Here you can see how Buy Buy Baby and Crate & Barrel match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Baby Crib Stores in 2025.
Buy Buy Baby was once owned by Bed Bath & Beyond until their big bankruptcy changes in 2023. Dream On Me, a new company, has since taken over the Buy Buy Baby retail chain to rebuild the retailer and return it to the company we're all familiar with. They have a good selection of cribs that fall within different price ranges to meet a range of budgets. We like that there are unfiltered customer reviews on these cribs, so we suggest that customers read through them before making a purchase. Some perks of shopping at Buy Buy Baby are their price-match guarantee and a 60-day return policy, which is more generous than many competitors. Besides some issues with their customer service, we don't see any reason not to give their crib selection your consideration. We like what Buy Buy Baby has to offer, so they've earned a good rating from us.
Crate & Barrel is an upscale retailer specializing in furniture and home goods. They have a small but mighty selection of cribs ranging from $399 to $1,399. Their cribs are beautiful and unique, but come with high prices and potentially difficult and expensive returns. Customers rate the cribs here very highly and Crate & Barrel has an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, but reviews about their customer service are terrible. We'd definitely be concerned about communication with this company if we needed to sort out an issue. Although the cribs here are high-quality, GREENGUARD gold certified, and classy, we don't love their prices or poor customer reviews.
Nothing makes the arrival of a new baby feel more real than pulling together a nursery at home. As you pick out wall art, a soft rug, and those tiny clothes for the closet, the space starts to become a safe, cozy place where you'll nurture your little one. The crib is the big purchase - it's the focal point of the room and the piece you'll use the most. It's also smart to check current safety standards or consider a convertible option that can grow with your child.
If you're just stepping into the world of baby gear, it's easy to assume cribs are all the same - think again. You'll quickly notice a wide range of colors, styles, and features to suit your taste and budget. Some keep it simple with clean lines, a single finish, and hardly any extras, while others are more decorative, come in multiple finishes, and convert from a crib to a toddler bed as your child grows. Before you buy, think about your nursery's size and how long you want the crib to last so your choice fits both your space and your plans.
When you're shopping online for baby sleep gear, you'll usually run into three go-to options. For the first months, many parents keep a small bassinet by the bed - it makes nighttime feeds, soothing, and quick check-ins easier. Once you're both ready, a full-size, stationary crib belongs in the nursery. For flexibility, a basic pack-n-play is a compact, often budget-friendly crib you can fold up for travel or stash away between naps. Many families mix and match these as their routines evolve, and it's worth checking current safety standards and measuring your space before you buy.
When you're shopping for cribs, it's worth picking up two styles - a stationary crib and a travel crib. Start with a bassinet for those first few months while everyone adjusts, then transition to a beautiful crib that suits your room and your growing baby. Keep a pack-n-play in the mix - it's easy to toss in the trunk and take along for naps on-the-go or overnights at the grandparents'. That flexibility makes day-to-day life simpler and helps keep sleep routines consistent wherever you are.
Some companies will offer major sales on their baby gear every so often, so this would be a great way to save some money on a crib. Shopping online will allow you to easily compare prices between retailers, see all the details and features of the crib, and not have to go store-to-store to see what type of selection everyone has. There are quite a few stores to choose from that have a great selection of cribs, so keep the following things in mind when choosing who to go with:
Top Consumer Reviews has researched everything you need to know about the best crib companies you can buy from online. We hope this information helps you find a beautiful, high-quality, cozy baby crib for the new addition to your family. Have fun exploring all the baby crib options available to you. It's a special purchase that brings the reality of a new baby to life.
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.