Bagel Clubs Reviews

8 Best Bagel Clubs of 2026

We've analyzed the best Bagel Clubs to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Bagel Club Reviews

Which Bagel Club is the Best?  Few breakfast foods are as beloved as a fresh, chewy bagel. Whether toasted with a smear of cream cheese, loaded with smoked salmon, or simply enjoyed as-is, bagels have been a go-to comfort food for decades.

5.0

EXCELLENT

1

Best Option

  • $57.95 to $59.95/month, depending on subscription length
  • 16 made-in-NYC bagels per delivery, in 2 different varieties
  • Can subscribe for 3, 4 (seasonal), 6, or 12 months
  • Choose between monthly and bi-monthly deliveries
  • Pay upfront or month-to-month
  • Fantastic gift-giving features
  • Shipping is included in the bagel club price
  • Fun Whatta Bagel newsletter with every delivery
  • Exceptional customer service
  • "They'll Love It!" guarantee

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the Amazing Clubs website

When it comes to monthly subscriptions, Amazing Clubs is a name that consistently delivers top-tier experiences. From cupcakes to candles, honey to hot sauce, their lineup of 38 clubs covers just about every interest. If you want variety, you can even mix and match different subscriptions, alternating bagels with flowers, desserts, or jam. But if bagels are your main event, this club is hands-down the best choice.

16 freshly-baked bagels in every box

Every Amazing Clubs shipment brings you 16 full-sized bagels, baked fresh by some of New York's best bagel makers and shipped straight to your door. You'll receive two different flavors each month, with eight bagels of each. The lineup has included everything from classics like egg and cinnamon raisin to more novel picks like "Black Russian" (dark pumpernickel/raisin), sunflower seed, and cranberry. While you won't get to pick your own flavors, Amazing Clubs takes the guesswork out by letting you know the selections ahead of time. If there's a month that doesn't quite match your taste, you can easily skip it and have that delivery added to the end of your plan.

A side of bagel knowledge

Each shipment also includes Whatta Bagel, a fun newsletter packed with insights about the bakeries behind your bagels, creative serving ideas, and interesting bagel trivia. Whether you're a die-hard bagel fan or just bagel-curious, it's a great little bonus to your monthly delivery.

Best Bagel Clubs

Pricing and subscription flexibility

So, how much does Amazing Clubs' bagel subscription cost? That depends on the length of your subscription:

  • 3-month plan: $59.95/delivery
  • 4-month seasonal plan: $59.95/delivery
  • 6-month plan: $58.95/delivery
  • 12-month plan: $57.95/delivery

The good news? Shipping is already included, no matter which plan you choose. You also have the option to space out deliveries every other month if that works better for you. Plus, while many rival bagel clubs require full payment upfront, Amazing Clubs lets you pay as you go if that's your preference.

Delivers on the discounts

Even though Amazing Clubs is already super-affordable, they're always offering discounts to tempt you into signing up for anything you've been eyeing. The one we see most often is if we browse around a while before clicking on anything: we almost always get a pop-up offering $5 off a 3-month subscription, $10 off a seasonal club, $15 off a 6-month club, and $30 off a 12-month club, with the requirement that we complete our order within an hour. Also, once you become an Amazing Clubs customer, expect to get emails almost daily (honestly, it's a bit much) with discounts on new subscriptions. In short, there's no reason you'll ever have to pay full price on a subscription here - bagels or anything else.

The ultimate bagel gift

If you're looking for a unique gift, this bagel club is one of the easiest to give. At checkout, you can provide the recipient's details and choose how they'll be notified - either by email, USPS mail, or a printable gift announcement you can hand-deliver yourself. You also get to select when their first shipment will go out, with options for any month in the upcoming year. No matter when they subscribe, bagels always ship during the last week of the month. Also, your lucky recipient will get the preview emails, so they can skip any months with bagel flavors they don't particularly like (or times when they'll be out of town). It's really hassle-free for everyone.

A satisfaction guarantee that's hard to beat

Over the years, we've tested multiple clubs from Amazing Clubs, and one thing has remained constant: their "You'll Love It! Guarantee." If anything goes wrong - whether the bagels arrive stale, the flavors don't meet expectations, or a shipment goes missing - customer service will do whatever it takes to make it right. And if you ever decide to cancel, any unused portion of a prepaid plan is refunded, while pay-as-you-go members can simply stop future shipments.

Best Bagel Clubs

Even New Yorkers give it a thumbs-up

Bagel snobs, take note: even lifelong New Yorkers have been impressed by this club. Some started out skeptical but ended up pleasantly surprised by the authenticity and freshness of these bagels. The only complaints we found came from people who thought that "bagels are a very weird gift" (okay then...) or wished the club included more plain varieties. Fortunately, Amazing Clubs allows easy swaps to another subscription if needed.

