Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

DutchCrafters Review

Wednesday, October 20th

2021 Amish Furniture Store Reviews

DutchCrafters Review 4.5 Star Rating


4.5 Star Rating
  • Return Policy: No returns.

DutchCrafters has been selling Amish furniture online for over 17 years. The company was founded by a man named Jim Miller, a Mennonite from Indiana and Michigan. Miller started DutchCrafters as a way to promote products that represented his heritage and add authentic products to the furniture market. Their heirloom-quality pieces are primarily sourced from Ohio, Indiana, and Pennsylvania. They sell and ship their furniture throughout the contiguous United States.

Huge Inventory

DutchCrafters has one of the biggest inventories of Amish furniture we have found. They blow many of the competitors out of the water as far as selection goes. In addition to the standard pieces you think of when shopping for furniture like dining room tables, headboards, or desks, DutchCrafters sells things like play kitchens and rocking horses for kids, game tables, dog beds, calendar frames, bed steps, coat hooks, and more. DutchCrafters fits the bill of an online store that sells things you didn't even know you needed!

Fair Prices

Like all Amish furniture stores, the prices for pieces here are a little higher than what you might be used to, if you typically buy flimsier, mass-produced furniture. DutchCrafters' prices are very reasonable for the industry and sometimes even seem to be a little cheaper. Some customers have said after doing a lot of research for the furniture they wanted, they found the best deal at DutchCrafters. Each product description comes with plenty of details and specifications and even tells you in which location your piece of furniture will be made.

Long Delivery

Once furniture is purchased, it takes anywhere from 6-16 weeks to be made and then an additional 2-3 weeks for delivery. Once your order is ready, you'll receive an email confirmation with delivery details. The company delivering your furniture will also reach out to go over the delivery process and schedule a time to drop off your items.

Best Amish Furniture Companies

Returns Accepted

If you're unhappy with your order after receiving it and want to send it back, you have up to 10 days to inform DutchCrafters. Since each furniture piece is custom made, there is a 15% restocking fee. The original delivery charges are not refundable, and you must pay the return shipping charges.

Shipping $249

DutchCrafters charges a $249 flat-rate shipping fee for most of the products they sell. This is one of the most expensive delivery costs we have seen among Amish furniture retailers. If you want white glove inside delivery service (drivers unload your items, unpackage them, take them to the correct rooms, and perform light assembly) this will cost an additional $150.

Mostly Postive Reviews

DutchCrafters receives good reviews from customers. For people who aren't used to spending thousands of dollars on furniture, many of them reported that they felt the investment was well worth it here. Some were unhappy with how their stain turned out, the upholstery on furniture, or the delivery times. However, most of the negative feedback could be attributed to customers not doing their due diligence to research how processes work when buying from Amish retailers or not ordering stain samples ahead of time.

One Of The Best

Overall, DutchCrafters is a great place to buy from. We are especially impressed with their huge selection of inventory and pricing. We strongly recommend that you take a look at DutchCrafters for your next Amish Furniture purchase.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Amish Furniture?

When people hear the term "Amish furniture" they will often go to great lengths, spend more money, and wait a long time to have something made for them. This unique and specific type of furniture first gained attention in the 1920's when American folk art was becoming popular.

The Amish people in Indiana, Ohio, and Pennsylvania are typically the ones who make these sought-after pieces. Luckily you don't have to travel around the United States or find a specialty store in order to get your hands on them, but rather you can shop online and have something made and delivered direct to your home.

