Auto Insurance Plans Reviews

Who's better?

Esurance vs Trusted Rates

We've analyzed the best Auto Insurance Plans to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Auto Insurance Plan Reviews

Here you can see how Esurance and Trusted Rates match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Auto Insurance Plans in 2025.

Winner

Esurance

  • Average quote in 6 minutes
  • Available in 43 states
  • Save an average of $462 by switching

Esurance is run by Allstate and is potentially being phased out by them. For now, if you want an auto insurance quote from Esurance, you'll need to call the number on their website to talk to a sales agent. They operate in 43 states, so be sure to check if Esurance is even an option for you. They boast that you can get a quote within 6 minutes on average and customers save around $462 by switching to their company from a competitor. They're known for providing fair pricing, so although we wish they had more of an online process, we still recommend calling Esurance to see what their pricing is like for you.

Trusted Rates

  • Promises to keep information private
  • Save $500 or more on auto insurance
  • Quotes within 1 minute

Trusted Rates has a very simple website without any information about the company or exactly what they even do. The site hasn't been updated for a couple of years and the button to reach a sales agent doesn't work, so all you can do is input information about yourself and your vehicle to get a "quick quote". In the end, the links to all auto insurance companies that Trusted Rates sends you to are broken, so there is no benefit to spending even a second of your time with Trusted Rates. They've earned our lowest rating.

Whether you've just turned 16, or you're 99 years old and out driving on the roads, you need auto insurance. This protects you and everyone else by making sure that if an accident happens, it will be paid for and taken care of. Whether you get in a small fender bender or (heaven forbid) a devastating large-scale accident, your insurance will kick in and save you from potentially having to pay thousands of dollars out of pocket.

Besides paying for damage done to your car and anyone else potentially involved in an issue on the road, auto insurance can cover things like theft, weather, keying, or natural disasters. It can help pay for medical bills, lost wages, or even a funeral if anyone is injured or killed. There are a range of other things your insurance can help with depending on the plan like a cracked windshield, which comes in handy since we've all been hit by a flying rock or two on the road.

There are usually different tiers of auto insurance plans that you can choose from that will determine how much is covered. You're probably familiar with a few big-name auto insurance companies that seem to dominate the marketplace with ads and commercials. But there are actually quite a few companies out there and some could save you a significant amount of money compared to their competitors.

You can usually get a quick online quote within minutes that will help you compare pricing between companies. There are even some services that will take your information and instantly help you compare quotes among a bunch of different companies without you having to visit them one at a time. Depending on your driving history, some of these services give you more accurate quotes than others, but it's always worth a try.

We've done a lot of the deep dive research regarding some of the top online websites that sell auto insurance and recommend keeping the following things in mind when you're shopping:

The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked the most popular auto insurance sites you're likely to consider when shopping for coverage. We hope this information helps you have peace of mind as you head out on the road and feel taken care of when the time comes to use your policy!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Auto Insurance Plan FAQ

What is auto insurance?
Auto insurance is used to provide financial protection from physical damage or bodily injury caused by a car accident. It is a contract between you and an insurer that says if you pay a monthly or yearly premium to have insurance, the auto insurance company will take care of costs that arise in the event of an accident. Your insurance might cover things like damage to or theft of your car, legal responsibilities, or medical costs to treat injuries and rehabilitation.
Why do I need auto insurance?
Everyone needs car insurance. Motorists who drive without insurance can receive hefty fines from police officers if they are pulled over. In other cases, their car could be impounded or their driver's license revoked. If you're in a car accident that causes harm to another person or their property, you would be responsible for 100% of the cost which could easily equal tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars. Many states have a pay-to-play rule which states that if you're in a car accident and it's someone else's fault, you can only collect money from their insurance if you have car insurance of your own. In short, it's extremely risky and an overall bad idea not to have auto insurance.
How much is auto insurance?
Many auto insurance companies have calculators on their website that ask you a series of questions to help you get an estimate of your monthly or yearly auto insurance cost. If you have a solid driving record and want good insurance, you can expect to pay somewhere around $300-$500 per year. Oftentimes you can bundle and save if you put more than one vehicle on your auto insurance. If you get a speeding ticket or are a responsible party in a car accident, it's more than likely that your insurance rate will go up. This is because the insurance company looks at you as a higher liability.
How are auto insurance rates determined?
Some of the main factors in determining auto insurance rates are your driving record, how often you use your car, where you live (e.g. are you somewhere where vandalism rates are high?), your gender and age, the kind of car you drive (e.g. how much would it cost to replace?), and the type of insurance you want. There is no one-size-fits-all insurance policy, so you'll be asked about all of these things when you apply for auto insurance. You may also get discounts for being a good student, bundling more than one type of insurance (like homeowner's and life), or even for being married!
What if I want to switch my auto insurance policy?
You can change auto insurance policies at any time. If you find somewhere that offers you as good or better car insurance than what you currently have for a better price, go for it! Although it is a minor pain to shop around and fill out the paperwork to make the switch, you can do it at any time. There are no penalties for changing auto insurance companies, but be cautious of the companies that make you pay termination fees.
How do I find auto insurance online?
Some online companies will take your information and match you to the best auto insurance companies around. Others will let you sign up for an auto insurance policy with them directly. It's as simple as finding a highly-rated auto insurance group and filling out an application. You'll be asked for basic personal information and some details about your driving history, location, vehicle, and other things.
How do I choose the best auto insurance company?
It doesn't hurt to get quotes from multiple auto insurance companies. It's a no-brainer that you want to get the lowest premiums possible. Check the company's Better Business Bureau rating and make sure the insurance is comprehensive in offering everything you would need in the event of an accident. As long as the auto insurance company is known for having good customer service, you should be safe signing up for a policy with them.
How do I use my auto insurance?
If you're involved in a car crash, fender bender, or your car is stolen, call your insurance company. It's also wise to get the auto insurance information of all other parties involved so that the companies can work together to sort things out. When you contact your own insurance company, they will ask you any relevant questions about the situation you're in and walk you through the process to give you the best coverage possible.

