The Best Amish Furniture Stores

Thursday, September 28th

2023 Amish Furniture Store Reviews

Online Amish Furniture

• Return Policy: 1 year, 25% restocking fee

Online Amish Furniture ships their furniture to all of the United States, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, and many countries in Europe. The company was started in 1998 as a brick-and-mortar store and in 2006, Online Amish Furniture went exclusively online. Their goal is to provide long-lasting pieces to families looking for an alternative to disposable furniture.

Website Could Use An Update

You won't find the prettiest website when you navigate your way around Online Amish Furniture's store. It also loads quite slowly on some pages. However, this doesn't seem to have any reflection on their quality or customer satisfaction. It's still easy enough to find what you're looking for. The inventory here doesn't include as many modern-looking pieces as some other online Amish retailers, but if you're shopping for the sturdy classics, this is your place.

Sitewide Discounts

Online Amish Furniture offers sitewide discounts depending on the total cost of your order. The breakdown is as follows:

• $1,000 - $2,999: 2% off
• $3,000 - $4,999: 4% off
• $5,000 - $9,999: 6% off
• $10,000+: 10% off

Shipping $199

You'll periodically find additional onsite discounts to give you an even better deal. At the time of this review, an extra 5% off of purchases of $2,000 or more was offered. Delivery costs for furniture are a fixed rate of $199. If you want white glove delivery where the packages are brought into your home and assembled, the cost is $349.

Each Piece Custom Made

The timeframe in which customers will receive orders after they are purchased ranges from 10-16 weeks. Some larger items like dressers, chests of drawers, and hutches might take 12-16 weeks. Once orders are placed, Amish craftsmen in Ohio and/or Pennsylvania begin working on your product, so this explains the longer-than-typical wait period for delivery.

Generous Return Policy

When you place an order with Online Amish Furniture, you have 72 hours to cancel it for a full refund or make any changes. Once that window has passed and you receive your products, you have one year to contact customer service and return your furniture. You'll need to pay the full cost of shipping your items back as well as a 25% restocking fee. This is an extremely generous return policy that we haven't seen anywhere else.

Highest Rating

The Better Business Bureau gives Online Amish Furniture an A+ rating and plenty of customers have left positive reviews online. We wish that Online Amish Furniture had a larger variety of furniture, but if this company has products that fit your taste, it is a terrific place for your purchase. They earn our highest rating.

DutchCrafters

• Return Policy: No returns.

DutchCrafters has been selling Amish furniture online for over 17 years. The company was founded by a man named Jim Miller, a Mennonite from Indiana and Michigan. Miller started DutchCrafters as a way to promote products that represented his heritage and add authentic products to the furniture market. Their heirloom-quality pieces are primarily sourced from Ohio, Indiana, and Pennsylvania. They sell and ship their furniture throughout the contiguous United States.

Huge Inventory

DutchCrafters has one of the biggest inventories of Amish furniture we have found. They blow many of the competitors out of the water as far as selection goes. In addition to the standard pieces you think of when shopping for furniture like dining room tables, headboards, or desks, DutchCrafters sells things like play kitchens and rocking horses for kids, game tables, dog beds, calendar frames, bed steps, coat hooks, and more. DutchCrafters fits the bill of an online store that sells things you didn't even know you needed!

Fair Prices

Like all Amish furniture stores, the prices for pieces here are a little higher than what you might be used to, if you typically buy flimsier, mass-produced furniture. DutchCrafters' prices are very reasonable for the industry and sometimes even seem to be a little cheaper. Some customers have said after doing a lot of research for the furniture they wanted, they found the best deal at DutchCrafters. Each product description comes with plenty of details and specifications and even tells you in which location your piece of furniture will be made.

Long Delivery

Once furniture is purchased, it takes anywhere from 6-16 weeks to be made and then an additional 2-3 weeks for delivery. Once your order is ready, you'll receive an email confirmation with delivery details. The company delivering your furniture will also reach out to go over the delivery process and schedule a time to drop off your items.

