Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Shiply vs American Auto Shipping

Tuesday, March 18th

2025 Auto Transport Reviews

Shiply Review 2 Star Rating

Shiply

2 Star Rating
  • Free quotes
  • Full refunds if transporters cancel
  • Piano shipping
  • International shipping available
  • Reverse bidding method

Shiply's model makes you in charge of vetting and choosing an auto transport carrier. You post a job bid and then choose the carrier and price you want. Nearly every complaint regarding Shiply had to do with carriers, not the Shiply platform, which we found simple and easy to use. For those who have no experience with shipping cars or find it difficult to vet carriers, Shiply is not the best choice. So, overall, it's a good choice for a niche market, but really not the best if you don't fit into that niche.

American Auto Shipping Review 1 Star Rating

American Auto Shipping

1 Star Rating
  • Damage-free guarantee
  • Free rental car for delays
  • Car wash available
  • Multiple options for getting to the destination point
  • Personal concierge service

American Auto Shipping has been operating for 20 years but appears to have difficulty with customer service - and the company has been investigated on at least one review site for possibly inflating rankings with fake positive reviews. That, along with some questionable actions regarding charging customers $100 to get their job accepted by a carrier but reportedly pocketing the $100, makes us wary of American Auto Shipping. If you enjoy taking risks, you might want to try it - they do offer a free rental car, but that's only for when your delivery has been delayed for the past two weeks (!). We'd recommend going with another auto transport company.

Where Can You Find the Best Auto Transport Companies?

Auto transport companies make it easy and fast to move vehicles from one place to another. The biggest benefit is that it saves time. Driving a car across long distances can take a lot of time, especially if you're not familiar with the route or don't have enough time. Auto transport companies handle everything, so you don't have to worry about the trip. Many companies also offer door-to-door service, picking up and delivering your car exactly where you want it, which makes the whole process easier.

Whether you're a car enthusiast, classic car collector, snowbird, or being relocated by the military, there are lots of brokers and other options out there available to help you transport your car to wherever it is you're going.

The Best Auto Transport Companies Compare Auto Transport Companies Compare Auto Transport Reviews What are the best Auto Transport Companies Best Auto Transport Reviews

Auto Transport FAQ

Transport brokers serve as the middleman between you and carriers. Their job is to vet the carriers for you, take the hassle out of the search process, and set you up with the best carrier for your needs.
The main difference is what they offer. Auto shipping services provide you with options for different auto carriers, insurance for your trip, and management for your transportation. The auto carrier is the actual business that will take your car from one place to the next.
Some vehicle moves require shipping, like an overseas journey, but if you're just going from one state to the next, it might seem strange to hire someone to move your car. However, the benefits of having someone else move your car include less stress on moving day, fewer trips back and forth if you have more than one car, fewer miles on a car that has a lease or low mileage, and safety for your vehicle.
Instead of going directly to the carrier, using a middleman or broker can save you time, money, and help you get a trustworthy service the first time. You may also get extra benefits like damage coverage or a rental car if your delivery winds up being late.
This depends on which company you go with, but many brokers offer options for cars, boats, golf carts, RVs, heavy machinery, military vehicles, and much more. Just make sure that the company you're working with has what you need.
Many brokers guarantee that their carriers are insured on their own, but some brokers also offer additional insurance packages if you're transporting something you're really worried about. Average insurance options cover up to $200,000.
Pricing is difficult in this industry. You'll see a lot of brokers that don't have prices on their site because the final quote will depend on several factors: what you're trying to ship, where you're going, what time of year you're trying to move, what kind of supply and demand there is for carriers, and what your timeline is. The best brokers will give you a quote and stick to it, so make sure you find one that promises to lock in the quote after they give it to you.
This can be perfectly safe. However, it is a lot more work, and you have to do more vetting on your own than if you use a broker. The risk is about the same as hiring a moving company yourself, but you won't get any of the additional insurance offered by most brokers.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

One big advantage for using an auto transport company is that these companies keep your car safe during the journey. They use special trucks, like open or closed trailers, to make sure your car is protected from road debris, bad weather, or accidents that could happen on the road. Some companies even offer insurance to cover any damage, so you don't have to worry. This is especially important if you have a valuable or classic car that needs extra care.

Another plus for auto transport companies is they can actually be cheaper than driving the car yourself. When you add up costs like gas, food, lodging, and the wear and tear on your car, driving long distances can get expensive. Auto transport services usually include everything in the price, and it can be more affordable than you think. If you need to move more than one car, many companies give discounts for transporting multiple vehicles, making it a great option for businesses or people moving with several cars.

