Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Academy Sports vs Dick's Sporting Goods

Thursday, July 18th

2024 Baseball Equipment Store Reviews

Academy Sports Review 3 Star Rating

Academy Sports

3 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $19.99 to $499.99
  • 2,243 items in the baseball category
  • Kids and adults gear
  • Casual and pro gear
  • Offers a price match guarantee to reduce prices by 5%
  • Offers 60-day return policy

Academy Sports + Outdoors has a unique history compared to other options in this review. In 1938, Academy Sports was founded primarily as a tire sales company. Over time, it grew to offer various sporting goods and outdoor gear - and a competitive range of baseball equipment. However, with some concerning factors like a "C+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, Academy Sports gets a middle-range score. It's got a competitive inventory, but if you are getting poor products, it may not be worth it to shop here.

Dick's Sporting Goods Review 2.5 Star Rating

Dick's Sporting Goods

2.5 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $12.99 to $549.99
  • 400+ bats on sale
  • Kids and adults gear
  • Casual and pro gear
  • Softball gear available
  • Price match guarantee
  • 90-days for returns

For nearly 40 years, DICK'S Sporting Goods has been a well-known destination for sports gear, with both physical stores and an online platform. They offer a variety of equipment types at decent prices including baseball gear. With a 90-day return policy, they seem to be pretty competitive, but some customers have had significant problems with the customer service and overall shopping experience here. While shopping in person at DICK'S might still be an option, we recommend that you explore other online retailers with better customer ratings for a better overall shopping experience for baseball equipment.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Baseball Equipment?

Thanks to the convenience of online shopping, finding the perfect baseball equipment has become more popular and accessible than ever. There are tons of places for fans and players to pick up their baseball necessities. Online retailers not only offer convenience but also ensure that players have access to the latest and most innovative baseball apparel and gear, helping them hit that grand slam.

On top of being able to compare top-notch gear side by side, customers can also pick out custom items (bats, gloves, and more) depending on where they shop. A well-crafted bat, the perfect mitt, reliable cleats, and a comfortable uniform can make a world of difference in a player's confidence and skill (and don't forget the baseball socks so you don't get hurt sliding home). If getting that made-for-you equipment is a top priority, there's definitely an online baseball retailer that can help.

The Best Baseball Equipment Stores Compare Baseball Equipment Stores Compare Baseball Equipment Store Reviews What are the best Baseball Equipment Stores Best Baseball Equipment Store Reviews

Baseball Equipment Store FAQ

There are six main items you need to play baseball: a bat, a baseball, a baseball glove, batting gloves, cleats, and protective gear. Protective gear might include a hard helmet for batters, and sometimes arm guards and shin guards. Catchers wear a unique set of protective gear like body armor, a catcher's mask, throat guard, and catcher's mitt to avoid being hurt by fast-moving balls coming their way.
There are a few factors that go into buying a baseball bat. The first is age. If you're buying a bat for someone 6 years of age or under, they'll need a tee ball bat. Anyone 7-13 years old will likely want a USA or USSSA bat, and anyone older will need a BBCOR bat. Look for these logos stamped on the bat to help you get started. Next, the bat should be arm's length from the middle of your chest to the end of your fingertips. It should also not feel so heavy that you might drop it when you swing. Lastly, the material of the bat will depend on how much you want to spend and how often you'll be using it. Alloy bats require no break-in time, are durable, and have a smaller sweet spot, but are more affordable. Composite bats take 150-200 hits to break in, have a larger sweet spot, and are more expensive.
Yes! Most stores allow you to return new and unused items as long as it's in the specified return window (usually 30-60 days). Some retailers even let you return gear if you've used it: they know it's hard to gauge the performance of a product if you aren't playing baseball with it. Make sure to read the baseball store's return policy online before checking out.
Do you throw with your right or left hand? This is the first factor in what type of glove you'll need. The best thing to do is try different gloves on before ordering online to see what feels comfortable. If your friend has a glove, you might try playing catch to see how it feels. You could buy that particular brand or one comparable. Regardless of the mitt you buy, it will take time to break in. You'll have to use it a few times before it's flexible enough to be "game ready" .
Anyone! When boys and girls are small, they often start out playing tee ball, where they aren't batting from pitches from another player. This helps them learn hand-eye coordination and have an easier time at bat. As you get older, women typically play softball and men play baseball, but the sport is available and fun for everyone!
The price of baseball equipment depends on what you're buying and its quality. By the time you purchase everything you need from top to bottom, you can expect to spend a few hundred dollars. Cleats could be expensive if you buy a name brand, but the only other items that might cost you a pretty penny are your glove and bat. If you want them to last a long time and have optimal performance, you'll want to go high-end and get the best type of leather and a composite bat. However, if you're buying baseball gear for a child or to use recreationally, you could save a few hundred dollars by getting more practical, less fancy items.
Some online baseball retailers have a chat box that allows you to connect right away with an expert from their customer service team. They can help you find the right sizes and products you need without you even having to leave your house. If this isn't an option, you could reach out to their customer service team by email or phone and talk to someone who can walk you through everything.
It can. If you've been playing baseball for years, you'll know the difference between good quality products and cheap, off-brand ones. A perfect-fitting mitt and a bat that feels comfortable could make all the difference in your game. If you're using flimsy equipment, you likely won't play as well regardless of your skill level. Finding an online baseball equipment retailer with good reviews and top-of-the-line equipment will make a big difference for you.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Online baseball equipment shopping has gained tremendous popularity over the years for a multitude of compelling reasons that revolve around convenience, variety, price competitiveness, and accessibility, among other factors. This transformation in consumer behavior is indicative of the broader shift towards e-commerce and digital retail, reflecting the unique advantages it offers to baseball enthusiasts and players alike.

