Who's better?

Pinecraft vs Amish Furniture Collection

We've analyzed the best Amish Furniture Stores to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Amish Furniture Store Reviews

Here you can see how Pinecraft and Amish Furniture Collection match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Amish Furniture Stores in 2025.

Winner

Pinecraft

  • Prices for key items range from $328 to $6,417
  • Only outdoor furniture
  • Eco friendly

Pinecraft is your go-to destination for outdoor Amish furniture, offering a diverse range of sustainably sourced products inspired by Amish craftsmanship. The website's clean design makes browsing easy, and prices are budget-friendly. Plus, orders over $199 enjoy completely free shipping - almost unheard of in this industry. Pinecraft holds a strong reputation, and overall, it's an excellent choice for outdoor furniture needs. For these reasons (especially the free shipping) it earns a very high spot as a unique outdoor Amish furniture option.

Amish Furniture Collection

  • Prices only available via call or visit
  • Offers all furniture types
  • Custom items available

Amish Furniture Collection offers stylish furniture, but its limited sales circle (only offering furniture to Southeast Michigan) is a huge disappointment to those outside the region. Their website is well-designed, showcasing a curated selection of furniture styles, but unfortunately, you can't make purchases online, and discounts are scarce. Despite overwhelmingly positive Google Reviews, the regional limitation makes it less accessible to most customers, earning Amish Furniture Collection its lower-than-average rating in this review.

What's the first thing you think of when you hear the term "Amish furniture"? Maybe you think of beautiful handmade items or unique and artisanal designs? When customers start looking at Amish Furniture, they'll discover a new world of home design.

The appeal of Amish furniture goes beyond aesthetics, owing much of its popularity to its unparalleled quality, exceptional craftsmanship, and timeless design. In a world where mass-produced furniture often relies on materials like particle board or laminate, susceptible to wear and tear, Amish furniture stands out from the pack. Each piece is meticulously crafted from hand-selected wood, tailored to the customer's specific design needs.

This particular genre of furniture came into the limelight during the 1920s, a period when American folk art was gaining popularity. The allure of Amish craftsmanship, deeply rooted in tradition, began to captivate the hearts of furniture enthusiasts across the nation. Amish furniture can be passed down through generations, truly becoming a cherished family heirloom.

Plus, if you're looking for ways to reduce your impact on the environment, Amish furniture is the way to go. The manufacturing process adheres to sustainable practices, with tools frequently powered by hydraulic and pneumatic systems. Since the Amish community is averse to electricity usage due to their principles, they use alternative resources in the pursuit of their craft. In their unwavering dedication to their trade, the Amish take pride in their deliberate, time-honored methods of furniture making.

If you're wondering where you can pick up one of these amazing pieces, don't worry. You can find Amish Furniture all over, but some of the most talented Amish artisans hail from states such as Indiana, Ohio, and Pennsylvania, where they diligently craft these highly sought-after pieces. Fortunately, with modern online shopping, you don't have to take a big road trip or sniff out specialized Amish boutiques to add artisanal pieces to your collection.

There are lots of online stores for Amish Furniture which allow you to explore and purchase completely online, with the added convenience of having these exquisite pieces tailor-made and delivered directly to your doorstep. But with so many options online, it can be hard to know where to start.

Here are some factors to consider when you begin your search for Amish furniture:

Are you ready for some beautiful Amish furniture in your home? At Top Consumer Reviews, we've reviewed and ranked the top Amish furniture retailers out there today. We hope this helps you pick out the best deals and styles of this artisanal furniture, so that you can enjoy it for generations to come!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Amish Furniture Store FAQ