Returns Accepted

If you're unhappy with your order after receiving it and want to send it back, you have up to 10 days to inform DutchCrafters. Since each furniture piece is custom made, there is a 15% restocking fee. The original delivery charges are not refundable, and you must pay the return shipping charges.

Shipping $249

DutchCrafters charges a $249 flat-rate shipping fee for most of the products they sell. This is one of the most expensive delivery costs we have seen among Amish furniture retailers. If you want white glove inside delivery service (drivers unload your items, unpackage them, take them to the correct rooms, and perform light assembly) this will cost an additional $150.

Mostly Postive Reviews

DutchCrafters receives good reviews from customers. For people who aren't used to spending thousands of dollars on furniture, many of them reported that they felt the investment was well worth it here. Some were unhappy with how their stain turned out, the upholstery on furniture, or the delivery times. However, most of the negative feedback could be attributed to customers not doing their due diligence to research how processes work when buying from Amish retailers or not ordering stain samples ahead of time.

One Of The Best

Overall, DutchCrafters is a great place to buy from. We are especially impressed with their huge selection of inventory and pricing. We strongly recommend that you take a look at DutchCrafters for your next Amish Furniture purchase.

Amish Furniture Factory

• Return Policy: Refunds can be given, minus a 15% restocking fee and shipping costs, within 30 days of delivery

Amish Furniture Factory sells genuine Amish furniture to customers across the United States. Although their website is not as appealing as some competitors', they have a big selection of furniture and it is easy to find what you're looking for. The turnaround time for products bought from Amish Furniture Factory is typically 8-12 weeks because 95% of their product line is not actually in-stock and has to be hand-crafted after an order is placed.

Search By Room

You can narrow down the products at Amish Furniture Factory by the area of the house you're shopping for. These include:

• Baby Room
• Bedroom
• Dining Room
• Entertainment & TV
• Kid's Play Room
• Kitchen & Bar
• Lawn, Garden, & Patio
• Living Room
• Miscellaneous
• Office
• Rustic Cabin & Lodge

Volume Discounts

Volume discounts are available from 2% - 14% on purchases. Starting at $1,000, for every additional thousand dollars you spend, an extra percent is taken off of your purchase. For orders of $1,000 or more, you'll need to put down a 30% deposit to get your furniture started. From there you'll have three more months before delivery to pay off the remaining balance. Most products are $700 and above - you should expect to pay at least a thousand dollars or more on most pieces found here.

Free Stain And Finish Samples

Sometimes it can be hard to know exactly what stain color would match your space just based on an online photo. Different lighting can skew the way something looks on your computer. Luckily Amish Furniture Factory will send you free stain and finish samples in the mail if you request them. We highly recommend doing this so that you can make sure you order exactly what you want the first time around and see how different colors look with your flooring, walls, and other furniture in the room. If you don't request samples and end up wanting to send your furniture back because it doesn't match like you'd hoped, you'll be denied a refund.

Return Policy

If you're unsatisfied with your order for any other reason, you are able to return it for a refund within 30 days of delivery. You will still have to pay to ship the furniture both ways and pay a 15% restocking fee. The exception is if your items come broken or defective. In this case, you get a full refund without having to pay the restocking fee. Customers who place an order have 72 hours to cancel their order free of charge.

Shipping Costs Vary

Shipping costs vary based on the products ordered. Rates are calculated based on the approximate size and weight of the items and the shipping destination. These are calculated in the shopping cart online after you've provided your zip code.

High Customer Satisfaction

Testimonials from satisfied customers can be viewed on the Amish Furniture Factory website. Often we are skeptical of reviews directly from a website because they may highlight only positive feedback and get filtered. However, many of the reviews here contain customers' photographs of the furniture they purchased. These show how high quality each piece is. The Better Business Bureau gives Amish Furniture Factory an A+ rating, and feedback from third-party sites gives more credibility to the fact that people really like buying from this retailer.

