Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Vermont Brownie Company Review

Wednesday, February 12th

2025 Brownie Club Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Vermont Brownie Company Review 5 Star Rating

Vermont Brownie Company

5 Star Rating
  • Starting at $129.99 for 3 months
  • Either 6 or 12 brownies per box
  • Pretty packaging
  • Free shipping
  • High customer reviews
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

On New Year's Day in 2008, Vermont Brownie Company came to life. They pride themselves in using farm-fresh ingredients without any preservatives and shipping all orders in fun, whimsical packaging. All of the brownies sold by this company are baked in small batches, straight from their Vermont bakery, with as many locally sourced ingredients as possible.

Mouth-watering flavors

The brownies from Vermont Brownie Company look absolutely mouth-watering. When we were ordering, the selection of flavors included signature chocolate, candy cane, maple toffee crunch, pumpkin spice, triple chocolate chunk blondie, coconut brownie, apple blondie, peanut butter, walnut chunk, dark chocolate chevre, and espresso. Our mouths were watering by the time we had finished looking into this company and we couldn't wait to get our hands on one of their brownies.

Best Brownie Clubs

Half or full dozen

Each brownie made by Vermont Brownie Company is approximately 2.5” x 2.75” x 1” and weighs 3 oz. In their monthly brownie program you'll get either a half or full dozen, depending on your preference. The duration of subscriptions can be either 3, 6, or 12 months and requires prepayment for all the deliveries upfront. All orders from Vermont Brownie Company qualify for free shipping, which is one of our favorite things to see as a customer.

3, 6, or 12 month subscriptions

We found the cost of Vermont Brownie Company's monthly brownie program to be pretty competitive when compared to other companies. For 3 months, the price is $129.99 for a half dozen and $199.99 for a full dozen. A 6 month subscription is $259.99 for a half dozen and $399.99 for a full. Then, the most expensive option is either a half dozen for a year at $519.99 or $799.99 for a full year. This comes out to be under $8 per brownie, which is similar to what we saw elsewhere.

Pretty packaging choices

After you select the quantity and duration of your brownie club, Vermont Brownie Company also has a dropdown menu of 6 packaging choices. You can see photos of what each one will look like and they're all classy and simple, making it a perfect choice for a gift.

Enjoy immediately

Ideally, the brownies you receive in your subscription should be eaten right away. Brownies will stay fresh at room temperature for about a week after arrival. If you wait longer than this to enjoy your treats, refrigerate or freeze them for longer-term storage. All of them are exposed to nuts and include wheat, eggs, dairy, and soy, but a full list of ingredients can be viewed on the website, which we appreciate.

Best Brownie Clubs

Love it or your money back

Vermont Brownie Company offers a simple and straightforward guarantee that ensures if you're not happy with your order, they'll replace or refund it. All it takes is an email or phone call to the company to get this taken care of.

Glowing customer reviews

There are over 2,000 unfiltered customer reviews on Vermont Brownie Company's website and we are really impressed by what we see there. Customers have nothing but great things to say about this company, their brownie flavors, the quality, and the consistency. People have been buying here for years and often have made Vermont Brownie Company part of their seasonal traditions. The company is not rated by the Better Business Bureau, but the customer reviews speak for themselves here.

Top choice

Everything about Vermont Brownie Company makes us eager to order from them. Their prices, flavors, ingredient quality, and customer reviews have easily made this our top choice for brownie clubs.

Which is the Best Brownie Club Subscription?

If you're a chocolate lover and live for biting into a gooey warm brownie, you've got to consider a brownie club. You may be surprised (and delighted) to find that there are companies that exist to ensure that you get regular deliveries of your favorite treat straight to your doorstep all year round.

These companies have rotations of gourmet brownies for you to enjoy or gift to a loved one without you having to do any of the work to make them yourself. Most people haven't experienced how delectable a brownie can be beyond the kind that comes in a box. Let's face it, most of us have never made brownies from scratch, right?