Our top pick for bagel lovers

If you're all about plain bagels, this might not be your perfect match. But if you love variety, top-quality bagels, and a flexible subscription with fantastic customer service, Amazing Clubs is the clear winner. Whether for yourself or as a gift, this bagel club offers an unbeatable combination of freshness, fun, and reliability, earning it our #1 spot among bagel subscriptions.

On the Amazing Clubs website

4.5

GREAT

2

Great

  • Prices start at $26.55/month for a dozen bagels
  • 22 flavors to choose from, in classic and more novel flavors, both sweet and savory options
  • 3 subscription options to choose from (custom, 1-flavor, gift)
  • Can have deliveries come every 1-4 months
  • Free FedEx 2-day shipping on every bagel club
  • Bagel Dough rewards program
  • Lots of positive reviews
  • In business for over 50 years

GREAT

4.5

On the New Yorker Bagels website

New Yorker Bagels has been serving up classic New York bagels for over 50 years, first as The Bagel Buffet on NYC's 6th Avenue before expanding into wholesale distribution about two decades ago. Fortunately, you don't have to be in the tri-state area to enjoy these fresh-baked bagels - thanks to their bagel club.

Three ways to get your bagel fix

New Yorker Bagels offers three flexible subscription options:

  • Custom Bagel of the Month: Choose from a dozen or three dozen bagels per delivery, with two or six flavors, respectively. Pricing starts at $26.55 per dozen, with shipping included.
  • Specific Flavor Subscription: Prefer to stick with one favorite flavor? You can get a dozen delivered on a regular schedule for the same $26.55, with free shipping.
  • Bagel of the Month Gift: Sending a taste of NYC to a friend? Or maybe you just want to get bagels for a certain timeframe without having to remember to cancel your subscription? This gift option runs for 3, 6, 9, or 12 months and lets you select the flavors you'd like to include (2 flavors, 6 each). Pricing starts at $89 for a 3-month plan, with shipping included.

Lots of love from New Yorkers (and everyone else)

While some bagel lovers have strong opinions on what makes a true NYC bagel, most New Yorker Bagels customers are extremely loyal. Reviews across various platforms are mostly positive, but with enough negative ones sprinkled throughout (and responded to appropriately) for us to have confidence that the comments are all from real customers. We were particularly glad to read through the reviews left on Facebook: most of them were regarding shipped orders, and almost everyone says that the bagels arrive fresh and taste exactly how you'd expect for a Big Apple bagel.

Best Bagel Clubs

Almost two dozen delicious bagel flavors

Speaking of flavors, New Yorker Bagels has an incredible variety to choose from. At the time of our review, we were able to select from the following:

  • Apple Cinnamon Raisin
  • Blueberry
  • Cinnamon Raisin
  • Cranberry Energy
  • French Toast
  • Jalapeño Red Pepper
  • Marble Rye
  • Poppy
  • Plain
  • Pumpernickel
  • And more than a dozen more

You're the boss of this bagel club

That's not where the customization ends, though. You also can choose to have your bagels delivered every 1-4 months. Plus, New Yorker Bagels makes it easy to adjust your subscription. You can pause deliveries, change flavors, or update your schedule as needed. Since you're paying month to month (unless it's a gift subscription), you can also cancel anytime. And, to top it all off, New Yorker Bagels gives you free 2-day FedEx shipping on every bagel club subscription.

Don't miss the free rewards program

But wait, there's more. This is the only bagel club on our list that has a loyalty program, called Bagel Dough Rewards. You earn "sesame seeds" (points) for signing up (250), 5 "seeds" for every dollar spent, 25 for liking New Yorker Bagels on Facebook, 75 for following the bakery on Instagram, you get the idea. Oh, and starting a bagel subscription? 500 sesame seeds. When you have at least 500 seeds (easy to do when you sign up before starting your subscription), you can redeem them for $5 off your order, including subscriptions. Why not?!

Best Bagel Clubs

Best bagel club for variety and authenticity

With decades of experience and a reputation for quality, New Yorker Bagels knows how to deliver an authentic bagel experience. Whether you're craving a classic or something a little different, their subscription service gives you plenty of options. If you're looking for a convenient way to enjoy nearly two dozen flavors of fresh NYC bagels at home, New Yorker Bagels' club should be near the top of your list.

