The Best Amish Furniture Stores

Sunday, October 6th

2024 Amish Furniture Store Reviews

Online Amish Furniture

• Prices for key items range from $213 to $4,102
• Offers all furniture types
• Ships internationally
• Eco friendly
• Discounts from 5% to 10%
• Flat-rate shipping for $199
• Additional promo discounts offered
• 365-day returns (with 25% restocking fee)
• Cancellations within 3 days
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Online Amish Furniture is a family-owned company that embarked on its journey back in 1998 as a traditional brick-and-mortar establishment. However, the founders transitioned exclusively to the online realm in 2006, where they've been crafting exceptional furniture ever since.

Top quality delivered around the world

Online Amish Furniture's mission is as noble as it is timeless: to offer families an eco-friendly alternative to disposable furniture, ensuring that each piece stands the test of time. The best part? Online Amish Furniture extends its reach to deliver exquisite pieces to customers not only across the United States but also to furniture enthusiasts in Canada, New Zealand, Australia, and a range of European countries too.

Design is a little outdated but still does the job

When you first land on Online Amish Furniture's website, you might notice that it lacks some of the streamlined design elements of most modern online retailers. However, the large and old-fashioned text doesn't take away from how well this site works. These minor quirks in website aesthetics don't affect your ability to browse at all. Navigating the site is still a breeze. All of the key furniture items are organized in easy-to-find dropdown menus, and when you select your preferred category, you can narrow down by style or just see the entire inventory. The only thing that's really missing during browsing is more extensive filters, but you can narrow by price or alphabetically, so it's not just an organizational free-for-all.

Handmade within 10-16 weeks

Every piece of furniture from Online Amish Furniture is custom-made, adding an extra layer of uniqueness to your home decor. Made following the latest eco-friendly practices, the items from Online Amish Furniture are each designed especially for you. While the waiting period for your handcrafted masterpiece may be longer than what you're accustomed to, ranging from 10 to 16 weeks, patience truly pays off when you see the impeccable craftsmanship. Some larger items, like dressers, chests of drawers, and hutches, might take a bit longer, typically falling within the 12- to 16-week range. These delays are simply a testament to the dedication of the Amish craftsmen in Ohio and Pennsylvania who labor meticulously on each piece.

Budget-friendly prices with sales

Now, we know that Amish furniture isn't the most budget-friendly, but Online Amish Furniture offers highly competitive rates. To compare the prices directly with other retailers, we checked out three items at each company: dining tables, dining chairs, and beds. Starting off with dining tables, we had to narrow down the options a little to see pricing, so we selected "leg tables” specifically. The prices at Online Amish Furniture range from $878 to $2,092 with many of the items in stock on sale at the time of this review. For the dining chairs, the prices range from $213 to $895 per chair. Again, many of these were also on sale at the time of this review. Finally, the price range for beds at Online Amish Furniture runs from $1,183 to $4,102. Overall, the prices are much lower than many competitors, offering a more budget-friendly selection here.

Tons of discount opportunities

One of the standout features of Online Amish Furniture is its sitewide discount structure. Depending on the total cost of your order, you can enjoy significant savings. Here is how the spending tiers shake out:

• Spend between $1,000 and $2,999 to earn a 2% discount
• Spend between $3,000 and $4,999 to earn a 4% discount
• Spend between $5,000 and $9,999 to earn a 6% discount
• Spend over $10,000 or more to earn a 10% discount

On top of those standard discounts, you'll occasionally stumble upon on-site discounts that bring down prices even further. For example, at the time of this review, Online Amish Furniture was offering an additional 5% off sitewide.

Shipping costs from $199 to $349

When it comes to delivery, Online Amish Furniture charges a flat rate of $199. This is much lower than many competitors whose flat-rate shipping starts over $200. However, this price doesn't include setup or assembly. For those seeking the white-glove experience, where your new furniture items are brought into your home and expertly assembled, the total cost is $349 (including the flat rate shipping and white-glove expenses).

1-year return policy

Online Amish Furniture also offers a remarkably generous return policy. For a no-penalty cancellation, Online Amish Furniture offers a 72-hour window. If you make your cancellation within that time frame, you can expect a complete refund. Beyond that initial period, you still have an entire year to contact their responsive customer service team and initiate a return. That's right, 365 days to think about whether your new furniture fits your needs. Now, if you do decide to make the return, you will need to cover the shipping expenses for the return and there is a 25% restocking fee. But that still doesn't take away from the fact that Online Amish Furniture has the longest return window of any retailer in our review.

Fan favorite with reviewers

Online Amish Furniture holds an impressive "A+” rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau, a testament to its commitment to customer satisfaction and ethical business practices. On top of that, Online Amish Furniture has a solid 4.9-star average from reviewers with comments from verified customers including statements like "unmatched quality” and "worth the wait”. Basically, clients can't stop raving about Online Amish Furniture, and based on what we've seen, we can't help but agree.

It's a clean sweep for Online Amish Furniture

Bottom line? There are just too many great things to talk about with Online Amish Furniture. With the longest return window of any retailer in this review, tons of discounts, and an ample selection of high-quality furniture items, Online Amish Furniture easily pulls to the front of the pack. This retailer has earned our highest rating, and we wholeheartedly recommend giving them a look when furnishing your home with timeless, enduring Amish pieces.

Pinecraft

• Prices for key items range from $328 to $6,417
• Only outdoor furniture
• Eco friendly
• Discounts for email subscription
• Discounts from promos
• Sustainable sourcing
• Free shipping on orders $199+
• Cancellations within 2 days
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Pinecraft's Amish furniture proudly showcases the craftsmanship from the Amish communities of Ohio, Indiana, Pennsylvania, and Montana. However, the company's name, Pinecraft, pays homage to another Amish community located in Sarasota, Florida, from which they draw inspiration. The standout feature of Pinecraft is its outdoor furniture. Almost every item on their site is outdoor-related, including playhouses, deck furniture, and even unique animal housing like chicken coops or dog houses. If you have outdoor designs in mind, Pinecraft is the place to go for Amish furniture.

