What is the best audiobook service? You're not alone if you've ever wished you could read more but can't find the time. Maybe you're commuting an hour each way to work, folding endless loads of laundry, or logging miles on the treadmill. Audiobook services solve a problem that's become all too common: wanting to consume great literature, learn new skills, or just escape into a good story, but lacking the chunks of uninterrupted time to sit down with a physical book.
Fair
Founded in 2000, BookLender lets you rent physical audiobook CDs and MP3-CDs by mail - yes, actual discs delivered to your door. While most audiobook services have gone fully digital, BookLender distinguishes itself with its old-school rental model where you can keep titles as long as you want with no late fees.
Physical audiobooks delivered straight to your door
BookLender offers both Limited and Unlimited rental plans for physical audiobook CDs. With Unlimited plans, you'll get a set number of audiobooks "at-a-time" (1-6 or even 9) with free shipping both ways. Once you return an audiobook, they'll automatically send your next selection. Limited plans, on the other hand, restrict you to a specific number of audiobooks per month (1-3). Monthly plans start at $15.49 for one Limited audiobook per month, while Unlimited plans begin at $26.49 monthly for one audiobook at-a-time. First-time subscribers get 50% off their first month - making it as low as $7.75 to try it out. Here's a breakdown:
CDs vs. MP3-CDs: a primer for the analog-curious
If you're a young person getting into physical media for the first time as part of the analog renaissance, you might be wondering about the difference between standard audiobook CDs and MP3-CDs. We've got you. Standard audiobooks on CD use the traditional audio CD format, which holds about 80 minutes of audio per disc - meaning a 10-hour audiobook might require 7-8 separate discs. MP3-CDs, on the other hand, compress the audio files using the MP3 format, allowing an entire audiobook (often 10+ hours) to fit on a single disc. While this sounds more convenient, MP3-CDs won't play in all CD players; you'll need a device specifically compatible with MP3-CDs or a computer with a CD drive. Some Blu-Ray DVD players can also handle MP3-CDs.
Is BookLender worth it compared to digital services?
When comparing BookLender's pricing to digital audiobook services, both their Unlimited and Limited plans come up short on value. At $26.49 monthly for just one audiobook at a time in the Unlimited plan, you're paying significantly more than credit-based services which typically offer one permanent audiobook for around $14 per month. Even the Limited plan at $15.49 for just one audiobook per month is still pricier than most digital subscription services - and remember, with BookLender you don't even get to keep the audiobook. You're essentially paying more for a temporary rental than you would for permanent ownership through a digital service. Add in the inconvenience of physical delivery versus instant digital access, and BookLender's value proposition becomes even harder to justify. Unless you specifically need physical audiobook CDs - perhaps for a car without Bluetooth or for someone who genuinely prefers tangible media - digital services simply offer better value and convenience for most listeners.
Limited selection leaves you wanting more
BookLender's catalog of 250,000 titles sounds impressive until you realize it's about half the size of what their most popular rivals offer, and that that number might include books BookLender has on paperback, but not in audiobook format. You'll likely find yourself searching for titles that simply aren't available - we found the "new releases" section to be completely empty, and when we sorted BookLender's "bestsellers" category by newest to oldest, we discovered the most recent title was an astonishing two years old. Why might that be? Well, audiobooks aren't always produced on CD anymore. No matter how much you love physical media, if you're looking for fresh audiobook content, you might be forced to consider digital alternatives instead.
Return policy is a breeze, but customer service leaves a lot to be desired
Returning your audiobook CDs is straightforward, thankfully - they'll include a return mailer in your package. You're required to return the same number of titles you receive, though they don't have to be from the same order. BookLender processes returns the same day they receive them. If you fall in love with an audiobook, you can keep it by clicking the "Keep Book" button on your Orders page (though some limited-availability titles can't be kept). Just don't lose those return mailers - replacements are "costly" according to BookLender.
Customer service exists, but don't expect a robust online presence
BookLender maintains a minimal online footprint with just a sparse Better Business Bureau listing sporting a "B+" rating. They've had only one complaint in the last three years (which was resolved). While their testimonials page showcases glowing customer feedback about their "stellar service" and quick email responses, remember that these are cherry-picked positive reviews. No matter how hard you look, you probably won't find the kind of comprehensive third-party reviews that might reveal any common complaints or issues - which simply reflects BookLender's small, niche position in today's vastly digital audiobook landscape.
An audiobook service that time forgot - with perks for a very specific audience
Looking for an audiobook service that delivers physical CDs to your door? BookLender might be your only remaining option - but that doesn't mean it's keeping up with the times. You'll appreciate the straightforward rental system and hassle-free returns, but the severely outdated catalog (newest titles are two years old) and limited selection (half the size of digital competitors) make this a tough sell for most listeners. BookLender is only recommended for die-hard CD listeners. If you're comfortable with modern technology, you'll find virtually every aspect of this service better served by digital alternatives.
