Best Auto Parts Stores in New York

We've analyzed the best Auto Parts Stores to help you find the right solution for your needs.

The Best Auto Parts Stores in New York

Where can I find the best Auto Parts Stores in New York? In New York, you don't always want to rely on the corner parts counter - you can tap into broader online shelves tied to familiar stores. With hundreds of storefronts spread across New York, you can usually line up delivery to your door or set a quick pickup at a nearby location. Real-time fitment tools and VIN lookups can spare you a subway ride or a crosstown drive for the wrong part. When snow or traffic hits, you can still get rotors, filters, or sensors moving without leaving the block.

The Best Auto Parts Stores in New York

5.0

EXCELLENT

1

Best Option

  • Pricing from from $26.99 to $62.49 for researched parts
  • Returns within 30 days
  • Large inventory of parts for repairs and body work

Read Full Review

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the Parts Geek website

4.0

VERY GOOD

2

Very Good

  • Pricing from from $91.80 to $174.99 per tire
  • Returns within 30 days
  • 90-day or 3,000 miles standard warranty for installs

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the Pep Boys website

3.5

GOOD

3

Good

  • Pricing from from $91.95 to $1,123.95
  • Pricing for wrench sets from $21.95 to $219.95
  • Returns within 30 days

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.5

On the Auto Barn website

3.0

AVERAGE

4

Average

  • Pricing around $38.41 for researched parts
  • Returns within 60 days only for unopened items
  • Includes parts for upgrades and performance

Read Full Review

AVERAGE

3.0

On the Buy Auto Parts website

2.5

FAIR

5

Fair

  • Pricing from from $26.99 to $62.49 for researched parts
  • Pricing for wrench sets from $8.99 to $36.99
  • Shipping free on orders of $35+

Read Full Review

FAIR

2.5

On the AutoZone website

2.4

FAIR

6

Fair

  • Pricing from from $31.99 to $614.95 for researched parts
  • Pricing for wrench sets from $70.52 (only one available)
  • Shipping is free for Car Parts+ members

Read Full Review

FAIR

2.4

On the Car Parts website

2.0

SUBPAR

7

Subpar

  • Pricing from from $51.99 to $157.99 for researched parts
  • Returns within 30 days with fees
  • Focuses entirely on European cars

Read Full Review

SUBPAR

2.0

On the Autohaus AZ website

1.5

WEAK

8

Weak

  • Pricing from from $8.99 to $577.99 for researched parts
  • Pricing for wrench sets from $26.99 to $161.99
  • Shipping free on $35+ orders

Read Full Review

WEAK

1.5

On the Advance Auto Parts website

1.4

WEAK

9

Weak

  • Returns within 30 days
  • 5-year warranty offer
  • "B+" rating from the BBB

Read Full Review

WEAK

1.4

On the Get All Parts website

1.0

POOR

10

Poor

  • Pricing from $91.99 to $107.99 for researched parts
  • Pricing for wrench sets from $25.99 to $509.99
  • Shipping free on $49+ orders

Read Full Review

POOR

1.0

On the NAPA website

Continued from above...

Where Can I Find the Best Auto Parts Stores in New York?

In New York, you don't always want to rely on the corner parts counter - you can tap into broader online shelves tied to familiar stores. With hundreds of storefronts spread across New York, you can usually line up delivery to your door or set a quick pickup at a nearby location. Real-time fitment tools and VIN lookups can spare you a subway ride or a crosstown drive for the wrong part. When snow or traffic hits, you can still get rotors, filters, or sensors moving without leaving the block.

On a freezing morning in Buffalo, you might need brake lines, hardware, or a new hub fast - road salt up there does a number on metal. With online stock across multiple stores, you can sort by exact fit and see which warehouse can move first. Ground shipping to most New York ZIPs from East Coast hubs often lands in 1-2 days, and same-day courier options do pop up around larger metros. If price matters, you can stack promo codes with loyalty points to bring that total down.

From New York City traffic to weekend wrenching in a driveway, you do end up caring about legal compliance as much as price. New York follows California emissions standards, so you'll want catalytic converters that show CARB approval and proper labeling, and you can filter for that before you hit add-to-cart. For batteries, you can plan on a refundable $5 deposit in New York when you don't swap an old one at purchase, so hang on to the core and return it. You can also look for free testing or install guidance at pickup locations to keep things smooth.

Meanwhile, in Rochester, you might notice taxes and fees shifting your cart total. Sales tax in New York varies by county - New York City sits at 8.875 percent - so you'll want to preview the final checkout before you commit. Tires bring a $2.50 state waste-tire fee per new tire, and certain rebuilt parts add core charges that you can get back after a return. When timing matters, you can choose ship-to-home for bulky items and reserve counter pickup for small stuff, and you can split the order so everything arrives when it should.