Clean site is perfect for user-friendliness

Visiting Pinecraft's website, your attention is immediately drawn to their enchanting collection of outdoor furniture. With the clean white and black site design, it's easy to start browsing unique outdoor furniture right away. With menu drop-downs like "Amish Patio Furniture,” "Yard & Garden,” and "Pets & Animals,” you can quickly find what you need for your outdoor paradise. Each title offers a convenient dropdown menu that makes it easy to see all their categories at a glance.

Good filters

On top of the dropdowns, you can also find a variety of helpful filters once you've decided on a particular item. You can filter various products with options like:

• Category
• Material
• Assembly
• Collection
• Available

Delivery depends on the product you order

All of the items offered at Pinecraft are sustainably sourced by the craftsmen locally. Pinecraft itself is located in Florida, but they sell items from Amish craftsmen across the US, providing a wide variety of handcrafted designs. As a note for manufacturing times, the lead times for each product are listed on a per-product basis. So to see how long it will take to craft a particular item, you'll need to check out the particular listing. Afterward, the actual delivery time may vary, typically taking an extra 2-5 days depending on your location.

Outdoor pricing is budget-friendly

With our other retailers, we checked out the same products at each one. However, since Pinecraft is an outdoor retailer, it doesn't offer any of the same items as the rest of the stores on our list. So, to try and get a close-ish price comparison, we found items that were similar to the items chosen for other companies. For this price comparison, we looked at outdoor dining tables, outdoor dining chairs, and porch swings. For the outdoor dining tables, the prices ranged from $660 to $6,417. For the outdoor dining chairs, the prices ranged from $328 to $1,180 per chair. Finally, for the porch swings, the prices at Pinecraft ranged from $663 to $2,690.

Email subscriptions and promo discounts

For savvy shoppers, Pinecraft offers an email subscription to unlock savings right away. By subscribing to their email list, you'll earn a 10% discount on your next purchase. On top of that, customers can also find a variety of limited-time promotions to bring down prices. For example, at the time of this review, the site was running a 10% off promo with a code for two weeks.

Free shipping on $199+

The cost of shipping is one of the best features at Pinecraft. Orders that cost more than $199 earn completely free shipping. That's right: zero-cost shipping. This is totally different from many other Amish furniture stores, which often charge hefty shipping fees. While there may be exceptions for large structures such as barns, sheds, playhouses, and coops, most orders are likely to qualify for this exceptional free shipping offer, making Pinecraft an even more attractive destination.

2-day cancellation policy

If you are worried about returns there are a couple of things to keep in mind with Pinecraft. If you decide to cancel your order within 48 hours, you are eligible for a full refund. After this period, the order is considered final, as their custom-made products are likely already in production. Also, if you receive a product that is not functioning correctly, missing parts, or visibly damaged, these issues are likely covered under warranty and can be resolved through replacement parts or a complete exchange. In terms of regular returns, since all sales are final, most items will not be accepted back. This is determined on a case-by-case basis. If your item is accepted for a return, you can expect to pay a 15% restocking fee and return shipping costs.

Strong reputation with a few concerns about lead times

On top of the other great features of this site, Pinecraft also holds a solid "A+” rating and accreditation with the Better Business Bureau, and it's doing just as well with customer ratings. Looking at third-party review sites and verified shoppers, the company holds an average rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars. Customers praised the quality of items including final color and durability. However, it's worth noting that the comments that brought down the ratings from 5 stars noted that they had trouble with getting a hold of customer service some of the time or felt shipping was too slow. But for those willing to wait, Pinecraft is an overall excellent experience.

Top option for Amish outdoor furniture

Bottom line? If you want Amish outdoor furniture, Pinecraft offers the best selection you can find. Here, you can discover a wide variety of unique and enchanting products both for you and for your furry friends. What's more, their shipping fees are refreshingly low, with the option for free shipping on almost every order, and their pricing remains reasonable across the board. However, for those in search of indoor furniture, Pinecraft's offerings will be limited in scope. Despite this limitation, Pinecraft emerges as a fantastic choice for virtually all outdoor Amish furniture needs.

Amish Furniture Factory

• Prices for key items range from $268 to $7,248
• Offers all furniture types
• Sends stain and finish samples
• Discounts up to 14%
• 30-day returns
• Cancellations within 3 days
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

If you want to get to know Amish Furniture Factory, their tagline says it all: "Handmade Solid Wood & Built to Last”. With this store, you know you're getting solid, handmade pieces with unique details tailor-made to your preferences.

2 ways to shop

With Amish Furniture Factory, there are two ways to shop. First, you can send them a digital request for a particular piece and they'll reply by helping you get samples or get right to the quotes. Second, you can browse their online catalog of furniture items and customize them right in the order window. With different stains and unique hand-carved designs, each item is made to order just for you. Most of their wide selection of products aren't "in stock”, as they are crafted based on the customer's particular requirements. If you want that "made for me” feel to fit your ideal home aesthetic, Amish Furniture Factory is a great place to start.

User interface could use some polish

Amish Furniture Factory's website isn't the most user-friendly we've ever seen. With tons of long scrolling pages and example photos, they offer a lot of information, but it's not super easy to read or find. However, with their carefully curated drop-down menus, you can quickly pick out the type of furniture you want to preview. You can choose to shop by furniture type, shop by area where you'll put the furniture, or shop by a particular style. Whether you're furnishing your baby room, transforming your bedroom into a cozy haven, upgrading your dining room, or enhancing your entertainment & TV space, they've got you covered. On the whole, it might be helpful for them to update their site to fit in with modern retailers a bit better, but overall the site does the job it needs to do (even if it isn't the prettiest one we've ever seen).

Handmade with customer-focused samples

When crafting furniture, the experts at Amish Furniture Factory create almost every piece to order. Their creation process is great at making customers feel confident about their final purchase. For some of the most nerve-wracking choices like stain color or wood finish, Amish Furniture Factory offers a remarkable service: free stain and finish samples delivered to your doorstep. The artisans want you to avoid the heartache of disappointment later by offering easy in-home examples of what your final product will look like.

