Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Macy's Beauty Box Review

Monday, May 20th

2024 Beauty Box Subscription Reviews

Macy's Beauty Box Review 2.5 Star Rating

Macy's Beauty Box

2.5 Star Rating
  • Costs $15 per month
  • 1 box style
  • Valued around the same as the items in it
  • Makeup and fragrance focused
  • Luxury items included
  • "A+" rating from the BBB

Macy's beauty subscription box features beauty products, skincare, makeup, and fragrances without committing to full-size products. In Macy's subscription, you'll receive a variety of themed boxes inspired by color palettes, activities (like a glam look for date night), and seasonal themes tailored to your monthly plans. The company also dedicates boxes to your favorite brands, ensuring you get more of what you adore. Just keep in mind that this more affordable option only promises sample sizes in each box, so if you're looking for full-size beauty products each month, you may want to keep shopping.

Lots of fragrance options

The Macy's Beauty Box doesn't specialize in one or two things. Instead the shopping mall favorite offers a bunch of different items in one package, allowing you to try out new samples and then buy the full size directly from Macy's once you figure out what you like best. However, you will find a lot of fragrances since Macy's sells plenty of perfumes and colognes. You can expect to find brands like NYX, Estee Lauder, Smashbox, MAC, PRADA, YSL, and more.

Best Beauty Box Subscriptions

What's in the box?

If you're curious, here's an example of what a previous box included:

  • Lancome Monsieur Big Instant Volume Mascara
  • Too-Faced Lip Injection Maximum Plump Extra-Strength Lip Plumping Gloss
  • NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil All-In-One Eyeshadow Eyeliner Pencil
  • Yves Saint Laurent Libre Eau de Parfum Spray, 5-oz.
  • Yves Saint Laurent Men's L'Homme Eau de Parfum Spray, 3.3 oz.
  • Smashbox Photo Finish Primerizer+ Hydrating Primer with Hyaluronic Acid
  • Yves Saint Laurent Touche Eclat Blur Face Primer, 1 oz.

Only 1 box and it's sample size

There's only one box to choose from at Macy's, and it's a sampler. While this can be fun if you don't know what you want, it can also be frustrating if you really like a product and then immediately need to buy more. Macy's doesn't offer an estimated value of its boxes, but customers have said that it's "hard to find one worth the price." A lot of the draw for Macy's Beauty Box is the fragrance samples from various designers and scent profiles. If you're not into fragrance, Macy's might not be worth it.

Only $15 per box

With only one box, Macy's keeps it simple. The price each month is a competitive $15. Macy promises a bonus coupon with your monthly payment too. However, the value for money with the Macy's Beauty Box just isn't as competitive. $15 per month is a lower-than-average cost, but with only sample-size items in the box, you're not getting much for your money (even $15 worth).

Best Beauty Box Subscriptions

Doesn't stand out from competition

What sets Macy's Beauty Box apart from other makeup subscription services? Honestly, not much. Macy's tries to sell itself with the extra coupon and a "free gift" , but the details on the amounts or value of these "extras" aren't available online. Compared to other companies that offer POC-focused palettes or unique Korean skincare, Macy's doesn't quite stand out from the pack.

Mixed reviews and concerns about cancellation

While Macy's itself has a solid "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, the subscription box doesn't do quite as well. With an average rating of 3.5 stars out of 5 from different third-party review sites (and a few beauty bloggers), the Macy's Beauty Box has some seriously mixed feedback. Customers who liked Macy's are fragrance fans who love seeing their favorites like YSL on the roster. However, those who didn't enjoy the Macy's Beauty Box experience said that the cost of the box was about even with the value of the samples, meaning you could do just as well buying sample sizes from your local beauty store. Further, many customers complained about how hard it was to unsubscribe, making it a more concerning option to try out than others in our review.

Macy's doesn't impress

While mixed reviews aren't usually enough to knock a company down to a below-average rating, that red flag plus the fact that all of the boxes only offer samples create a beauty box that really isn't doing anything special (even compared to other mid-tier companies). It might be worth your time if you're a fan of fragrance, but otherwise, you may be happier checking out one of our higher-rated options instead.

What's the Best Beauty Box Subscription Online Today?

Looking for the best beauty box subscription to elevate your self-care routine? Or maybe you're looking for a way to explore new (or expensive) brands that you wouldn't try otherwise? A Beauty Box Subscription is a great way to start a new self-care journey. And there are lots of fun options to choose from!

