Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Grill Masters Club Review

Monday, June 17th

2024 BBQ Sauce Club Reviews

Grill Masters Club Review 4 Star Rating

Grill Masters Club

4 Star Rating
  • Price ranges from $49.99 for 1 box to $491.88 for 12 boxes
  • 5 full-sized products in each box: 2 sauces/marinades, 2 rubs/spice blends, 1 surprise item (like wood chips, accessories like meat claws or brine injectors, cocktail mixes, and so on)
  • Each box is valued at $80+
  • Each box includes pitmaster recipes and pro tips
  • Free shipping on all BBQ sauce clubs
  • Choose to receive deliveries monthly, every other month, or quarterly
  • Satisfaction guaranteed

Grill Masters Club is a subscription-based service that provides monthly boxes of BBQ products, including sauces, rubs, marinades, wood chips, and grilling accessories. The company was founded with the aim of helping BBQ enthusiasts like you discover new flavors and techniques to enhance your grilling experience. The company curates high-quality products from both well-known and up-and-coming brands.

Not just BBQ sauce in each box

Grill Masters Club's subscription box is the perfect all-in-one monthly surprise. You'll always get 2 full-size bottles of BBQ sauce or marinade, 2 rubs or spice blends, and 1 surprise item. Those items could be another type of mix, like for cocktails or an extra rub, handy accessories and tools, wood chips for the smoker, and so on. We invite you to take a look at some of the unboxing videos and photos right on the main club page: it's fun to see what some of the previous selections have been.

Less than $50/month

You'll pay anywhere from $40.99 to $49.99 per box, depending on the subscription you choose: go month-to-month (highest price) or prepay a membership spanning 3, 4, 6 or 12 deliveries (lowest price). Each box is valued at $80 or more, so no matter which one you choose, you'll get your money's worth.

Best BBQ Sauce Clubs

Get a box every 1, 2, or 3 months

You've also got flexibility with the delivery schedule, and just like Goldilocks and the Three Bears, there's a "lots" option, a "less" option, and a medium-sized one (though you may think that any of those is "just right" ). If you're a super-avid griller, you may want Grill Masters Club to come every month. For the less-frequent BBQers, bi-monthly or even quarterly boxes could be the perfect fit.

Get tips for going next-level with your grill skills

And, taking "the thrill of the grill" to the next level, each box comes with a booklet with recipes with ideas for how to use what's included, background on the brands behind the rubs and sauces. Not to be left behind in the modern era, Grill Masters Club now has a QR code inside each box too, to give you even more tips and curated content.

Solid gift-giving tools

As you might guess, this BBQ sauce club makes for a great gift. Just specify all of the corresponding details during checkout. Grill Masters Club also has a Gift Notification Card page (we found it in the FAQ, by the way) where you can choose among various print and digital options for letting your recipient know they've got some grillin' goodness on the way.

Best BBQ Sauce Clubs

No refunds when you cancel prepaid subscriptions

The one downside we found with this BBQ sauce club is in the refund policy. We're happy that Grill Masters Club guarantees your satisfaction, so if your products arrive damaged or there's something not quite right, they'll probably be more than happy to replace it with the same item or something comparable. However, that satisfaction guarantee doesn't extend to refunds on unshipped, prepaid boxes. So, if you jump right in and pay upfront for 12 boxes, but you decide after box #1 that you really don't like the club as much as you anticipated, you'll still get the remaining 11 shipments. That's not as generous as some of Grill Masters Club's rivals, who will gladly give you a prorated refund on anything not yet shipped out.

High rating, but could be more generous with refunds

Of all of the BBQ sauce clubs we've reviewed, Grill Masters Club is probably the most fun. Not only do you get some delicious sauces for your next cookout, but you also get novel tools and extras you might not have known you needed (and then you wonder how you ever grilled without them). But, their refund policy could be more generous, especially if they want to encourage customers to prepay for a longer-term subscription. All of that averages out to a strong rating for Grill Masters Club.

Where Can You Find the Best BBQ Sauce Clubs?

Barbecue sauce and rubs have earned a revered status in culinary culture, captivating taste buds with their rich, complex flavors and enhancing the succulence of grilled or smoked meats. And when it comes to flavors, the possibilities are vast.