Pricing is competitive for the industry

To make a quick and easy price comparison between different retailers in this review, we decided to check out the same items at each online Amish furniture store. So, to see how Amish Furniture Factory stacks up against competitors' prices, we looked at the price ranges for dining tables, dining chairs, and beds. For dining tables, the prices range from $775 to $4,488. For chairs to complement your new table, the prices range from $268 to $610. It's important to note that this price is per chair and not for a full set. Finally, the prices for handcrafted beds range from $321 for a small pet bed to $7,248 for a queen-size murphy bed. To kickstart your furniture creation, a 30% deposit is required for orders totaling $1,000 or more. Afterward, you'll have a generous three-month window to settle the remaining balance.

More discounts the more you spend

While the prices are higher than your average furniture items, Amish Furniture Factory believes in rewarding your commitment with a range of discounts. These can range from 2%-14% depending on what you buy. The savings start when you spend $1,000, with each additional thousand dollars incrementally reducing the cost of your order.

Shipping is calculated at the end

Shipping costs at Amish Furniture Factory depend on the specifics of your order. The rates are calculated based on factors such as the approximate size and weight of the items and your shipping destination. These precise calculations are made in the online shopping cart, requiring your input of the zip code to get your final cost.

30-day returns

On top of discounts, Amish Furniture Factory also supports customers through their return policy. If for any reason you are dissatisfied with your order, you have 30 days from the date of delivery to request a refund. It's worth noting that the customer is responsible for covering the shipping expenses both ways and there is also a 15% restocking fee. However, if your items arrive damaged or defective, you'll receive a full refund without the restocking fee. Plus, you have 72 hours to change your mind and cancel the order completely without any cost.

"A+” for quality furniture

Amish Furniture Factory takes pride in showcasing testimonials from customers on its website. While we often approach website-hosted reviews with a degree of skepticism, this collection stands out as it often includes customer-submitted photographs of the furniture they've purchased. These visual endorsements underscore the high-quality craftsmanship evident in each piece. On top of that, Amish Furniture Factory has an "A+” rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau which further demonstrates the company's commitment to excellence.

Top place to preview

Overall, Amish Furniture Factory earns its place among the top contenders for Amish furniture enthusiasts. Their extensive selection, coupled with a wealth of satisfied customers, speaks volumes. With the added benefit of free color samples and comprehensive information at your fingertips, you can shop with confidence, knowing that you're making an investment in quality and long-term enjoyment of your hand-made furniture. For these reasons, Amish Furniture Factory has secured one of our highest ratings for Amish furniture, making it a solid choice for discerning customers seeking timeless and enduring pieces for their homes.

Amish Outlet Store

• Prices for key items range from $180 to $16,348
• Offers all furniture types
• Custom items available
• In-stock items available
• Discounts depending on promos
• 10-day returns
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Amish Outlet Store is one of the top destinations to find Ohio Amish furniture, mission furniture, and shaker furniture. With a legacy spanning over two decades, this family-owned establishment, nestled in the heart of Amish country near Smithville, Ohio, takes pride in offering top-notch, American-made furniture.

Extensive quality collection

Their extensive collection showcases handcrafted Amish furniture and promises competitive prices across the board. Crafted by highly skilled Amish artisans, each piece is custom-made, employing time-honored techniques and the finest solid wood and materials. This results in furniture that marries durability, functionality, and unparalleled aesthetic appeal.

Streamlined website is easy to browse

One of our favorite things about browsing at the Amish Outlet Store is their web interface. With easy-to-use drop-down menus, you can find everything you need in easy-to-read lists categorized by type. Some of the menus include:

• In-stock inventory
• Quick-ship furniture
• Bedroom
• Dining room
• Living room
• Rustic furniture
• Entertainment
• Reclaimed barnwood
• Bathroom
• Outdoor furniture

Thoughtful category organization

There are a ton more categories than this, ensuring that any type of furniture customers might want is available with easy-to-browse photos. Each category includes further organization. For example under "bedroom" you can find:

• Amish bedroom collections
• Amish cedar/blanket chests
• Amish nightstands
• Amish bedroom sets
• Amish dressers
• Amish beds
• Amish jewelry chests/dressing tables

Hand-made hardwoods only

Amish Outlet Store's production process prioritizes the use of premium materials to make sure customers get the highest quality every time. The company's furniture is exclusively crafted from North American kiln-dried hardwood. They offer a diverse range of woods, including oak, maple, walnut, brown maple, hickory, and rustic woods like cherry and quarter-sawn white oak. Furthermore, Amish Outlet Store offers customers the opportunity to tailor their furniture to their specific preferences, with a wide variety of stain options available for customization. While they do offer in-stock furniture you can buy as-is, you can also participate in the design process for a personalized and seamless fit within your existing home decor.

Prices offer items for all budgets

To compare prices across various retailers featured in this review, we checked out the same (or similar) items at each Amish furniture store: dining tables, dining chairs, and beds, among other items. Since Amish Outlet Store required shoppers to limit the dining tables to a particular type, we specifically looked at "leg tables” which have four legs with one at each corner. The price range for these tables was $860 to $1,945. For the dining chairs, pieces start at $180 and go as high as $1,370 per chair. Finally, for beds, the prices ranged from $806 to $16,348. Notably, there are more higher-priced items at Amish Outlet Store than other retailers, though they also offer a number of budget-friendly styles too. They offer a competitive range for all budgets whether you want something basic or more luxurious.

Occasional discounts available

While there are discounts at Amish Outlet Store, they are dependent on particular promotions and often have limited time frames. For example, at the time of this review, Amish Outlet Store was offering a discount from 5% to 10% off your entire order depending on what you buy. However, it was noted that the discounts did not extend to cover shipping costs or outdoor furniture purchases.