Solid Choice

We are impressed with the selection at Amish Furniture Factory as well as the number of satisfied customers who have made purchases here. Since you can order free color samples and get all of the information you need before you order, we are confident that you'll be happy with anything you purchase from their online store. Amish Furniture Factory has earned one of our top ratings for Amish furniture.

Amish Showroom

• Return Policy: No returns

Amish Showroom is based out of Minnesota. They work directly with a small Amish woodworking shop that builds orders on demand. The process of ordering, shipping, and delivery usually takes 4-12 weeks depending on the item. Amish Showroom has an "in-stock" section of their website with a variety of products that are ready to ship or pick up, but unfortunately they are only available for Minneapolis/St. Paul local delivery or in-store pickup.

Ton Of Variety

There is a ton of variety in the products carried by Amish Showroom. For example, if you're looking for a dining room table, you can choose from styles that include trestle, leg, pedestal, tall gathering, narrow, breadboard, long expanding, live edge, and breakfast nooks. With every category of furniture, there is a fairly long list of even more specific pieces to choose from. Categories include:

• Sale Items
• Dining Room
• Living Room
• Bedroom
• Office
• Vanities
• Entryway

Stain Sample

To make sure you order exactly what you want from Amish Showroom, they recommend giving them a call to go over stain choices and any other details relevant to the purchase. After you place your order, they will send a stain sample for your review. This helps guarantee that you order the right stain and match it with surrounding room colors to your satisfaction.

Competitive Pricing

There is a 50% non-refundable deposit due at the time of order. The remaining amount is due at the time your order is delivered. Prices here are comparable to other Amish furniture stores. You'll pay at least $1,000 for almost any given product, but could easily spend a few thousand dollars on multi-piece products. They have a sale page, but at the time of this review, there were only 5 total products listed there. In other words, you probably won't score a great deal this way.

No Refund Policy

Before ordering from Amish Showroom, keep in mind there is no refund policy. They make it clear that grain patterns vary with each product and it's part of the beauty of the furniture. They can never be sure exactly how the stain and wood grain will turn out, so they don't allow returns based on the understanding that each piece of furniture is unique.

Check It Out

The Better Business Bureau gives Amish Showroom an A+ rating. Unfiltered customer reviews found in various places online give 5-star ratings nearly across the board. The huge assortment of furniture here makes Amish Showroom a no-brainer when it comes to browsing different styles for ideas. Their no-return policy might make some customers shy away from buying anything here, but other than that we recommend checking out the beautiful pieces found at Amish Showroom.

Countryside Amish Furniture

• Return Policy: No returns

The real-wood furniture sold by Countryside Amish Furniture is primarily manufactured in Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Indiana. All of their pieces are sealed with a conversion varnish that helps protect against everyday wear and tear. They feel strongly that each piece of furniture they sell is not just a "look or style", but rather a piece of art.

Types Of Furniture

The specific types of furniture that you can select at Countryside Amish Furniture include:

• Arts and Crafts
• Traditional
• Farmhouse
• Mid Century
• Mission
• Shaker
• Queen Anne
• Walnut
• Contemporary
• French Country
• Cherry Wood

Outdoor Products Too

In addition to indoor furniture for your dining room, bedroom, office, living room, and kid's room, Countryside Amish Furniture has a huge selection of outdoor products as well. These include patio swings, lounge seating, patio benches, rockers, and more.

To make sure you get the perfect match for your home, you can order samples of stains, fabrics, leathers, outdoor fabrics, and poly colors.

Shipping $150

The cost for delivery and set up anywhere in the United States is $150. A few customers that have bought smaller pieces from Countryside Amish Furniture have complained about that: if you're ordering huge bedroom sets, you should be paying more for shipping than if you order a small side table or chest. Some have felt that the delivery fee was extremely high for the products they ordered.

Reasonable Pricing

Pricing at Countryside Amish Furniture is reasonable for the quality and is comparable to other Amish furniture stores. If you spend $2,000, you get 5% off your total purchase. If you spend $5,000, you get 8% off and if you spend $8,000 you get 10% off. That's a good chunk of change to spend regardless of the discount, but it might help customers who have had their eye on some expensive pieces. Since every item is made-to-order at Countryside Amish Furniture, they do not accept returns.