The Best Amish Furniture Stores Compare Amish Furniture Stores Compare Amish Furniture Store Reviews What are the best Amish Furniture Stores Best Amish Furniture Store Reviews

Amish Furniture Store FAQ

The Amish are a Christian group in North America whose roots go back to the late 17th century. Their church is a branch off of the Mennonite faith. Today, the largest groups of Amish people are mainly found in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, Iowa, Illinois, and Kansas. They believe in separating themselves from the world by wearing plain clothing, being slow to accept new technologies, and using bicycles or horse-and-buggies as their main source of transportation. The Amish are known for being excellent farmers, constructing their own tools, and being hard workers.
The level of craftsmanship that goes into Amish furniture is of higher quality than what you would find at a store that sells mass-manufactured items. Rather than lasting a few years, Amish furniture is such high quality that it can be passed down for generations and still look brand new if well cared for. Each item is handmade by an Amish woodworker, often on their own land. Amish furniture businesses are almost always family-owned and operated.
The Amish reject most modern machinery that requires operation by electricity. When making furniture, they often use handmade tools and alternative power sources like hydraulic pumps, propane gas, or compressed air. They make all their furniture by hand with real wood (i.e. no particle board or laminate), which is why it can take months for an order to be completed. It is not uncommon to see furniture made without nails, but rather using advanced joinery techniques that can last for generations.
Yes! When you're browsing Amish furniture online, you'll find that for any given piece you're interested in, you can usually pick the color of wood and sometimes add other details or engravings. Each piece of Amish furniture is made just for the buyer and no one else. Because of this, no two pieces are exactly alike and you get to request all of your specifications before the product is constructed.
You can get just about any type of furniture you want from an online Amish retailer. You'll find all the basics like bedroom sets, rocking chairs, tables, dining chairs, desks, and more. Some retailers also sell porch swings, outdoor playgrounds, patio sets, and office furniture. If you're wanting a timeless, long-lasting piece of furniture for any space in your house, you'll be able to find it Amish-made.
Amish furniture is always more expensive than mass-produced furniture because every piece is made of solid wood and crafted by hand. The quality of your furniture will far exceed anything you'll find elsewhere, making it well worth the cost. The price of any given item depends on the item and from what type of wood it is made. When shopping for Amish furniture, you can expect to spend hundreds to thousands of dollars for any given piece.
If you have an Amish community near you in the northern United States, you might be able to visit a showroom to get an idea of the quality and designs available. Some Amish retailers even work with other home furnishing stores throughout the US and supply them with some staple furniture products. However, most of the time when buying Amish furniture, you shop online: select the construction materials you want and any other customizable features and have it built for you. This is the most convenient and personalized way to buy Amish furniture.
Depending on the retailer, Amish furniture is sometimes returnable as long as it is not custom. Some retailers have a 25%+ restocking fee for anything returned, while others don't allow returns at all. Amish furniture is well-made piece-by-piece, so you won't need to worry about quality as much as you would if you were buying furniture from a traditional retailer. Because the pieces are typically made exactly to your specifications, most of the time there would be no need for returns. Read the return policy listed by the Amish furniture store you choose to buy from before placing an order so you know what to expect.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Amish furniture has become popular due to its high quality, excellent craftsmanship, and traditional style. There are many retailers that sell furniture, but they are often made with particle board or laminate, which tend to break more easily and support less weight. Amish furniture is typically made completely out of wood, hand-selected to fit each furniture piece. The durability of Amish furniture allows it to be used for generations.

Another reason to love Amish furniture is that they are considered "green products". The making of the furniture is a sustainable practice since the tools used are often powered by hydraulic and pneumatic power from diesel compressors. Since Amish beliefs discourage the use of electricity, they use alternative resources to make furniture. The Amish are known for never taking shortcuts to save time or money and they take great pride in their process of furniture making.

When purchasing Amish furniture online, we suggest you keep the following criteria in mind:

  • Cost. Remember that Amish furniture is higher-quality than you'll find in a lot of places - and priced accordingly. However, when comparing prices between retailers, pay attention to how a piece is made and how it measures up against the competition.
  • Return Policy. If the furniture doesn't fit in your space, like you'd hoped, or it happens to break in shipping, are you able to send it back for a refund or exchange?
  • Selection. When buying furniture, you often have a particular color or style in mind. Finding a store with a big selection will help ensure you're able to purchase something you really like.

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked a variety of Amish furniture retailers. We hope this information helps you find the pieces that will suit your style and needs for years to come!

See the Best Amish Furniture Store
The Best Reviews of Amish Furniture Stores