The Best Brownie Clubs Compare Brownie Clubs Compare Brownie Club Reviews What are the best Brownie Clubs Best Brownie Club Reviews

Brownie Club FAQ

Once you start exploring the flavors of gourmet brownies you can find from an online store, you'll realize there is so much more to enjoy than the classic chocolate brownie we've all come to love. Brownie clubs have created sweet and savory mouth-watering flavors that can be delivered straight to your front porch on a regular schedule. Ever tried a salted caramel brownie? How about raspberry, turtle, or gingerbread? This is just a tiny sample of what you might get from a brownie club and we're sure you'd enjoy every bite.
When it's an option, shopping online is far more convenient than going to the store. You can browse all brownie flavors in a company's inventory from the comfort of your own home and compare pricing among other brands too. It's the best way to get the lowest prices. Plus, when it comes to food items like brownies, it's a major time saver when someone else does the cooking for you. It may also be your only option if you want to try the unique variety of flavors out there and don't have all the recipes. Gourmet brownie stores are extremely hard to come by, so there's also a high chance that you won't even be able to get the quality and flavor you're looking for unless you turn to the internet.
Look for a company that is transparent about their nutrition facts and provides a full ingredient list. They will usually highlight potential allergens that you should be aware of that you can identify quickly. If a company is gluten, dairy, or nut-free, they will often promote this as a good option for people with these intolerances or allergies. If you really want to try a flavor from a company that doesn't have their ingredients listed, reach out to them via phone or email and they'll undoubtedly work with you to ensure that your order will be safe.
The great thing about brownie clubs is that you can operate with a "set it and forget it” mentality. Once you place an initial order, you won't have to do much afterwards. You'll choose how big of a box you want delivered, how often you want it to come, and how long you want your subscription to last. From there, brownies will be delivered based on the schedule you set and you won't have to do anything else unless the company allows you to go in and make changes to upcoming flavors that you want to specify.
It's a big perk when you find a company that offers a satisfaction guarantee. With brownies, you won't be able to ship back your order for them to resell, so if you're unhappy with an order, it's possible that the company will refund your money or offer you a store credit. Most companies stand strongly behind their product and want their customers to be happy, so don't hesitate to reach out to them if you are unsatisfied with your order.
Pay attention to a company's process for making brownies and shipping them out. Many companies boast that they bake their brownies the same day that they're shipped to ensure maximum freshness. They will usually tell you how soon they should be consumed upon arrival. Sometimes, if you order in bulk, you might consider freezing your brownies so that they're ready to pull out and use at a future date whenever you are hosting guests or crave a sweet treat.
Brownies make a classy and delicious gift. Is there anyone who doesn't love this satisfying and delectable dessert? Many companies cater their subscription service for gift-giving by offering personalized messaging for whoever is receiving the delivery. Plus, some will also offer gift wrapping and themed packaging for special occasions as well. Regardless of who the brownie subscription is for or what the event is, you can (and should) give brownies as a fun, tasty gift.
You've got a few different brownie clubs to choose from, so there are some key things you should pay attention to when deciding which one to go with. First and foremost, look over their menu. See if their flavors look appetizing to you and be sure there is enough variety to keep you interested for the duration of your subscription. Next, look at pricing. Do they offer discounts if you subscribe rather than if you place one-time orders? Is shipping free or at least not too expensive? It's never fun to pay as much for shipping as the brownies themselves. Lastly, read customer reviews about the company to see if their products are fresh, delivered on time, and if their employees are easy to work with. You should be able to narrow down the one that will provide you the most satisfaction.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

A simple chocolate brownie is as good as it gets for many of us and we still can't get enough. Once you discover how many brownie flavors there are, you'll be hooked. Think rocky road, blondies, cheesecake, coconut, s'mores, or caramel toffee brownies: the flavors are endless and make for an exciting trip for your tastebuds.

With a brownie subscription, you can usually choose the duration of your deliveries, how often they come, and sometimes even the flavors you receive in the box. A usual length of deliveries is around 3, 6, 9, or 12 months long. Some companies will let you know ahead of time what their flavors for the year are going to be and others will surprise you with each order. In between, you can often do single purchases as well if you want to try a one-off flavor, so there are plenty of options.

Many brownie clubs prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients. They typically include their nutrition facts and any allergens you should be aware of, so you can always feel confident about what is headed your way. Here are a few things to keep in mind when looking at different brownie clubs:

  • Variety. How many different flavors of brownies are offered by the company? Do they have seasonal flavors that are unique to the company and can't be purchased anywhere else? Will you get brownies in a range of sizes or quantities?
  • Cost. The cost of brownies will vary based on the ingredients, flavor, and quantity. Take shipping costs into consideration when you're comparing prices between companies as well. Some clubs offer free shipping but others will charge you for each shipment, and this can drastically affect the overall price.
  • Reputation. What do customers say about the brownie flavors offered by a club? Do they taste fresh and soft? Do orders arrive when they're expected? Pay attention to comments about a company's customer service, policies, and overall reliability to determine whether or not you want to buy from them.

The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best brownie clubs available for you to sign up for online. We know you'll have no trouble signing up with a subscription that offers high-quality, unique brownie flavors that you can treat yourself or a loved one to all year round!

The Best Reviews of Brownie Clubs