Where Can You Find the Best Book Club?
If you're looking for a new way to enjoy reading, joining a book club subscription can be a fun and enriching experience. Whether you're an avid reader seeking to expand your literary horizons or someone looking to rediscover the joy of reading, participating in a book club offers numerous benefits.
But modern book clubs aren't the same as you might be thinking: a group picking one book to read and getting together in person to talk it over. Instead, virtual book clubs more closely resemble a wine club or something similar where you subscribe to a "club” to get new books sent to you each month.
Thursday, April 24th
2025 Book Club Reviews
Brilliant Books
Brilliant Books offers subscription options that include a variety of genres and age groups, with curated selections handpicked by their staff. You can customize your reading experience by choosing specific book box types, ranging from standard monthly subscriptions to iconic reads like banned books or modern classics. While pricing ranges from $99 to $360 for 6-month or 1-year subscriptions, the flexibility to change delivery schedules and the satisfaction guarantee make it our top choice among book clubs.
A Box of Stories
A Box of Stories surprises readers with a monthly box containing four books across various genres, offering a delightful reading experience. Starting at $51.29 per month, there is considerable value despite the higher price tag, and you can pause shipments or change genres anytime without interrupting your subscription. While shipping times may be slow, the unique book selections and flexibility make A Box of Stories a top book club for adventurous readers, earning it a solid rating in our review.
Once Upon a Book Club
Short Once Upon a Book Club provides a unique reading experience with a curated box containing a newly released book and 3-5 gifts, carefully timed to coincide with specific points in the story. While slightly pricier, ranging from $49 per month to $570 per year, subscribers appreciate the immersive journey and well-written book selections, making it a top pick for adult, young adult, and tween readers seeking a distinctive literary adventure.
Book of the Month Club
Book of the Month Club offers a selection of 5-7 books each month across various genres like crime, fantasy, and romance. New members can snag their first book for $5 and then pay between $12.50 to $17.99 monthly, with free shipping included. While some customers find it pricey, its flexible subscription allows you to skip months and unlock bonuses for loyalty, earning this book club a strong rating.
Just the Right Book
Just the Right Book, from RJ Julia Bookstores, offers personalized book recommendations based on your Reading Profile questionnaire, featuring plenty of genres like literary fiction, thriller, and fantasy. Pricing ranges from $26.75 to $41.50 per month depending on your preferences, with hardcover, paperback, or mixed selections. Despite limited reviews, Just the Right Book earns a solid rating for its impressive selection and gifting options.
The Book Drop
The Book Drop, powered by Bethany Beach Books, offers nine subscription boxes, each with handpicked books in various genres, including adult fiction, young adult, graphic novels, and kids' reads. While the monthly surprise factor adds excitement, the pricing, especially for adult subscriptions, might seem a bit steep for just one book per month. However, The Book Drop's club shines with its exceptional options for young readers, making it a solid choice for parents or guardians looking to foster a love of reading in children.
Nowhere Bookshop
Nowhere Bookshop, founded by Jenny Lawson in San Antonio, Texas, offers a cozy spot for book lovers to enjoy new releases, author events, and themed book clubs with surprises each month. With adult clubs like Fantastic Strangelings and Happy Endings, plus a spooky option called Nightmares from Nowhere, there's something for every reader. However, the pricing, including a $10 enrollment fee and shipping costs, might deter some potential subscribers despite the positive reviews.
Fresh Fiction Box
Fresh Fiction Box offers monthly deliveries with 3-5 romance and suspense books per shipment, priced at $35.95 per month with discounts for 3-month subscriptions. While lacking customization options, the box's value is praised by customers, though sign-up by the 20th of each month is required for the upcoming box. Despite mixed reviews on customer service and limited book choices, it remains a good-enough choice for continuous reading enjoyment.
Books & More
Books & More offers curated book packages with extras like wine and bookmarks, but lacks transparency on shipping costs. While their subscription options allow for customization and a short survey helps tailor your preferences, the pricing structure can be confusing, starting at $39.99 for one book plus extras. However, the lack of customer reviews and unclear shipping fees raise concerns, earning this book club a lower rating in our review.
BookTide
BookTide offers monthly boxes featuring hand-picked paperbacks and personalized notes, creating a charming reading experience. However, the lack of transparency on their website regarding book selection and genres limits what you'll know in advance. Priced at $19 per month with minimal customization options or scheduling flexibility, BookTide's new subscription program earns a low rating due to its lack of established reputation and information.
Continued from above...
Book clubs offer an extensive array of genres ranging from mysteries and sci-fi to historical dramas and fantasy epics. However, the abundance of options can sometimes feel overwhelming, leaving you unsure of where to start. A book club helps solve that problem by providing you with curated selections delivered right to your doorstep. Such a service would not only save you time but also keeps up a steady supply of books perfectly suited to your interests. You can choose from a selection of award-winning titles from both renowned and emerging authors in your favorite genre, or branch out and try some new literary categories you've never read before.
With a book club subscription, you can bid farewell to the hassle of scouring bookstores or endlessly scrolling through online catalogs. Instead, each month brings a delightful surprise as you receive a handpicked selection of books directly to your home. At most book club subscriptions, you have the flexibility to customize your membership duration and even give a subscription to fellow book lovers, spreading the joy of reading far and wide.
In the fast-paced world we live in, finding moments of relaxation and enjoyment is essential for maintaining a healthy balance. Investing in a book club subscription not only provides endless hours of entertainment but also fosters a sense of anticipation and excitement as you eagerly await each month's new arrivals. So why not treat yourself or a loved one to the gift of literary exploration? It's a worthwhile investment in both leisure and personal enrichment, offering a fulfilling escape from the demands of everyday life.
Choosing the right book club is essential to a fulfilling and enjoyable reading experience. To help you navigate the variety of book clubs out there, here are some factors to consider:
- Book selection. Evaluate the types of books chosen by the club, including genres, themes, and authors. Look for clubs that follow your reading interests and preferences, so that you'll enjoy the selected books and actively engage in discussions.
- Customization. Can you add specific books to your order? Can you customize the shipping periods or pause your book club shipments if you travel? You want your book club subscription to fit your life, so make sure there are options to make the service feel like it's tailored for you.
- Price. All book aficionados know that their hobby can come with a bit of a price tag (especially if you're getting multiple books at a time or gunning for a hardcover, new-release copy of a novel). So, make sure that the price of the book club subscription makes sense with the value of books and quantity that you receive.
- Reputation. What are other readers saying about each book club? Are the novels worth the subscription? Are there enough perks to keep customers coming back? Seeing what reviewers say about your chosen book club can help you narrow your options.
To help you find the best book club for your reading journey, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top options on the market. We hope our recommendations will help you discover the perfect book club subscription to enrich your reading experience. So, set aside your worries for a moment, find a cozy spot, maybe even light a scented candle, and immerse yourself in a captivating novel. Before you know it, hours may slip away unnoticed as you become engrossed in the journey of your next book!
Book Club FAQ
Compare Book Clubs
Select any 2 Book Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Book Club News
Related Book Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Book Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
