Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Bake Me a Wish! Review

Monday, February 10th

2025 Brownies Delivery Reviews

Bake Me a Wish! Review 4.5 Star Rating

Bake Me a Wish!

4.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing at $34 to $83 per package
  • 24 multi-packs to choose from
  • 6 flavors
  • Brownies, blondies, and brookies
  • 4-12pc packs
  • Refunds offered
  • Gluten-free options
  • 5-star average with in-house ratings
  • "A-” rating from the BBB

Bake Me a Wish! is a popular site for giving baked goods as gifts. The bakery opened in 2004 to address a problem the founder was having in New York: there weren't any bakeries that could deliver out of state. While Bake Me a Wish! first started as a cake-baking endeavor, it has grown its menu to include cookies, pies, cupcakes, cheesecakes, brownies, and more. Popular in news outlets like Forbes, The Sun, and Windy City Times, Bake Me a Wish! is considered a go-to destination for gifting a delicious treat for your loved ones or for yourself.

Helpful listings with mouth-watering photos

Exploring Bake Me a Wish!'s brownie selection is simple - just click on "Brownies" in the top navigation bar. From there, you'll be greeted with all of Bake Me a Wish!'s brownie delivery packages. From holiday treats to standard brownies and bars, most of the selections at Bake Me a Wish! come with a variety of brownies and flavors. The listing photos include the names, the number of brownies in each pack, the pricing, and individual star ratings for each package. Selecting a specific brownie package reveals more details, including a description of the flavors included in each pack and all allergy information. From the listing, you can also add a custom delivery date, add a gift message, or upgrade your gift with extra cookies or a teddy bear plushie.

Best Brownies Delivery

25 packs and 6 flavors

There are 25 different boxes, assortments, and packages that include brownies. From mixed-bag assortments that include brownies, cookies, and cakes, to holiday-themed boxes with different kinds of brownies and bars, to snack boxes with pretzels, popcorn, and brownies all in one, you'll find tons of ways to enjoy Bake Me a Wish!'s brownies. There are 6 flavors to choose from at Bake Me a Wish! The chocolatey favorites are Velvet Ganache Chocolate, Cheesecake, Tuxedo, and Brookie. The non-chocolate brownie/bar flavors are Iced Lemon Blondie and Raspberry Crumb. You can also find gluten-free brownies and blondies at Bake Me a Wish!

Pricing from $34 to $83 per package

The pricing on Bake Me a Wish! for brownies varies depending on the box you choose. If you're looking at selections that only have brownies, the prices range from $42 to $57 for the Gourmet Brownie Sampler and the 12pc Brownie Sampler, respectively. Across all boxes, the prices start at $34 for the Cookie and Brownie Snack Box and go up to $83 for The Waldorf Chest.

Shipping costs around $22.99

The only drawback at Bake Me a Wish! is the higher-than-average cost of shipping. For our location, shipping costs $22.99, though this may change depending on where you live. There are no alternative shipping options with Bake Me a Wish!, and pretty much all of their orders cost the same for shipping and handling. You'll have to wait until after you finish your checkout to see the shipping costs, so be aware that your price may increase significantly before you complete your purchase.

On-time guarantee and refunds offered

Bake Me a Wish! promises an "On Time Guarantee" for its brownie deliveries (and all its other sweets too). All orders are shipped through UPS, and if your brownies don't arrive on the scheduled date, the full cost of shipping will be refunded. Bake Me a Wish! also promises to resolve issues with the quality of brownies after shipping. Bake Me a Wish! currently offers partial or full refunds, store credit, or replacement of your brownies, depending on the specific issue at hand.

Best Brownies Delivery

High praise for flavor

Bake Me a Wish! has a solid score with the Better Business Bureau, currently holding an "A-” rating. On Bake Me a Wish!'s website the brownie packages all have 4- or 5-star ratings with many of the brownie treats showing thousands of reviews on each listing. On third-party review sites like Trustpilot, Bake Me a Wish! has a more measured rating. With 3.4 stars on average, Bake Me a Wish!'s customers generally love the cookies and bars, but there are some complaints about shipping. Most of the complaints were about cake orders, specifically, though, so you'll likely be safe if you're ordering brownies. In general, sweet fans agree that the flavors at Bake Me a Wish! are top-notch.