The car transport industry includes any company that ships finished vehicles. That means that many car transport companies deal in businesses and corporate-level car hauling in addition to working with individuals. Some carriers deal mainly with individuals, as they are smaller and independent. Other companies have a fleet - but most do not deal directly with individuals. They instead rely on brokers who post your job on a bid board that only brokers and carriers have access to see. Then, your broker will give you the best quote and set up your pickup and delivery, charging a fee for their services. The carrier's part of the total money billed is given directly to them by you. The broker is not associated with the carrier and is not responsible for damages or theft of your vehicle - the carrier is the only one liable for damages.

The average cost to ship a car across the country is around $1,500. However, numerous variables affect pricing. And although auto transportation companies can feel similar at first glance, it's important to consider the best fit for your needs and your vehicle. Most companies can transport your car to almost any location.

So, how do you choose the auto transport company for your needs? With so many different services out there, it can be hard to select the best option. If you're not sure where to start, here are a few things to help you decide:

  • Location. Find out where your vehicle will be picked up. Do you want the vehicle picked up and delivered to your door, or can you take a drive to a terminal instead?
  • Size and modification inclusivity. Do you need a service that offers transport for large vehicles? Or do you only need smaller sedans shipped? Do you need a service that specializes in modified vehicles or sport models? Do you live a life of luxury and need a yacht transported (we only wish we did)?
  • Timeline. Do you have a tight delivery timeline? Or are you more flexible with your delivery and pickup?
  • Insurance options. There are a lot of different things covered by insurance. Do you need separate insurance for the move, or do you want a company that offers insurance with the transportation? Do you have gap insurance for things that the mandatory cargo shipping insurance doesn't or won't cover?
  • Expectations and understanding. Do you understand that the broker is not in any way responsible for your vehicle? Does the company you're working with explain that there can be unexpected issues and there is no specific date that can be guaranteed? Would you rather manage expectations, vetting, and choosing a carrier yourself and bid for a carrier on your own?
  • Customer service. With something as important as your car, you want to pick a company you trust. How can you contact the company? If you read online reviews, make sure the reviewers have read the company's responses to complaints - sometimes their responses will shed light on the company culture and the quality of customer service training.

To help you find the right transportation for your vehicles, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked today's most popular auto transport companies across the US. We hope this will make it easy to choose the best way to let someone else get your dream car safely home.

Compare Auto Transport Companies

Select any 2 Auto Transport Companies to compare them head to head

best-auto-transport-companies
  • AmeriFreight
  • Sherpa Auto Transport
  • Montway Auto Transport
  • uShip
  • Easy Auto Ship
  • Nexus Auto Transport
  • Shiply
  • SGT Auto Transport
  • American Auto Shipping
  • eShip
AmeriFreight vs Sherpa Auto Transport AmeriFreight vs Montway Auto Transport AmeriFreight vs uShip AmeriFreight vs Easy Auto Ship AmeriFreight vs Nexus Auto Transport AmeriFreight vs Shiply AmeriFreight vs SGT Auto Transport AmeriFreight vs American Auto Shipping AmeriFreight vs eShip Sherpa Auto Transport vs Montway Auto Transport Sherpa Auto Transport vs uShip Sherpa Auto Transport vs Easy Auto Ship Sherpa Auto Transport vs Nexus Auto Transport Sherpa Auto Transport vs Shiply Sherpa Auto Transport vs SGT Auto Transport Sherpa Auto Transport vs American Auto Shipping Sherpa Auto Transport vs eShip Montway Auto Transport vs uShip Montway Auto Transport vs Easy Auto Ship Montway Auto Transport vs Nexus Auto Transport Montway Auto Transport vs Shiply Montway Auto Transport vs SGT Auto Transport Montway Auto Transport vs American Auto Shipping Montway Auto Transport vs eShip uShip vs Easy Auto Ship uShip vs Nexus Auto Transport uShip vs Shiply uShip vs SGT Auto Transport uShip vs American Auto Shipping uShip vs eShip Easy Auto Ship vs Nexus Auto Transport Easy Auto Ship vs Shiply Easy Auto Ship vs SGT Auto Transport Easy Auto Ship vs American Auto Shipping Easy Auto Ship vs eShip Nexus Auto Transport vs Shiply Nexus Auto Transport vs SGT Auto Transport Nexus Auto Transport vs American Auto Shipping Nexus Auto Transport vs eShip Shiply vs SGT Auto Transport Shiply vs American Auto Shipping Shiply vs eShip SGT Auto Transport vs American Auto Shipping SGT Auto Transport vs eShip American Auto Shipping vs eShip
Compare the Best Auto Transport Companies
- VS -
Review the Best Auto Transport Companies
The Best Reviews of Auto Transport Companies