On the New Yorker Bagels website

4.0

VERY GOOD

3

Very Good

  • Starting at $54 for 16 bagels; discounts if you order 24+
  • All bagels are gluten-free and don't contain any of the top 9 allergens
  • You choose at least 4 flavors in your build-your-own subscription (4 bagels in each flavor)
  • Flavors include "everything", cinnamon raisin, chocolate chip, tomato basil, French toast, garlic, onion, plain, poppy seed, pumpkin, salt, and snickerdoodle
  • Deliveries can be every 30, 60, or 90 days
  • Shipping is free on every order
  • Women-owned business since 2012

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the The Greater Knead website

If you're a bagel lover with allergies, you know how tough it can be to find a good option. That's exactly why The Greater Knead was created - to make bagels that are safe for people with dietary restrictions. The founder started the bakery in 2012 after her sister and grandfather were diagnosed with Celiac Disease, and since then, they've been crafting bagels and baked goods that are free from the top nine allergens: wheat/gluten, dairy, eggs, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, fish, shellfish, and sesame. (And just to be extra careful, they also don't use mustard, celery, or sulfites, per EU guidelines.)

You choose the flavors and create your subscription

You can order any combo of bagels you like as a one-off order from The Greater Knead. Your box has to contain at least 4 bags, with 4 bagels in each one (a total of 16 bagels). But, as soon as you hit the "Subscribe" button and choose a delivery frequency - every 30, 60, or 90 days - you'll see the price drop from $60 to $54. That's your "bagel club" discount.

Best Bagel Clubs

Over a dozen fantastic flavors of bagels

And flavors? Your perfect lineup can include any of the following: "everything", cinnamon raisin, chocolate chip, tomato basil, French toast, garlic, onion, plain, poppy seed, pumpkin, salt, or snickerdoodle. You may also have seasonal specialties to choose from; for example, we've seen heart-shaped bagels in the past.

Other tasty baked goods you can add to your box

Bagels aren't the only thing on the menu. If you're in the mood for a little extra, The Greater Knead also offers gluten- and allergen-free soft pretzels and pretzel nuggets. It's a great way to add some variety to your order while still keeping things safe and delicious. We noticed that when we created a subscription with the minimum requirement of 4 bagel packs, we got a notification saying we could add 2 more frozen baked goods to our cart and get a discount - so keep that in mind if you'd like to mix-and-match a bit outside of "just bagels".

Free shipping

Are you thinking "I bet there's a catch, and it's going to be ‘expensive shipping'"? Nope. All orders at The Greater Knead ship for free. Your bagels (and other baked goods) arrive frozen, so there isn't the same time crunch/deadline you might have when buying freshly-baked bagels from other bakeries.

No spam, please

The one thing we didn't like? When all we had done was enter our name and email address to find out shipping costs, we still got a "here's a discount" email from The Greater Knead, even though we had checked the box saying we weren't interested in getting promotions or being added to the mailing list. That always leaves a bad taste in our mouth, and we'd recommend that this bakery take steps to remove that from their online process.

Best Bagel Clubs

Terrific customer service

The Greater Knead has built a loyal following. Customers rave about how these bagels taste just like (or even better than) traditional ones. Many have said they never thought they'd get to enjoy a bagel again until they found this bakery. While you'll have to look at the a la carte bagels to see reviews on individual flavors, you can rest assured that if something goes awry with your delivery, all it takes is a reach-out to The Greater Knead's customer service team and they'll make it right.

Game-changer for bagel-lovers with allergies

If you need a bagel subscription that's completely allergen-free, The Greater Knead is a no-brainer. But even if you don't have dietary restrictions, it's still a fantastic choice. The bagels are delicious, the subscription is flexible, and the price is competitive. The only downside? You won't find super adventurous flavors, but that's a small price to pay for a safe and high-quality product - and there's still a broader selection of both sweet and savory bagels than many of the competitors on our list. Whether you have food sensitivities or just want to try something new, this is a bagel club worth checking out.

On the The Greater Knead website

3.5

GOOD

4

Good

  • $95.95/month
  • Each delivery comes with a dozen NYC-made bagels, 3 half-pound containers of schmears, and a surprise treat (coffee mug, dessert, toasted "everything" seeds)
  • Flavors include plain/sesame/everything for the bagels and plain/scallion/flavor-of-the-month for the schmears
  • Subscribe for 3, 6, 9, or 12 months
  • Shipping is included in the club price
  • Strong focus on sustainability and giving back to the community
  • In business since 2006

GOOD

3.5

On the Zucker's website

Zucker's Bagels and Smoked Fish is a true New York staple, bringing classic, hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels to the city since 2006. Founded in TriBeCa, Zucker's takes pride in doing things the old-fashioned way - using high-quality, unbleached, and unbromated flours with a touch of malt syrup for a perfect golden crust and chewy bite. They don't skimp on the toppings either, making sure every bagel is generously coated on both sides. And, with its bagel club, Zucker's delivers the tradition of a great New York bagel anywhere in the US (even Alaska and Hawaii, with a $20 delivery surcharge).

You get way more than bagels with this club

Out of all of the bagel clubs on our list, Zucker's is the one you might call "bagels and more": every delivery comes not just with a dozen bagels, but also three half-pound containers of schmear in true New York fashion. Plus, you'll always get a surprise "extra": sometimes that might be a little babka dessert, another month it might be a coffee mug, and so on.

