Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

BBQ Box Review

Saturday, July 2nd

2022 BBQ Sauce Club Reviews

BBQ Box Review 2 Star Rating

BBQ Box

2 Star Rating
  • 20% off first box with email signup
  • 4 BBQ essentials per box
  • Pay month-to-month or for 3 or 6 months

The only thing we really know about BBQ Box is that their mission is to provide BBQ essentials to help customers create unique flavors. Their BBQ boxes are sold through Cratejoy, a platform that aims to connect people with exciting gifts and subscriptions all in one place. Whether your passion relates to beauty, self-care, food and drink, entertainment, travel, spirituality, crafts, or anything in-between, Cratejoy has subscription boxes for you.

4 essentials per box

With each BBQ subscription box from BBQ Box, you'll receive one sauce or marinade, one rub or spice, one snack or bonus item, and one sample pack of wood chips to go along with your recipe. You can view a video of a BBQ Box unboxing where they show a recipe card and the size of all the featured products to give you an idea of what to expect.

Deliveries each month

You can choose to pay month-to-month for your BBQ box or prepay for the 3-, 6- or 12-month plan. Month-to-month is $30/month, 3 months is $28.66/month ($85.97 total), the 6-month plan is $28.33/month ($169.97 total) and the 12-month plan is $27.50/month ($329.97 total). Rather than selecting if you want your sauces to come each month, every other month, or every 4 months, BBQ Box sends all boxes monthly, meaning if you sign up in January, you'll get a box for January, February, and March. Subscription will continue to auto-renew until you cancel them. At the time of this review, BBQ Box was offering a code for 20% off your first order.

Best BBQ Sauce Clubs

Orders ship the 30th of each month

Boxes ship out on the 30th of each month and should arrive no later than the 5th of the following month. In order to have your box shipped the same month you order it, you have to order by 11:59 pm EST on the 24th of the month. For example, if you order before 11:59 pm EST on March 24, your order will ship out March 30. If you order after 11:59 pm EST March 24, your order will ship April 30.

Shipping discrepancies

A big reason we aren't huge fans of Cratejoy is because once you select the subscription plan you want, you have to provide your payment details before they tell you how much you are paying for taxes and shipping. On the Q&A section of BBQ Box's Cratejoy page, someone said that BBQ Box was offering free shipping on all the boxes, but then there was a $10 shipping charge at checkout. We wish the company were more clear with their delivery pricing.

Look elsewhere

Cratejoy, the platform on which BBQ Box sells their boxes, has a failing "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau. They've received many complaints from customers about their unreliability and haven't responded to most of them. A few examples of issues people run into are paying for subscriptions that never arrive and trying to reach an unresponsive customer service team. On top of this, BBQ Box has only two reviews. One was from someone who hadn't received their order yet but was excited to, and the other was from an upset customer who said that they weren't warned before their subscription renewed. They tried to cancel 30 minutes later, but weren't able to get their money back or stop the order. Besides the fact that this subscription box comes with more than just BBQ sauce, there aren't a lot of reasons to choose this company over another BBQ sauce club.

Where Can You Find the Best BBQ Sauce Clubs?

If you didn't even know these existed - now you're in for a real treat! Everyone knows that a good BBQ sauce can make all the difference with your meal. It can change the whole flavor of a food from spicy to sweet or savory with just a few drops. You could eat the same food for every meal, but changing up your BBQ sauce flavors gives you a whole different experience.

Whether you're an experienced grill master or just a parent trying to keep dinners exciting, having unique BBQ sauces on hand is a must. BBQ sauce clubs are available to bring you flavors like smoked maple, peach pecan, raspberry chipotle, jalapeno, or a good old Texas original BBQ sauce monthly. The sky's the limit with unique and savory sauces that can be delivered straight to your door (or the door of a loved one if you want to give a delicious gift).

The Best BBQ Sauce Clubs Compare BBQ Sauce Clubs Compare BBQ Sauce Club Reviews What are the best BBQ Sauce Clubs Best BBQ Sauce Club Reviews

BBQ Sauce Club FAQ

Most BBQ sauce clubs go to great lengths to source unique flavors from around the nation - or around the world! Typically crafted in small batches by artisanal producers, these sauces really pack a punch and give you the opportunity to try flavors you probably won't find on any supermarket shelf.
BBQ sauce clubs usually give you plenty of options. You can choose to get deliveries every month, every other month, or quarterly. You may opt for a three-month club, a six-month plan, or a full year subscription.
Not at all. You'll pay anywhere from $17 to $27 per month, and that includes up to three full-sized bottles of BBQ sauce, depending on the subscription you select.
Sometimes. Many BBQ sauce clubs include delivery costs in your monthly price, while others tack on extra fees for shipping. Be sure to read the details of any BBQ sauce membership that interests you, so that there aren't any unpleasant surprises when you go to check out!
The majority of companies that offer BBQ sauce clubs want you to be thrilled with every package you receive. If you get a sauce that doesn't quite taste right or that arrives damaged in some way, you can almost always get a replacement or a refund. But again, services vary and it's always wise to check the particulars before committing to a subscription.
Absolutely! Some clubs have been around for ten years or more, building up a loyal fan base of subscribers that renew their plans from one year to the next. Even some of the newer companies on the market have already generated significant buzz with unique BBQ sauce flavors and a track record of great customer service.
It's pretty common for BBQ sauce clubs - and most subscription clubs in general - to include a fun, informative newsletter that describes the origin of each product, offers recipe tips, and shares entertaining related trivia. A few clubs may give you a chance to add on to your order, or to buy your favorite sauces a la carte.
For the meat-lovers in your life, BBQ sauce clubs make an excellent gift that keeps on giving. You can include a greeting with your well-wishes for a special occasion, and some services let you print it out or have it emailed directly on the date of your choice. Once they start receiving their monthly deliveries, your lucky recipients can usually see which BBQ sauce flavors they'll be getting, and some clubs will let them skip a shipment if they're going to be out of town or have allergies to a particular blend.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

With BBQ sauce club memberships you can arrange for sauces to be delivered monthly, every other month, or every three months depending on your budget and needs. The selection of sauces in each delivery is pre-determined by the company and usually comes with at least 2 different kinds. With some suppliers, you can view all the flavors for the whole year - letting you pick and choose the months that look the most intriguing to you.

You can get creative with your BBQ sauces and use them for pizza, meat, salad dressing, stir it into a vegetable dip, or upgrade your potato salad. If you're looking for an exciting way to treat yourself or someone else for Christmas, a birthday, Father's Day, or any other holiday (or non-holiday... we all love BBQ sauce year-round), you can't go wrong with a BBQ sauce club membership.

Not all BBQ sauce clubs work exactly the same way, but you're in for a delightful experience no matter what.

As you browse different BBQ sauce club companies, there are some important things to consider:

  • Flexibility: Do you have the ability to pick the membership length and how often you receive deliveries? Can you take a break from BBQ sauce deliveries and then start back up again later?
  • Cost: How does the cost of one BBQ sauce club compare to another? Do you pay a flat fee ahead of time for the deliveries or pay month-to-month? Is shipping included in this cost?
  • Satisfaction Policy: What if you aren't happy with the BBQ sauce quality, taste, or the timeliness of the delivery? What if something happens to the bottles in transit? Can you get a refund if there are any issues?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best BBQ sauce clubs available today. We hope this information helps you fill your pantry with some of the most robust and delectable flavors from all around the country!

The Best Reviews of BBQ Sauce Clubs