Shipping from $249

In terms of shipping, Amish Outlet store offers Standard Residential Curbside Delivery, priced at $249. This is offered to most US zip codes, with items being delivered as close to the customer's home as possible and unloaded by professionals from the delivery truck. However, customers are responsible for moving the furniture indoors and any necessary assembly. For $199 extra, you can opt for White Glove In-home Delivery, which covers the cost of the delivery staff bringing in your furniture, placing it in the chosen room, and fully assembling the pieces. As another option, customers may choose to pick up their orders in person from the company's Ohio warehouse, which can help them save on shipping costs but does require that customers have their own moving vehicle and furniture blankets.

10-day limited returns

Amish Outlet Store offers returns for standard items within a ten-day window. Customers are required to cover the return shipping expenses, and there is a 20% restocking fee. Certain exceptions apply to this policy, including instances of shipping damage where Amish Outlet Store offers repair or replacement at no additional cost. However, keep in mind that customized furniture, involving alterations from the standard size and design, as well as specialty finishes or stain-matched items, are also excluded from the return policy.

Customers love the quality

Amish Outlet Store is a standout service according to reviews and the Better Business Bureau. Customers who left verified reviews on third-party sites noted that they loved the quality of the items. Many opted for the White Glove shipping option and particularly praised how simple and stress-free the delivery process was. The only complaint customers had was that they wanted Amish Outlet Store to add color photos to each item to show how different finishes would look. However, the company had an overall rating average of 4.5 stars out of 5 across multiple review sites. On top of that Amish Outlet Store holds an "A+” rating as well as accreditation from the BBB.

Widest variety of styles and prices

In terms of selection and variety, Amish Outlet Store is one of the top contenders out there. Offering in-home delivery and setup, Amish Outlet Store streamlines the whole process from furniture selection to furniture set-up. They offer budget-friendly options as low as $180 and also cater to the higher budgets with hand-made items in the thousands. There are only two things that keep Amish Outlet Store from the top three: they don't offer quality previews of their different stains (which is a common customer complaint) and their discounts and returns are limited, making it difficult for customers to keep costs down even when shopping the lower-cost items. However, if you're looking for a wide variety of items that can be tailored to your aesthetic, Amish Outlet Store is definitely worth browsing.

Countryside Amish Furniture

• Prices for key items range from $250 to $7,374
• Offers all furniture types
• $150 flat-rate shipping
• Eco-friendly
• Sends stain and finish samples
• Discounts between 5%-10%
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Countryside Amish Furniture is a company that sells handcrafted hardwood furniture primarily sourced in the heartlands of Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Indiana. The possibilities are virtually limitless when it comes to furniture styles.

Conversion varnish included

What sets their furniture apart is the meticulous sealing process that involves a conversion varnish. This protective layer not only enhances the aesthetic appeal but also acts as a shield against the rigors of everyday wear and tear. For Countryside Amish Furniture, a piece of furniture is not merely a "look or style"; it's meant to be a work of art.

Cute countryside site design

Countryside Amish Furniture has a cute web design that harks back to the early Pinterest days with monogram logos and an outdoorsy green and cream color scheme that's easy to read. The site offers useful labels across the top menu that open into drop-down lists with the full range of Countryside Amish Furniture's products all in one place. For example, you can expect to see dropdowns for dining room, bedroom, office, living room, and even the kids' room. Plus, Countryside Amish Furniture goes the extra mile by offering a substantial collection of outdoor products. However, there is one downside to the site design: Countryside Amish Furniture doesn't allow customers to sort the results. With pages and pages of items, there's no way to narrow down by price or by popularity, which may frustrate many shoppers.

Eco-friendly and customer-focused

The process of crafting furniture at Countryside Amish Furniture has a strong emphasis on sustainability. The company proudly champions eco-friendliness by sourcing hardwoods that are responsibly harvested and domestically grown. This commitment to environmentally conscious practices aligns with the belief that every piece, being crafted from pure wood, is built to last a lifetime. Plus, as part of their process, Countryside Amish Furniture allows you to order samples of stains, fabrics, leathers, outdoor fabrics, and poly colors. This way you can make informed decisions and visualize how each element fits in with the rest of your home.

Competitive prices for handmade items

Pricing at Countryside Amish Furniture is notably reasonable, considering the exceptional quality on offer. It aligns well with other esteemed Amish furniture retailers. To look at the prices at Countryside Amish Furniture against other companies in this review we looked at three key items: dining room tables, dining chairs, and handmade beds. Note that these are approximate prices, and there may be lower or higher-priced items across the site. For dining tables, the prices at Countryside Amish Furniture ranged from $1,373 to $6,574. For dining chairs, the prices ranged from approximately $250 to $1,303. Finally, for beds, the prices ranged from $950 to $7,374.

Discounts from 5% to 10% off

One place where Countryside Amish Furniture stands out price-wise is its discounts. Spend $2,000, and you earn a 5% discount on your total purchase. This percentage goes up depending on how much you spend. A $5,000 purchase will earn you an 8% discount, while the most substantial savings come with an $8,000+ purchase which offers 10% off. These discounts can make a significant difference, especially for those eyeing more expensive pieces.

Flat-rate shipping and setup

Getting your items delivered is a breeze. Countryside Amish Furniture charges a flat-rate fee of $150 for delivery and set-up anywhere within the United States. This is an amazing deal as many companies charge over $100 just for the setup and add that to the cost of shipping. For only $150 to cover the entire shipment process to any US location is a bargain deal if you're buying something large like a bed or a dining table. However, there might be concerns about this fee when ordering smaller items, feeling that it might disproportionately impact the cost of their purchase.

No returns available

One place where Countryside Amish Furniture doesn't stand out is its return policy. Due to the made-to-order nature of their products, Countryside Amish Furniture does not accept returns. So, make sure you love it before you buy it.

Top scores overall

Countryside Amish Furniture has a solid reputation among reviewers and the Better Business Bureau, though the company is a little light on buzz. For example, Countryside Amish Furniture only has reviews on 2 websites with a total of 28 reviews. However, the reviews are almost all 5 out of 5 stars, which shows that while it's not the most popular site, the customers who shop there come away totally satisfied. On top of that, Countryside Amish Furniture holds a perfect "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB, further supporting the company's top-notch reputation.

