Who's better?

Pep Boys vs Get All Parts

We've analyzed the best Auto Parts Stores to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Auto Parts Store Reviews

Here you can see how Pep Boys and Get All Parts match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Auto Parts Stores in 2025.

Winner

Pep Boys

  • Search tailored to your car
  • In person and online shopping
  • Mechanics on staff to do jobs for you

Pep Boys, a well-established auto parts retailer with a strong focus on service and tire centers, isn't a top competitor for auto parts shopping. It's a little hard to find what you need. You need to select your local Pep Boys location and enter your car's information to shop, which can be cumbersome. Unfortunately, they also have missing inventory for common items like brake pads, shocks, and motor oil for a standard car, which makes price comparisons difficult. While they offer a 30-day return policy, it just doesn't stand out of the pack in any positive way.

Get All Parts

  • Search tailored to your car
  • Price match guarantee
  • 60-day return window

Get All Parts, established in 2010, focuses on aftermarket auto parts but doesn't offer OEM components. The website is somewhat slow and lacks essential items like brake pads, shocks, and engine oil. While they provide a price match guarantee and have a 60-day return policy, the absence of comprehensive reviews and missing standard inventory items may make them less appealing compared to other auto parts suppliers with larger inventories and positive customer feedback.

Owning a car means maintenance and repairs will come due sooner or later, and plenty of drivers tackle them themselves to save hundreds - even thousands - over the life of the vehicle. If you're going the DIY route, you'll need the right parts and tools - just like a neighborhood mechanic - to keep your favorite machine running smoothly (or finally silence that annoying ticking noise). Before you dive in, a quick check of the service manual and a trusted tutorial can help you gauge the job and avoid surprises.

Not long ago, getting parts meant driving to the local counter and hoping they had the right piece. For anyone who isn't a pro - and especially many women who've felt judged or talked down to - that experience can be intimidating. Now, online auto parts stores have changed the game, letting you compare options, check fitment guides and reviews, and order exactly what you need. Many even suggest compatible tools and how-to resources so you can finish the job with confidence.

Shopping at an online auto parts store makes it easy to confirm you're ordering the right parts for your exact vehicle, all without leaving the couch. VIN lookups and smart search tools handle the fitment checks for you, taking the hassle out of the process. Need a fresh set of tires, a turbo kit for your already over-taxed hatchback, or a metric wrench for those Euro bolts? It's all a click away. You can also compare prices and read real customer reviews before you buy, so you can shop with confidence. It's faster - and far less stressful - than wandering the aisles, and it keeps your project moving.

Buying auto parts online is often cheaper than picking them up in-store - even when both options come from the same company - because there's more competition and less overhead per part. On top of the lower prices, you can have everything shipped straight to your door. It's smart to compare sellers and factor in shipping and return policies, since those details can make a good deal even better.

With the right parts in hand and your go-to repair YouTuber queued up, you can dive into DIY car work fast. Just remember, auto parts stores aren't all the same - prices, quality, and return policies can vary more than you'd expect. Before you buy, check reviews, ask about warranties and fitment guarantees, and pick the shop that'll stand behind you if the job doesn't go as planned.

Whether you're shopping for brand-new factory components or certified pre-owned parts, aim for the best quality you can find. There are deals all over the internet, but choosing a seller you can trust matters most - for your wallet and your safety. Before you check out, scan reviews, return policies, and warranty details to confirm the parts are legit and will fit your vehicle.

