Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Baseball Equipment Stores

Where is the Best Place to Buy Baseball Equipment?

Baseball has long been considered America's pastime. Legends like Babe Ruth, Jackie Robinson, Lou Gehrig, and Hank Aaron perpetuated the thrill of baseball from early on in history and have remained iconic ever since.

Whether it be collecting baseball cards or playing out on the diamond, almost every person in the U.S. has joined in on a game of baseball in some way. It remains one of the most popular sports played by both young and old alike. In order to be comfortable and confident in their performance when playing baseball, athletes need good equipment.

Saturday, September 30th

2023 Baseball Equipment Store Reviews

Baseball Monkey Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating

Baseball Monkey

5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Baseball Monkey is a division of MonkeySports, Inc. that also sells softball, hockey, and lacrosse gear. Baseball Monkey sells affordable baseball equipment for both novice and experienced players. Their website makes it easy to find name-brand products quickly. We are happy with their generous 90-day return policy. Baseball Monkey earns our highest rating.

Paragon Sports Review 4 Star Rating

Paragon Sports

4 Star Rating

Paragon Sports carries name brand products like Wilson, Rawlings, and LS. Shoppers who buy from Paragon Sports will find products that make them look good while playing their sport. Lots of high-end apparel and styles can be found here. However, their selection of products is slimmer than some of our higher-rated sites and the Better Business Bureau only gives them a B- rating.

Baseball Express Review 3 Star Rating

Baseball Express

3 Star Rating

Baseball Express sells all the baseball equipment you would hope to find through an online sports retailer. They are part of a family of sporting goods brands including Team Express, Softball, and Football America. Baseball Express falls under the umbrella of Team Express, which has mixed feedback from customers. Their B rating from the Better Business Bureau and average customer reviews make Baseball Express a decent place to shop, but not quite our first pick.

Epic Sports Review 3 Star Rating

Epic Sports

3 Star Rating

Baseball equipment is just one of the many categories of products sold at Epic Sports. They have one of the biggest selections of inventory we have seen with pricing that is affordable for most customers. Visually speaking, Epic Sports needs a lot of website design work to make it easier to find information on products. Epic Sports comes with a lot of pros and cons, landing them in the middle of the pack when it comes to baseball equipment.

Baseball Savings Review 2.5 Star Rating

Baseball Savings

2.5 Star Rating

Baseball Savings provides exactly what you'd imagine based on their name. All products are discounted, making it one of the most affordable online baseball equipment retailers you'll find. Unfortunately, customer complaints about return issues and poor customer service make shopping at Baseball Savings a bit risky.

Dick's Sporting Goods Review 2 Star Rating

Dick's Sporting Goods

2 Star Rating

DICK'S Sporting Goods carries hundreds of products for baseball players. If you're looking for batting gloves, bags, apparel, cleats, or bats, you name it and DICK'S has it. Considering all that DICK'S has going for them, it is disappointing to find that they receive a lot of critical feedback from their customers and an "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau.

Academy Sports Review 1 Star Rating

Academy Sports

1 Star Rating

Academy Sports carries hundreds of products for sports and outdoor hobbies. Within each category of sporting goods, such as baseball equipment, there is a wide variety of items to choose from. We will say upfront that the Better Business Bureau has posted an alert for Academy Sports letting customers know they have received many disputes about the company, earning this retailer our lowest ranking.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Not only is there a need for high-quality gear, but players need bats, mitts, cleats, and uniforms that fit them well. Are you right- or left-handed? How tall are you? What shoe size do you wear? These questions matter because the answers might be the difference between finding baseball equipment that works well and equipment that really knocks you off your game. With online sizing guides and product reviews, shoppers have a better chance of finding exactly what products they need.

Shopping online for baseball equipment lets customers compare pricing between competing retailers and view all brands, sizes, and designs easily. Ideally, retailers allow customers to leave reviews for the individual products, which helps shoppers identify the best, most popular products. New baseball apparel and gear to amp up your game is just a few clicks away!