Who are the Amish?
The Amish are a Christian group in North America whose roots go back to the late 17th century. Their church is a branch off of the Mennonite faith. Today, the largest groups of Amish people are mainly found in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, Iowa, Illinois, and Kansas. They believe in separating themselves from the world by wearing plain clothing, being slow to accept new technologies, and using bicycles or horse-and-buggies as their main source of transportation. The Amish are known for being excellent farmers, constructing their own tools, and being hard workers.
What makes Amish furniture unique?
The level of craftsmanship that goes into Amish furniture is of higher quality than what you would find at a store that sells mass-manufactured items. Rather than lasting a few years, Amish furniture is such high quality that it can be passed down for generations and still look brand new if well cared for. Each item is handmade by an Amish woodworker, often on their own land. Amish furniture businesses are almost always family-owned and operated.
How is Amish furniture made?
The Amish reject most modern machinery that requires operation by electricity. When making furniture, they often use handmade tools and alternative power sources like hydraulic pumps, propane gas, or compressed air. They make all their furniture by hand with real wood (i.e. no particle board or laminate), which is why it can take months for an order to be completed. It is not uncommon to see furniture made without nails, but rather using advanced joinery techniques that can last for generations.
Is Amish furniture customizable?
Yes! When you're browsing Amish furniture online, you'll find that for any given piece you're interested in, you can usually pick the color of wood and sometimes add other details or engravings. Each piece of Amish furniture is made just for the buyer and no one else. Because of this, no two pieces are exactly alike and you get to request all of your specifications before the product is constructed.
What types of Amish furniture are available?
You can get just about any type of furniture you want from an online Amish retailer. You'll find all the basics like bedroom sets, rocking chairs, tables, dining chairs, desks, and more. Some retailers also sell porch swings, outdoor playgrounds, patio sets, and office furniture. If you're wanting a timeless, long-lasting piece of furniture for any space in your house, you'll be able to find it Amish-made.
How much does Amish furniture cost?
Amish furniture is always more expensive than mass-produced furniture because every piece is made of solid wood and crafted by hand. The quality of your furniture will far exceed anything you'll find elsewhere, making it well worth the cost. The price of any given item depends on the item and from what type of wood it is made. When shopping for Amish furniture, you can expect to spend hundreds to thousands of dollars for any given piece.
Are there local Amish furniture shops I can visit in person?
If you have an Amish community near you in the northern United States, you might be able to visit a showroom to get an idea of the quality and designs available. Some Amish retailers even work with other home furnishing stores throughout the US and supply them with some staple furniture products. However, most of the time when buying Amish furniture, you shop online: select the construction materials you want and any other customizable features and have it built for you. This is the most convenient and personalized way to buy Amish furniture.
Is Amish furniture returnable?
Depending on the retailer, Amish furniture is sometimes returnable as long as it is not custom. Some retailers have a 25%+ restocking fee for anything returned, while others don't allow returns at all. Amish furniture is well-made piece-by-piece, so you won't need to worry about quality as much as you would if you were buying furniture from a traditional retailer. Because the pieces are typically made exactly to your specifications, most of the time there would be no need for returns. Read the return policy listed by the Amish furniture store you choose to buy from before placing an order so you know what to expect.

Compare Any 2 Products

Online Amish Furniture
Pinecraft
Amish Furniture Factory
Amish Outlet Store
Countryside Amish Furniture
Amish Showroom
DutchCrafters
Cabinfield
Simply Amish
Amish Furniture Collection
vs
Online Amish Furniture vs PinecraftOnline Amish Furniture vs Amish Furniture FactoryOnline Amish Furniture vs Amish Outlet StoreOnline Amish Furniture vs Countryside Amish FurnitureOnline Amish Furniture vs Amish ShowroomOnline Amish Furniture vs DutchCraftersOnline Amish Furniture vs CabinfieldOnline Amish Furniture vs Simply AmishOnline Amish Furniture vs Amish Furniture CollectionPinecraft vs Amish Furniture FactoryPinecraft vs Amish Outlet StorePinecraft vs Countryside Amish FurniturePinecraft vs Amish ShowroomPinecraft vs DutchCraftersPinecraft vs CabinfieldPinecraft vs Simply AmishPinecraft vs Amish Furniture CollectionAmish Furniture Factory vs Amish Outlet StoreAmish Furniture Factory vs Countryside Amish FurnitureAmish Furniture Factory vs Amish ShowroomAmish Furniture Factory vs DutchCraftersAmish Furniture Factory vs CabinfieldAmish Furniture Factory vs Simply AmishAmish Furniture Factory vs Amish Furniture CollectionAmish Outlet Store vs Countryside Amish FurnitureAmish Outlet Store vs Amish ShowroomAmish Outlet Store vs DutchCraftersAmish Outlet Store vs CabinfieldAmish Outlet Store vs Simply AmishAmish Outlet Store vs Amish Furniture CollectionCountryside Amish Furniture vs Amish ShowroomCountryside Amish Furniture vs DutchCraftersCountryside Amish Furniture vs CabinfieldCountryside Amish Furniture vs Simply AmishCountryside Amish Furniture vs Amish Furniture CollectionAmish Showroom vs DutchCraftersAmish Showroom vs CabinfieldAmish Showroom vs Simply AmishAmish Showroom vs Amish Furniture CollectionDutchCrafters vs CabinfieldDutchCrafters vs Simply AmishDutchCrafters vs Amish Furniture CollectionCabinfield vs Simply AmishCabinfield vs Amish Furniture CollectionSimply Amish vs Amish Furniture Collection Amish Furniture Collection vs Simply AmishAmish Furniture Collection vs CabinfieldAmish Furniture Collection vs DutchCraftersAmish Furniture Collection vs Amish ShowroomAmish Furniture Collection vs Countryside Amish FurnitureAmish Furniture Collection vs Amish Outlet StoreAmish Furniture Collection vs Amish Furniture FactoryAmish Furniture Collection vs PinecraftAmish Furniture Collection vs Online Amish FurnitureSimply Amish vs CabinfieldSimply Amish vs DutchCraftersSimply Amish vs Amish ShowroomSimply Amish vs Countryside Amish FurnitureSimply Amish vs Amish Outlet StoreSimply Amish vs Amish Furniture FactorySimply Amish vs PinecraftSimply Amish vs Online Amish FurnitureCabinfield vs DutchCraftersCabinfield vs Amish ShowroomCabinfield vs Countryside Amish FurnitureCabinfield vs Amish Outlet StoreCabinfield vs Amish Furniture FactoryCabinfield vs PinecraftCabinfield vs Online Amish FurnitureDutchCrafters vs Amish ShowroomDutchCrafters vs Countryside Amish FurnitureDutchCrafters vs Amish Outlet StoreDutchCrafters vs Amish Furniture FactoryDutchCrafters vs PinecraftDutchCrafters vs Online Amish FurnitureAmish Showroom vs Countryside Amish FurnitureAmish Showroom vs Amish Outlet StoreAmish Showroom vs Amish Furniture FactoryAmish Showroom vs PinecraftAmish Showroom vs Online Amish FurnitureCountryside Amish Furniture vs Amish Outlet StoreCountryside Amish Furniture vs Amish Furniture FactoryCountryside Amish Furniture vs PinecraftCountryside Amish Furniture vs Online Amish FurnitureAmish Outlet Store vs Amish Furniture FactoryAmish Outlet Store vs PinecraftAmish Outlet Store vs Online Amish FurnitureAmish Furniture Factory vs PinecraftAmish Furniture Factory vs Online Amish FurniturePinecraft vs Online Amish Furniture
See the Best Amish Furniture Stores in Your State