Who doesn't love the convenience of shopping 24/7? This is another big reason driving online baseball shopping popularity. Unlike traditional brick-and-mortar stores, online platforms are open 24/7, letting you shop at your own convenience, breaking free from the constraints of operating hours. This is particularly beneficial for busy people who might not have the time to visit physical stores during regular business hours. Moreover, the ease of browsing and purchasing from the comfort of one's home or using a mobile device has redefined the shopping experience. Online stores provide detailed product descriptions, reviews, and sizing charts, which let you make informed decisions without the need for in-person assistance.

Of course, the immense variety of baseball equipment available online is another attractive feature to shopping online. Website retailers often boast extensive catalogs, featuring a wide array of baseball equipment options. This includes various brands, models, and sizes of bats, gloves, helmets, cleats, and other accessories, catering to diverse preferences and needs. Considering factors like right- vs. left-handedness, height, and shoe size becomes essential in selecting gear that suits each player's unique needs. This wide selection means that you can easily compare and find products that suit your specific requirements, whether you're shopping for amateur players, professionals, or simply fans of the sport.

Baseball, often referred to as America's pastime, is a huge part of the country's sports and cultural history. The sport has been host to legendary players like Babe Ruth, Jackie Robinson, Lou Gehrig, and Hank Aaron, whose contributions inspired generations of athletes. Throughout the years, baseball has become hugely popular, with millions of people jumping in either as players or avid fans.

According to data from the Sports & Fitness Industry Association (SFIA), around 9.6 million kids aged 6 to 17 years old, and about 12.5 million adults aged 18 and above join in the sport every year. From Little League to college ball to the NBL, baseball is a favorite with people of all ages. Whether you're a little league parent, part of a local baseball team, or somebody looking to go pro, you know that athletes need more than just talent and dedication; they require the best equipment for their sport.

With so many places out there to get baseball equipment online, it can feel like there are just too many good options out there to decide. If you're not sure where to start, we've got the bases covered for you.

Here are some factors to consider to help you decide which online baseball equipment store is best for your needs:

  • Cost. Have you ever wondered how the price of a baseball product at one store stacks up against the price of the same item at another store? Comparing pricing between retailers can help you make sure you're getting the best deal and value for your money. Keeping an eye on the gear and potential sales can make sure you pick the retailer with the best options for your budget.
  • Returns. Imagine you buy some baseball equipment, but it doesn't meet your expectations or doesn't work as you hoped. Don't worry - most retailers have a return policy that allows you to send or bring back the items you're not satisfied with.
  • Selection. When you're on the hunt for sporting equipment, having a wide range of options is like hitting a home run. Maybe you're just in the market for a new bat, or maybe you need a complete set of baseball gear. Either way, keep an eye on what each retailer has on offer so that you can make it a one-stop shop.
  • Reputation. If you get to the end of your research and you're still not sure, checking out a company's reputation is the way to go. Check out the customer reviews or the ratings from the Better Business Bureau to make sure that the retailer meets the needs of other baseball fans just like you.

To make your next baseball game a home run, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and rated the best options for buying baseball equipment on the market today. We hope this helps you take the stress out of shopping online and get back to enjoying this all-American pastime!

Compare Baseball Equipment Stores

Select any 2 Baseball Equipment Stores to compare them head to head

  • Better Baseball
  • Baseball Monkey
  • Scheels
  • Baseball Express
  • Franklin
  • Academy Sports
  • Walmart
  • Baseball Savings
  • Dick's Sporting Goods
  • Epic Sports
Better Baseball vs Baseball Monkey Better Baseball vs Scheels Better Baseball vs Baseball Express Better Baseball vs Franklin Better Baseball vs Academy Sports Better Baseball vs Walmart Better Baseball vs Baseball Savings Better Baseball vs Dick's Sporting Goods Better Baseball vs Epic Sports Baseball Monkey vs Scheels Baseball Monkey vs Baseball Express Baseball Monkey vs Franklin Baseball Monkey vs Academy Sports Baseball Monkey vs Walmart Baseball Monkey vs Baseball Savings Baseball Monkey vs Dick's Sporting Goods Baseball Monkey vs Epic Sports Scheels vs Baseball Express Scheels vs Franklin Scheels vs Academy Sports Scheels vs Walmart Scheels vs Baseball Savings Scheels vs Dick's Sporting Goods Scheels vs Epic Sports Baseball Express vs Franklin Baseball Express vs Academy Sports Baseball Express vs Walmart Baseball Express vs Baseball Savings Baseball Express vs Dick's Sporting Goods Baseball Express vs Epic Sports Franklin vs Academy Sports Franklin vs Walmart Franklin vs Baseball Savings Franklin vs Dick's Sporting Goods Franklin vs Epic Sports Academy Sports vs Walmart Academy Sports vs Baseball Savings Academy Sports vs Dick's Sporting Goods Academy Sports vs Epic Sports Walmart vs Baseball Savings Walmart vs Dick's Sporting Goods Walmart vs Epic Sports Baseball Savings vs Dick's Sporting Goods Baseball Savings vs Epic Sports Dick's Sporting Goods vs Epic Sports
Compare the Best Baseball Equipment Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Baseball Equipment Stores
See the Best Baseball Equipment Store
The Best Reviews of Baseball Equipment Stores