Best Bagel Clubs

Expect the bagels and schmears to be savory

With respect to flavors, you should anticipate that all of your bagels-and-schmear will be savory: the bagels are an assortment of plain, sesame, and "everything", and the cream cheese flavors will be plain, scallion, and the flavor of the month. That doesn't sound like you would be getting any cinnamon-raisin bagels with a brown sugar cream cheese spread, but we wouldn't completely rule it out. (We recommend calling Zucker's if you absolutely need to know.)

Pay in full for at least 3 months

Knowing that you get all of that in your delivery, you probably won't be surprised to learn that this is the most expensive bagel club on our list. Regardless of whether you subscribe for 3, 6, 9, or 12 months, your cost will be $95.95 per delivery, with shipping included in that price. You do have to pay for your entire bagel club plan upfront: that's a jaw-dropping $1151.40 if you go for a full year subscription.

Dedicated to helping the local community

Zucker's isn't just about making great bagels - they also believe in giving back to the community that helped shape them. Owners Matt Pomerantz and Dan Pace are dedicated to running a business that supports its team, its customers, and the city they call home. Zucker's prioritizes sustainability by sourcing locally whenever possible, using eco-friendly packaging, and even delivering by bicycle. They also have a deep commitment to helping those in need, donating 500 bagels every day - about 180,000 meals a year - to The Bowery Mission, which provides food and services to homeless and hungry New Yorkers. From supporting local schools and sports teams to making sure no bagel goes to waste, Zucker's is about more than just breakfast - it's about being a good neighbor. And that's a bagel bakery we can get behind.

Could use more feedback from bagel club subscribers

We can't really tell you how people feel about Zucker's Bagel + Cream Cheese subscription: there were absolutely no reviews for it on the Goldbelly platform that the bakery uses for fulfillment of shipped orders (and we didn't even see a place where customers could rate it). So, yes, you are taking a bit of a chance when you sign up here, because the minimum commitment is three months. And, with Goldbelly not saying that customers can cancel subscriptions and get a refund once they've started, we're not entirely confident that there will be any kind of satisfaction guarantee. But, Goldbelly does invite customers to reach out within 14 days if there's a problem with an order; you just might not be in luck if you simply don't like the bagels and schmear on taste alone.

Best Bagel Clubs

Reviews for in-person experiences are mid-tier

Over on Yelp, Zucker's Bagels gets a 3-star average score across more than 2,200 reviews. Of course, that feedback is almost always for the in-person experience; high ratings typically come in for the food itself, while lower ratings usually refer to poor service or wrong orders. None of the latter is likely to apply to your month-to-month bagel subscription, though.

Better than average bagel club

Final verdict? Zucker's Bagel + Cream Cheese club is one we'd be excited to get as a gift (you can specify that during checkout, and your recipient will get an email announcement) or to try for a 3-month subscription. It's a great pairing of the quintessential NYC bagel-and-schmear that people go all over the city to test out, and you won't find it with the other subscriptions on our list. On the other hand, the lack of feedback and the spendy $300-ish you'll have to pay for the shortest plan are what keep Zucker's from rating any higher.

On the Zucker's website

3.0

AVERAGE

5

Average

  • $49.99/month or $599.88/year
  • 20 bagels per delivery; you choose up to 4 flavors (5 each)
  • Flavors include Everything, 7-Grain, Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, Pumpernickel, Garlic, Poppy, Onion, Sesame, Plain, Egg, Sourdough, and Whole Wheat
  • Shipping is included in the club price; some locations have to upgrade to second-day shipping to keep bagels fresh
  • In business since 1998

AVERAGE

3.0

On the Davidovich Bakery website

Davidovich Bakery has its roots in tradition, shaped by the childhood memories of Gene Davidovich and the aromas of fresh-baked bread in his grandmother's Ukrainian kitchen. After immigrating to the US in 1980, he carried those flavors and techniques with him, eventually turning a passion for baking into a family-run business in 1998. From the beginning, the focus has been on hand-rolled, high-quality bagels made with all-natural ingredients, a commitment that continues today. Even as the bakery has grown, it remains dedicated to the craftsmanship and care that first inspired it, with Gene himself still stepping in to roll and bake, keeping the tradition alive.

Go month-to-month or pay for a year upfront

The bagel club here has made some positive changes since our earlier review. You've now got two subscriptions to choose from: a month-to-month plan at $49.99, or a paid-in-full, annual plan for $599.88. Shipping costs are included in both subscriptions (with the exception of orders going to FL, CA, TX, AZ, UT, ID, CO, NM, and KS; those customers will have to upgrade to second-day shipping), and since there's no savings when you subscribe for a year (and pay upfront), we'd recommend going with the month-to-month plan.