Why is Amish Furniture So Popular?

As you prepare to buy new furnishings for your home, you undoubtedly will come across many Amish-style pieces for the bedroom, living room and other areas of the house. These include hardwood options like dining tables, chairs, end tables, bookshelves, desks, dressers and more. With so many types of Amish furniture available in local stores and online, you can see that Amish furnishings are a popular option. By taking a closer look at why Amish furniture continues to be highly coveted in homes across the country and beyond, you may decide that these are pieces that are perfect for your home.

Premium Materials

Many wood furnishings available in local stores and online today are not actually made out of hardwood. Instead, they are made out of manufactured materials that could include a combination of veneer, fiberboard, particleboard and even plywood. Wood is generally a durable material that can last a lifetime, but this is not the case for the many types of manufactured wood materials. In fact, furnishings made out of these manufactured wood materials may only last a decade or less before they begin to fall apart. Unlike hardwood, the manufactured wood cannot be refinished. As a result, it generally is tossed in the trash when it falls apart.

Amish furnishings are exclusively made out of true hardwoods. Solid red oak and cherry wood are commonly used. Other types of solid wood used in Amish furnishings are hickory, walnut, maple, and white oak. The wood is produced in a sustainable fashion. Because the trees usually grow in a northern climate where the rate of growth is slow, the wood is dense and durable. As a result, Amish furnishings are durable. In fact, they can easily last a lifetime or much longer.

More than that, these are American-made items that are often not created until an order has been placed. Many other furnishings may be assembled on the other side of an ocean. The manufacturing processes can generate unnecessary waste, and shipping may lead to the unnecessary consumption of fossil fuels and the generation of pollutants. Because Amish furniture may not be produced until it is ordered, there is no need for the Amish to maintain a large warehouse. The Amish are able to optimize valuable space strategically.

Handcrafted Quality

The Amish people are known for living simple lives without modern luxuries like electricity. Most of the furnishings that you will find for sale online and in local stores are mass-produced pieces that are quickly made. The manufacturing processes may yield defects, and they can result in weaker and less durable furnishings. The Amish, however, make all of their pieces by hand using many of the same carpentry tools and joinery methods that have been used for generations. While some Amish craftsmen use select power tools for specific tasks, they never mass-produce their work.

One of the unique qualities of Amish furnishings is their lack of nails. Instead, the Amish use various traditional joinery methods that require exceptional craftsmanship. They also utilize non-toxic wood adhesives to ensure the longevity of their artisan furniture.

Low-Maintenance Furnishings

One of the many endearing qualities of Amish furniture is that they require minimal maintenance. Because of the intensive manufacturing processes and the lower-grade materials used in many other types of furnishings, special care may be required to optimize their longevity. However, even with detailed care and frequent attention, the mass-produced furnishings may have a much shorter life.