A great pick if you want brownies for a gift

Bake Me a Wish! is a top choice for delicious brownie assortments. Ideal for sending as a gift, Bake Me a Wish! is perfect for any occasion. If you're flexible with delivery timing, you shouldn't expect to have any complaints. Though we'd like to see the delivery issues resolved (given the On-Time Guarantee), this is a minor concern in an overall solid bakery. On the whole, Bake Me a Wish! earns an excellent rating for its tasty brownies and impressive gifting options.

Where is the Best Place to Order Brownies for Delivery?

There's nothing quite like the decadent chocolaty scent of fresh brownies, except maybe that soft and gooey first bite. And there's never a bad time for brownies. Whether you're celebrating a fun occasion, looking for a way to spice up date night dessert, or just craving a tasty pick-me-up, brownies are a classic treat that never goes out of style.

Brownies combine all the best parts of a dessert: the comforting baked feel of a cake mixed with a dense, melty chocolate texture that comes in various flavors. But if you're looking for brownies that stand out from the crowd (no basic boxed mixes here), you might feel limited by what you can find at local bakeries. But don't worry. Now you can have tasty gourmet brownies shipped straight to your door.

The Best Brownies Delivery Compare Brownies Delivery Compare Brownies Delivery Reviews What are the best Brownies Delivery Best Brownies Delivery Reviews

Brownies Delivery FAQ

It's simple! You browse an online bakery, pick your favorite brownie flavors (or a variety box), and decide when you want your treats delivered. Bakeries typically make your order the same day it ships, so you get the freshest brownies possible short of baking them yourself. Your brownies are basically just a couple of clicks away.
Yes, they will! Most brownie delivery services use airtight packaging and cooling packs to ensure your treats stay fresh. When they arrive, your brownies will either be ready to eat or have warming instructions included in the package. If you don't want to eat them right away, most packages will also include freezing or refrigeration instructions.
Prices vary depending on the bakery you choose and the size of your order. Other factors like your location (in terms of shipping costs) can also change the overall price. Typically the cost for a package of brownies is around $20 to $100+ (not including shipping). Many services also offer deals or discounts for holiday specials or extras too.
All kinds! Brownies, blondies, and brookies are all on the table. The selection really just depends on which bakery you buy from and what flavors they offer. You can score a traditional fudge brownie, or find extra special flavors like Peanut Butter or Salted Caramel. Some bakeries also cater to dietary needs with vegan, gluten-free, or sugar-free brownies too.
Most services ship within 2-5 days depending on how their brownies are packaged and how much you want to spend on shipping. You can book your shipments in advance if you want (especially if you're planning a party or a wedding), but for brownies you want right away, you can expect to get them within 1-5 days of your order date.
It depends on the bakery, but in most cases, brownies are individually wrapped to keep them fresh for a longer period. Some other boxes keep the brownies loose inside the packaging. But the majority of bakeries will keep your treats separate so you can open each brownie when you're ready.
Most solid brownie delivery services have a satisfaction guarantee where you can score a refund or a reship of your order if something goes wrong. So, if your brownies arrive damaged or in poor condition, you can send a photo to the bakery and contact them for assistance. While not all bakeries offer refund policies, the best ones put their customers first.
Of course! What better way to show your love than by sending fudgy chocolate treats? Many services let you add gift wrap, personal notes, or even add-ons like plushies to a gift order. Whether you want a birthday treat, a thank-you, or something for the holidays, the best bakeries offer boxes that cater to each celebration.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

The history of brownies can be traced to the year 1893 when baker Bertha Palmer asked for a new dessert for the World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago. A US-based treat, brownies are known for their glossy upper crust and either having a "fudgy” or "cakey” texture. Popular brownie recipes include chocolate chips, peanuts, caramel, and more. The first known printed use of the word "brownie” for a recipe was in a cookbook by Fannie Farmer in 1896. Today, studies show that Americans eat around 1.45 billion brownies per year (and we're definitely part of that number. Yum!.

Sending brownies through the mail might seem challenging - after all, they're delicate and can sometimes crumble. However, modern bakeries that specialize in shipping out their treats work to make sure you get fast delivery with little to no damage. You should have no trouble getting picture-perfect brownies from the right bakery, and you won't need to stress about receiving dried-out or damaged brownies when you order from the best.