Solid company with room to grow

Countryside Amish Furniture's wide variety of styles and specific products within each category plus their commitment to sustainability and environmentally responsible practices is commendable. However, it's important to keep in mind their no-return policy, which may give some potential buyers pause, especially when making substantial furniture investments. Plus, the browsing was a little clunky in spots which might make it harder for customers to find what they need. On the other hand, with the $150 flat-rate delivery and set-up fee, many customers might find they're spending less than with competitors on shipping. So all things considered, this business gets a solid rating. If they update their website to something a little more user-friendly, they could easily move higher in the rankings.

Amish Showroom

• Prices for key items range from $214 to $5,854
• Offers all furniture types
• Custom items available
• Ships samples to customers
• In-stock items available
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Amish Showroom is headquartered in the picturesque state of Minnesota. For its first 16 years of operation, the company worked as a lumber provider. They sold locally sourced lumber to Amish craftsmen from their family tree farm and gradually expanded to offer consumer-direct sales from Amish workshops. Amish Showroom specializes in custom furniture, kitchen cabinets, and interior doors for both commercial and residential clients. Unlike traditional furniture stores, Amish Showroom focuses exclusively on direct-to-consumer sales.

Solid site design could use a little polish

Amish Showroom's website is solid overall. It's easy to use, although it is just a WordPress website, which is a little odd for a professional company. However, it showcases the wide variety at Amish Showroom perfectly. With an array of dropdown menus, room collections, and lists of featured products, it's easy to find what you need here. If they added a little polish to the details like fixing icons and text that are a little blurry, the UI would be top-notch. If you want an example of their web design, just check out their dining room section - a category that unfolds with a rich tapestry of styles, including trestle, leg, pedestal, tall gathering, narrow, breadboard, long expanding, live edge, and even cozy breakfast nooks.

Diverse categories

This diversity extends across all furniture categories, where you'll discover an extensive selection of specific pieces to suit your unique needs. These categories include:

• Sale items
• Dining room
• Living room
• Bedroom
• Office
• Vanities
• Entryway

One thing to note is that when sorting furniture, the load times at Amish Showroom's website can be a little slow. So if you think the site isn't moving, just give it a few extra seconds than normal.

From their hands to your home in 4-12 weeks

Amish Showroom's process from selection to delivery is meant to be seamless. First, the experts at Amish Showroom recommend customers have a conversation with one of their team members about stain choices and any pertinent details before placing their orders. After that, Amish Showroom goes the extra mile by sending you a stain sample for your review to make sure your final product will fit properly with your current aesthetic. This personalized touch is visible in the final product through meticulous attention to detail. The journey from order placement to the arrival of your furniture typically spans 4 to 12 weeks, depending on the item selected. While Amish Showroom does offer an "in-stock" section on their website, brimming with ready-to-ship or pick-up items, it's important to note that these treasures are exclusively available for Minneapolis/St. Paul local delivery or in-store pickup.

Not too pricey for high-end items

Amish Showroom follows a pricing structure that includes a 50% non-refundable deposit at the time of order placement. The remaining balance becomes due when your order is prepared for delivery. Prices at Amish Showroom are in line with other reputable Amish furniture stores, typically starting at a minimum of $1,000 for most products. However, for larger, multi-piece products, it's not uncommon to find yourself investing a few thousand dollars. To get an accurate comparison (at the time of this review) of the prices at Amish Showroom against other retailers in this review, we looked at three key items: dining tables, dining chairs, and beds. For dining tables at Amish Showroom, the prices ranged from $926 to $4,208. For dining chairs, you can expect costs to range between $214 to $671. Finally for beds, the prices at Amish Showroom range from $1,100 to $5,854. While some of the prices (like those for tables) start higher than some competitors, the higher-priced options are much more affordable.

Not a lot of discounts

While they do offer a sale page, it's worth noting that, at the time of this review, it featured only ten items. These items change out regularly and come in sets of two or more items, which may not be ideal for customers who are looking for a full matching set. In general, it's pretty hard to get a solid discount from Amish Showroom.

No return policy at all

A downside that is super important for customers to be aware of is that Amish Showroom operates with a strict no-return policy. This policy is rooted in the understanding that each piece of furniture they create is always going to be a little unique, from the grain patterns to the wood's natural characteristics. Embracing this uniqueness is part of the charm of Amish furniture. Amish Showroom notes that due to the unpredictable nature of how stain and wood grain will interact, they don't guarantee precise outcomes. Therefore, they do not permit returns based on "imperfections”, a policy that distinguishes them within the industry. So if a completely matching set is important to you, you might want to pick a different spot to browse.

Good reviews, but not many of them

Amish Showroom enjoys a solid reputation, underscored by an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau. While it's not uncommon for companies to curate reviews on their websites, it's noteworthy that independent sources online have awarded Amish Showroom 5-star ratings. However, it's worth keeping in mind that there are fewer than 25 total reviews available from third-party sites, which shows, at the very least, that Amish Showroom is much less popular than some of its competitors.

Solid option for low-cost handmade items

The extensive assortment of furniture available at Amish Showroom makes it a solid choice for those seeking inspiration across different styles and genres. Although their no-return policy may give some prospective buyers pause, and the lack of discounts may create a much more expensive bottom line, it's still worth checking out the Amish Showroom for guaranteed unique furniture pieces. However, this won't be the ideal spot if you're looking for a retailer that will promise a matching set every time.

DutchCrafters

• Prices for key items range from $239 to $17,495
• Offers all furniture types
• $250 flat-rate shipping
• Eco-friendly
• Sends stain and finish samples
• Regular promo discounts
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

DutchCrafters, one of the oldest online Amish furniture retailers on the market, has been delighting customers for over 17 years. The company was founded by Jim Miller, a proud Mennonite hailing from Indiana and Michigan.