Enviromentally Sustainable

We really like the focus on sustainability at this store. They are environmentally friendly and make sure all the hardwoods used to create furniture are responsibly harvested and domestically grown. Since everything is made of pure wood, it should be able to last a lifetime. Surprisingly, however, some customers have complained that their pieces started to break apart within a few months or years and that they had difficulty working with customer service to resolve the issues.

Worth A Look

Countryside Amish Furniture has many pieces to choose from. We like that there is a wide variety of styles and specific products within each category. It's interesting to browse their many unique outdoor furniture pieces as well. Their no-return policy is understandable, but may be an issue for some customers who are leery of spending so much money on furniture. The $150 flat-rate delivery and set-up fee might also be a turn-off for anyone looking to make a smaller purchase here. Aside from those two things Countryside Amish Furniture has a great selection, so you may want to browse their inventory - particularly if you're looking for a hard-to-find piece you can't get elsewhere.

Pinecraft

• Return Policy: No return time frame specified, but a 15% restocking fee applies

Pinecraft sells Amish furniture that is crafted in Ohio, Indiana, Pennsylvania, and Montana. They are named after their local Amish community, Pinecraft, in the Sarasota, Florida area. Pinecraft receives an A- rating from the Better Business Bureau and customers overall have good things to say about their quality, customer service, and online ordering process.

Outdoor Furniture Highlighted

Pinecraft sells both indoor and outdoor furniture, but their outdoor furniture is highlighted when you arrive at the site. Right away we saw amazing Amish chicken coops that looked so nice a human could live in one, dreamy playground equipment, princess castles, and big playhouses with slides. If you want the coolest yard in town, this is the place to shop.

Amish Furniture Categories

In addition to outdoor furniture they also sell decor, gardening products, and storage items. Other categories of Amish furniture available at Pinecraft include:

• Patio Sets
• Porch Swings and Stands
• Patio Benches
• Patio Tables
• Patio Chairs
• Bedroom Furniture
• Kitchen & Dining Furniture
• Living Room Furniture
• Office Furniture
• Outdoor Playtime
• Toys
• Animal Supplies

Indoor Furntiure Selection Lacking

We noticed that their indoor furniture selection is somewhat lacking. For example, they don't sell indoor dining tables here, which is a bit odd. They sell office chairs, but not desks. Their focus is definitely on outdoor furniture, which is great, but if you're in the market to furnish the inside of your house, you might have to look elsewhere for certain items.

Get That Discount

If you sign up for Pinecraft's email list, you'll receive 10% off your next order. This is definitely worth doing since that could save you a couple hundred dollars if you're buying something big! Pinecraft says all orders are final, but if you choose to ship your products back, you'll be charged a 15% delivery fee. They don't give a timeframe for returns, so we recommend contacting customer service about your particular order.

Free Shipping

We did a double take when we read that orders over $199 ship free from Pinecraft. This is quite the deal considering many other Amish furniture stores charge a few hundred dollars for each piece they deliver. The only exceptions might be for large structures like barns, sheds, playhouses, coops, etc. Most orders will likely qualify for free shipping though, since many of the products cost at least a few hundred dollars.

Fun Place To Shop

Overall, Pinecraft is a really fun place to look for Amish furniture. We especially recommend shopping here if you want outdoor furniture of any kind. They have a great selection of really unique products, and we are impressed with their low shipping fee and reasonable prices. They are lacking in the indoor furniture arena, so they aren't our first pick for those types of products, but for all other Amish furniture purchases, Pinecraft is a fantastic place to shop.

Simply Amish

• Return Policy: Case-by-case basis

Simply Amish was founded in 1979 by a father and his sons who learned furniture construction together on their family farm. Here you can browse over 50 collections of furniture, shop by room, view live edge pieces, and buy the finishing touches for your products. You can even style your own furniture online by specifying size, shape, wood, stain, height, edges, and more.