Traditional BBQ sauces often feature a tomato or vinegar base, infused with a myriad of spices such as garlic, onion, paprika, and cayenne pepper. Some variations may lean towards the sweeter side with added honey or brown sugar, while others deliver a fiery intensity with the inclusion of chili peppers or hot sauce.

The Best BBQ Sauce Clubs Compare BBQ Sauce Clubs Compare BBQ Sauce Club Reviews What are the best BBQ Sauce Clubs Best BBQ Sauce Club Reviews

BBQ Sauce Club FAQ

Most BBQ sauce clubs go to great lengths to source unique flavors from around the nation - or around the world! Typically crafted in small batches by artisanal producers, these sauces really pack a punch and give you the opportunity to try flavors you probably won't find on any supermarket shelf.
BBQ sauce clubs usually give you plenty of options. You can choose to get deliveries every month, every other month, or quarterly. You may opt for a three-month club, a six-month plan, or a full year subscription.
Not at all. You'll pay anywhere from $17 to $27 per month, and that includes up to three full-sized bottles of BBQ sauce, depending on the subscription you select.
Sometimes. Many BBQ sauce clubs include delivery costs in your monthly price, while others tack on extra fees for shipping. Be sure to read the details of any BBQ sauce membership that interests you, so that there aren't any unpleasant surprises when you go to check out!
The majority of companies that offer BBQ sauce clubs want you to be thrilled with every package you receive. If you get a sauce that doesn't quite taste right or that arrives damaged in some way, you can almost always get a replacement or a refund. But again, services vary and it's always wise to check the particulars before committing to a subscription.
Absolutely! Some clubs have been around for ten years or more, building up a loyal fan base of subscribers that renew their plans from one year to the next. Even some of the newer companies on the market have already generated significant buzz with unique BBQ sauce flavors and a track record of great customer service.
It's pretty common for BBQ sauce clubs - and most subscription clubs in general - to include a fun, informative newsletter that describes the origin of each product, offers recipe tips, and shares entertaining related trivia. A few clubs may give you a chance to add on to your order, or to buy your favorite sauces a la carte.
For the meat-lovers in your life, BBQ sauce clubs make an excellent gift that keeps on giving. You can include a greeting with your well-wishes for a special occasion, and some services let you print it out or have it emailed directly on the date of your choice. Once they start receiving their monthly deliveries, your lucky recipients can usually see which BBQ sauce flavors they'll be getting, and some clubs will let them skip a shipment if they're going to be out of town or have allergies to a particular blend.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

As for BBQ rubs, they are a blend of dry spices and herbs meticulously crafted to enhance the flavor and texture of meats. Common ingredients include salt, black pepper, cumin, chili powder, and brown sugar, but the beauty of rubs lies in their versatility, allowing grillmasters to experiment to their hearts' delight.

Now, let's explore the regional nuances of BBQ sauces, each offering a distinct taste of American barbecue tradition. In the Carolinas, vinegar-based sauces reign supreme, imparting a tangy, acidic punch to smoked pork. Meanwhile, in Kansas City, tomato-based sauces take center stage, balancing sweet and tangy flavors that pair perfectly with ribs and brisket. In Texas, BBQ aficionados swear by thick, peppery sauces that let the smoky flavor of the meat shine through, while in Memphis, a dry rub is often preferred, allowing the quality of the meat to speak for itself.

But, we all know that the options for truly unique BBQ sauces and rubs are a little limited when we visit our local supermarket. Wouldn't it be amazing if the nation's best flavors and newest selections could be delivered right to your doorstep?

Well, you're in luck. BBQ sauce clubs bring you the best of Texas, KC, the Carolinas, Tennessee, and beyond, so you'll never be disappointed by the grocery store condiment aisle ever again. Whether you send it as a gift to a lucky recipient or you keep the joy all to yourself, a BBQ sauce club lets you try flavors you probably won't find near you.

These clubs can usually be set up to be delivered for three months up to a year, and the best ones come with fun extras like recipes, grilling tips, and fun facts about the makers behind each sauce and rub.

