Best Auto Warranty Plans in Wisconsin

We've analyzed the best Auto Warranty Plans to help you find the right solution for your needs.

The Best Auto Warranty Plans in Wisconsin

Where can I find the best Auto Warranty Plans in Wisconsin? In Wisconsin, you might hop online to shop for auto warranty plans rather than sticking with the local dealership. You can pull multiple quotes from companies based across state lines right from the kitchen table while the coffee brews. You usually see prices and coverage tiers appear within minutes, so you can narrow choices without a sales pitch. With road salt and deep freezes, you could lean toward coverage that includes heating and electrical components.

The Best Auto Warranty Plans in Wisconsin

5.0

EXCELLENT

1

Best Option

  • Coverage up to 250,000 miles
  • Your mechanic or choice of repair shop to perform work
  • Perks include 24/7 roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and Openbay+ membership

Read Full Review

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the Toco website

4.5

GREAT

2

Great

  • Three plan options with monthly subscription
  • Take it to your mechanic or use theirs
  • Towing and rental car perks

Read Full Review

GREAT

4.5

On the Olive website

4.0

VERY GOOD

3

Very Good

  • Broker who works with other providers to offer plans
  • Work may be done by your own mechanic or one of their network shops
  • Roadside assistance, towing, rental, and trip interruption coverage

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the autopom! website

3.9

VERY GOOD

4

Very Good

  • Three plan options
  • Use your mechanic or one from their network
  • Pay monthly for coverage up to 40,000 miles or 30 months

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

3.9

On the Endurance website

3.5

GOOD

5

Good

  • Five plan options
  • Work can be done at any licensed repair shop
  • Website full of helpful general information

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.5

On the CARCHEX website

3.4

GOOD

6

Good

  • Four plan options
  • Use their vetted repair shops
  • Perks include roadside assistance and ID Theft Protection

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.4

On the 1 800 Warranty website

3.0

AVERAGE

7

Average

  • Five levels of coverage
  • Covers high-mileage vehicles, rideshares, and motorcycles
  • Choose your mechanic or one of their preferred repair shops

Read Full Review

AVERAGE

3.0

On the CarShield website

2.0

SUBPAR

8

Subpar

  • Three tiers of plan options which are customizable
  • Has specialty contracts for RVs, motorcycles, ATVs, UTVs, scooters, and personal watercraft
  • Work with your favorite repair shop or one of their vetted partners

Read Full Review

SUBPAR

2.0

On the Premier Auto Protect website

1.5

WEAK

9

Weak

  • Three plan options
  • Any licensed repair shop can complete the work
  • Perks include roadside assistance, trip interruption benefits, towing, and gas refill services

Read Full Review

WEAK

1.5

On the Select Auto Protect website

1.0

POOR

10

Poor

  • Submit request for a quote
  • Third-party vendor
  • In business since 2019

Read Full Review

POOR

1.0

On the Complete Car Warranty website

Continued from above...

Where Can I Find the Best Auto Warranty Plans in Wisconsin?

In Wisconsin, you might hop online to shop for auto warranty plans rather than sticking with the local dealership. You can pull multiple quotes from companies based across state lines right from the kitchen table while the coffee brews. You usually see prices and coverage tiers appear within minutes, so you can narrow choices without a sales pitch. With road salt and deep freezes, you could lean toward coverage that includes heating and electrical components.

On a snowy morning, you could sort plans by deductible, term length, and what's covered. In Wisconsin, you benefit from a Lemon Law that applies during the first year - after 4 failed repair attempts for the same defect or 30 total days out of service, you can pursue relief - so a service contract tends to matter more as the odometer climbs. You usually see quotes landing around $70-$120 per month for mid-mileage cars, with total prices running roughly $1,500 to $3,000 based on coverage depth. You usually get a 30‑day free‑look refund if no claims, then a prorated refund, so a careful read of the cancellation clause does help.

From Milwaukee to Madison, you might juggle slush, salt, and spring potholes on I‑94, so you'd want to scan exclusions closely. You'll usually see preexisting conditions and wear‑and‑tear listed out, and you'll usually find road‑hazard tire and wheel coverage offered as an add‑on. You could favor plans that include ABS sensors, heating elements, and electrical modules, because cold snaps tend to stress those parts. You can also pick a per‑visit deductible - $0, $100, or $200 - depending on how you'd rather handle surprise bills.

Meanwhile, around Green Bay, you could care most about the claims process when a cold front blows through the Lambeau lot. You usually get freedom to use any ASE‑certified shop, not just a dealer, and you usually see the shop paid directly after authorization. You'd want to confirm rental car and roadside assistance limits - tows in winter can add up fast - along with trip‑interruption coverage for long drives up US‑41. You can also check whether the contract allows OEM parts for newer rides or calls for remanufactured components.