You might be considering makeup-focused subscriptions, skincare-centric boxes, or those that offer a mix of beauty products. With all there is to choose from, it's no wonder that beauty boxes have gained widespread popularity in recent years. They offer a curated selection of beauty products delivered right to your doorstep, allowing you to discover new brands and products without leaving the comfort of your home.

The Best Beauty Box Subscriptions Compare Beauty Box Subscriptions Compare Beauty Box Subscription Reviews What are the best Beauty Box Subscriptions Best Beauty Box Subscription Reviews

Beauty Box Subscription FAQ

If you're someone who loves discovering new beauty products without the hassle of shopping in-store (or browsing endless beauty lists online), these services are crafted just for you. Whether you're a makeup enthusiast, skincare fan, or someone looking to spice up your beauty routine, beauty boxes can be a fun way to get started.
Beauty Box Subscriptions curate a delightful selection of beauty goodies and deliver them straight to your doorstep. Some of them will allow you to choose items or add personalization to the package, but with most, you can just sit back, relax, and enjoy your surprise collection of beauty products in each shipment.
The benefit of a subscription is that experts handpick a variety of products, from makeup must-haves to skincare essentials. It's like receiving a personalized gift every time. This means the makeup pros are sending you the best products to try for yourself.
Choosing a Beauty Box Subscription means saying goodbye to decision fatigue and hello to delightful surprises. No more endless aisles or overwhelming choices and brands. While you can choose a box that offers the types of products you enjoy, you can take the research out of beauty and just enjoy the excitement of trying new things (usually for a far lower price than buying them in-store).
Your beauty journey is in your hands. Choose from flexible subscription options, whether it's monthly, quarterly, or annually. You decide how often you want to indulge in the joy of unboxing new beauty treasures. Some subscriptions offer seasonal boxes while others offer monthly shipments. So, you can choose how much and how often.
Beauty has lots of different definitions. Some boxes are focused on makeup while others offer hair masks and shampoos. You can find a few one-stop shops that will give you a taste of all the beauty areas or focus narrowly on Korean beauty. It just depends on what you want for your body.
Each subscription offers a different range of products. Some focus on luxury items with big brand names like Drunk Elephant or YSL. Others are standalone companies that offer their own products for subscription. Depending on what you're looking for, you can find drugstore makeup, luxury brands, or small-town cottagecore beauty. Most companies will show you an example box as well as a list of brands, so you can decide if that box is right for you.
Cost is relative to the particular box you choose. Some companies have multiple plans, so you can pick between cost-effective and luxury. Others offer only one price. The balance is looking at the value against the monthly cost. For example, some companies offer high-end makeup like Charlotte Tilbury (which can cost up to $90 for one item at retail prices). If the box costs less than the item at retail price, you're already getting a good deal. Many boxes cost around $20 to $30 on average, so the value will change depending on what you're getting in your box (and how many items).
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Beauty boxes also provide a convenient way to explore the latest trends, discover your "holy grail" products, and treat yourself to a monthly dose of beauty excitement. And here's a little-known secret: it's often more cost-effective than shopping for the same products at retail prices.

Many beauty fans who've hit the makeup store recently know that for 2 or 3 items you can walk out paying over $100. Well, many Beauty Box Subscriptions offer items that value between $100 to $350 for a monthly cost around $30. Considering that most beauty boxes also provide full-size items in the subscription, you can enjoy high-end items for a fraction of the price.

The Beauty Box Subscription trend has grown rapidly, and now there are tons of beauty options out there. Some focus on cruelty-free and clean beauty, some focus on luxury makeup and skincare, while others embrace a wide range of products suitable for all skin types and tones. The variety ensures that there's a box out there for everyone, regardless of your beauty goals and lifestyle.

You might be wondering if investing in a Beauty Box Subscription is worth it. For one thing, many subscribers find joy in the surprise element, eagerly anticipating each month's selection. Additionally, with some subscriptions coming in under $10 per box, you can find plenty of price ranges to fit your budget, making sure your beauty exploration doesn't break the bank. This is particularly appealing for beauty enthusiasts who love experimenting with new items and staying ahead of the curve.