You choose up to 4 flavors in each delivery

It's also possible now to see all of the flavors on offer and select the ones you want in your bagel club boxes. You get 20 bagels each month: 5 each in the 4 flavors you choose. Those flavors include Everything, 7-Grain, Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, Pumpernickel, Garlic, Poppy, Onion, Sesame, Plain, Egg, Sourdough, and Whole Wheat.

Best Bagel Clubs

Just a basic bagel box here

That's really about all you can expect with this bagel club: classic flavors with nothing crazy or seasonal in the mix, no gift-giving options or other perks like a newsletter, just a shipment of the same bagels you'd get if you stopped by the Essex Street Market location on the Lower East Side.

Customers have mixed feelings about bagel delivery

Reputation-wise overall, Davidovich Bakery does okay. They've been around long enough (almost 3 decades) to be a well-known staple in NYC, but most of the feedback out there is based on in-person purchases. We did spot a few reviews from customers who ordered from Davidovich Bakery online, and they were mixed. One person said "the bagels were hard when received and cookies were broken". But, another said that this bakery is "the best delivery service to get NYC bagels remotely". All we can say after reading through dozens of reviews is that your delivery experience with Davidovich Bakery is going to be hit-or-miss.

Not the best or the worst bagel club

All told, Davidovich Bakery's bagel club has made enough changes to move the needle on its reputation since our last review, up to a "just average" score. You get a lot of bagel-for-your-buck here at under $50 for 20, and some customers will really appreciate being able to pick the specific flavors that come in their box. However, compared with some of its rivals on our list, Davidovich Bakery comes up a little short. We'd suggest looking a little higher in our rankings first, but loop back to this bakery if you don't find what you need there.

On the Davidovich Bakery website

2.9

AVERAGE

6

Average

  • $15/half-dozen or $29/dozen bagels every 4 weeks
  • Choose 1-2 flavors per month from plain, "everything", sesame, poppy seed, sea salt, pumpernickel, and the monthly special
  • Pay-as-you-go; no long-term commitment required
  • Shipping not included in the price (could be $17+ for USPS Priority)
  • Can donate an extra dozen at half-price to hunger relief program

AVERAGE

2.9

On the Knead & Nosh website

Knead & Nosh's bagel subscription is the work of Jeff Mao, a baker, educator, and technologist who blends his skills into a unique culinary experience. This small business isn't just about selling bagels - it's about sharing the love of baking through online classes, recipes, and articles to help home bakers up their game.

Get 6 or 12 bagels, mostly in savory flavors

One of Jeff's newest offerings is Knead & Nosh's monthly bagel subscription. Each delivery includes either a dozen ($29) or a half-dozen ($15) hand-rolled bagels, featuring classic options like plain and "everything", as well as more adventurous "monthly special" flavors like roasted garlic and Maine blueberry. Subscribers can customize their selections or opt for a rotating variety each month, making it a fun way to discover new favorites. Just be aware that the "monthly special" flavor is the only slot where you might get a sweet bagel; the regular flavors are all savory (plain, "everything", sesame, poppy seed, sea salt, pumpernickel), or at least not sugary like a cinnamon raisin or French toast variety.

Shipping from Maine can take a while

As exciting as it is to support a small business with a growing reputation, this subscription does come with some logistical concerns. The bagels ship from Maine via USPS Priority Mail, and depending on where you live, they could take a week or more to arrive - meaning you may need to toast them rather than enjoy them fresh. Shipping costs vary by location, but one test address in Florida showed a $17.38 charge, which can add up quickly. Once you've added your bagel club to the cart, enter the delivery address to get your estimate - Knead & Nosh doesn't believe in any nasty surprises or hidden costs.

Best Bagel Clubs

More than just bagels: Learn to bake your own

One thing that really sets Knead & Nosh apart is its focus on education. Beyond the subscription, Jeff Mao offers a wide range of online baking classes and resources, including step-by-step videos, live virtual workshops, and downloadable guides. Whether you're a beginner trying to master the basics or an experienced home baker looking to refine your technique, there's something for every skill level. It's a great way to deepen your appreciation for what goes into a truly good bagel - and maybe even inspire you to start baking your own.

Donate bagels at half price

That said, we love that Knead & Nosh offers an option to give back: you can donate a dozen bagels to the Mid Coast Hunger Prevention Program at half price, providing food to a family in need. Just look for that in the options as you're setting up your bagel club.

Off to a good start

While this subscription is still new and hasn't built up reviews yet, Knead & Nosh's strong local presence at farmer's markets in Maine and its community-focused mission make it one to watch. For now, we're giving it a "just average" rating, but we hope to see great feedback regarding this bagel club in the (near) future that would easily bring that rating up.

