The Best Baseball Equipment Stores

Thursday, May 22nd

2025 Baseball Equipment Store Reviews

Better Baseball

As our top option for baseball equipment, Better Baseball really lives up to its name. This service stands out as a premier destination for baseball and softball enthusiasts. They offer a diverse selection of products from major brands, a fun and user-friendly website with great filters, and, most importantly: competitive prices. On top of that, they've scored top ratings from the BBB and customers are raving about the quality of customer service and products. It's a home run if we've ever seen one, making Better Baseball our #1 pick for baseball equipment.

Baseball Monkey

Baseball Monkey, a division of MonkeySports Inc., is a well-established sports gear retailer with a wide range of baseball, hockey, softball, and lacrosse equipment. Despite a slightly cluttered website design, they offer an amazing variety of products at competitive prices, and they have a price match guarantee. Their return policy allows customers to return new and unused items within a year of purchase. With an "A+" rating from the BBB, Baseball Monkey is our second-place pick for baseball enthusiasts looking for top-quality gear and excellent deals.

Scheels

Scheels, a well-known retailer with stores in 13 states, offers a diverse selection of sporting goods, apparel, footwear, and other products from famous brands. Their website is user-friendly, visually attractive, and has a wide range of baseball equipment at competitive prices. With a price match guarantee, easy returns, and rebates on some items, Scheels has earned a strong reputation for excellent customer service, making it a top choice (and our third-place pick) for purchasing baseball equipment online.

Baseball Express

Short Baseball Express, owned by Team Express, is a well-established sports equipment company with a wide range of baseball products from various reputable brands. The website offers detailed filters and a sister site for softball gear, making it easy to find what you need. Although their starting prices might be slightly higher than some competitors, they provide good value for the money, especially with regular deals and sales. Only their less robust return policy and lack of price matching knocks this service a bit lower, but it still easily deserves its high rating in our review.

Franklin

Franklin Sports, founded in 1946, gained prominence by focusing on a single athlete, Joe Namath, and partnering with sports icons like Mike Schmidt. The website offers a clean layout and user-friendly filters, but the product selection is limited primarily to gloves. Despite having a good reputation and an "A+" rating from BBB, it lacks the variety of other retailers on our list. Nonetheless, Franklin is a top choice for those seeking high-quality gloves and earns a good rating overall for baseball equipment.

Academy Sports

Academy Sports + Outdoors has a unique history compared to other options in this review. In 1938, Academy Sports was founded primarily as a tire sales company. Over time, it grew to offer various sporting goods and outdoor gear - and a competitive range of baseball equipment. However, with some concerning factors like a "C+” rating from the Better Business Bureau, Academy Sports gets a middle-range score. It's got a competitive inventory, but if you are getting poor products, it may not be worth it to shop here.

Walmart

Walmart is a well-known retail giant. While its online platform offers a good user interface with convenient shipping, the baseball equipment selection is somewhat disorganized, making it necessary to use the search bar. The pricing is competitive, but some items may not meet sports-quality standards. With mixed reviews including complaints about customer service and damaged packages, we were a little concerned about the overall shopping experience here. While Walmart can be a good local option, its lack of focus on sports gear and negative customer feedback lowers its overall score as a retailer for baseball equipment.

Baseball Savings

Baseball Savings, operated by Golf Warehouse Inc. since 2005, offers a wide range of baseball products with featured brands at affordable prices. They have a user-friendly website with good filters, but their prices often start higher than some competitors. They also have a price match guarantee, but shopper reviews are largely negative, citing issues with shipping, item quality, and customer service. Overall, Baseball Savings receives a middle-of-the-road rating compared to the industry, but its poor customer ratings knocked it down further. It may be better to check out a better-rated option before you try Baseball Savings for your next equipment purchase.

Dick's Sporting Goods

For nearly 40 years, DICK'S Sporting Goods has been a well-known destination for sports gear, with both physical stores and an online platform. They offer a variety of equipment types at decent prices including baseball gear. With a 90-day return policy, they seem to be pretty competitive, but some customers have had significant problems with the customer service and overall shopping experience here. While shopping in person at DICK'S might still be an option, we recommend that you explore other online retailers with better customer ratings for a better overall shopping experience for baseball equipment.

Epic Sports

While it has potential with gear from different sports and rave reviews, Epic Sports unfortunately doesn't stand out from the pack. With an outdated website, slow load times, and limited modern features, the site just can't compete with our top baseball equipment retailers. The inventory is smaller compared to other sites, and there is no price match or free shipping. However, despite these drawbacks, customers give positive reviews, praising the selection and quick shipments. Epic Sports has a decent BBB rating, but it still doesn't stand out compared to other retailers.