After a quick look at the fine print, you can tailor coverage to how you drive across Wisconsin. You might want emission‑system coverage if you live in the counties that require biennial testing, because oxygen sensors and catalytic converters aren't cheap. You can match mileage and term - say, 3 years and 36,000 miles versus 5 years and 100,000 miles - to your commute and road‑trip plans, and you can cap monthly cost by choosing a higher deductible. You could also time the start date so the contract kicks in as the factory warranty winds down.

When comparing auto warranty companies, there are many factors to consider. We suggest making sure to consider these first:

At Top Consumer Reviews, we know that unexpected breakdowns can lead to costly repairs and financial hardship. If you're considering an auto warranty plan, we want to help you find the best ones for your personal situation. That's why we have rated and ranked these providers so you can choose the one you prefer to help you get back to driving when you encounter various bumps along the highway of life.

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Auto Warranty Plan FAQ

Who offers auto warranty plans?
There are lots of companies offering warranty coverage for your car. They work very similarly to health insurance: you'll pay more for higher coverage, some things are covered and some aren't, and your policy will have a time limit. You can shop around for auto warranty plans just like insurance, too: you don't have to go with the plans offered at the dealership.
How much do auto warranties cost?
That depends on your car and your coverage. On a new vehicle, you might pay $25/month for bumper-to-bumper coverage, but an older vehicle's premium could be three times that. You can usually pay in full or monthly, with no difference in total cost.
My car is brand new. Why would I buy a warranty?
The cost of your auto warranty will never be cheaper than when your car is new. But, you'll want to read the terms of your plan very carefully. While warranty plans at the dealership usually start from the time the manufacturer's warranty runs out, third-party plans often start from the date you purchase them. That could mean you're paying twice for the same coverage.
My car is old or has a lot of miles. Can I get a plan?
Probably. Each provider sets the limit for coverage, but there are options for cars with up to 150,000 miles! Most auto warranty plans are available for cars that are 20 years old or newer.
Are there any exclusions in what's covered?
YES! The most important part of choosing an auto warranty plan is knowing what's covered and what isn't! Even comprehensive plans don't cover items with normal wear-and-tear, like brake pads and tires. The most user-friendly plans usually give you a list of what isn't covered - and if it's not on that list, it's covered!
Is there a satisfaction guarantee?
Sometimes, but it's usually limited to the first 30 days after the purchase date. Again, be sure to read the terms of your auto warranty plan very carefully, to avoid any unpleasant surprises when you go to use your policy for the first time.
Can I use my warranty at any mechanic?
Almost all plans let you use the mechanic of your choice. Some providers will reduce your deductible if you go to one of their network partners.
Are auto warranty plans legitimate?
Despite all of the annoying spam phone calls you've gotten, desperately trying to contact you about the expiring warranty on your car, auto warranty plans are a real thing. And, when you choose a plan from a reputable provider, you can save thousands of dollars on car repairs.

Compare Any 2 Products

Toco
Olive
autopom!
Endurance
CARCHEX
1 800 Warranty
CarShield
Premier Auto Protect
Select Auto Protect
Complete Car Warranty
vs
Toco vs OliveToco vs autopom!Toco vs EnduranceToco vs CARCHEXToco vs 1 800 WarrantyToco vs CarShieldToco vs Premier Auto ProtectToco vs Select Auto ProtectToco vs Complete Car WarrantyOlive vs autopom!Olive vs EnduranceOlive vs CARCHEXOlive vs 1 800 WarrantyOlive vs CarShieldOlive vs Premier Auto ProtectOlive vs Select Auto ProtectOlive vs Complete Car Warrantyautopom! vs Enduranceautopom! vs CARCHEXautopom! vs 1 800 Warrantyautopom! vs CarShieldautopom! vs Premier Auto Protectautopom! vs Select Auto Protectautopom! vs Complete Car WarrantyEndurance vs CARCHEXEndurance vs 1 800 WarrantyEndurance vs CarShieldEndurance vs Premier Auto ProtectEndurance vs Select Auto ProtectEndurance vs Complete Car WarrantyCARCHEX vs 1 800 WarrantyCARCHEX vs CarShieldCARCHEX vs Premier Auto ProtectCARCHEX vs Select Auto ProtectCARCHEX vs Complete Car Warranty1 800 Warranty vs CarShield1 800 Warranty vs Premier Auto Protect1 800 Warranty vs Select Auto Protect1 800 Warranty vs Complete Car WarrantyCarShield vs Premier Auto ProtectCarShield vs Select Auto ProtectCarShield vs Complete Car WarrantyPremier Auto Protect vs Select Auto ProtectPremier Auto Protect vs Complete Car WarrantySelect Auto Protect vs Complete Car Warranty Complete Car Warranty vs Select Auto ProtectComplete Car Warranty vs Premier Auto ProtectComplete Car Warranty vs CarShieldComplete Car Warranty vs 1 800 WarrantyComplete Car Warranty vs CARCHEXComplete Car Warranty vs EnduranceComplete Car Warranty vs autopom!Complete Car Warranty vs OliveComplete Car Warranty vs TocoSelect Auto Protect vs Premier Auto ProtectSelect Auto Protect vs CarShieldSelect Auto Protect vs 1 800 WarrantySelect Auto Protect vs CARCHEXSelect Auto Protect vs EnduranceSelect Auto Protect vs autopom!Select Auto Protect vs OliveSelect Auto Protect vs TocoPremier Auto Protect vs CarShieldPremier Auto Protect vs 1 800 WarrantyPremier Auto Protect vs CARCHEXPremier Auto Protect vs EndurancePremier Auto Protect vs autopom!Premier Auto Protect vs OlivePremier Auto Protect vs TocoCarShield vs 1 800 WarrantyCarShield vs CARCHEXCarShield vs EnduranceCarShield vs autopom!CarShield vs OliveCarShield vs Toco1 800 Warranty vs CARCHEX1 800 Warranty vs Endurance1 800 Warranty vs autopom!1 800 Warranty vs Olive1 800 Warranty vs TocoCARCHEX vs EnduranceCARCHEX vs autopom!CARCHEX vs OliveCARCHEX vs TocoEndurance vs autopom!Endurance vs OliveEndurance vs Tocoautopom! vs Oliveautopom! vs TocoOlive vs Toco
See the Best Auto Warranty Plans in Your State