Owner's heritage infuses the furniture

Driven by a deep-seated desire to promote products steeped in his heritage and infuse the furniture market with authenticity, Miller laid the foundation for DutchCrafters. The heart and soul of DutchCrafters' heirloom-quality pieces primarily hail from the Amish communities of Ohio, Indiana, and Pennsylvania. However their services extend far and wide, catering to customers across the contiguous United States.

Thoughtful site design is easy to browse

DutchCrafters' website has everything you could need. So, prepare to be wowed by its colossal inventory. It's not just about the run-of-the-mill furniture pieces here; DutchCrafters offers plenty of surprises, including play kitchens and rocking horses for the little ones, game tables for the leisure enthusiasts, dog beds for your furry companions, calendar frames to organize your life, bed steps, coat hooks, and more. And all of it is carefully organized across the site design. With a clean white yellow and brown design, and thoughtfully designed icons and buttons, the site is a breeze to browse.

Good filtering options

Once you get into different sections of the website the wide variety of filters make it simple to narrow down what you need. Some of the filters include:

• Price
• Estimated delivery time
• Category
• Style
• Material
• Adjustable base
• Storage

Plus, once you pick your favorite items, each product description is loaded with details and specifications, ensuring that you have all the necessary information at your fingertips, right down to the location where your piece of furniture will be lovingly crafted.

Sustainable practices and local sourcing

The process of creating items at DutchCrafters results in top-notch furniture. Some customers have shared that, after extensive research, they found DutchCrafters to be the beacon of value in the Amish furniture realm. On top of their locally sourced wood, DutchCrafters also offers furniture made of reclaimed, recycled, or responsibly sourced materials. Though, it's worth noting that the path from purchase to possession involves a bit of patience when dealing with DutchCrafters. Once you've made your furniture selection, you can order stain samples to preview your final product. Then, you should anticipate a production time of anywhere from 6 to 16 weeks, followed by 2 to 3 weeks for delivery. The delivery team will also make contact to coordinate the drop-off process and establish a convenient delivery time, to always keep you in the loop.

Full range of prices with budget-friendly options

While it's true that Amish furniture tends to come with a slightly higher price tag compared to mass-produced alternatives, DutchCrafters strives to strike a balance by offering very reasonable prices within the industry. To compare their prices with the other retailers in this review, we checked out three different pieces of furniture at DutchCrafters: dining room tables, dining chairs, and beds. For the dining room tables, the prices at DutchCrafters ranged from $676 to $6,329 which is a much lower price range than many competitors. For dining chairs, the prices ranged from $239 to $1,529 per chair. Finally, for beds, the prices ranged from $639 to $17,495 which includes both low-range and big-spending budgets. Across the board, the pricing is inclusive of different shoppers' needs but also highlights a host of budget-friendly options.

Regular promos available

While there aren't built-in discounts at DutchCrafters like at a few other competitors, they do offer regular promotions to keep costs down for customers. For example, at the time of this review, DutchCrafters was offering a sitewide sale of 15% off. This included everything. So, if you like something but want to wait for it to go on sale, you can check back periodically to see what promos are going on at DutchCrafters.

10-day return policy

Should you find yourself dissatisfied with your order upon receiving it and wish to initiate a return, DutchCrafters extends a 10-day window for you to send back your furniture pieces. Keep in mind that, owing to the custom-made nature of their products, a 15% restocking fee applies. Plus, the original delivery charges are non-refundable, and you'll be responsible for covering the return shipping expenses. This is standard for the industry, and it is a benefit as some Amish furniture retailers don't offer returns at all.

Shipping starts at $250

For shipping, DutchCrafters imposes a flat-rate fee of $250 for most of their product offerings. This might be on the higher end compared to some other Amish furniture retailers, so budget-conscious shoppers should take this into account. It's also worth noting that this doesn't include setup inside your home, which is a separate charge. For those seeking the white glove inside delivery service, which includes unloading, unpackaging, room placement, and light assembly, an additional $150 fee applies.

Some concerts on finish and quality

During our research into DutchCrafters' reputation, we found that DutchCrafters is owned by JMX Brands Inc. The company holds an impressive "A+” rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau. For regular reviews, DutchCrafters garners largely positive feedback from its customers with many sites showing a 4-star average rating. On the other hand, some sites only rated DutchCrafters a 3.6, which was much lower than many retailers in our review. For those unaccustomed to shelling out thousands of dollars on furniture, many found the investment well worth it. However, a handful expressed disappointment with aspects like stain finish, upholstery quality, or delivery times. It seems like most negative feedback stemmed from customers perhaps not fully understanding the intricacies of the Amish retail experience or neglecting to order stain samples in advance.

Missing out on customer feedback

DutchCrafters stands out as a solid destination for your Amish furniture needs, with tons of processes in place to support customers (like their return policy and regular promotional sales). They also offer the option to get samples of finishes and stains so customers can preview their items in their own homes. However, there are a few drawbacks that knocked DutchCrafters down the ratings a bit. First, the company's shipping costs are a little higher than average. Second, and more importantly, the retailer's feedback and ratings are much lower than many of its competitors. Considering that returns do cost customers a 15% restocking fee and return shipping, the fact that some customers weren't satisfied with their purchases is somewhat concerning. With this in mind, DutchCrafters earns a good rating in this review, falling below sites that have more positive feedback overall.

Cabinfield

• Prices for key items range from $713 to $8,247
• Offers all furniture types
• Sends stain and finish samples
• Free cancellation within 1 days
• Eco-friendly focus
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Cabinfield has a fun backstory that really highlights the homemade nature of their designs. During a family journey across the heartland of America, the founders stumbled upon the workshops of Amish craftsmen in the picturesque landscapes of Ohio, Indiana, and Pennsylvania. Inspired by these artisans, the founders of Cabinfield started their own business in partnership with the Amish craftsman who inspired them.