With an array of options available, it can be overwhelming to pinpoint the ideal box that aligns with your unique preferences and beauty needs. So, we've put together a few key considerations that can guide you toward the perfect fit:

  • Cost. Check the subscription cost and consider whether it aligns with your budget. Some subscriptions offer great value for the price, providing a cost-effective way to explore premium beauty products without paying retail costs for the same items.
  • Product variety. Explore the range of products included in each box. Are you looking for a mix of skincare, makeup, and haircare, or do you have a specific focus in mind? Make sure that you're getting enough items in each box to explore your beauty desires.
  • Brands featured. Check out the brands that the beauty box collaborates with. Some subscriptions partner with well-known beauty brands, while others highlight emerging and indie labels. Depending on what you want to try, the brands on the list might make or break your decision.
  • Personalization. Consider whether the beauty box allows any personalization based on your beauty preferences. Some services tailor their offerings to your skin type, tone, or specific product interests while others leave it as a surprise.
  • Customer reviews. Don't forget to check customer reviews and testimonials to see how current and past subscribers feel about a particular box. Honest feedback can help you decide which companies actually offer beauty box value and which aren't worth your time.

To help you pick the best box in a world of Beauty Box Subscriptions, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best options available today. Our goal is to help you discover the beauty box that adds a touch of excitement and joy to your beauty routine. We hope this helps you find the perfect beauty subscription that upgrades your self-care journey!

Compare Beauty Box Subscriptions

Select any 2 Beauty Box Subscriptions to compare them head to head

  • IPSY
  • Prose
  • BoxyCharm
  • Allure Beauty Box
  • BeautyFix
  • FaceTory
  • Walmart Beauty Box
  • Margot Elena
  • Macy's Beauty Box
  • The Detox Box
  • Birchbox
  • GlossyBox
IPSY vs Prose IPSY vs BoxyCharm IPSY vs Allure Beauty Box IPSY vs BeautyFix IPSY vs FaceTory IPSY vs Walmart Beauty Box IPSY vs Margot Elena IPSY vs Macy's Beauty Box IPSY vs The Detox Box IPSY vs Birchbox IPSY vs GlossyBox Prose vs BoxyCharm Prose vs Allure Beauty Box Prose vs BeautyFix Prose vs FaceTory Prose vs Walmart Beauty Box Prose vs Margot Elena Prose vs Macy's Beauty Box Prose vs The Detox Box Prose vs Birchbox Prose vs GlossyBox BoxyCharm vs Allure Beauty Box BoxyCharm vs BeautyFix BoxyCharm vs FaceTory BoxyCharm vs Walmart Beauty Box BoxyCharm vs Margot Elena BoxyCharm vs Macy's Beauty Box BoxyCharm vs The Detox Box BoxyCharm vs Birchbox BoxyCharm vs GlossyBox Allure Beauty Box vs BeautyFix Allure Beauty Box vs FaceTory Allure Beauty Box vs Walmart Beauty Box Allure Beauty Box vs Margot Elena Allure Beauty Box vs Macy's Beauty Box Allure Beauty Box vs The Detox Box Allure Beauty Box vs Birchbox Allure Beauty Box vs GlossyBox BeautyFix vs FaceTory BeautyFix vs Walmart Beauty Box BeautyFix vs Margot Elena BeautyFix vs Macy's Beauty Box BeautyFix vs The Detox Box BeautyFix vs Birchbox BeautyFix vs GlossyBox FaceTory vs Walmart Beauty Box FaceTory vs Margot Elena FaceTory vs Macy's Beauty Box FaceTory vs The Detox Box FaceTory vs Birchbox FaceTory vs GlossyBox Walmart Beauty Box vs Margot Elena Walmart Beauty Box vs Macy's Beauty Box Walmart Beauty Box vs The Detox Box Walmart Beauty Box vs Birchbox Walmart Beauty Box vs GlossyBox Margot Elena vs Macy's Beauty Box Margot Elena vs The Detox Box Margot Elena vs Birchbox Margot Elena vs GlossyBox Macy's Beauty Box vs The Detox Box Macy's Beauty Box vs Birchbox Macy's Beauty Box vs GlossyBox The Detox Box vs Birchbox The Detox Box vs GlossyBox Birchbox vs GlossyBox
Compare the Best Beauty Box Subscriptions
- VS -
Review the Best Beauty Box Subscriptions
The Best Reviews of Beauty Box Subscriptions