Here you can see how Feed Your Soul and David's Cookies match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Brownie Clubs in 2025.
Feed Your Soul specializes in gourmet cookies and brownies. When you make a purchase here, a portion of your sale will go towards feeding someone in need and sending cookies through the Coalition for the Homeless in New York. There are 7 brownie flavors here that are rotated in a 3, 6, or 12 month brownie subscription, all of which are individually wrapped. There aren't a ton of details about how the Brownie of the Month Club works here and there is no satisfaction guarantee. Customers do really like the quality of brownies, though, so we give Feed Your Soul's brownie club an above-average rating.
David's Cookies has a wide range of products like cakes, muffins, cheesecakes, cookies, pies, and brownies. Customers can subscribe for recurrent deliveries for 3, 6, 9, or 12 months starting at $85.35 if you pay upfront. There are only 6 flavors total, so it's possible that if you subscribe long-term, you'll get the same kind twice. David's Cookies has good reviews and an "A" rating from the Better Business Bureau, but they aren't entirely clear on the quantity of brownies you'll receive and how they are packaged or how fresh they are. Although this isn't our first choice for brownie clubs, they do offer a satisfaction guarantee where you can possibly get your money back or a new shipment if you aren't happy with the quality you receive. This is a decent option for brownie clubs, but definitely not our favorite option.
If you live for that first bite of a warm, gooey brownie, a brownie club could be your new favorite indulgence. You might be pleasantly surprised - and genuinely delighted - to discover there are services that send fresh batches to your doorstep on a regular schedule all year long. Many even let you pick flavors or seasonal specials so every delivery feels like a small celebration.
These companies offer rotating selections of gourmet brownies you can enjoy or send as a gift - no mixing bowls, no oven mitts, no effort required. Truth is, most of us haven't tasted how truly decadent a brownie can be beyond box-mix staples, and even fewer have baked a batch from scratch. With seasonal flavors, thoughtful packaging, and delivery straight to your door, they make treating someone (or yourself) feel special from the first bite to the last.
Sometimes a plain chocolate brownie hits the spot, and for many of us it never gets old. But once you start exploring, you'll be hooked - there are far more variations than you'd expect. Think rocky road, blondies, cheesecake swirls, coconut, s'mores, or caramel-toffee brownies, each one a mini adventure for your taste buds. Try one at a bakery or bake a batch at home and you'll see there's a brownie for every craving.
Most brownie subscriptions let you set the cadence - how long the plan runs and how often boxes arrive - and sometimes even choose the flavors. Typical timelines span 3, 6, 9, or 12 months. Some companies publish a flavor calendar for the year, while others send a surprise with every shipment. If you're eyeing a one-off flavor, you can usually place a single order between deliveries, so you've got plenty of flexibility. They also make easy, crowd-pleasing gifts for birthdays and holidays.
Many brownie clubs prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients. They typically include their nutrition facts and any allergens you should be aware of, so you can always feel confident about what is headed your way. Here are a few things to keep in mind when looking at different brownie clubs:
The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best brownie clubs available for you to sign up for online. We know you'll have no trouble signing up with a subscription that offers high-quality, unique brownie flavors that you can treat yourself or a loved one to all year round!
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.