Before purchasing baseball equipment online, we suggest you keep the following criteria in mind:

  • Cost. How does the pricing of a baseball product compare with the cost of the same item through another retailer?
  • Return Policy. What if you purchase some equipment that doesn't perform to your expectations? Retailers typically allow returns to make sure you end up with the right products.
  • Selection. When it comes to sporting equipment, a big selection means a range of styles and a higher chance of finding gear that is going to fit well and last a long time.

To help you find the best baseball equipment, TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked a variety of retailers to give you an idea of which choice might be the most effective for you. We hope this information helps you find all the equipment you need for your next baseball game!

The Best Baseball Equipment Stores Compare Baseball Equipment Stores Compare Baseball Equipment Store Reviews What are the best Baseball Equipment Stores Best Baseball Equipment Store Reviews

Baseball Equipment Store FAQ

There are six main items you need to play baseball: a bat, a baseball, a baseball glove, batting gloves, cleats, and protective gear. Protective gear might include a hard helmet for batters, and sometimes arm guards and shin guards. Catchers wear a unique set of protective gear like body armor, a catcher's mask, throat guard, and catcher's mitt to avoid being hurt by fast-moving balls coming their way.
There are a few factors that go into buying a baseball bat. The first is age. If you're buying a bat for someone 6 years of age or under, they'll need a tee ball bat. Anyone 7-13 years old will likely want a USA or USSSA bat, and anyone older will need a BBCOR bat. Look for these logos stamped on the bat to help you get started. Next, the bat should be arm's length from the middle of your chest to the end of your fingertips. It should also not feel so heavy that you might drop it when you swing. Lastly, the material of the bat will depend on how much you want to spend and how often you'll be using it. Alloy bats require no break-in time, are durable, and have a smaller sweet spot, but are more affordable. Composite bats take 150-200 hits to break in, have a larger sweet spot, and are more expensive.
Yes! Most stores allow you to return new and unused items as long as it's in the specified return window (usually 30-60 days). Some retailers even let you return gear if you've used it: they know it's hard to gauge the performance of a product if you aren't playing baseball with it. Make sure to read the baseball store's return policy online before checking out.
Do you throw with your right or left hand? This is the first factor in what type of glove you'll need. The best thing to do is try different gloves on before ordering online to see what feels comfortable. If your friend has a glove, you might try playing catch to see how it feels. You could buy that particular brand or one comparable. Regardless of the mitt you buy, it will take time to break in. You'll have to use it a few times before it's flexible enough to be "game ready" .
Anyone! When boys and girls are small, they often start out playing tee ball, where they aren't batting from pitches from another player. This helps them learn hand-eye coordination and have an easier time at bat. As you get older, women typically play softball and men play baseball, but the sport is available and fun for everyone!
The price of baseball equipment depends on what you're buying and its quality. By the time you purchase everything you need from top to bottom, you can expect to spend a few hundred dollars. Cleats could be expensive if you buy a name brand, but the only other items that might cost you a pretty penny are your glove and bat. If you want them to last a long time and have optimal performance, you'll want to go high-end and get the best type of leather and a composite bat. However, if you're buying baseball gear for a child or to use recreationally, you could save a few hundred dollars by getting more practical, less fancy items.
Some online baseball retailers have a chat box that allows you to connect right away with an expert from their customer service team. They can help you find the right sizes and products you need without you even having to leave your house. If this isn't an option, you could reach out to their customer service team by email or phone and talk to someone who can walk you through everything.
It can. If you've been playing baseball for years, you'll know the difference between good quality products and cheap, off-brand ones. A perfect-fitting mitt and a bat that feels comfortable could make all the difference in your game. If you're using flimsy equipment, you likely won't play as well regardless of your skill level. Finding an online baseball equipment retailer with good reviews and top-of-the-line equipment will make a big difference for you.
See the Best Baseball Equipment Store
The Best Reviews of Baseball Equipment Stores