Continued from above...
You're not alone if you've ever wished you could read more but can't find the time. Maybe you're commuting an hour each way to work, folding endless loads of laundry, or logging miles on the treadmill. Audiobook services solve a problem that's become all too common: wanting to consume great literature, learn new skills, or just escape into a good story, but lacking the chunks of uninterrupted time to sit down with a physical book.
Whether you're a multitasker by necessity or simply prefer listening to reading, audiobooks let you turn downtime into story time - and that's a win for anyone trying to squeeze more culture into their day. But not all audiobook services are created equal. Some operate on a subscription model, giving you a set number of credits each month to "purchase" titles you'll own forever. Others work more like Netflix, offering unlimited streaming from a catalog as long as you keep paying your monthly fee.
Then there are the pay-per-title services, which let you buy audiobooks outright without any recurring commitment. Finally, there are library-based audiobook services, where your free ticket to entry is your library card. The model you choose will depend on how many books you listen to, whether you like to revisit favorites, and how much you're willing to spend.
Subscription services tend to dominate the audiobook landscape. They're popular because they offer decent value if you're a regular listener, typically giving you one or two credits per month that you can exchange for any audiobook in their catalog, regardless of retail price. This model works well if you devour lengthy fantasy epics or non-fiction tomes that would otherwise cost $30 or more. On the flip side, unlimited streaming services appeal to binge-listeners who tear through multiple books a week and don't care about "owning" them permanently. If you're the type who rarely re-reads (or re-listens), this can be a more economical route - though you'll want to make sure the catalog is robust enough to keep you entertained.
Audiobook subscription services differ when it comes to ethical considerations, too. You'll want to think about how the service supports authors and narrators, and their impact on the publishing industry as a whole. Some platforms offer better royalty rates or direct support for independent creators, while others prioritize corporate publishers. Library-based services allow you to borrow audiobooks for free using your library card, which supports public library systems. If supporting authors and fair compensation matters to you, you'll want to research how each service shares revenue with the people who create the content you enjoy.
So what should you actually look for when shopping for an audiobook service? Here are the key considerations:
Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the audiobook services available today. We've looked at catalog depth, pricing models, app functionality, and overall user experience to help you find the service that fits your lifestyle. Whether you're a daily commuter looking to make the most of drive time or a fitness enthusiast who wants company on long runs, we hope this review helps you find the best audiobook service for you.
Compare Any 2 Products
So You Want to Hear About Audiobooks
If you're looking to decide if you should take the dive and get into audiobooks, you've come to the right place! We here at Top Consumer Reviews love audiobooks and have quite the extensive collection ourselves. There are plenty of reasons you may be unsure if audiobooks are right for you, but here are some ways to help you determine if this is the right step for you.
Audiobooks can often seem intimidating. It's not the same as reading, and can take a lot of time to listen to an entire book, so it's natural to be unsure if this will be the right fit for you. One way to tell if this is something to consider, is to look at your current listening time. Do you have a long commute to work? A long workout you never miss? Even long showers? If you have time now, that you spend listening to music or podcasts, then you should have time for an audiobook. It might seem like a big time commitment at first, since the book listening time can be several hours long, but just remember to listen in chunks and fit it in where you normally listen to things. Soon you'll be flying through books in no time!
Some people worry if the audiobook method will be boring. While some books may be dry, each one is different and it just depends on your tastes to see if the book is one you will like or not. Additionally, audiobooks are rather like podcasts, they can have a wide range of people for different characters that really add to the experience. Audiobooks can even be read by their own author, especially if that author is famous. You can feel closer to the likes of Nick Offerman or Amy Poehler as you hear them narrate their own books and life stories.
If that hasn't convinced you of how fun audiobooks can be, think of this: Audiobooks can be shared. You can literally have your own book club by sharing your favorite new book with whomever you want. Now you can have friends and family join in the fun as you all listen and share your favorite new book.
Another concern you might have may be about the cost. Some audiobook stores have a recurring membership. This can be good if you decide you like the audiobook world and want to continue on with a series, or listen to audiobooks often. However, you might not want to commit to a subscription right off the bat, and that's understandable. Some stores will let you buy one book at a time, if you just want to test the waters first and then that would be your best bet. A one time purchase may be the best for starting out, but chances are pretty soon you'll want that membership and all the benefits that come with it!
All in all, audiobooks are not going to be for everyone. Some people just never get into the feel of it. If you can take the first step of trying it out though, you might discover a whole new world of reading that you enjoy. We think it's well worth the risk, and you should take the plunge and start your newest adventure today!
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