No Option To Buy

Simply Amish has plenty of products to view on their website. However, that's just the problem: the pieces are only available for viewing and not for actually buying online. Each product description gives dimensions, construction information, stain options, and more, but there is no pricing or option to purchase the pieces. In order to buy furniture, you can input your zip code and get directions to a dealer nearest you that sells Simply Amish furniture. Unfortunately, not everyone will have locations close by, so this will really limit who will find this site useful.

Contact A Dealer

If you do have a dealer nearby, you will need to contact them about pieces you're interested in and see if they can order in anything for you that they don't already stock. The time it takes to request a piece of furniture and pick it up is about 8-10 weeks. Depending on delivery routes, it may take an additional 2-3 weeks on top of that for the products to arrive.

Case-by-case Returns

If you buy furniture from Simply Amish, keep in mind they don't have a black and white return policy. Everything is considered on a case-by-case basis. To request a refund, a phone number and email address are provided on the website. However, they do have a lifetime guarantee on their products, which means if their furniture fails during normal household use in the lifetime of the original owner, they will either repair it or replace it at no charge.

Unrated With The BBB

The Better Business Bureau has Simply Amish listed as non-accredited and unrated. There are hardly any reviews to be found about this company online. You'll likely have to delve into details about the dealer nearest you if you are really interested in their reputation and the quality of pieces listed on this site.

Disappointing

We are mostly disappointed that you can't buy directly online from this retailer because it makes purchasing Amish furniture much more complicated. There are plenty of online-exclusive retailers that provide Amish furniture, so it would be easiest to shop there instead.

Amish Furniture Collection

• Return Policy: Unspecified

Amish Furniture Collection screams class. Their website is professional and provides pictures of all their pieces, making it obvious that everything they sell would fit in either a modern or traditional home. Furniture is picked up directly from the Amish in Ohio and Indiana in an effort to keep costs lower for customers.

Out Of Luck If You're Not In Michigan

One big downside with Amish Furniture Collection is that they only serve Southeast Michigan. This is disappointing since we really like what is offered here. If you live in the Michigan area, we highly recommend checking out their website or showroom. For everyone else, you're out of luck and will have to look elsewhere for Amish Furniture.

In Stock Or Custom Order

For local shoppers, there are two ways to buy items from Amish Furniture Collection. The first way is to order what is already made and ready to ship from their storeroom. This is the fastest way to get the products you want. The other option is to find something you like on their website or in-store and request the stain color, wood type, dimensions, and so on to customize the piece to exactly what you have in mind. The standard wait time for this process is about 12 weeks: you'll get something unique to your style, but you'll have to be patient while it's being built.

Can't Purchase Online Or See Pricing

Customers can view photos of what's available at Amish Furniture Collection, but they can't actually purchase anything online or see pricing. For specific details about cost, delivery times, what's in-stock, or customization, a phone number, address, and contact form are available to reach out to customer service.

Few Styles To Choose From

There are few styles of furniture available at Amish Furniture Collection. If you're looking for a kitchen table, they come in circles, squares, rectangles, and a small variety of leg types and styles. Mostly they carry staple pieces of furniture that have enough variety to fit different tastes, but most competitors have more to choose from. You can change the colors and wood types if you want, so that does add a handful of additional options.

No Return Policy Listed

If you end up purchasing something from Amish Furniture Collection, you'll have to ask what the return policy is. This may be dependent on whether or not the piece was customized. There is no return policy listed on their website since it isn't actually built for sales.

Better Luick Elsewhere

Amish Furniture Collection undoubtedly has high-quality pieces for sale. Whether you're looking to furnish your kitchen, bedroom, office, living room, or another space, they have all the essentials. Customers who have shopped at their store in Michigan have great things to say about the products and the buying process. They've earned a lower rating from us because their Michigan-only service area is limiting and there is no online sales process. Because many people won't be able to get anything here, you may want to try shopping at one of the higher-rated Amish furniture stores we evaluated.