On the Knead & Nosh website

2.0

SUBPAR

7

Subpar

  • $25.99 for a dozen bagels
  • You choose up to 6 flavors (2 each) per shipment, 16 flavors total
  • Can get bagels weekly, bi-weekly, monthly, or bi-monthly
  • Shipping costs $21+ per delivery
  • Can request a preferred delivery date

SUBPAR

2.0

On the Best New York Bagel website

Picture yourself as a born-and-raised New Yorker, leaving the bright lights and big city to attend college in the Midwest. You go to a local bakery for a bagel breakfast - and it's good, but it's absolutely nothing like what you get back home. That was the inspiration behind the creation of Best New York Bagel, owned and operated by a NYC firefighter who found out firsthand that there's just something special about bagels from the Big Apple. This bakery designed its bagel subscription so that no matter where you live, you can always enjoy a fresh New York bite.

Choose your bagel flavors two-by-two

If you really like being able to choose all of the flavors in your bagel box, Best New York Bagel will really appeal to you. They have 16 flavors in total - including classics like plain and sesame seed, plus more novel ones like blueberry and French toast (though there's a slight surcharge for those last two). And, you get to pick what comes in each shipment: you choose your flavors 2 bagels at a time, so that means you get up to 6 different flavors per delivery. (But yes, if you want a dozen in a single flavor, you can do that too.) Whatever your favorite bagel combos are, you'll pay $25.99 for a dozen.

Shipping costs about as much as the bagels

Once you've added your bagel flavors to your cart, and indicated whether you want them to be delivered weekly, every other week, every month, or every other month, you'll want to check out the shipping rates calculator on the Shopping Cart page. While what you pay will depend on where you're sending your Best New York Bagel subscription, you're likely looking at a minimum of $21 for USPS Priority Mail or UPS 2nd Day Air at $23. We'd strongly recommend going with UPS, since we've seen many USPS Priority Mail shipments taking a week or more - and your bagels would be more likely to arrive stale or spoiled.

Best Bagel Clubs

High shipping fees

Those high shipping fees take what looks like a super-low-priced bagel club and put it into range with most of the rival subscriptions on our list. It's also a smart idea to put it in the optional notes section if you have a preferred delivery date; that will depend on the shipping carrier you select, but it's a nice benefit if you're trying to get your bagels arriving on a particular day (like Thursday Bagel Breakfast at the office).

No new feedback, and old reviews weren't great

We really wish we could tell you more about this bakery and bagel club, but the company's reputation is pretty elusive. The Better Business Bureau gives the bakery a "C" rating for not responding to one of the three complaints filed there; those issues all mentioned late or missing deliveries. Even Best New York Bagel's social media channels didn't have new posts in the last 18+ months. There was one mention on Facebook in 2024 from someone who said that their bagels arrived in open bags and were dried out, and that no one at Best New York Bagel ever responded to their phone calls and emails. But, that's where the trail of breadcrumbs (pun intended) fades out: no one is saying anything about this bagel bakery lately, and that's a problem.

Not a bagel club we recommend

We were hopeful that Best New York Bagel would have tons more customer comments in the time since our previous review of their subscription - because we really love the idea of being able to try six different bagel flavors in every order. We might have even been willing to pay those exorbitant shipping costs. However, Best New York Bagel just doesn't deliver (literally or figuratively) well enough to justify the risk. With such a high likelihood of winding up disappointed here, you're better off getting your bagels on the regular from a different club on our list.

On the Best New York Bagel website

1.0

POOR

8

Poor

  • $14.40/week or $16.20/month for a half-dozen bagels
  • Flavors may include plain, "everything", sesame seed, onion, poppy seed, salted, cheddar, and French toast
  • Shipping may be included in the price

POOR

1.0

On the Exes & Zees website

When you land on the Exes & Zees site, thinking you're going to get a bagel subscription, the first word that will probably come to your mind (as it did to ours) is "random". We can promise you that there's no other bagel club on our list that also offers market coffee (makes sense), supplements (stretching it a bit), beauty products (why?)... and professional services for graphic design and website development (?!). Exes & Zees seems to be based in Minnesota somewhere, but that's really all we can tell you about the business behind the bagels here.

Lots of questions remain about this bagel club

If you love the idea of getting a mystery bagel box, this could very well be the club for you. It's available as a weekly or monthly subscription, but the bagel club page doesn't tell you much more beyond the fact that you'll pay $14.40 on a weekly plan and $16.20 on a monthly one. It does auto-renew, but in theory, you can skip or cancel anytime.

Best Bagel Clubs

Look at the a la carte shop to figure out bagel flavors

Since there's nowhere on the bagel subscription page that tells you what flavors might be in your subscription, we went to the main Bagels page in the online store to do some detective work. From what we can tell, you can expect flavors to include French toast, plain, "everything", sesame seed, onion, poppy seed, salted, and cheddar. Are any of those seasonal? How often do they add flavors to the menu? We have no idea.

