Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

New Yorker Bagels vs Best New York Bagel

Thursday, July 18th

2024 Bagel Club Reviews

New Yorker Bagels Review 4.5 Star Rating

New Yorker Bagels

4.5 Star Rating
  • $34.76 for one dozen bagels, $70.22 for three dozen
  • Choose two flavors per dozen, or subscribe to a recurring delivery of a single favorite flavor (monthly or weekly)
  • No long-term commitment: pause, change, or cancel anytime
  • Bagel-of-the-Month Gift available for 3, 6, 9, or 12 months; bagel flavors are preset (plain/sesame/poppy/cinnamon raisin) and club is prepaid: $39.50/month
  • In business for over 50 years

New Yorker Bagels, in business for over 50 years, offers a variety of bagel club options. You can choose the Custom Bagel of the Month option, with prices starting at $34.76 for a dozen bagels and the ability to select two flavors per dozen. Alternatively, you can opt for a Specific Flavor subscription for $35.55/dozen, receiving the same flavor each month or week. And, the Bagel of the Month Gift allows you to send a prepaid subscription of plain, sesame, poppy, and cinnamon raisin bagels for 3-12 months at $39.50/month. New Yorker Bagels provides flexibility to pause, change, or cancel subscriptions anytime. This company has a strong presence in the bagel industry, and its loyal long-term customers would tell you this is an excellent choice for a bagel club membership.

Best New York Bagel Review 3.5 Star Rating

Best New York Bagel

3.5 Star Rating
  • $24.69 for a recurring monthly subscription of 12 bagels
  • Shipping fees of $20+ per delivery
  • Choose up to 6 flavors in each delivery
  • Choose delivery weekly, bi-weekly, monthly, or bi-monthly
  • "A" rated by the BBB

Best New York Bagel, founded by a NYC firefighter who wanted to bring authentic bagels to the nation, offers a bagel club with a recurring monthly subscription of 12 bagels priced at $24.69. However, the shipping fees of $20+ per delivery significantly increase the total cost, making it comparable to other bagel clubs. On the plus side, this club allows you to choose up to 6 flavors in each delivery and offers flexible delivery options, including weekly, bi-weekly, monthly, or bi-monthly. Although Best New York Bagel has received an "A" rating from the Better Business Bureau, it could use more customer feedback to move up in our rankings. Despite this, the club's affordability, flavor selection, and flexibility make it a worthy option to consider, especially for those seeking more frequent deliveries.

Which Bagel Club is the Best?

In recent years, bagel clubs have emerged as a way to cater to bagel enthusiasts who crave regular access to fresh, high-quality bagels. Why sign up for a bagel club? There's no better way to get a consistent supply of freshly baked bagels without the need to visit a bakery or grocery store.

Bagel clubs also create a sense of anticipation and surprise. Members typically receive different flavors with each delivery, adding an element of excitement to their bagel experience. This variety keeps things interesting and allows members to sample a range of flavors they may not have tried otherwise.

The Best Bagel Clubs Compare Bagel Clubs Compare Bagel Club Reviews What are the best Bagel Clubs Best Bagel Club Reviews

Bagel Club FAQ

A bagel club is a subscription service that delivers fresh bagels to your doorstep on a regular basis. It allows you to enjoy a variety of bagels without having to go to a bakery or store each time.
Bagel clubs typically offer different subscription plans where you choose the frequency of delivery and the number of bagels you want. You place an order, and the bagels are freshly prepared and shipped to you on the specified schedule. Some bagel clubs require you to prepay for the full membership length (three months or a year), while others are month-to-month and you can pay as you go.
Joining a bagel club ensures a regular supply of freshly baked bagels without the hassle of going out to buy them. It provides convenience, variety, and often introduces you to unique flavors and combinations. You might also get fun extras like a newsletter, or the ability to try new bagel flavors before they're released to the public.
Many bagel clubs allow you to select the flavors of the bagels you receive. This gives you the freedom to customize your orders and try different flavors each time. Some give you a predetermined flavor selection but let you skip a month if there's one you don't like.
A few bagel clubs offer options for dietary restrictions such as gluten-free or vegan bagels. However, it's important to check with the specific club to ensure they can accommodate your dietary needs.
Yes, bagel club subscriptions make great gifts! Many clubs offer gift options, allowing you to send a subscription to a friend or family member for a certain duration, typically with a gift announcement sent via email or USPS.
Bagels are typically packaged in a way that ensures their freshness during transit. They may be individually wrapped or sealed in airtight bags to maintain their taste and texture. Follow the instructions included with your baked goods: you may need to enjoy them right away or refrigerate/freeze them to keep them fresh for a later date.
Most bagel clubs offer flexibility, allowing you to cancel or modify your subscription. Check the specific club's terms and conditions to understand their cancellation or modification policies.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

The convenience of a Bagel Club is particularly appealing to busy individuals or those who have trouble finding authentic and not-mass-produced bagels in their area. Additionally, bagel clubs often offer a wider variety of flavors and specialty options that may not be readily available elsewhere, allowing members to explore new tastes and indulge in their bagel cravings.

Bagel clubs can even foster a sense of community and connection. Some clubs encourage members to share their bagel experiences on social media or participate in online discussions, creating a space for bagel enthusiasts to engage with like-minded individuals and share their love for this iconic food.

Bagels have a long and rich history that spans centuries, starting in Eastern Europe and making their way to become a beloved staple in various parts of the world. The origin of bagels can be traced back to Jewish communities in Poland in the 16th century, with the round shape of the bagel said to symbolize eternity and often associated with celebrations and religious events.

Bagels were traditionally made by boiling the dough first and then baking it, resulting in a distinct chewy texture and shiny crust. Jewish immigrants brought bagel-making techniques to the United States in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, where they gained popularity among a wider audience.

Over time, bagels evolved beyond their traditional flavors of plain and sesame. Today, you can find a variety of flavors, such as poppy seed, cinnamon raisin, "everything" , and even more experimental flavors like cranberry orange or jalapeno. Bagels have become a versatile food item, enjoyed on their own, sliced and toasted, or used as a base for sandwiches and spreads.

However, it's important to note that not all bagel clubs are created equal. How can you tell which ones are worth your attention? Here are a few criteria to help you pick the best plan for your bagel deliveries:

  • Variety. Are you looking for a new flavor twist on a favorite food? Or do you prefer getting regular shipments of something tried-and-true? You can get a bagel club that caters to either one.
  • Price. What will you pay for your bagel subscription? Is shipping included in the cost?
  • Delivery schedule. What's your ideal delivery frequency for your bagels? Most clubs operate on a monthly basis, but some let you set up your membership to bring you fresh bagels every week, every other week, or every other month.
  • Reputation. What do other bagel-lovers say about their experience with the club? Some clubs offered by smaller bakeries may not have as much feedback, so check out what customers say about other aspects of the business (quality of the food served at an in-person location, freshness of a la carte orders shipped across the country, and so on).

Bagel clubs have emerged as a modern concept, catering to bagel enthusiasts who seek convenience, variety, and a sense of community. By providing regular deliveries of fresh, delicious bagels, these clubs offer a unique experience that allows individuals to indulge in their love for bagels and explore new flavors. That's why Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated the best - and the worst - bagel clubs, to help you elevate your breakfast routine and add a delightful touch to your culinary adventures.

The Best Reviews of Bagel Clubs