Pricing for sets

Since 2005, their family-owned business has been providing top-notch, custom-made furniture that reflects the uniqueness of every individual they serve. One standout feature of Cabinfield is that it offers its pricing in sets for items that generally need multiples (like dining chairs). This way you can easily see how much it will cost to buy a set of four chairs, instead of paying per item like with other retailers.

Site is clean and easy to use

One of the standout features of Cabinfield is its web design. With clean text, lots of blank space to keep the site from looking cluttered, and clean quick links, it's easy to find what you need at Cabinfield. With all of their furniture organized into three main categories (Fine Furniture, Rustic Lodge, and Outdoor), you can see everything they offer at a glance. This system is particularly helpful for customers who want to design based on their existing or chosen styling. If you want to see all of their options in a particular item (like all the chairs, for example), you can easily pop that into the search bar at the top of the site and get a full range of products right away.

Crafting process focused on eco-friendly practices

Cabinfield takes pride in offering furniture designs that are both beneficial to customers and environmentally conscious. Their authentic Amish furniture is skillfully crafted from sustainably harvested, locally sourced wood, and finished with a low-VOC varnish for a health-conscious approach. Cabinfield provides outdoor furniture constructed from recycled materials, engineered to withstand various challenges such as water, fungi, insects, stains, fading, and scratches.

6 step process to get your furniture

Getting your furniture from Cabinfield is a breeze with only six easy steps to complete:

1. Choose your preferred piece (or pieces).
2. Request complimentary swatch samples.
3. Personalize your selection, specifying dimensions, wood type, stain color, and other preferences.
4. Finalize your order by making a payment via check or card.
5. Wait while the artisans craft your furniture before dispatching it to your doorstep.
6. Receive your new furniture

Competitive pricing with bundle options

At Cabinfield the price ranges are a little different than competitors. For items that are usually lower-cost (like dining chairs), Cabinfield sells those in groups of four, so the prices appear to start much higher at this retailer than other Amish furniture companies. However, if you look at how much a full dining set costs at each retailer, you'll note that Cabinfield is just about average for the industry. To give you a clear look at the prices, we looked at three key items: dining tables, dining chairs, and beds. For the dining tables, prices at Cabinfield range from $713 to $6,213. For dining chairs, the prices (for a set of 4-6 chairs) range from $988 to $6,194. Finally, the prices for beds at Cabinfield range from $970 to $8,247. It's worth noting that most of these prices are at the "basic” level, so if you add custom styling or furniture stains, the prices will go up from there. On the bright side, Cabinfield only requires a 25% deposit at the time that you place your order for indoor furniture unless you purchase a custom item, and then the deposit is 50%.

No discounts available

One place that Cabinfield fell behind was its discounts. During our research into the site, we couldn't find any mentions of discounts or promotions. While this doesn't deeply impact the final price, it was disappointing when comparing Cabinfield to its competitors who usually offer some kind of discount, even if it's a short-term promo.

Limited cancelation and no returns

If it turns out you're not happy with your item, you do have the option to cancel with Cabinfield. For "Standard Orders," (those without custom items) you have one day to cancel without any fuss or fees. If you want to cancel after two days, you'll have to pay the credit card fees. Finally, after three days, you will lose 15% of the order's total value along with any related credit card charges and fees. On top of that, Cabinfield only offers returns if there is an error in manufacturing or damage from shipping. Otherwise, the furniture is yours no matter what.

Top scores from BBB and reviewers

The reputation and reviews for Cabinfield showcase a solid reputation. Cabinfield holds an impressive "A+” rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau. On top of that, the company shows customers are happy with their purchases with a solid 4.9 stars out of 5 from Google Reviews. The company also has an impressive 4.5-star rating on Facebook, where customers praise the high quality and detailed work of the customer service team when buying custom items. Overall, Cabinfield enjoys a reputation that matches its claims for high-quality service and furniture.

A nice middle-ground option

Overall, Cabinfield's most interesting feature is that it offers sets of items instead of individual purchases for items like dining chairs. With an easy-to-use website and stylized collections, it's a fun place to shop. However, it doesn't stand out more than many of the other sites we've reviewed. The prices remain about average and there are no regular sales to look forward to. While the no-returns policy is a little frustrating, customers note that they usually don't want to return items purchased from Cabinfield, which is a bonus. In general, Cabinfield is missing standout features compared with its competitors, and with no promo discounts or returns, we hesitate to put it among our top options.

Simply Amish

• Prices only available via call or visit
• Offers all furniture types
• Custom items available
• In-stock items available
• Lifetime warranty

Simply Amish originally opened in 1979 when a dedicated father and his sons began working on the art of furniture construction. While the Simply Amish website dazzles with its wide range of furniture offerings, there's just one (not so tiny) snag: the products on display are for viewing purposes only and cannot be directly purchased online.

Clumsy buying process

Each product description, though detailed and informative, lacks the crucial elements of pricing and an option to actually purchase the furniture. In order to start buying, you'll have to insert your zip code, which will lead you to the nearest authorized dealer in your vicinity. Unfortunately, this approach may pose challenges for customers who don't have dealers nearby.

No online shopping here

As you delve into the virtual aisles, you can shop by room, explore the world of live edge pieces, and even add those all-important finishing touches to your chosen products. What sets Simply Amish apart is the ability to customize your furniture online, offering a plethora of choices such as size, shape, wood type, stain color, height, edges, and more. But for an online retailer, there's a huge disappointment lurking under the beautiful site design of Simply Amish: you can't buy most items from the website. There are only a handful of items on the front page marked "buy online” and only one of them is a furniture item: the Limited Edition Bamboo Writing Desk. Other than that, customers are limited to their nearest in-person location, which almost nullifies the point of having a site to begin with.

All the modern design elements in one place

In terms of the Simply Amish design process, the company offers furniture in seven Northern Hardwoods and Bamboo, catering to various design styles from Contemporary to Modern, Arts & Crafts, and more. The company invites clients to explore customization possibilities, whether it's modifying existing creations, working on personalized designs, or collaborating to bring unique visions to life. The company prides itself on superior quality construction, rich burnished finishes, and up-to-date surface treatments.

