Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Book of the Month Club Review

Saturday, January 28th

2023 Book Club Reviews

Book of the Month Club Review 4.5 Star Rating

Book of the Month Club

4.5 Star Rating
  • Free shipping on all boxes
  • Skip any month you want
  • First book for $9.99
  • Qualify for discounts after 12 boxes

Book of the Month has been helping people discover new books since 1926. Rather than having you sign up for a 3, 6, or 12-month plan, you pay each month that you want a new book. This way you can skip any months you aren't interested in the selection or get a new one each month. Genres include contemporary fiction, young adult, thriller, historical fiction, romance, and everything in between.

Choose from 5 new books

Rather than having a mystery selection of books sent to you each month, Book of the Month features 5 new and exciting reads and you can choose one (or more) of them to be delivered to you. If you're not excited about upcoming selections or you aren't ready for a new book yet, you can skip as many months as you want and pick back up with your subscription delivery when you're ready.

Make informed choices

The 5 featured books each month come with a detailed product page that includes an author bio, book review, and other relevant information to help you make the best choice for your tastes. The selections come from a wide range of genres and can be either fiction or nonfiction.

Add-on options

Book of the Month includes add-on options where you can choose up to two extra books a month. This includes current selections or books that were featured in previous months. You select these in addition to your chosen book of the month by the 6th of each month. If you don't select your book(s) in time, you'll see a credit in your account.

Best Book Clubs

Save on your first book

A discount code was provided at the time of this review for customers to get their first book for just $9.99. This is definitely something to take advantage of when you first sign up. Shipping is always free and the price of boxes are normally $15.99/month.

BFF Status

After you've received 12 book shipments, you qualify for "BFF" status through Book of the Month. This means that you'll receive a new tote bag for your books, get a free add-on during your birthday month, get 20% off of everything in their member-exclusive Blue Box Boutique, and get a free book every winter. Those are pretty sweet rewards for just reading a few books a year.

Final sales

If you receive a book that is damaged or defective, Book of the Month asks that you call their customer service line within 30 days of the original shipment date to request a replacement. However, you can't get your money back if you read the book you choose and decide that you didn't like it. In short, all sales are final.

One of the best options

We were surprised and concerned when we found that Book of the Month has an "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau. However, we are cutting them a break since the rating is based on their failure to respond to 4 customer complaints. Although we'd like to see them get on top of this and address these specific issues (mainly to do with difficulties cancelling memberships), we don't believe this is a sign that the company is unreliable, unenjoyable, or dishonest. We like that customers get some freedom in choosing the book they want that month and that they can skip any time they choose, so we believe this is one of the best options if you're looking to join a book club.

What is the Best Book Club to Join?

Any bookworm knows that one of the most enjoyable experiences in life is to cuddle up in a cozy blanket, maybe light a candle, grab your favorite snack, and dive into your novel. It's a healthy outlet to help you escape into a new world and learn something new. Hours can pass you by as you're engulfed in your book adventure and you may hardly realize it.

Whether you're a fan of mysteries, sci-fi, history, action, or fantasy books, there are thousands of titles out there for you to read. The hardest part is narrowing them down. Sometimes there is such a thing as too many options. Wouldn't it be nice if you could have hand-picked books delivered to you that fit your taste? It would save so much time and ensure you have an endless list of books ready to enjoy.

The Best Book Clubs Compare Book Clubs Compare Book Club Reviews What are the best Book Clubs Best Book Club Reviews

Book Club FAQ

These Book Club subscriptions are delivered once a month. They usually ship out on the first or middle of the month. Different services offer different variations on how many months are in the subscription.
This varies widely based on the service. Some offer just one book, while others might offer two. Some of the boxes are even themed and include unique handpicked gifts to match the book chosen.
Usually the different services will have the book picked out in advance. A few offer a choice between several books. The range of books varies greatly. Sometimes a panel chooses the book, and one service even has you work with a special book buyer to find the right book for you.
Book Clubs are a great gift! If you already love to read then it gives you new options to read, and if you aren't into reading yet, it gives you the perfect opportunity to start! Having a book picked out and delivered to you once a month will keep your bookshelf fresh.
Different options have different costs. Some are as low as $9.99 a month while others might be $50. The main price disparity is in the box contents. Boxes that are just books will be cheaper, while ones with goodies are going to cost more.
This is up to the service and you! Some services offer monthly subscriptions for a limited time, others offer month to month with the option to skip a month, and some offer one-time boxes. The only limit is your wallet!
Luckily this isn't a common issue, most of the boxes try to send out new books or even special early releases, so the chance of you having it is slim. There are also options to choose a different book or skip that months delivery for some services. The subscriptions also announce what book they are sending before it sends so you can have some warning to not buy the book.
There is a lot of variety! Some services offer themed subscriptions, so you can choose which genre of book to have sent each month. Some just offer several options every month to choose from, all different genres. Each service has its own way to keep it fresh, so make sure to find the best option for you!
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Lucky for all the bibliophiles out there, book clubs provide award-winning titles from popular and new authors that fit your reading preferences. You don't have to leave your house or do any research because each month you'll get new books delivered to your door. You can select the length of your membership and even give a book club as a gift to a loved one. We can't think of a more enjoyable way to spend money.

As you browse different book clubs, there are some important things to consider:

  • Membership fees: How much does it cost to participate in the book club? Does your membership auto-renew, or does it end after your selected duration?
  • Cancellation policy: Can you cancel your membership at any time? How much notice do you have to give the company beforehand?
  • Return policy: If you're disappointed in the book selection you receive, can you get a refund or send it back for a different book?
  • Reputation: Is the book club used by a lot of members? What do customers have to say about their experience with the company?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best book clubs available today. We hope this information helps you continue to find new book titles that provide all the enjoyment and relaxation you are hoping for!

Compare Book Clubs

Select any 2 Book Clubs to compare them head to head

See the Best Book Club
The Best Reviews of Book Clubs