You'll probably get a half-dozen bagels in your box

That Bagels page also makes us think that when you subscribe, you're getting just a half-dozen bagels per delivery (since the a la carte shop has bagels at $17 to $19 for a pack of 6). Amazingly, when we put the bagel club in our cart, there was no shipping fee.

They'll send you unsolicited emails

However, we weren't happy at all to get a "thanks for subscribing, you've earned 10 points." email from Exes & Zees, when all we did was enter our name and email address (unchecking the box for receiving offers) so that we could find out if we would be charged any shipping fees. That feels like a sneaky data grab, not a hallmark of a business that's looking out for its customers.

Company is a mystery

And that's it. We found zero reputation for anything related to Exes & Zees; they don't even have a phone number or an email address on their website, and our live chat went unanswered. We consulted our favorite e-commerce guru, and he took one look and said, "Looks like they didn't want to pay money for hosting separate websites for all of those different products and services...whoever ‘they' might be."

Best Bagel Clubs

A bagel club we'd avoid

That's enough to land this strange bagel club at the bottom of our list. Sure, we love the price point, but that's where the love for Exes & Zees ends. Everything else about this company (can we even call it a bakery?) is too mysterious, and not really in a fun way. Get your bagels from a company who's all too eager to tell you about itself - like one of the higher-rated clubs on our list.

On the Exes & Zees website

Continued from above...

Which Bagel Club is the Best?

Few breakfast foods are as beloved as a fresh, chewy bagel. Whether toasted with a smear of cream cheese, loaded with smoked salmon, or simply enjoyed as-is, bagels have been a go-to comfort food for decades.

If you've ever wished for a way to enjoy authentic, bakery-fresh bagels without having to leave home, a bagel club is your best bet. These subscription services ship hand-rolled bagels from top bakeries, so you can experience the best flavors without the hassle. Whether you're a die-hard bagel lover or just looking for a tried-and-true breakfast option, joining a bagel club can add variety and convenience to your routine. Plus, if you love trying new flavors, many clubs offer seasonal and specialty bagels that you might not find at your local store.

Bagel clubs are also a fantastic gift idea. They're perfect for family members who miss authentic bagels from the big city or for friends who simply appreciate high-quality baked goods. With flexible delivery options and a variety of flavors to enjoy, a bagel subscription makes for a thoughtful, delicious surprise.

Originating from Eastern Europe and brought to America by Jewish immigrants in the late 19th century, bagels have evolved from a regional specialty to a nationwide favorite. New York is still the gold standard when it comes to bagels, thanks to its unique water composition that helps create the perfect balance of crispiness and chew. But no matter where you are, getting your hands on top-quality bagels is easier than ever - thanks to bagel clubs that deliver fresh-baked goodness straight to your door.

So, which subscription is right for your monthly dose of carb-y goodness? There are quite a few bagel clubs to choose from, and here are a few key factors to consider:

The bagel-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked the most popular clubs available today. No matter which bagel club you choose, you're in for a treat. With bakery-fresh flavors and the convenience of home delivery, a great bagel subscription can bring a little taste of New York - or anywhere great bagels are made - right to your table.

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Bagel Club FAQ

What is a bagel club?
A bagel club is a subscription service that delivers fresh bagels to your doorstep on a regular basis. It allows you to enjoy a variety of bagels without having to go to a bakery or store each time.
How do bagel clubs work?
Bagel clubs typically offer different subscription plans where you choose the frequency of delivery and the number of bagels you want. You place an order, and the bagels are freshly prepared and shipped to you on the specified schedule. Some bagel clubs require you to prepay for the full membership length (three months or a year), while others are month-to-month and you can pay as you go.
What are the benefits of joining a bagel club?
Joining a bagel club ensures a regular supply of freshly baked bagels without the hassle of going out to buy them. It provides convenience, variety, and often introduces you to unique flavors and combinations. You might also get fun extras like a newsletter, or the ability to try new bagel flavors before they're released to the public.
Can I choose the flavors of bagels I receive?
Many bagel clubs allow you to select the flavors of the bagels you receive. This gives you the freedom to customize your orders and try different flavors each time. Some give you a predetermined flavor selection but let you skip a month if there's one you don't like.
Are there bagel clubs for people with dietary restrictions?
A few bagel clubs offer options for dietary restrictions such as gluten-free or vegan bagels. However, it's important to check with the specific club to ensure they can accommodate your dietary needs.
Can I gift a bagel club subscription to someone?
Yes, bagel club subscriptions make great gifts! Many clubs offer gift options, allowing you to send a subscription to a friend or family member for a certain duration, typically with a gift announcement sent via email or USPS.
How are the bagels packaged for delivery?
Bagels are typically packaged in a way that ensures their freshness during transit. They may be individually wrapped or sealed in airtight bags to maintain their taste and texture. Follow the instructions included with your baked goods: you may need to enjoy them right away or refrigerate/freeze them to keep them fresh for a later date.
Can I cancel or modify my bagel club subscription?
Most bagel clubs offer flexibility, allowing you to cancel or modify your subscription. Check the specific club's terms and conditions to understand their cancellation or modification policies.