Ready to jump in and get cooking? All you have to do is pick the right BBQ sauce club and you're good to go. Here are a few ways you can sort out which subscription you'll like best:

  • Sauces, rubs, or both? Some of today's most popular BBQ sauce clubs take it a step further and include rubs for more variety. But, if that's not your jam, no problem. There are plenty of options that are sauce-only, or that let you pick from one delivery to the next if you'd like to include a rub in your package.
  • Variety. Are you looking to try new-and-novel flavors from artisanal sauce-makers? Or would you prefer to get some tried-and-true favorites from month to month? You can use a BBQ sauce club to experiment with sauces not likely to be on your local store's shelves, or to keep your pantry well-stocked with what you already know and love.
  • Subscription structure. BBQ sauce clubs can be set up in a lot of ways. Do you want something that's easy to send as a gift? Do you want to be able to pause your deliveries while you go on vacation? Would you like to be able to pay as you go instead of paying in full at the start of the subscription?
  • Customer service. Is there a satisfaction guarantee or a refund policy in place? Can you get attentive, friendly help if something goes wrong with your BBQ sauce club?
  • Reputation. How popular is the BBQ sauce club? What do other sauce-lovers say about their experiences? Is it a subscription that really delivers or one that disappoints?

Whether you're drawn to the tangy allure of Carolina vinegar sauce or the bold flavors of Texas BBQ rubs, there's a world of barbecue delights waiting to be explored. To help you find the right BBQ sauce club, the experts at Top Consumer Reviews have reviewed and ranked some of today's tastiest options. So get ready to fire up the grill, slather on the sauce, and savor the irresistible taste of barbecue bliss!

Compare BBQ Sauce Clubs

Select any 2 BBQ Sauce Clubs to compare them head to head

  • Amazing Clubs
  • BBQ Rubs
  • Pig of the Month Sauce Club
  • Grill Masters Club
  • Oakland Dust
  • My BBQ Box
  • Maurice's Piggie Park
  • Month Club Store
  • Boost Your BBQ
  • BBQ Rub Club
Amazing Clubs vs BBQ Rubs Amazing Clubs vs Pig of the Month Sauce Club Amazing Clubs vs Grill Masters Club Amazing Clubs vs Oakland Dust Amazing Clubs vs My BBQ Box Amazing Clubs vs Maurice's Piggie Park Amazing Clubs vs Month Club Store Amazing Clubs vs Boost Your BBQ Amazing Clubs vs BBQ Rub Club BBQ Rubs vs Pig of the Month Sauce Club BBQ Rubs vs Grill Masters Club BBQ Rubs vs Oakland Dust BBQ Rubs vs My BBQ Box BBQ Rubs vs Maurice's Piggie Park BBQ Rubs vs Month Club Store BBQ Rubs vs Boost Your BBQ BBQ Rubs vs BBQ Rub Club Pig of the Month Sauce Club vs Grill Masters Club Pig of the Month Sauce Club vs Oakland Dust Pig of the Month Sauce Club vs My BBQ Box Pig of the Month Sauce Club vs Maurice's Piggie Park Pig of the Month Sauce Club vs Month Club Store Pig of the Month Sauce Club vs Boost Your BBQ Pig of the Month Sauce Club vs BBQ Rub Club Grill Masters Club vs Oakland Dust Grill Masters Club vs My BBQ Box Grill Masters Club vs Maurice's Piggie Park Grill Masters Club vs Month Club Store Grill Masters Club vs Boost Your BBQ Grill Masters Club vs BBQ Rub Club Oakland Dust vs My BBQ Box Oakland Dust vs Maurice's Piggie Park Oakland Dust vs Month Club Store Oakland Dust vs Boost Your BBQ Oakland Dust vs BBQ Rub Club My BBQ Box vs Maurice's Piggie Park My BBQ Box vs Month Club Store My BBQ Box vs Boost Your BBQ My BBQ Box vs BBQ Rub Club Maurice's Piggie Park vs Month Club Store Maurice's Piggie Park vs Boost Your BBQ Maurice's Piggie Park vs BBQ Rub Club Month Club Store vs Boost Your BBQ Month Club Store vs BBQ Rub Club Boost Your BBQ vs BBQ Rub Club
Compare the Best BBQ Sauce Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best BBQ Sauce Clubs
The Best Reviews of BBQ Sauce Clubs