Not sure where to start your online search for auto parts? Don't worry - we've completed a full review and ranking of all the best auto parts stores out there today. Here are some basic criteria that might help you narrow the field:

To make sure your car stays running smoothly, Top Consumer Reviews is here to give you all the insights on the best auto parts stores on the market. We hope this helps you get started with your DIY mechanic shop right in the safety of your own garage. Soon, your friends will be coming to you for the quick fixes, since you'll be an auto parts expert. Happy driving!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Auto Parts Store FAQ

What types of auto parts can I purchase online?
You can buy just about every part and product related to the functioning of your vehicle or other machinery from an auto parts store. From alternators to belts, and hoses to gaskets and shocks, you can replace pretty much anything you need in your car from the inside out. Take advantage of the knowledgeable customer service teams, "How To" guides, and other services made available by auto parts retailers to make your online shopping experience successful.
What if I am not sure which auto part I am looking for?
If you're experiencing trouble with your vehicle, but aren't sure what you need to fix it, you have a few options. First, you could take it into your local auto shop and have them check it out. The mechanic will be able to give you the exact part and specifications of what you need to purchase online. Your other option would be to chat with an auto parts representative through an online retailer. They are knowledgeable and helpful in guiding customers in the right direction to get their vehicles fixed.
How do I ensure that I purchase the right auto part?
If you chat online or call the auto parts retailer to describe the part you're planning to buy, they can help make sure it's the one you need. There are also detailed descriptions of each product listed online that should give enough information for customers to make educated purchases. If you realize that you need a different part after you've already submitted an online order, you can usually return or exchange your part for the right one!
Can I order auto parts online but pick up in-store?
Yes! Many online auto parts retailers have an in-store pickup option that is fast and convenient. You'll simply order online and head straight to the store to pick it up. Some auto parts stores will even bring your purchase outside to your car, so you don't have to go into the store! This ensures you get the products you need same-day and as an added perk, you save on shipping costs.
What is a refurbished auto part?
Used auto parts are often referred to as remanufactured or refurbished. This means that it was professionally remanufactured to meet industry standards and work like new. They may be less expensive than a new auto part and often come with warranties.
What is the difference between OEM and aftermarket auto parts?
OEM stands for "original equipment manufacturer". This label means that a part was manufactured by the maker of your vehicle. It was made specifically for your make and model. An aftermarket auto part is equally as effective, may cost less, but was made by a third-party for the purpose of replacing damaged parts.
Should I buy new or used auto parts?
If you have a brand-new vehicle or need a critical part replaced, it is usually recommended to buy a new part. For simple parts with shorter shelf lives, buying a used or refurbished part is a good alternative. It is best practice to consult your mechanic when making this decision and checking the part's price, warranty, and return policy before purchase. As long as you're shopping online from a reputable auto parts retailer, you will be able to get your needs met with confidence.
What do I do with old or defective auto parts?
You can either take old auto parts to a metal recycling center, donate them, or sell them to a used auto parts store. Some used parts retailers will pay cash on the spot for scrap metal. This is a great way to earn a little extra cash to put toward the new auto parts you need to purchase online.