Because Amish furniture is exclusively made using high-quality hardwood material with handcrafted assembly, it does not have special care requirements. While all furniture needs to be dusted frequently, Amish furniture requires infrequent additional steps to keep it looking great. In fact, polishing it every six months is the only specialized care that may be needed. Because solid hardwood is used, you can expect the material to resist nicks and scratches that may plague soft wood and manufactured wood furnishings. When Amish furniture finally shows signs of age and wear, it can be sanded and refinished to give it a like-new appearance. However, when Amish furniture is well-maintained, refinishing may only be needed once every few decades or less.

Timeless Style

The processes used by Amish people to create their artisan furniture pieces have changed very little. With this in mind, you may assume that the style of current Amish furniture is equivalent to that of modern furnishings. In reality, the style has evolved slowly over time. Today's Amish furniture usually has a Mission or Shaker style. These styles have been prevalent for the last few decades, and this is a sign that they have timeless appeal.

All Amish furniture is made out of solid wood, so the pieces bring a natural element into your space. This natural element may be well-suited for a cottage-style home or a cabin. Likewise, it looks beautiful in homes with traditional décor and even contemporary décor.

While the style of Amish furniture has evolved slowly over time, that does not mean that all Amish furniture looks the same. Because Amish craftsmen use different materials, stains and techniques, each handmade piece is unique. When you invest in Amish furniture, you are buying a one-of-a-kind item. However, do not look for the craftsman's mark. The Amish are humble people who do not seek individual recognition. Instead, they want the focus to be on the fine work that they did to craft the furniture.

Furniture is expensive to purchase, so you understandably want to optimize the life of any furnishings that you decide to invest in. Buying high-quality furniture that can last for decades or longer is only beneficial if these are pieces that will still be aesthetically appealing many years down the road. Because Amish furniture has a timeless, classic look that corresponds well with many interior design schemes, the furniture likely will be a treasured part of your home décor for a lifetime.

Family Heirlooms

In many families, certain heirlooms have been handed down for generations, and this includes furniture. While many of the current furnishings that you find in local stores today will not still be in use a decade or two from now, older pieces that have been handcrafted from quality materials may be a century old or even older. The Amish continue to use the same artisan techniques that they have used for generations. These are techniques that have been taught by elders and that have evolved very little over the decades. Because of this, when you buy Amish furniture, you are buying furniture that has the same quality as yesteryear's pieces.

Of course, many older items get tossed out because they lose their appeal. Even if a dresser, table or another piece of furniture is still in good shape, it may have an outdated look that makes it undesirable. Amish furniture has a charm that is sustained over the years. These are pieces that may look just as wonderful in a home today as they will look decades from now. Because Amish furniture continues to be desired over the years, you can realistically plan on the furniture to become family heirlooms.

True Value

Are Amish furnishings right for your home? You will undoubtedly notice that Amish furniture is priced slightly higher than some of the other lower-quality furniture that has been mass-produced. However, you can see that each Amish furnishing is instilled with true value and is an investment well worth making. With variations in style and materials, now is the perfect time to begin exploring the beautiful possibilities that are available for your home. An easy way to compare a wide variety of Amish pieces is by shopping online.

Only the Best Reviews

Only In Your State ...

6 Breathtaking Locations in Virginia's Amish Country to Explore

The article explores the Amish communities in Virginia, highlighting their history, lifestyle, and presence in various counties.

Mon, 27 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

WTOL

Herron's Amish Furniture store expands, moves to Napoleon

NAPOLEON, OH (WTOL) - Herron's Amish Furniture is getting a bigger store and a different location. Herron's is moving from Okolona to Napoleon to a store more than double the size of their previous ...

Tue, 30 May 2017

Only the Best Reviews

Sarasota Magazine

DutchCrafters Has a New Sarasota Showroom

At the newly remodeled DutchCrafters showroom in Sarasota, you can get a jelly cabinet and a pie safe—quality crafted by Amish hands—but you’ll also find outdoor furniture made of recycled plastic and ...

Mon, 23 May 2022

Only the Best Reviews

KUTV

Simply Amish Furniture at Vintage Oak

(KUTV) — Summer is fast approaching and now is the perfect time to get your furniture on order for the holidays. With the lingering supply chain disruptions from COVID, we all need to think ahead this ...

Fri, 28 May 2021

Only the Best Reviews

LancasterOnline

Kings Amish Furniture sets opening date for new store in Shops at ...

Kings Amish Furniture is set to open its new store in the Shops at Rockvale. The store, which debuts Saturday, Aug. 10, is a third location for Kings Amish Furniture, which has its main store in ...

Thu, 08 Aug 2024

Only the Best Reviews

The Times-Reporter

The 'granddaddy' of Amish furniture stores — Farmerstown Furniture

Farmerstown Furniture has been dubbed the granddaddy and oldest Amish furniture store in Holmes County. Since 1969, Eli Junior Hershberger and his family have been providing the area with high-quality ...

Thu, 10 Sep 2015

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.