Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Brooklyn Bedding Review

Friday, June 21st

2024 Bedding Company Reviews

Brooklyn Bedding Review 2 Star Rating

Brooklyn Bedding

2 Star Rating
  • Bedding items from $24 to $169
  • Free shipping on all orders
  • 30-day returns
  • Great prices for mattresses
  • "A+" rating and accreditation from the BBB

Brooklyn Bedding, established in 1995, is primarily recognized for its mattress selection. Over the years, the company expanded its product line to encompass items such as pillows, sheets, blankets, mattress protection, foundations, and adjustable bases. If you're in the market for a mattress, Brooklyn Bedding is certainly a worthwhile destination to explore. However, when it comes to bedding recommendations, this retailer may not be your top choice in terms of a unique inventory.

The site and navigation focus on mattresses

The selection of bedding products at Brooklyn Bedding is noticeably limited. Most of this website is dedicated to mattresses while the other bedding items are harder to find. Everything sleep-related (sheets, blankets, pillows) is hidden under the "accessories" tab. While they do offer three-sheet sets crafted from different materials like microfiber, bamboo twill, and tencel sateen, the overall selection of colors and styles is beyond small. It's evident that Brooklyn Bedding's primary focus lies in mattress sales, with other bedding items occupying a secondary role within their product range and their site design.

Best Bedding Stores

Not enough inventory for a full bed set

While we normally check prices at each retailer with the same four search terms, we weren't able to do that at Brooklyn Bedding for one important reason: they don't have any kind of duvet or "top" cover (even comforters or quilts). So, we couldn't put together a full bed's worth of pricing ranges for you. What this company did offer was sheet sets and blankets.

  • There are exactly three sheet sets with prices ranging from $24 to $169
  • As for blankets, there is just one option for a weighted blanket which costs $149 to $164 depending on which size you get

Unsurprisingly Brooklyn Bedding also didn't have any bed-in-bag sets, so those are left out of our price comparison too.

Free shipping on all orders

Brooklyn Bedding offers free FedEx Ground Shipping for all their products within the contiguous U.S. Typically, orders are shipped within 3-7 business days, although some delays may occur through the carrier. Since this includes mattresses, it definitely is one of the better shipping policies in this review.

Best Bedding Stores

30-day no-hassle returns

Brooklyn Bedding extends a 30-day return policy for sleep accessories. This policy comes with a full refund and offers a free shipping label for return shipments. Across the board, this is one of the most customer-focused return policies we've seen, as it alleviates any concerns about the return process or extra charges if the items don't work out for you.

Solid reputation, but mostly focused on mattresses

The Better Business Bureau shows an "A+" rating and accreditation for Brooklyn Bedding, which is an impressive score. Although customer feedback tends to be positive, most of it revolves around the experience of purchasing and sleeping on the mattresses they offer. Should you desire insights into their sheet sets or pillows, you can glean valuable information by reading customer reviews on the respective product pages. Many customers express satisfaction with Brooklyn Bedding's bedding products, highlighting the cooling properties and soft texture of their sheets. They report that these items helped increase their comfort during sleep. However, some customers note that washing and maintaining bed linens from Brooklyn Bedding requires extra effort, such as ironing sheets and pillowcases and adopting specific washing precautions.

Not a hotspot for bedding

While Brooklyn Bedding serves as an attractive option for individuals seeking mattresses, with a notable emphasis on quality, it doesn't quite stack up when it comes to bedding. Customers visiting Brooklyn Bedding for actual bedding recommendations may find their choices lacking. They do not offer comforter sets, quilts, or duvet covers, and their selection of sheets and pillows is notably limited. For comprehensive bedding needs, you'll have to look at alternative retailers better equipped to cater to your requirements. So, while the site itself (and its shipping and return policies) is a positive experience, we have to give Brooklyn Bedding ja lower rating since it's missing most of the bedding necessities.

Where is the Best Bedding Store Online Today?

Securing a perfect night's sleep is everyone's dream, and quality bedding is pivotal in achieving this goal. Whether you're in the market for fresh pillowcases, crisp sheets, a cozy comforter, or an inviting quilt, the world of online shopping offers plenty of options for your next bedding makeover.

It's easy to see why shopping for bedding online has become so popular. First, you can avoid the hassles of driving from store to store and fighting the crowds. You can also enjoy a much wider selection of bedding to choose from online. And typically the prices you find online are lower than what you'll see in traditional bedding stores.

The Best Bedding Companies Compare Bedding Companies Compare Bedding Company Reviews What are the best Bedding Companies Best Bedding Company Reviews

