cain started The Crab Place in 1997 in Crisfield, Maryland. As the business grew more family members and others joined the team. The company began by selling and shipping fresh Maryland crab caught daily by local watermen and now offers a comprehensive seafood delivery website.

Despite the name, The Crab Place provides a plethora of fresh seafood options including live lobster, oysters, fresh fish, shrimp, breaded seafood and several crab varieties. We really liked the look of the website , the ease of use, the clear attractive pictures and the easy search maneuverability.

If you're looking for a gift at The Crab Place they mainly offer gift cards but you are easily able to make any selection and the check out process allows you to include a gift message.

The Crab Place says they offer the guaranteed lowest price on the web, when we compared their prices to several competitors we found they were a little on the high end. However, if you join their yearly VIP club for $49.00 the shipping costs drop in half making your total cost lower priced than most.

In the event you aren't satisfied as a result of product spoilage or a high mortality rate on live crabs, upon the shipments arrival, The Crab Place will replace free of charge.

In the end we really enjoyed the website including the layout, professionalism, pictures, check out process and ease in finding the information we were looking for. If live crabs are what you are after The Crab Place should probably be your first choice. But, we felt that without the VIP membership the prices were a little steep.

Visit Site

3.5 stars
All Fersh Seafood

ALL FRESH SEAFOOD Visit Site

Gift Options:

Gift cards, gift baskets, gift message with any selection

All Fresh Seafood Inc. had been in the wholesale fresh seafood business for 20 years. Located in New York the company services nearly 400 restaurants in the area. All Fresh Seafood offers an extensive line of seafood including,oysters, live lobsters, shrimp, whole fish, caviar, prepared meals and much more.

Despite the positive reputation and extensive seafood selection we were a little turned off by the website. The product pictures were unappetizing at times and navigating through the website was awkward at best. Certain search product links were only available from the home page.

If you are looking for a gift All Fresh Seafood has a great list of gifts including gift cards, gift baskets, caviar and more. You may choose a gift message on any selection at All Fresh Seafood.

From our comparison, we found the prices to be generally middle of the road. Shipping was fairly priced and prices came in overall very fair for the size and weight of the products.

The return policy at All Fresh Seafood is rather straightforward. In the event you aren't satisfied with you order you must call within 24 hours of delivery. If All Fresh Seafood sees it as a valid issue they will replace or refund your purchase upon your choosing.

Once you get over the unappetizing pictures and navigational issues of the website you'll find one of the most extensive lines of fresh seafood available. Prices and shipping are fair and many gift giving options are available to meet anyone's needs.

Visit Site

3.5 stars
Hancock Gourmet Lobster Co

HANCOCK GOURMET LOBSTER CO Visit Site

Gift Options:

Gift certificates, samplers, combo dinners, gift tag with any purchase

Hancock Gourmet Lobster Company was founded by Cal Hancock in 2000 on the premise to make lobster more accessible for eating at home. Located in Maine the company creates gourmet Maine lobster and seafood products that are all-natural without preservatives.

Outside of live lobster product, most of the food at Hancock are prepared meals. Those include award willing lobster macaroni and cheese, New England clambake, oyster stew and lobster pot pies. They also offer crab cakes and lobster hors d'oeuvre for party appetizers, soups, lobster tails, desserts and more. The website offers a nice layout with great pictures of the products and an easy check out process. If you are looking for fresh raw seafood you will find very little at Hancock's but if you are looking for delicious prepared seafood items this is a great place to shop.

Gift giving is a focus at Hancock Gourmet Lobster Co and they offer fun items like dinners for two, sampler platters, gift bags, lobster flavored dog treats and more. You may also choose a gift card and a gift message may be sent with any order.

Most of this prepared food is not inexpensive and adds up especially if you are feeding several guests. The product and shipping prices are inline with other providers of prepared seafood products and didn't stand out either way. The fact that they use lobster in many of their dishes pushes up the prices so be prepared to bring your wallet when shopping.

In the event that something goes wrong with your order Hancock takes a pretty firm stance that they don't accept returns but will definitely discuss the situation with you.

Hancock Gourmet Lobster Company is a great place to shop for delicious prepared seafood appetizers, meals and more. They've received positive press for their delicious food and have appeared on Oprah and in several magazines. But, bring your big credit card with you and be prepared to shop elsewhere if you'[re looking for fresh raw seafood - that's not their specialty.

Visit Site

3 stars
Chesapeake Bay Crabcakes

CHESAPEAKE BAY CRABCAKES Visit Site

Gift Options:

Gift tag with any purchase

Chesapeake Bay Crab Cakes specializes in Crab Cakes and other prepared seafood appetizers, biscuits, soups, entrees and more. Their company is headquartered out of Baltimore Maryland. You will find limited uncooked seafood here and no live lobsters, fresh fish or shrimp. Most of the food is heat and serve and is geared well for those looking to entertain at home but without the skill and hassle necessary to make from scratch.

If you love crab cakes Chesapeake Bay Crab Cakes has all sizes and varieties for appetizers and meals or somewhere in between. Ingredients in their specialty cakes includes premium jumbo lump crabmeat that is handpicked and a secret recipe of herbs, spices and more. Cakes are then flash frozen to preserve the taste and flavor. We found reviews of very happy crab cake customers along with those that were less impressed - the reviews were mixed overall.

If you're in the market for a seafood gift, Chesapeake Bay Crab Cakes allows you to pick out any item and attach a gift message - they do not have a special line of items dedicated for gift giving. But, we liked the idea of sending a nice gift of prepared seafood to someone special.

