Sunday, May 18th
2025 Bagel Club Reviews
New Yorker Bagels
- Prices start at $26.55/month for a dozen bagels
- 22 flavors to choose from, in classic and more novel flavors, both sweet and savory options
- 3 subscription options to choose from (custom, 1-flavor, gift)
- Can have deliveries come every 1-4 months
- Free FedEx 2-day shipping on every bagel club
- Bagel Dough rewards program
- Lots of positive reviews
- In business for over 50 years
New Yorker Bagels has been a staple of the NYC bagel scene for over 50 years, and now you can get their fresh, authentic bagels delivered straight to your door with their flexible subscription service. With three plans to choose from - custom, single-flavor, or gift - you can enjoy almost 2 dozen classic and unique flavors, delivered every 1-4 months with free 2-day FedEx shipping. The Bagel Dough Rewards program adds extra perks, letting you earn discounts on future orders. Customers rave about the freshness and quality, making New Yorker Bagels' club an excellent choice for anyone craving a true Big Apple bagel experience at home.
Zucker's
- $95.95/month
- Each delivery comes with a dozen NYC-made bagels, 3 half-pound containers of schmears, and a surprise treat (coffee mug, dessert, toasted "everything” seeds)
- Flavors include plain/sesame/everything for the bagels and plain/scallion/flavor-of-the-month for the schmears
- Subscribe for 3, 6, 9, or 12 months
- Shipping is included in the club price
- Strong focus on sustainability and giving back to the community
- In business since 2006
Zucker's Bagels and Smoked Fish brings the true taste of a New York bagel straight to your doorstep with their Bagel + Cream Cheese subscription. Every month, you'll get a dozen authentic, hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels, three half-pound containers of schmear, and a fun surprise like a coffee mug or a sweet treat. The flavors stick to the savory side: plain, sesame, and "everything” bagels, paired with plain, scallion, and a rotating spread of the month. While Zucker's stands out for its commitment to sustainability and community, donating 500 bagels daily to The Bowery Mission, the subscription itself is a bit of a gamble - there are no customer reviews for the bagel club, and at $95.95 per box (paid upfront for a minimum of 3 months), it's the priciest option on our list. If you're craving a premium NYC bagel experience, Zucker's is worth trying for a short-term splurge, but the high cost and lack of feedback keep it from ranking higher on our list.
More Bagel Club Reviews
The 8 Best Bagel Clubs
Which Bagel Club is the Best?
Few breakfast foods are as beloved as a fresh, chewy bagel. Whether toasted with a smear of cream cheese, loaded with smoked salmon, or simply enjoyed as-is, bagels have been a go-to comfort food for decades.
If you've ever wished for a way to enjoy authentic, bakery-fresh bagels without having to leave home, a bagel club is your best bet. These subscription services ship hand-rolled bagels from top bakeries, so you can experience the best flavors without the hassle. Whether you're a die-hard bagel lover or just looking for a tried-and-true breakfast option, joining a bagel club can add variety and convenience to your routine. Plus, if you love trying new flavors, many clubs offer seasonal and specialty bagels that you might not find at your local store.
Bagel Club FAQ
Continued from above...
Bagel clubs are also a fantastic gift idea. They're perfect for family members who miss authentic bagels from the big city or for friends who simply appreciate high-quality baked goods. With flexible delivery options and a variety of flavors to enjoy, a bagel subscription makes for a thoughtful, delicious surprise.
Originating from Eastern Europe and brought to America by Jewish immigrants in the late 19th century, bagels have evolved from a regional specialty to a nationwide favorite. New York is still the gold standard when it comes to bagels, thanks to its unique water composition that helps create the perfect balance of crispiness and chew. But no matter where you are, getting your hands on top-quality bagels is easier than ever - thanks to bagel clubs that deliver fresh-baked goodness straight to your door.
So, which subscription is right for your monthly dose of carb-y goodness? There are quite a few bagel clubs to choose from, and here are a few key factors to consider:
- Cost. What will you pay for your delivery, and how many bagels do you get? Most clubs ship a dozen per month, but some give you 16 or more. Check to see if shipping fees are included in the price.
- Bagel variety. Do you want a mix of classic flavors like sesame and cinnamon raisin, or are you interested in trying more unique options like French toast or "everything” egg bagels?
- Customization options. Some clubs let you pick your flavors, while others select them for you. If you have strong preferences, look for a subscription that gives you some control.
- Gift-friendly features. If you're ordering a bagel club as a gift, look for easy gifting options like printable announcements, customizable start dates, and flexible payment plans.
- Reputation and reviews. What have other bagel fans said about their experiences with the subscription? Does the bakery offer a solid satisfaction guarantee? Pick a bagel club that gets lots of love from loyal customers.
The bagel-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked the most popular clubs available today. No matter which bagel club you choose, you're in for a treat. With bakery-fresh flavors and the convenience of home delivery, a great bagel subscription can bring a little taste of New York - or anywhere great bagels are made - right to your table.
Compare Bagel Clubs
Select any 2 Bagel Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Bagel Club News
Related Bagel Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Bagel Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