Compare Any 2 Products

Insurify
The Zebra
Savvy
Esurance
Gabi
Progressive
ValuePenguin
CARCHEX
US Insurance Online
Trusted Rates
vs
Insurify vs The ZebraInsurify vs SavvyInsurify vs EsuranceInsurify vs GabiInsurify vs ProgressiveInsurify vs ValuePenguinInsurify vs CARCHEXInsurify vs US Insurance OnlineInsurify vs Trusted RatesThe Zebra vs SavvyThe Zebra vs EsuranceThe Zebra vs GabiThe Zebra vs ProgressiveThe Zebra vs ValuePenguinThe Zebra vs CARCHEXThe Zebra vs US Insurance OnlineThe Zebra vs Trusted RatesSavvy vs EsuranceSavvy vs GabiSavvy vs ProgressiveSavvy vs ValuePenguinSavvy vs CARCHEXSavvy vs US Insurance OnlineSavvy vs Trusted RatesEsurance vs GabiEsurance vs ProgressiveEsurance vs ValuePenguinEsurance vs CARCHEXEsurance vs US Insurance OnlineEsurance vs Trusted RatesGabi vs ProgressiveGabi vs ValuePenguinGabi vs CARCHEXGabi vs US Insurance OnlineGabi vs Trusted RatesProgressive vs ValuePenguinProgressive vs CARCHEXProgressive vs US Insurance OnlineProgressive vs Trusted RatesValuePenguin vs CARCHEXValuePenguin vs US Insurance OnlineValuePenguin vs Trusted RatesCARCHEX vs US Insurance OnlineCARCHEX vs Trusted RatesUS Insurance Online vs Trusted Rates Trusted Rates vs US Insurance OnlineTrusted Rates vs CARCHEXTrusted Rates vs ValuePenguinTrusted Rates vs ProgressiveTrusted Rates vs GabiTrusted Rates vs EsuranceTrusted Rates vs SavvyTrusted Rates vs The ZebraTrusted Rates vs InsurifyUS Insurance Online vs CARCHEXUS Insurance Online vs ValuePenguinUS Insurance Online vs ProgressiveUS Insurance Online vs GabiUS Insurance Online vs EsuranceUS Insurance Online vs SavvyUS Insurance Online vs The ZebraUS Insurance Online vs InsurifyCARCHEX vs ValuePenguinCARCHEX vs ProgressiveCARCHEX vs GabiCARCHEX vs EsuranceCARCHEX vs SavvyCARCHEX vs The ZebraCARCHEX vs InsurifyValuePenguin vs ProgressiveValuePenguin vs GabiValuePenguin vs EsuranceValuePenguin vs SavvyValuePenguin vs The ZebraValuePenguin vs InsurifyProgressive vs GabiProgressive vs EsuranceProgressive vs SavvyProgressive vs The ZebraProgressive vs InsurifyGabi vs EsuranceGabi vs SavvyGabi vs The ZebraGabi vs InsurifyEsurance vs SavvyEsurance vs The ZebraEsurance vs InsurifySavvy vs The ZebraSavvy vs InsurifyThe Zebra vs Insurify
See the Best Auto Insurance Plans in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

The Wall Street ...

Best Car Insurance Companies of 2025

Progressive is the best car insurance company in our analysis, earning 5 out 5 stars. Other top companies from our evaluation are Travelers, Geico, Auto-Owners, Erie and USAA.

Fri, 07 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Wall Street ...

State Farm Car Insurance Review: Coverage, Cost and Trends

Coverage, Cost and Trends ...

Tue, 04 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

USA TODAY

Affordable Full Coverage Auto Insurance: What Drivers Should Know ...

Experts caution that a cheap premium can disguise steep deductibles or limited repair networks. Drivers should verify what’s excluded — particularly glass coverage, rental reimbursement, and uninsured ...

Thu, 06 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

NPR

Why car insurance costs have soared (and what drivers are doing about ...

Car insurance premiums have increased at twice the rate of overall inflation. They've stabilized, at least for now, but more than half of Americans say the costs are painful.

Thu, 30 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Sacramento Bee

Understanding the 2025 auto insurance landscape: What drivers need to ...

The General reports that auto insurance rates are stabilizing after years of increases, but factors like tech, climate change, and economic pressures may drive costs up again.

Mon, 03 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

5 factors that secretly raise your auto insurance rates

CheapInsurance.com reports five hidden factors affecting auto insurance rates: ZIP code, credit score, mileage, vehicle repair costs, and coverage gaps.

Thu, 06 Nov 2025

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.