Here you can see how Davidovich Bakery and Best New York Bagel match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Bagel Clubs in 2025.
Davidovich Bakery brings old-school NYC bagel-making straight to your door, sticking to the same hand-rolled, all-natural recipes that started it all back in 1998. With their bagel club, you get 20 bagels per delivery and can pick 4 flavors from a lineup of classics - nothing wild or seasonal, just solid, time-tested choices. It's $49.99 a month with shipping included, though customers in some states will have to pay for a shipping upgrade to keep bagels fresh. Reviews on Davidovich Bakery's deliveries are a bit mixed, but if you're after a no-frills way to get legit NYC bagels at home, this club could be worth a try if you don't find what you need higher on our list.
Best New York Bagel offers a flexible subscription where you can mix and match up to six flavors per dozen, delivered on your schedule - weekly, bi-weekly, monthly, or bi-monthly - but the appeal starts to fade once you see the shipping costs, which tack on at least $21 per order. While the concept is solid, with 16 flavors including unique options like blueberry and French toast, the execution is questionable: the company's social media has been silent since 2023, customer reviews are practically nonexistent, and the BBB gives them a "C" rating for unresolved complaints. With no recent buzz and earlier reports of poor customer service, it's hard to justify the high price and potential hassle at Best New York Bagel - it's better to go with a more reliable bagel club.
Few breakfast foods are as beloved as a fresh, chewy bagel. Whether toasted with a smear of cream cheese, loaded with smoked salmon, or simply enjoyed as-is, bagels have been a go-to comfort food for decades.
If you've ever wished for a way to enjoy authentic, bakery-fresh bagels without having to leave home, a bagel club is your best bet. These subscription services ship hand-rolled bagels from top bakeries, so you can experience the best flavors without the hassle. Whether you're a die-hard bagel lover or just looking for a tried-and-true breakfast option, joining a bagel club can add variety and convenience to your routine. Plus, if you love trying new flavors, many clubs offer seasonal and specialty bagels that you might not find at your local store.
Bagel clubs are also a fantastic gift idea. They're perfect for family members who miss authentic bagels from the big city or for friends who simply appreciate high-quality baked goods. With flexible delivery options and a variety of flavors to enjoy, a bagel subscription makes for a thoughtful, delicious surprise.
Originating from Eastern Europe and brought to America by Jewish immigrants in the late 19th century, bagels have evolved from a regional specialty to a nationwide favorite. New York is still the gold standard when it comes to bagels, thanks to its unique water composition that helps create the perfect balance of crispiness and chew. But no matter where you are, getting your hands on top-quality bagels is easier than ever - thanks to bagel clubs that deliver fresh-baked goodness straight to your door.
So, which subscription is right for your monthly dose of carb-y goodness? There are quite a few bagel clubs to choose from, and here are a few key factors to consider:
The bagel-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked the most popular clubs available today. No matter which bagel club you choose, you're in for a treat. With bakery-fresh flavors and the convenience of home delivery, a great bagel subscription can bring a little taste of New York - or anywhere great bagels are made - right to your table.
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.