Whether you want a classic chocolate fudge brownie or something more adventurous like salted caramel or peanut butter swirl, or even a brownie loaded with toppings like Oreos or pretzels, there is a bakery out there for you. Some bakeries even offer seasonal brownies with flavors like peppermint. No matter what, you'll get a perfect bite of chocolatey goodness that's just right for your sweet tooth.

If you're ready to get that decadent smell of brownies wafting through your home, but don't know which bakery to choose, we've got your back. Here are some factors that can help you pick the best vendors for brownie deliveries:

  • Cost. When buying brownies for delivery online, check the value vs. cost of the brownies. How many do you get for the price? Are there flavors you can't find anywhere else? How large are the individual treats? You'll also want to check on shipping costs to make sure that's affordable too.
  • Variety. There are tons of brownie flavors out there, so make sure your chosen bakery offers you a competitive variety so you don't have to browse other places once you find a brownie recipe you love. You don't want to miss out.
  • Dietary restrictions. If you're on a special diet, don't worry. There are plenty of bakeries that offer vegan alternatives and more. Check the menu for options that fit your unique diet to make sure the bakery of your choice has what you need to enjoy your favorite treat.
  • Reputation. When shopping for treats online, it's always a good idea to look up your bakery of choice on trusted review sites like Trustpilot or the Better Business Bureau. Fellow brownie lovers who've shared their experiences can help you pick the best bakery in terms of quality, taste, and reliability.

It's time to get a batch of brownies in your kitchen. To help you find the best service to satisfy your chocolate cravings, Top Consumer Reviews has researched the top brownie delivery services out there today. Treat yourself and indulge in some fudgy and cakey brownies. You deserve it!

Compare Brownies Delivery

Select any 2 Brownies Delivery to compare them head to head

best-brownies-delivery
  • Fairytale Brownies
  • Here We Go Brownies
  • Bake Me a Wish!
  • Vermont Brownie Company
  • Greyston Bakery
  • The Brownie Gourmet
  • Baked Cravings
  • David's Cookies
  • Harry & David
  • Magnolia Bakery
Fairytale Brownies vs Here We Go Brownies Fairytale Brownies vs Bake Me a Wish! Fairytale Brownies vs Vermont Brownie Company Fairytale Brownies vs Greyston Bakery Fairytale Brownies vs The Brownie Gourmet Fairytale Brownies vs Baked Cravings Fairytale Brownies vs David's Cookies Fairytale Brownies vs Harry & David Fairytale Brownies vs Magnolia Bakery Here We Go Brownies vs Bake Me a Wish! Here We Go Brownies vs Vermont Brownie Company Here We Go Brownies vs Greyston Bakery Here We Go Brownies vs The Brownie Gourmet Here We Go Brownies vs Baked Cravings Here We Go Brownies vs David's Cookies Here We Go Brownies vs Harry & David Here We Go Brownies vs Magnolia Bakery Bake Me a Wish! vs Vermont Brownie Company Bake Me a Wish! vs Greyston Bakery Bake Me a Wish! vs The Brownie Gourmet Bake Me a Wish! vs Baked Cravings Bake Me a Wish! vs David's Cookies Bake Me a Wish! vs Harry & David Bake Me a Wish! vs Magnolia Bakery Vermont Brownie Company vs Greyston Bakery Vermont Brownie Company vs The Brownie Gourmet Vermont Brownie Company vs Baked Cravings Vermont Brownie Company vs David's Cookies Vermont Brownie Company vs Harry & David Vermont Brownie Company vs Magnolia Bakery Greyston Bakery vs The Brownie Gourmet Greyston Bakery vs Baked Cravings Greyston Bakery vs David's Cookies Greyston Bakery vs Harry & David Greyston Bakery vs Magnolia Bakery The Brownie Gourmet vs Baked Cravings The Brownie Gourmet vs David's Cookies The Brownie Gourmet vs Harry & David The Brownie Gourmet vs Magnolia Bakery Baked Cravings vs David's Cookies Baked Cravings vs Harry & David Baked Cravings vs Magnolia Bakery David's Cookies vs Harry & David David's Cookies vs Magnolia Bakery Harry & David vs Magnolia Bakery
Compare the Best Brownies Delivery
- VS -
Review the Best Brownies Delivery
The Best Reviews of Brownies Delivery