No pricing on site

As there aren't any prices available online (you've got to go in person to a store for that), we couldn't do a price comparison for Simply Amish. For fortunate shoppers with a nearby dealer, the next step involves reaching out to the local dealer to express interest in specific pieces. The purchase journey at Simply Amish unfolds with a timeline of approximately 8-10 weeks from request to pickup. Depending on delivery routes, you may need to wait around 2-3 weeks on top of the lead time for your items to arrive.

Discounts are missing too

As there are no prices available on the site, it's no surprise that we couldn't find any discounts either. It's possible that there will be discounts or price reductions once you get to the Simply Amish in-store shopping experience, but from their online retail site, it's hard to say.

Lifetime warranty

While the site doesn't have a specific return policy, Simply Amish stands by its products with a lifetime guarantee. This means that if, in the lifetime of the original owner, any furniture piece fails due to normal household use, the company will either repair or replace it at no charge, underscoring their commitment to quality and durability.

Not rated and few reviews

The Better Business Bureau places Simply Amish in the category of non-accredited and unrated, making it challenging to gauge their standing overall. Further complicating the quest for insights into the company's reputation and product quality is the scarcity of online reviews. The handful that are out there pertain to particular local retailers, which only give a small snapshot look at the business practices in that one location. A deeper dive into details about the authorized dealer nearest to you may be necessary if you go forward with Simply Amish.

In-person shopping is too limiting

While there is much to admire about Simply Amish (that lifetime warranty is a huge bonus), there's a lingering sense of disappointment regarding the site as a whole. Since customers can't make direct online purchases, it's kind of a moot point. While there are more locations of Simply Amish than seen from the other retailers that don't offer online shopping, it's still frustrating for customers who are looking to bypass a long drive into a brick-and-mortar location. In an age of online exclusivity, where many retailers offer virtual buying experiences, this limitation seriously knocks Simply Amish down in our ratings.

Amish Furniture Collection

• Prices only available via call or visit
• Offers all furniture types
• Custom items available
• In-stock items available
• 5-star ratings from customers

Amish Furniture Collection has some beautiful pieces. The site's gorgeous photos show unique home pieces in the Amish Furniture Collection's local showroom. It's enough to excite any shopper.

Michigan only

Unfortunately, there's a significant caveat to shopping with Amish Furniture Collection: it caters exclusively to the Southeast Michigan region. For fortunate Michiganders, an exploration of their website or a visit to their showroom is highly recommended, as it promises a world of stylish possibilities. However, if you live in any other state (or even outside of the Southeast Michigan area), you're out of luck.

Clean site with competitive furniture styles

It's a serious disappointment that Amish Furniture Collection doesn't service a wider area. Their meticulously designed website is the epitome of professionalism, offering an extensive gallery of high-quality images that showcase their offerings in thoughtfully organized rooms. Amish Furniture Collection offers a curated selection of furniture styles, though it may not rival the expansive variety found at some competitors. For instance, if you're on the hunt for a kitchen table, you'll find options like circular, square, and rectangular complemented by different leg types and styles. While the range may appear limited, the potential for customization allows you to personalize your chosen piece by selecting your preferred colors and wood types. The only area where the site doesn't stand out is that many of the listings don't have prices on them at all, so even customers who want to buy in person won't have a clear idea of the cost until they call in or visit.

Ready-made and custom items

For local patrons, Amish Furniture Collection presents two ways to buy. The first option involves selecting from a range of ready-made items available in their storeroom, ensuring quick local delivery of your desired products. The second, more personalized approach involves choosing a piece from the website or in-store inventory and working with the Amish Furniture Collection team to customize it to your exact specifications. While this bespoke approach yields unique creations that perfectly align with your personal style, it does require a bit of patience, as the standard wait time for these customized pieces typically spans around 12 weeks.

No prices or purchases online

Customers looking through Amish Furniture Collection's website will quickly discover that it serves as a window-shopping experience rather than a virtual marketplace. The absence of an online purchasing option and pricing details poses a significant limitation. To glean specific information about costs, delivery times, available in-stock items, or the customization process, potential buyers need to either call the company or visit their physical store. While some of the ready-made pieces have ballpark prices, you still can't buy them from the website which is a huge disappointment.

Light on discounts

Another detail that's missing from the site is options for discounts. Since there aren't prices readily available on the site, there aren't any sales listed either. The only discount we found was a now out-of-date promotion for floor samples on sale. Unfortunately, the site didn't list any minimum order requirements or percentages for the discounts, so it's hard to know what to expect until you get there in person.

No return policy and unclear warranty

Unfortunately, Amish Furniture Collection's return policy is also a mystery. There are no specific details regarding returns on the retailer's website. On the bright side, we were able to find that all of the furniture items at Amish Furniture Collection are sold with a 1-year warranty. However, it's hard to tell what this warranty does cover, as the entire warranty page is dedicated to what the warranty will not cover.

Top scores from Google Reviews

Unsurprisingly, the local-only store doesn't have any presence on the Better Business Bureau. However, there are a decent amount of reviews for Amish Furniture Collection. For example, there are over 200 individual reviews all showing that the company has earned a full 5 stars. Themes across the reviews include praise for the quality of the items, the quick delivery, and the hands-on approach of the team members when working with custom items. All of the customers in the Google Reviews section were completely happy with their final purchases. It makes it even more of a bummer that most people can't shop here unless they want to take a moving truck on a road trip.

Only available in Michigan

Amish Furniture Collection offers high-quality pieces designed for all spaces from kitchens to bedrooms, offices to living rooms, and beyond. The feedback from customers who have frequented their Michigan-based store underscores their top-notch reputation for exceptional products and a smooth buying process. However, the extremely restricted service area - confined to Southeast Michigan - and the absence of an online sales platform knocked Amish Furniture Collection down significantly in the ratings. No matter how great the items are, if most customers can't buy them, it's a moot point. The bottom line? Any customers beyond Michigan's borders may find their shopping needs better met by exploring alternative, higher-rated Amish furniture establishments.