Prices on much of the products was generally more expensive than raw seafood as it's prepared by a chef and ready for baking. In comparing the cost of crab cakes to other stores we found them generally in the mid range for pricing.

In the event you aren't happy with your purchase as a result of issues in transit, Chesapeake Bay Crab Company will replace your product or refund if the package arrives late, thawed, or damaged in any way.

Overall, we felt that Chesapeake Bay Crab Company was not the company for most looking for fresh seafood. With mixed reviews on the taste of their prepared food we left feeling like a higher ranked seafood provider was probably a better option for most.

Visit Site

2.5 stars
Lobsters Online

LOBSTERS ONLINE Visit Site

Gift Options:

Gift certificates available and a gift tag with any purchase.

Lobsters Online has been in business since 1997. Located in Cape Cod Maine Lobsters Online offers Live lobsters a nice selection of fresh fish, crab, shrimp, and prepared foods.

The Lobsters Online website is geared for the lobster lover with interesting information about the history behind these crustaceans and how to cook and eat a lobster properly. We found navigating Lobsters-Online easy to maneuver for most of the products and information we were looking for.

Unfortunately, when looking for other customers comments and experience with this company we found several disappointed with the size of the lobsters and unresolved shipping issues. The customer service department came up several times as a downside to this company.

The prices are right at Lobsters Online and were some of the cheapest we could find. Customers also receive a 5% discount with any purchase over $100.

If you are looking for a gift you will find seafood combo meals and gift certificates. A gift tag is available with any purchase at Lobsters Online.

We were excited about the products and prices at this company but hesitate in our confidence with them due to unfavorable reviews numerous customers reported.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Online seafood stores offer an excellent selection of the freshest and finest seafood. For those looking to buy seafood for themselves or as gift they should consider the following before making a purchase:

  • Selection. Can you anticipate a wide variety of fresh seafood, or does the company cater toward one particular seafood product? Do they offer seafood gift giving options?
  • Cost. Compared to the competition, how does the price and quality of the seafood compare?
  • Satisfaction Guarantee. If something goes wrong with your seafood delivery, will the company make every effort to satisfy you?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best seafood companies available today. We hope these reviews help you find the right seafood that you're looking for!

Great Ogeechee Seafood Festival draws thousands

Before you reached the entrance gate to the Great Ogeechee Seafood Festival in Richmond Hill's J.F. Gregory Park Saturday afternoon, the aroma of frying shrimp and other seafood filled the air. The three-day south Bryan County event drew thousands over ...

Published:  Sat, 21 Oct 2017 19:51:00 GMT



Learn details of the frozen fish & seafood market

Frozen fish and seafood are packaged food items that are prepared by freezing the foods to preserve them from the time of their preparation to consumption. With hectic schedules of consumers and subsequent demand for quick meal options, the popularity of ...

Published:  Sat, 21 Oct 2017 22:03:00 GMT



Giuseppe's seafood dream is safe in family's hands at Samuels & Son

The seafood store that Giuseppe Ippolito, a Sicilian immigrant, opened in 1945 at the corner of Dickinson Street and South 13th Street, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, is in no danger of leaving the family any time soon. That's because Sam D'Angelo ...

Published:  Thu, 19 Oct 2017 16:00:00 GMT



Iconic restaurants breakup: Banks solo at Harry's Seafood

Iconic restaurants breakup: Banks solo at Harry's Seafood Xavier Teixido and David Banks, the savvy team behind some of Wilmington's most popular and iconic restaurants, have ended their almost 30-year culinary partnership. Check out this story on ...

Published:  Fri, 20 Oct 2017 13:28:00 GMT



Good vibes at Port Royal Seafood Festival

THE 14th staging of the Grace Tropical Rhythms Port Royal Seafood Festival took place on Monday at the Port Royal football field in Kingston. Promoted by Jenny Jenny Productions for the past 10 years, the event saw patrons enjoying seafood all day.

Published:  Sat, 21 Oct 2017 06:33:00 GMT



A meal to remember at Jack's Seafood Shack in Montclair

So there I was at Jack's Seafood Shack on Bloomfield Avenue, having dinner with two complete strangers and having an absolute blast. Say wha! Time for some backstory. At the last gala fundraiser for the Montclair Food + Wine Festival (Bourbon + Biergarten ...

Published:  Fri, 20 Oct 2017 13:09:00 GMT



Eventide Fenway a sleek setting for seafood lovers

Where to Eventide Fenway, the Boston outpost of Portland, Maine's bivalve haven - a rite of passage for every northbound seafood lover. What for Oysters, crudo, brown butter lobster rolls, lobster stew, and soft-serve in the heart of the newly ...

Published:  Fri, 20 Oct 2017 19:00:00 GMT



Plans submitted for new seafood restaurant named after historic landmark in downtown Greenville

Plans for a new seafood restaurant and raw bar in downtown Greenville have been submitted to the city's Urban Design Panel, according to documents released by the city. The plans were received on October 2 to renovate the site of the former Yaz ...

Published:  Fri, 20 Oct 2017 08:49:00 GMT



Fire heavily damages Jack London Square seafood wholesaler

OAKLAND - A fire Wednesday night heavily damaged a longtime Jack London Square seafood wholesaler, authorities said Thursday. Authorities said fire investigators were trying to determine if the fire was a result of a homeless person cooking outside the ...

Published:  Thu, 19 Oct 2017 14:44:00 GMT



Share Us!    Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Twitter Share TopConsumerReviews.com on LinkedIn Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Google+ Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Pinterest

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure