Amish Outlet Store Review

Tuesday, January 21st

2025 Amish Furniture Store Reviews

Amish Outlet Store

• Prices for key items range from $180 to $16,348
• Offers all furniture types
• Custom items available
• In-stock items available
• Discounts depending on promos
• 10-day returns
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Amish Outlet Store is one of the top destinations to find Ohio Amish furniture, mission furniture, and shaker furniture. With a legacy spanning over two decades, this family-owned establishment, nestled in the heart of Amish country near Smithville, Ohio, takes pride in offering top-notch, American-made furniture.

Extensive quality collection

Their extensive collection showcases handcrafted Amish furniture and promises competitive prices across the board. Crafted by highly skilled Amish artisans, each piece is custom-made, employing time-honored techniques and the finest solid wood and materials. This results in furniture that marries durability, functionality, and unparalleled aesthetic appeal.

Streamlined website is easy to browse

One of our favorite things about browsing at the Amish Outlet Store is their web interface. With easy-to-use drop-down menus, you can find everything you need in easy-to-read lists categorized by type. Some of the menus include:

• In-stock inventory
• Quick-ship furniture
• Bedroom
• Dining room
• Living room
• Rustic furniture
• Entertainment
• Reclaimed barnwood
• Bathroom
• Outdoor furniture

Thoughtful category organization

There are a ton more categories than this, ensuring that any type of furniture customers might want is available with easy-to-browse photos. Each category includes further organization. For example under "bedroom" you can find:

• Amish bedroom collections
• Amish cedar/blanket chests
• Amish nightstands
• Amish bedroom sets
• Amish dressers
• Amish beds
• Amish jewelry chests/dressing tables

Hand-made hardwoods only

Amish Outlet Store's production process prioritizes the use of premium materials to make sure customers get the highest quality every time. The company's furniture is exclusively crafted from North American kiln-dried hardwood. They offer a diverse range of woods, including oak, maple, walnut, brown maple, hickory, and rustic woods like cherry and quarter-sawn white oak. Furthermore, Amish Outlet Store offers customers the opportunity to tailor their furniture to their specific preferences, with a wide variety of stain options available for customization. While they do offer in-stock furniture you can buy as-is, you can also participate in the design process for a personalized and seamless fit within your existing home decor.

Prices offer items for all budgets

To compare prices across various retailers featured in this review, we checked out the same (or similar) items at each Amish furniture store: dining tables, dining chairs, and beds, among other items. Since Amish Outlet Store required shoppers to limit the dining tables to a particular type, we specifically looked at "leg tables” which have four legs with one at each corner. The price range for these tables was $860 to $1,945. For the dining chairs, pieces start at $180 and go as high as $1,370 per chair. Finally, for beds, the prices ranged from $806 to $16,348. Notably, there are more higher-priced items at Amish Outlet Store than other retailers, though they also offer a number of budget-friendly styles too. They offer a competitive range for all budgets whether you want something basic or more luxurious.

Occasional discounts available

While there are discounts at Amish Outlet Store, they are dependent on particular promotions and often have limited time frames. For example, at the time of this review, Amish Outlet Store was offering a discount from 5% to 10% off your entire order depending on what you buy. However, it was noted that the discounts did not extend to cover shipping costs or outdoor furniture purchases.

Shipping from $249

In terms of shipping, Amish Outlet store offers Standard Residential Curbside Delivery, priced at $249. This is offered to most US zip codes, with items being delivered as close to the customer's home as possible and unloaded by professionals from the delivery truck. However, customers are responsible for moving the furniture indoors and any necessary assembly. For $199 extra, you can opt for White Glove In-home Delivery, which covers the cost of the delivery staff bringing in your furniture, placing it in the chosen room, and fully assembling the pieces. As another option, customers may choose to pick up their orders in person from the company's Ohio warehouse, which can help them save on shipping costs but does require that customers have their own moving vehicle and furniture blankets.

10-day limited returns

Amish Outlet Store offers returns for standard items within a ten-day window. Customers are required to cover the return shipping expenses, and there is a 20% restocking fee. Certain exceptions apply to this policy, including instances of shipping damage where Amish Outlet Store offers repair or replacement at no additional cost. However, keep in mind that customized furniture, involving alterations from the standard size and design, as well as specialty finishes or stain-matched items, are also excluded from the return policy.

Customers love the quality

Amish Outlet Store is a standout service according to reviews and the Better Business Bureau. Customers who left verified reviews on third-party sites noted that they loved the quality of the items. Many opted for the White Glove shipping option and particularly praised how simple and stress-free the delivery process was. The only complaint customers had was that they wanted Amish Outlet Store to add color photos to each item to show how different finishes would look. However, the company had an overall rating average of 4.5 stars out of 5 across multiple review sites. On top of that Amish Outlet Store holds an "A+” rating as well as accreditation from the BBB.

Widest variety of styles and prices

In terms of selection and variety, Amish Outlet Store is one of the top contenders out there. Offering in-home delivery and setup, Amish Outlet Store streamlines the whole process from furniture selection to furniture set-up. They offer budget-friendly options as low as $180 and also cater to the higher budgets with hand-made items in the thousands. There are only two things that keep Amish Outlet Store from the top three: they don't offer quality previews of their different stains (which is a common customer complaint) and their discounts and returns are limited, making it difficult for customers to keep costs down even when shopping the lower-cost items. However, if you're looking for a wide variety of items that can be tailored to your aesthetic, Amish Outlet Store is definitely worth browsing.