After a long run up the Thruway, you can appreciate how inventory visibility saves time - you can see aisle numbers for pickup, you can check torque specs in the product docs, and you can line up tools on the same order. If a CEL pops on, you can pull the code with a plug-in reader and shop sensors by OEM number to avoid returns. Weather swings in New York tend to chew through wipers and batteries fast, so you'll probably set reminders and queue up refills ahead of winter. With chains and independents listing stock online side by side, you can mix brands, compare warranties without guesswork, and keep the car sorted while the city keeps moving.

If you're ready to get going on your next car project, but aren't sure which retailer to trust as your top auto parts store, we've done the hard work for you - so hopefully the process of getting your auto parts will be simple. There's enough stress when you're working on cars, and auto parts should be the easy-breezy step. Here are some factors you can consider to make sure you're getting the best auto parts from the best retailer on the market:

So, if you're ready to dive into your next project for maintenance or upgrading your ride, you've got the tools at your disposal (literally): Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the best options for auto parts stores available. Now, you can grab your parts, tools, paint, and more. Whether you're restoring an old Camaro (good luck) or just trying to fix your favorite ride, there's an auto parts store out there to help you get the job done. And try not to lose your 10mm this time!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Auto Parts Store FAQ

What types of auto parts can I purchase online?
You can buy just about every part and product related to the functioning of your vehicle or other machinery from an auto parts store. From alternators to belts, and hoses to gaskets and shocks, you can replace pretty much anything you need in your car from the inside out. Take advantage of the knowledgeable customer service teams, "How To" guides, and other services made available by auto parts retailers to make your online shopping experience successful.
What if I am not sure which auto part I am looking for?
If you're experiencing trouble with your vehicle, but aren't sure what you need to fix it, you have a few options. First, you could take it into your local auto shop and have them check it out. The mechanic will be able to give you the exact part and specifications of what you need to purchase online. Your other option would be to chat with an auto parts representative through an online retailer. They are knowledgeable and helpful in guiding customers in the right direction to get their vehicles fixed.
How do I ensure that I purchase the right auto part?
If you chat online or call the auto parts retailer to describe the part you're planning to buy, they can help make sure it's the one you need. There are also detailed descriptions of each product listed online that should give enough information for customers to make educated purchases. If you realize that you need a different part after you've already submitted an online order, you can usually return or exchange your part for the right one!
Can I order auto parts online but pick up in-store?
Yes! Many online auto parts retailers have an in-store pickup option that is fast and convenient. You'll simply order online and head straight to the store to pick it up. Some auto parts stores will even bring your purchase outside to your car, so you don't have to go into the store! This ensures you get the products you need same-day and as an added perk, you save on shipping costs.
What is a refurbished auto part?
Used auto parts are often referred to as remanufactured or refurbished. This means that it was professionally remanufactured to meet industry standards and work like new. They may be less expensive than a new auto part and often come with warranties.
What is the difference between OEM and aftermarket auto parts?
OEM stands for "original equipment manufacturer". This label means that a part was manufactured by the maker of your vehicle. It was made specifically for your make and model. An aftermarket auto part is equally as effective, may cost less, but was made by a third-party for the purpose of replacing damaged parts.
Should I buy new or used auto parts?
If you have a brand-new vehicle or need a critical part replaced, it is usually recommended to buy a new part. For simple parts with shorter shelf lives, buying a used or refurbished part is a good alternative. It is best practice to consult your mechanic when making this decision and checking the part's price, warranty, and return policy before purchase. As long as you're shopping online from a reputable auto parts retailer, you will be able to get your needs met with confidence.
What do I do with old or defective auto parts?
You can either take old auto parts to a metal recycling center, donate them, or sell them to a used auto parts store. Some used parts retailers will pay cash on the spot for scrap metal. This is a great way to earn a little extra cash to put toward the new auto parts you need to purchase online.