Bedding Company FAQ

Bedding can refer to a lot of things. Put simply, bedding is anything you might need to sleep in your bed or make it look nice when you're not. This includes pillows, pillow cases, fitted sheets, shams, comforters, duvet covers, quilts, bedskirts, decorative pillows, and more.
Yes! Most commonly you'll find bedding for twin (39" x 75" ), full/double (54" x 75" ), queen (60" x 80" ), or king (78" x 80" ) beds. This refers to the length and width of your bed and it's important to buy bedding that fits snug. Most companies carry the same bedding styles in multiple sizes, so you don't have to worry about not having a big selection for the size you need.
Bedding usually ranges anywhere from $30 to $200 (sometimes more) for a full set. However, if you're just buying a pillowcase or a new fitted sheet, you can expect to pay closer to $20 or $30. So much depends on what bedding product you're looking to buy and what material it is made of.
Since there are so many styles and designs when it comes to bedding, it helps to start out by identifying the size of bed you have. Once you've established this, decide what color of bedding you want and if you prefer it to have a design or just be a solid color. You can filter bedding selections down based on color and then browse the different options until you find bedding you are excited about!
A comforter is usually a thick bedding topper, most often made of cotton blends and synthetics. It is probably the most popular type of bedding topper in the US. It is sewn or quilted to keep the filling in place, but usually in plain, non-ornate patterns. A bedspread is a light-weight single-layer topper that covers the whole bed, sometimes down to the floor. They are good for cooler weather and sometimes come with elaborate finishes like pompom or chenille. Duvet covers are made to fit over a comforter with a zipper or buttons that can easily be removed for cleaning. You can switch out how heavy of a comforter you use on the inside to adjust to different temperatures throughout the year. Lastly, a quilt is an artistically crafted, heavy blanket with a top, inner batting, and bottom layer stitched together with complex patterns. They are popular for coastal, country, or rustic decorating styles.
It would be easier to ask what styles bedding does not come in! You can find bedding in all colors and designs, and with or without graphics. You can buy it all together in one matching set or mix and match patterns by purchasing different pieces of bedding individually. Some bedding themes include farmhouse, bohemian, Disney, sports, nautical, floral, shabby chic, and much more.
Some of the most common materials bedding comes in are cotton, flannel, silk, polyester, bamboo, microfiber, or lyocell. The different fabrics will play a part in the weight and temperature of your bed at night. Depending on if you like it cool or warm while you sleep, you will want to purchase bedding in materials that will help regulate temperature.
There are a variety of factors that play into how often you will need to replace bedding. Most experts believe bedding (at least sheets) should be washed weekly. After a few years of washing them weekly, they will likely thin and fade, which is a good indication that it's time for new ones. If you repaint your room or get new furniture, you might find that you want some new bedding to freshen up your bedroom vibe. Or maybe you spill something that stains your bedding and you can't stand to look at it any longer! As long as you keep your bedding clean, it should hold up for quite a while, but you'll be able to tell when it's time to follow the saying: "Out with the old, and in with the new!"
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

The diversity of bed options is astounding, spanning from elegant florals and sleek solids to captivating geometric patterns and even bedding adorned with 3D cotton designs or tassels. Picking out your ideal bedding is a means of personalizing your space, reflecting your style, and celebrating your hobbies.

The bed, often the centerpiece of the bedroom, is not just a place to sleep, but also a canvas for self-expression. Beyond the quest for the perfect bedding type, you'll find a ton of unique styles and designs that can bring your creativity out as you pick between duvet styles, sheet colors, and throw pillows to revamp your nighttime nest.

Diversity in bedding extends beyond style and aesthetics. Many individuals curate a collection of sheets, duvets, quilts, and comforters tailored to the seasons. A weighty quilt might be a sanctuary of warmth during the winter, cocooning you in comfort as you sleep, but it may prove less desirable for those residing in sweltering climates (like sunny FL) where cooling down or managing the amount of sand tracked into the bed at your beach house is a priority.

Similarly, the choice of sheets can greatly influence your sleep experience; fleece sheets, cozy for winter slumbers, may feel stifling in the heat of summer. Thus, the consideration of bedding in various weights and fabrics along with the climate in which you reside becomes a thoughtful and practical decision.

There are so many bedding types to choose from it can be hard to know where to start. Whether you're a zen-bedding guru, looking for the perfect eco-friendly comforter, or maybe you're a teen looking for the perfect dorm room set, there's bedding out there that can make your bedroom a dreamland.

If you're not sure where to start with so many retailers and so many styles, don't sweat. Here are a few key things to think about before jumping into cottons and percales:

  • Selection. Bedding can be an investment, often with you for years to come. So, you want to make sure you pick a store that offers a diverse array of styles, fabrics, and sizes, ensuring that your final choice resonates with your taste and specific requirements.
  • Budget. There are a lot of different price ranges out there depending on the type of bedding you want. Keep your ideal budget in mind as you browse. Some sites are good for one or two items but too pricey for a full bed set. Others are low-cost, but may not have high-end designs or eco-friendly options. So, knowing your ideal budget can help you decide where to buy.
  • Company reputation. The reputation of the bedding retailer can help you feel confident in your purchase. Feedback from customers can offer invaluable insights into the quality, delivery, and customer service provided by a particular company. Checking out customer reviews and product ratings can give you that extra assurance that your bedding will meet your expectations.
  • Return policy. Even if you carefully choose (or maybe you like to eenie-meenie-miney-mo, we don't judge) there may be instances where you need to return or exchange your bedding. Whether it's a sizing mishap or the color isn't right once you get into your room, finding a company with a flexible and hassle-free return policy is essential for confident shopping.

To make sure you get your dreamland exactly the way you want it, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the top bedding stores out there today. We hope to help you find the best new bedding that promises a peaceful, restful night's sleep. Good luck with your shopping, and enjoy catching those Zzzs!

The Best Reviews of Bedding Companies