Compare Any 2 Products

Amazing Clubs
New Yorker Bagels
The Greater Knead
Zucker's
Davidovich Bakery
Knead & Nosh
Best New York Bagel
Exes & Zees
vs
Amazing Clubs vs New Yorker BagelsAmazing Clubs vs The Greater KneadAmazing Clubs vs Zucker'sAmazing Clubs vs Davidovich BakeryAmazing Clubs vs Knead & NoshAmazing Clubs vs Best New York BagelAmazing Clubs vs Exes & ZeesNew Yorker Bagels vs The Greater KneadNew Yorker Bagels vs Zucker'sNew Yorker Bagels vs Davidovich BakeryNew Yorker Bagels vs Knead & NoshNew Yorker Bagels vs Best New York BagelNew Yorker Bagels vs Exes & ZeesThe Greater Knead vs Zucker'sThe Greater Knead vs Davidovich BakeryThe Greater Knead vs Knead & NoshThe Greater Knead vs Best New York BagelThe Greater Knead vs Exes & ZeesZucker's vs Davidovich BakeryZucker's vs Knead & NoshZucker's vs Best New York BagelZucker's vs Exes & ZeesDavidovich Bakery vs Knead & NoshDavidovich Bakery vs Best New York BagelDavidovich Bakery vs Exes & ZeesKnead & Nosh vs Best New York BagelKnead & Nosh vs Exes & ZeesBest New York Bagel vs Exes & Zees Exes & Zees vs Best New York BagelExes & Zees vs Knead & NoshExes & Zees vs Davidovich BakeryExes & Zees vs Zucker'sExes & Zees vs The Greater KneadExes & Zees vs New Yorker BagelsExes & Zees vs Amazing ClubsBest New York Bagel vs Knead & NoshBest New York Bagel vs Davidovich BakeryBest New York Bagel vs Zucker'sBest New York Bagel vs The Greater KneadBest New York Bagel vs New Yorker BagelsBest New York Bagel vs Amazing ClubsKnead & Nosh vs Davidovich BakeryKnead & Nosh vs Zucker'sKnead & Nosh vs The Greater KneadKnead & Nosh vs New Yorker BagelsKnead & Nosh vs Amazing ClubsDavidovich Bakery vs Zucker'sDavidovich Bakery vs The Greater KneadDavidovich Bakery vs New Yorker BagelsDavidovich Bakery vs Amazing ClubsZucker's vs The Greater KneadZucker's vs New Yorker BagelsZucker's vs Amazing ClubsThe Greater Knead vs New Yorker BagelsThe Greater Knead vs Amazing ClubsNew Yorker Bagels vs Amazing Clubs
See the Best Bagel Clubs in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

25 Types Of Bagels: Must Flavo

25 Types Of Bagels: Must Flavors You Must Try

Some bagel flavors may already be your favorites, but others are likely to be unknown to you or even forgotten. Read on to find your next tasting experience among the 25 best types of bagels to try, along with their preparation methods, unique flavors, and the best pairing ideas.

Thu, 07 May 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Home - The Bagel Den

Home - The Bagel Den

We are the ultimate experience of exciting bagel and schmear combinations in the form of a classic bagel sandwich, elevated – including breakfast! Need some sides?

Thu, 07 May 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Real Homemade Bagels Recipe

Real Homemade Bagels Recipe

A bagel recipe for that authentic bagel flavor and texture. Top them with coarse salt, sesame seeds, poppy seeds, onion flakes, or everything!

Fri, 08 May 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Homemade Bagels {New and Impro

Homemade Bagels {New and Improved} | Mel's Kitchen Cafe

Brush the top and sides of each bagel and then sprinkle with desired toppings: sesame seeds, everything bagel seasoning, cinnamon and sugar, coarse salt, grated Asiago or Parmesan cheese, or other toppings of choice.

Tue, 05 May 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Classic Chewy Bagels Recipe |

Classic Chewy Bagels Recipe | King Arthur Baking

Want to get creative with your bagel-making? Use our Classic Chewy Bagel Mix Kit to make Cream Cheese-Stuffed Bagel Pockets, Everything Bagel Twists, or Mini Pizza Bagels.

Thu, 07 May 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Daily Bagel Eugene | Fresh Bag

Daily Bagel Eugene | Fresh Bagels in Eugene, Oregon

Visit Daily Bagel Eugene in Eugene, Oregon, for fresh bagels, sandwiches, and more. Call 541.431.5700!

Wed, 06 May 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.