Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Wednesday, February 12th
David's Cookies opened their first shop in Manhattan in 1979 and the company still rocks an 80s-inspired vibe that captures these early start-up days. By 1987 they had transitioned to a mail-order company and began to offer a variety of baked goods like cheesecakes, brownies, and crumb cakes. They boast that their delectable baked goods are made from natural, fresh ingredients without any preservatives. Many of them are even gluten-free, making this company a good option for an even wider array of diets.
2 size options
Aside from the option to make one-time purchases of any of David's Cookies products, they offer a Brownie of the Month Club. You can choose between receiving 1 or 2 trays in each delivery. A single tray includes 26 oz. of brownies, so if you're feeding a big family or a larger group, 2 trays (52 oz.) is the way to go. We do wish that the company would clarify approximately how many brownies come in each tray to give some clarification on the quantity that you'd receive (since most of us don't measure out our brownie servings by weight).
Repeat flavors
With each shipment comes a single flavor of brownies. David's Cookies lists out the full year of flavors so you always know what will come ahead of time. Some of their flavors include rocky road, macaroon (coconut), pecan, cheesecake, and blondie with chocolate chips. In total there are just 6 flavors, so they repeat and you could end up getting each flavor twice if you subscribe for a full 12 months.
Review ingredient list
A full list of ingredients as well as the nutrition facts of each flavor are available to view on David's Cookies' website under "Nutritionals”. Although the company boasts that they have a lot of gluten-free products, none of the brownie flavors we found were gluten-free. Most of them also contain things like egg, milk, soy, and even fish, so if you're concerned about ingredients, pay attention to what is included with each flavor.
Pay-as-you-go or upfront
Monthly brownie club orders ship on the first Tuesday of each month and are charged on the first day of the month if you choose to pay-as-you-go. You can also pay your full subscription upfront if you choose to. Pricing depends on how many deliveries you receive and how many trays you choose to have in each shipment. The full list of prices includes:
$6.95 shipping for most orders
Standard delivery for most items and subscriptions purchased from David's Cookies is $6.95 for 2-day service, although it could vary based on your zip code. Expedited orders have a hefty fee of $39.95. Choose the shipping method you want at checkout to see your order total with shipping included.
Satisfaction guarantee
We are happy to see that David's Cookies has a 100% guarantee on all their products, so if you're less than satisfied with the quality or freshness, they will reship the item or refund the total value within 30 days of receipt if you call or email their customer service.
General satisfaction overall
David's Cookies has an "A” rating from the Better Business Bureau, but the only reviews from customers we found who had ordered their brownie subscription were straight from their own website. The majority of people said the flavors were delicious, but there were a few people here and there who had cancelled their subscription because they didn't feel like the deliveries lived up to their expectations. For most people, though, this brownie club would be satisfying and serve as a fun treat.
We have some reservations
David's Cookies doesn't specify how they package their brownies or how soon they are baked before they are shipped out in deliveries, and we wish they did just so we could gauge how fresh deliveries will be. Plus, they don't say anything about how to store the brownies or how soon they should be consumed upon arrival. We would like to see more flavor options as well and a little more clarity about how much comes in each delivery, so we are apprehensive about ordering this brownie club. David's Cookies has earned an average rating from us.
If you're a chocolate lover and live for biting into a gooey warm brownie, you've got to consider a brownie club. You may be surprised (and delighted) to find that there are companies that exist to ensure that you get regular deliveries of your favorite treat straight to your doorstep all year round.
These companies have rotations of gourmet brownies for you to enjoy or gift to a loved one without you having to do any of the work to make them yourself. Most people haven't experienced how delectable a brownie can be beyond the kind that comes in a box. Let's face it, most of us have never made brownies from scratch, right?
A simple chocolate brownie is as good as it gets for many of us and we still can't get enough. Once you discover how many brownie flavors there are, you'll be hooked. Think rocky road, blondies, cheesecake, coconut, s'mores, or caramel toffee brownies: the flavors are endless and make for an exciting trip for your tastebuds.
With a brownie subscription, you can usually choose the duration of your deliveries, how often they come, and sometimes even the flavors you receive in the box. A usual length of deliveries is around 3, 6, 9, or 12 months long. Some companies will let you know ahead of time what their flavors for the year are going to be and others will surprise you with each order. In between, you can often do single purchases as well if you want to try a one-off flavor, so there are plenty of options.
Many brownie clubs prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients. They typically include their nutrition facts and any allergens you should be aware of, so you can always feel confident about what is headed your way. Here are a few things to keep in mind when looking at different brownie clubs:
The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best brownie clubs available for you to sign up for online. We know you'll have no trouble signing up with a subscription that offers high-quality, unique brownie flavors that you can treat yourself or a loved one to all year round!
Select any 2 Brownie Clubs to compare them head to head