Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Amazing Clubs vs The Greater Knead

Sunday, May 18th

2025 Bagel Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs Review 5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

5 Star Rating
  • $57.95 to $59.95/month, depending on subscription length
  • 16 made-in-NYC bagels per delivery, in 2 different varieties
  • Can subscribe for 3, 4 (seasonal), 6, or 12 months
  • Choose between monthly and bi-monthly deliveries
  • Pay upfront or month-to-month
  • Fantastic gift-giving features
  • Shipping is included in the bagel club price
  • Fun Whatta Bagel newsletter with every delivery
  • Exceptional customer service
  • "They'll Love It!” guarantee
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Why get bagels from just one New York bakery when you can sample a bunch of them? That's just one reason Amazing Clubs' bagel club is our absolute favorite. This is the best option for anyone who loves a surprise, with two different bagel flavors in each delivery. Amazing Clubs goes above and beyond in every way, with a stellar satisfaction guarantee, easy gift-giving options, and a fun bagel-centric newsletter telling you all about the bakeries behind each bagel box. This bagel club should be the first one you consider.

The Greater Knead Review 4 Star Rating

The Greater Knead

4 Star Rating
  • Starting at $54 for 16 bagels; discounts if you order 24+
  • All bagels are gluten-free and don't contain any of the top 9 allergens
  • You choose at least 4 flavors in your build-your-own subscription (4 bagels in each flavor)
  • Flavors include "everything”, cinnamon raisin, chocolate chip, tomato basil, French toast, garlic, onion, plain, poppy seed, pumpkin, salt, and snickerdoodle
  • Deliveries can be every 30, 60, or 90 days
  • Shipping is free on every order
  • Women-owned business since 2012

If you're looking for great-tasting, allergen-free bagels, The Greater Knead has you covered. Founded in 2012, this bakery specializes in gluten-free bagels that are also free from the top nine allergens, making them a safe and tasty choice for anyone with dietary restrictions. You can mix and match from a variety of flavors - like "everything”, cinnamon raisin, and even chocolate chip - in a flexible subscription that delivers every 30, 45, or 60 days. Plus, they offer soft pretzels and pretzel nuggets for extra variety. With free shipping, great customer service, and rave reviews from happy customers, The Greater Knead makes it easy to enjoy delicious, safe bagels whenever you want.

Which Bagel Club is the Best?

Few breakfast foods are as beloved as a fresh, chewy bagel. Whether toasted with a smear of cream cheese, loaded with smoked salmon, or simply enjoyed as-is, bagels have been a go-to comfort food for decades.

If you've ever wished for a way to enjoy authentic, bakery-fresh bagels without having to leave home, a bagel club is your best bet. These subscription services ship hand-rolled bagels from top bakeries, so you can experience the best flavors without the hassle. Whether you're a die-hard bagel lover or just looking for a tried-and-true breakfast option, joining a bagel club can add variety and convenience to your routine. Plus, if you love trying new flavors, many clubs offer seasonal and specialty bagels that you might not find at your local store.

The Best Bagel Clubs Compare Bagel Clubs Compare Bagel Club Reviews What are the best Bagel Clubs Best Bagel Club Reviews

Bagel Club FAQ

A bagel club is a subscription service that delivers fresh bagels to your doorstep on a regular basis. It allows you to enjoy a variety of bagels without having to go to a bakery or store each time.
Bagel clubs typically offer different subscription plans where you choose the frequency of delivery and the number of bagels you want. You place an order, and the bagels are freshly prepared and shipped to you on the specified schedule. Some bagel clubs require you to prepay for the full membership length (three months or a year), while others are month-to-month and you can pay as you go.
Joining a bagel club ensures a regular supply of freshly baked bagels without the hassle of going out to buy them. It provides convenience, variety, and often introduces you to unique flavors and combinations. You might also get fun extras like a newsletter, or the ability to try new bagel flavors before they're released to the public.
Many bagel clubs allow you to select the flavors of the bagels you receive. This gives you the freedom to customize your orders and try different flavors each time. Some give you a predetermined flavor selection but let you skip a month if there's one you don't like.
A few bagel clubs offer options for dietary restrictions such as gluten-free or vegan bagels. However, it's important to check with the specific club to ensure they can accommodate your dietary needs.
Yes, bagel club subscriptions make great gifts! Many clubs offer gift options, allowing you to send a subscription to a friend or family member for a certain duration, typically with a gift announcement sent via email or USPS.
Bagels are typically packaged in a way that ensures their freshness during transit. They may be individually wrapped or sealed in airtight bags to maintain their taste and texture. Follow the instructions included with your baked goods: you may need to enjoy them right away or refrigerate/freeze them to keep them fresh for a later date.
Most bagel clubs offer flexibility, allowing you to cancel or modify your subscription. Check the specific club's terms and conditions to understand their cancellation or modification policies.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Bagel clubs are also a fantastic gift idea. They're perfect for family members who miss authentic bagels from the big city or for friends who simply appreciate high-quality baked goods. With flexible delivery options and a variety of flavors to enjoy, a bagel subscription makes for a thoughtful, delicious surprise.

Originating from Eastern Europe and brought to America by Jewish immigrants in the late 19th century, bagels have evolved from a regional specialty to a nationwide favorite. New York is still the gold standard when it comes to bagels, thanks to its unique water composition that helps create the perfect balance of crispiness and chew. But no matter where you are, getting your hands on top-quality bagels is easier than ever - thanks to bagel clubs that deliver fresh-baked goodness straight to your door.

So, which subscription is right for your monthly dose of carb-y goodness? There are quite a few bagel clubs to choose from, and here are a few key factors to consider:

  • Cost. What will you pay for your delivery, and how many bagels do you get? Most clubs ship a dozen per month, but some give you 16 or more. Check to see if shipping fees are included in the price.
  • Bagel variety. Do you want a mix of classic flavors like sesame and cinnamon raisin, or are you interested in trying more unique options like French toast or "everything” egg bagels?
  • Customization options. Some clubs let you pick your flavors, while others select them for you. If you have strong preferences, look for a subscription that gives you some control.
  • Gift-friendly features. If you're ordering a bagel club as a gift, look for easy gifting options like printable announcements, customizable start dates, and flexible payment plans.
  • Reputation and reviews. What have other bagel fans said about their experiences with the subscription? Does the bakery offer a solid satisfaction guarantee? Pick a bagel club that gets lots of love from loyal customers.

The bagel-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked the most popular clubs available today. No matter which bagel club you choose, you're in for a treat. With bakery-fresh flavors and the convenience of home delivery, a great bagel subscription can bring a little taste of New York - or anywhere great bagels are made - right to your table.

The Best Reviews of Bagel Clubs