Compare Any 2 Products

AutoZone
Car Parts
Advance Auto Parts
NAPA
Buy Auto Parts
Parts Geek
Autohaus AZ
Pep Boys
Get All Parts
Auto Barn
vs
AutoZone vs Car PartsAutoZone vs Advance Auto PartsAutoZone vs NAPAAutoZone vs Buy Auto PartsAutoZone vs Parts GeekAutoZone vs Autohaus AZAutoZone vs Pep BoysAutoZone vs Get All PartsAutoZone vs Auto BarnCar Parts vs Advance Auto PartsCar Parts vs NAPACar Parts vs Buy Auto PartsCar Parts vs Parts GeekCar Parts vs Autohaus AZCar Parts vs Pep BoysCar Parts vs Get All PartsCar Parts vs Auto BarnAdvance Auto Parts vs NAPAAdvance Auto Parts vs Buy Auto PartsAdvance Auto Parts vs Parts GeekAdvance Auto Parts vs Autohaus AZAdvance Auto Parts vs Pep BoysAdvance Auto Parts vs Get All PartsAdvance Auto Parts vs Auto BarnNAPA vs Buy Auto PartsNAPA vs Parts GeekNAPA vs Autohaus AZNAPA vs Pep BoysNAPA vs Get All PartsNAPA vs Auto BarnBuy Auto Parts vs Parts GeekBuy Auto Parts vs Autohaus AZBuy Auto Parts vs Pep BoysBuy Auto Parts vs Get All PartsBuy Auto Parts vs Auto BarnParts Geek vs Autohaus AZParts Geek vs Pep BoysParts Geek vs Get All PartsParts Geek vs Auto BarnAutohaus AZ vs Pep BoysAutohaus AZ vs Get All PartsAutohaus AZ vs Auto BarnPep Boys vs Get All PartsPep Boys vs Auto BarnGet All Parts vs Auto Barn Auto Barn vs Get All PartsAuto Barn vs Pep BoysAuto Barn vs Autohaus AZAuto Barn vs Parts GeekAuto Barn vs Buy Auto PartsAuto Barn vs NAPAAuto Barn vs Advance Auto PartsAuto Barn vs Car PartsAuto Barn vs AutoZoneGet All Parts vs Pep BoysGet All Parts vs Autohaus AZGet All Parts vs Parts GeekGet All Parts vs Buy Auto PartsGet All Parts vs NAPAGet All Parts vs Advance Auto PartsGet All Parts vs Car PartsGet All Parts vs AutoZonePep Boys vs Autohaus AZPep Boys vs Parts GeekPep Boys vs Buy Auto PartsPep Boys vs NAPAPep Boys vs Advance Auto PartsPep Boys vs Car PartsPep Boys vs AutoZoneAutohaus AZ vs Parts GeekAutohaus AZ vs Buy Auto PartsAutohaus AZ vs NAPAAutohaus AZ vs Advance Auto PartsAutohaus AZ vs Car PartsAutohaus AZ vs AutoZoneParts Geek vs Buy Auto PartsParts Geek vs NAPAParts Geek vs Advance Auto PartsParts Geek vs Car PartsParts Geek vs AutoZoneBuy Auto Parts vs NAPABuy Auto Parts vs Advance Auto PartsBuy Auto Parts vs Car PartsBuy Auto Parts vs AutoZoneNAPA vs Advance Auto PartsNAPA vs Car PartsNAPA vs AutoZoneAdvance Auto Parts vs Car PartsAdvance Auto Parts vs AutoZoneCar Parts vs AutoZone
See the Best Auto Parts Stores in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

The Motley Fool on ...

Here's why Advance Auto Parts stock recovered in November

Shares in autoparts retailer Advance Auto Parts (NYSE: AAP) rose by 10.1% in November, according to data provided by S&P Global Market Intelligence. The move follows a slew of analyst upgrades after ...

Mon, 08 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Reuters on MSN

Auto parts maker First Brands appoints Charles Moore as interim CEO

First Brands said on Friday it has appointed Charles Moore as the interim chief executive amid its bankruptcy restructuring process. The auto parts maker's founder Patrick James had stepped down as ...

Fri, 12 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

CarBuzz on MSN

Bankrupt Auto Parts Giant Gets Help From Former GM Executive

Craig Barnes also has growth and transformation in his track record, as well as a curious company called Hollywood Feed, which appears to be an online pet food store. However, he also served with ...

Thu, 11 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Crain's Detroit ...

First Brands hires former GM, auto parts executives amid bankruptcy ...

Bankrupt aftermarket auto parts supplier First Brands Group announced the hiring of three veteran automotive executives as it attempts to recover from alleged financial fraud and operational collapse.

Tue, 09 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

AOL

Why Advance Auto Parts Stock Slumped Today

Evercore ISI lowered its price target on Advance Auto Parts stock today. Also today, rival AutoZone reported earnings -- and missed! 10 stocks we like better than Adva ...

Tue, 09 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The News Journal

Auto parts store opens 20th Delaware location in Talleyville

After closing about 700 stores, Advance Auto Parts is opening 30 additional stores by the end of 2025, including one in Talleyville.

Sun, 30 Nov 2025

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.