Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

CarShield Review

Friday, December 3rd

2021 Auto Warranty Plan Reviews

CarShield Review 2.5 Star Rating

CarShield

2.5 Star Rating

CarShield was formed in 2005 and proudly boasts that they have covered over 1 million vehicles and have paid over 1 billion dollars in claims. They have been featured on ESPN, Inc. 5000, HGTV, CNN, CNBC, TBS, and other channels and websites. Customers can browse their professional website for plan information, FAQ, a glossary of terms, and an education center with tips and insights on vehicle protection.

6 auto warranty plans

Six coverage plans are available through CarShield. They include:

  • New Car Diamond: Total New Car Coverage (similar to manufacturers' new car warranty covering everything from engine and transmission failure to starter and fuel pump breakdowns)
  • Platinum: Comprehensive Coverage (best option for high mileage vehicles and covers the engine, transmission, AC, electrical system, water and fuel pump, starter, and more)
  • Gold: Powertrain Plus (covers major and minor vehicle parts including engine transmission, water, pump, A/C, starter, and more)
  • Silver: Power Train (most affordable policy that covers critical vehicle parts like transmission, water pump, and all lubricated engine parts)
  • High Tech: Specialty Coverage (covers most electrical and computer parts including starter, alternator, navigation/GPS, engine control module, and more)
  • Specialty: Other Coverage (contracts for special circumstances or other vehicles like motorcycles)

All contracts include towing

Most contracts through CarShield provide 24/7 roadside assistance in case your vehicle has an issue while driving as well as rental car services while your vehicle is being fixed. All contracts include towing services.

Best Auto Warranty Plans

Newer car options missing

To receive a quote for any given coverage plan, customers will be asked to fill out an online form and provide the year, make, model, and mileage of their vehicle along with their contact information. By submitting the form, CarShield receives consent to contact customers by phone, text, or email to go over pricing information. We did notice that when filling out this online form, some newer vehicle options were missing from the dropdown list. This could be a simple error on the part of CarShield, but it would affect new car owners looking to get an extended warranty on their vehicles. If this is the case for you, we suggest giving them a call to see if they will cover your specific vehicle.

Mixed reviews

Most third-party sites have customers with mixed, but overall good things to say about their experience with vehicle coverage through CarShield. We will note, however, that the Better Business Bureau gives an F rating to CarShield due to hundreds of customer complaints. At the time of this review, an alert was posted for this business warning customers to use caution when considering doing business with CarShield. Customers who have posted elsewhere have mixed things to say about CarShield. Most people who have positive things to say refer to the good experiences they have with customer service, while those who are upset claim there are discrepancies in coverage and a lack of transparency about processes.

Overall good choice

From what we have experienced with CarShield, we think they are a good choice for extended vehicle coverage. If you take the time to read your contract terms and really understand what you are getting by paying for a plan through CarShield, you shouldn't find yourself surprised when something isn't covered. We didn't find anywhere that states CarShield has a money-back guarantee, so we suggest doing your homework before deciding to move forward with vehicle coverage from them. Thousands of customers have been happy with CarShield's services and we think that this will continue to be the case for those who carefully choose their plan.

Where is the Best Place to Get an Auto Warranty Plan?

When you purchase a new car, an auto warranty is usually an optional purchase along with it. This is a good choice for vehicle owners who want to spend a little extra each month or in one lump sum for peace of mind about dealing with potential vehicle issues down the road (no pun intended). Generally, a warranty extends for a certain number of years or until the vehicle reaches a specific number of miles.

Heaven forbid you have an engine blowout, faulty brake system, electrical issue, or steering malfunction as you're cruising along in your car. If this were the case, a big concern for you (besides your safety) would be the thousands of dollars it could cost to get these major issues repaired. Whether your vehicle is brand new or a few years old, unfortunately things go wrong with cars that you can never predict.

The Best Auto Warranty Plans Compare Auto Warranty Plans Compare Auto Warranty Plan Reviews What are the best Auto Warranty Plans Best Auto Warranty Plan Reviews

Auto Warranty Plan FAQ

There are lots of companies offering warranty coverage for your car. They work very similarly to health insurance: you'll pay more for higher coverage, some things are covered and some aren't, and your policy will have a time limit. You can shop around for auto warranty plans just like insurance, too: you don't have to go with the plans offered at the dealership.
That depends on your car and your coverage. On a new vehicle, you might pay $25/month for bumper-to-bumper coverage, but an older vehicle's premium could be three times that. You can usually pay in full or monthly, with no difference in total cost.
The cost of your auto warranty will never be cheaper than when your car is new. But, you'll want to read the terms of your plan very carefully. While warranty plans at the dealership usually start from the time the manufacturer's warranty runs out, third-party plans often start from the date you purchase them. That could mean you're paying twice for the same coverage.
Probably. Each provider sets the limit for coverage, but there are options for cars with up to 150,000 miles! Most auto warranty plans are available for cars that are 20 years old or newer.
YES! The most important part of choosing an auto warranty plan is knowing what's covered and what isn't! Even comprehensive plans don't cover items with normal wear-and-tear, like brake pads and tires. The most user-friendly plans usually give you a list of what isn't covered - and if it's not on that list, it's covered!
Sometimes, but it's usually limited to the first 30 days after the purchase date. Again, be sure to read the terms of your auto warranty plan very carefully, to avoid any unpleasant surprises when you go to use your policy for the first time.
Almost all plans let you use the mechanic of your choice. Some providers will reduce your deductible if you go to one of their network partners.
Despite all of the annoying spam phone calls you've gotten, desperately trying to contact you about the expiring warranty on your car, auto warranty plans are a real thing. And, when you choose a plan from a reputable provider, you can save thousands of dollars on car repairs.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Auto warranties make it so that vehicle owners pay a contracted price much lower than the total cost of a major repair to ensure that if a big issue arises, the costs for fixing the vehicle will be covered. Some major repairs that might be covered under warranty include transmission, engine, powertrain, heating/cooling, and other necessary vehicle parts.

Before choosing an auto warranty plan, we suggest you keep the following criteria in mind:

  • Price. Consider the plans of a few different auto warranty plans. How do they compare cost-wise? Make sure the price of the plan will be worth it if you are paying for the warranty a few years before needing to get repairs covered.
  • Coverage. Make sure you know exactly what is covered under the auto warranty. You don't want to deal with a common vehicle issue and find out it wasn't included under the warranty you've been paying for.
  • Reputation. How smooth is the process for submitting a claim? When you have an auto warranty claim, will they stand behind you? Have they been in business with happy customers long enough for you to know they will still be around for a while?

To help you identify the best auto warranty plan, TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked a variety of options. We hope this information helps you find the auto warranty plan that fits your needs!

See the Best Auto Warranty Plan
The Best Reviews of Auto Warranty Plans