Compare Any 2 Products

Parts Geek
Pep Boys
Auto Barn
Buy Auto Parts
AutoZone
Car Parts
Autohaus AZ
Advance Auto Parts
Get All Parts
NAPA
vs
Parts Geek vs Pep BoysParts Geek vs Auto BarnParts Geek vs Buy Auto PartsParts Geek vs AutoZoneParts Geek vs Car PartsParts Geek vs Autohaus AZParts Geek vs Advance Auto PartsParts Geek vs Get All PartsParts Geek vs NAPAPep Boys vs Auto BarnPep Boys vs Buy Auto PartsPep Boys vs AutoZonePep Boys vs Car PartsPep Boys vs Autohaus AZPep Boys vs Advance Auto PartsPep Boys vs Get All PartsPep Boys vs NAPAAuto Barn vs Buy Auto PartsAuto Barn vs AutoZoneAuto Barn vs Car PartsAuto Barn vs Autohaus AZAuto Barn vs Advance Auto PartsAuto Barn vs Get All PartsAuto Barn vs NAPABuy Auto Parts vs AutoZoneBuy Auto Parts vs Car PartsBuy Auto Parts vs Autohaus AZBuy Auto Parts vs Advance Auto PartsBuy Auto Parts vs Get All PartsBuy Auto Parts vs NAPAAutoZone vs Car PartsAutoZone vs Autohaus AZAutoZone vs Advance Auto PartsAutoZone vs Get All PartsAutoZone vs NAPACar Parts vs Autohaus AZCar Parts vs Advance Auto PartsCar Parts vs Get All PartsCar Parts vs NAPAAutohaus AZ vs Advance Auto PartsAutohaus AZ vs Get All PartsAutohaus AZ vs NAPAAdvance Auto Parts vs Get All PartsAdvance Auto Parts vs NAPAGet All Parts vs NAPA NAPA vs Get All PartsNAPA vs Advance Auto PartsNAPA vs Autohaus AZNAPA vs Car PartsNAPA vs AutoZoneNAPA vs Buy Auto PartsNAPA vs Auto BarnNAPA vs Pep BoysNAPA vs Parts GeekGet All Parts vs Advance Auto PartsGet All Parts vs Autohaus AZGet All Parts vs Car PartsGet All Parts vs AutoZoneGet All Parts vs Buy Auto PartsGet All Parts vs Auto BarnGet All Parts vs Pep BoysGet All Parts vs Parts GeekAdvance Auto Parts vs Autohaus AZAdvance Auto Parts vs Car PartsAdvance Auto Parts vs AutoZoneAdvance Auto Parts vs Buy Auto PartsAdvance Auto Parts vs Auto BarnAdvance Auto Parts vs Pep BoysAdvance Auto Parts vs Parts GeekAutohaus AZ vs Car PartsAutohaus AZ vs AutoZoneAutohaus AZ vs Buy Auto PartsAutohaus AZ vs Auto BarnAutohaus AZ vs Pep BoysAutohaus AZ vs Parts GeekCar Parts vs AutoZoneCar Parts vs Buy Auto PartsCar Parts vs Auto BarnCar Parts vs Pep BoysCar Parts vs Parts GeekAutoZone vs Buy Auto PartsAutoZone vs Auto BarnAutoZone vs Pep BoysAutoZone vs Parts GeekBuy Auto Parts vs Auto BarnBuy Auto Parts vs Pep BoysBuy Auto Parts vs Parts GeekAuto Barn vs Pep BoysAuto Barn vs Parts GeekPep Boys vs Parts Geek
See the Best Auto Parts Stores in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Sporting News on MSN

NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series schedule 2026: Dates, times, TV ...

The former Xfinity Series has a new name but promises to bring the same thrills in 2026. Here's how to tune in to every race.

Mon, 13 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Athlon Sports on MSN

NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series Qualifying Results, Starting Lineup ...

Qualifying results, pole winner, and full starting lineup for the NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series from Bristol Motor Speedway.

Sat, 11 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo Sports

NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series driver Natalie Decker in photos

Natalie Decker has driven in the NASCAR Xfinity Series and Craftsman Truck Series. Lately, she's be racing in the NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series, driving for Joey Gase Motorsports with Scott Osteen ...

Fri, 10 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Athlon Sports on MSN

NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series Bristol Race Results, Winner and ...

Winner and full race results from the NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series race at Bristol Motor Speedway.

Sat, 11 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Online Athens

Advance Auto Parts hosts 'Cars & Coffee' event in Athens

Advance Auto Parts hosts a 'Cars & Coffee' event in Athens on April 18, featuring YouTube's Gears and Gasoline hosts.

Tue, 14 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Heavy

NASCAR O’Reilly Auto Parts Series Standings After Rockingham ...

NASCAR O’Reilly Auto Parts Series standings update after Rockingham Speedway race as Justin Allgaier leads after eight races.

Sun, 05 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

East Tennessee emerges as hub for auto parts manufacturing

Global automotive parts manufacturers SL Tennessee and Denso Manufacturing have invested heavily in East Tennessee, employing thousands of workers to make components for a ...

Wed, 01 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo Sports

NASCAR Results Today: O’Reilly Auto Parts Series Stage Results, ...

The NASCAR O’Reilly Auto Parts Series raced tonight at Bristo Motor Speedway’s iconic short track, with a field of drivers […] ...

Sat, 11 Apr 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.