The Basics of Auto Warranties

Cars are expensive investments, whether you like to purchase new or pre-owned. In protecting that investment and to avoid future repair expenses on your car, you may want to consider purchasing an auto warranty.

Most new and some used cars are covered by some sort of warranty when purchased. For example, new cars are usually covered by a manufacturer's warranty. These warranties vary greatly and are limited in duration. They may cover a variety of repairs until either a time limit or mileage limit such as three years or 36,000 miles. Once you reach that time or mileage limit, the warranty will either totally expire or much of what it covers will be void.

Some manufacturers also offer various program warranties on specific used or pre-owned cars, usually called "certified used" or something similar, that extend the original manufacturer's warranty or parts of the warranty.

If you plan on keeping the car past the life of the manufacturer's warranty, you may want to consider purchasing an extended warranty. Extended warranties are insurance policies against expensive, unforeseen repairs. In essence, extended warranties are actually service contracts. They cover expenses incurred that your warranty doesn't cover.

Unlike manufacturer's warranties, extended warranties are purchased separately from your car. They can be purchased either through the original manufacturer or through a third-party, independent warranty company. In some cases, you'll receive offers to purchase extended warranties in the mail or over the phone from the manufacturer just as the original manufacturer's warrantee is expiring.

Extended warranties are all different. They each differ on what repairs are covered, how much is covered, duration of the coverage and cost of the warranty. Before purchasing any extended warranty, determine what is still covered on the warranty you possess, determine how long past the life of the warranty you'll keep the car, what you want covered and for how long.

When researching the details of the warranty you want to purchase, look for information on the policy's deductible, whether the policy is transferable if you sell the car and whether repairs can be done anywhere or only with specific shops. Also, look for specifics on what is covered and what is not. For instance, does the warranty cover breakdown of parts as well as wear and tear? A warranty that only covers breakdown requires the part to break before the warranty will pay to replace it. A wear and tear policy will cover parts that need to be replaced because they are too worn to work efficiently.

Purchasing an extended warranty can be a smart investment. Don't forget to research the warranty specification and the companies offering them online before making the purchase.

Only the Best Reviews

The Wall Street ...

Extended Car Warranties: What You Should Know

Extended warranties can be costly, but they cover some repairs.

Tue, 03 Mar 2026

Only the Best Reviews

MarketWatch

Best Extended Car Warranty in California

Our team looked at dozens of auto warranty providers on the market, including top choices such as Endurance, Olive, CarShield, and autopom! 2,215 Data Points Analyzed We evaluate thousands of data ...

Wed, 19 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

Is an Extended Car Warranty Worth Buying? Here’s How To Tell

Add Yahoo as a preferred source to see more of our stories on Google. The 2022 Volvo XC90 PHEV SUV is one of the best used cars Is peace of mind worth the extra expense? And, does it really provide ...

Tue, 25 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

WXYZ

Extended car warranties: When and how to say no

I’d never buy an extended warranty for a new car. But if someone else asked whether they should buy one, I’d have a different answer: It depends. Over the years I’ve talked to hundreds of car buyers ...

Wed, 19 Feb 2020

Only the Best Reviews

MarketWatch

Best Car Warranty Companies

Our team looked at dozens of auto warranty providers on the market, including top choices such as Endurance, Olive, CarShield, and autopom! 2,215 Data Points Analyzed We evaluate thousands of data ...

Mon, 25 Aug 2025

Only the Best Reviews

USA TODAY

Route 66 Extended Warranty: Plans, cost and coverage

Here is everything to know about Route 66 Extended Warranty, including plans, pricing, restrictions, exclusion, and claims processes.

Thu, 26 Feb 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.