Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Cake Clubs

Who Has the Best Cake Club?

From some of the simplest ingredients - flour, sugar, eggs, and butter - to one of the world's most beloved and delicious desserts. Cake not only has rich flavor, but has a rich history, borrowing its namesake from Viking origin and dating back to Ancient Greek and Roman times.

Cake spans styles, added ingredients, shapes, sizes, and occasions. The art of cake decorating is noted as a valuable and beautiful artistic expression, and in numerous cultures it symbolizes some of our world's most revered customs: from weddings, to bat mitzvahs, to birthdays. One need only casually watch a single episode of The Great British Bake-Off to find themselves entrenched in the esteemed art and science of cake baking.

Wednesday, January 20th

2021 Cake Club Reviews

TopConsumerReviews.com Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Flying Noodle Review 5 Star Rating

Flying Noodle

5 Star Rating
  • Cost: From $25.95 per month
TopConsumerReviews.com Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

With a cake club membership from Flying Noodle, you are guaranteed to feel as though you've just been wrapped up in a big Italian family hug - and that's because passion seeps through every aspect of a Flying Noodle membership service.

Premium service

From the quality of cakes delivered, to the variety, to the cost, to the membership perks - Flying Noodle has your back just like the most loving and protective of family members would. While the website notes that not all employees at Flying Noodle may come from an Italian heritage, they are all bonded through an intense love of quality, Italian food. Featured in USA Today, Good Morning America, and Country Living, folks everywhere are raving about the premium and high quality service offered through Flying Noodle.

Over 25 years

As the company was founded 25 years ago, Flying Noodle has become quite skilled at anticipating what customers want and delivering on just that. Previous cakes delivered have ranged from Tiramisu, to Coffee Crumble, to Lemon-Raspberry and Blueberry Burst; and all are chosen from independent, specialty producers, by taste-testing professionals who seek cakes made with only the finest, all-natural ingredients.

Best Cake Clubs

Newsletter, free shipping, and more

Other benefits to a cake club membership with Flying Noodle include free shipping, ability to send a personalized gift announcement, discounted offers sent only to club members, a cake newsletter entitled "Let Them Eat Cake", and even a 100% satisfaction guarantee that ensures a customer's right to cancel membership at any time and receive a full refund. Flying Noodle also offers some of the greatest amount of flexibility for customers, with their offer to deliver their delightful cakes not only for the duration specified by customers, but even on an 'every-other-month' basis. If that doesn't showcase innovation, creativity, and thoughtfulness - well, we're not sure what does.

Cake Club Membership Overview

  • Cake Selection: 1 specialty cake per shipment including 8-10 servings
  • Duration: 3mo, 6mo, 12mo, Seasonal (4 total deliveries)
  • Frequency: Monthly or Every Other Month (Not applicable to Season Club)
  • Shipping: Free, available to all 48 continental states

Highest rating

Flying Noodle offers an exceptional, premium cake club at a highly competitive price - especially when compared to many of the other companies reviewed on our website. Their website showcases personality and professionalism, with strong and organized content that gets to the point for customers. We think you'll be hard-pressed to find another company that has anticipated the customer's every need while maintaining a consistent focus and passion on their vision. Don't take our word for it though; order today for yourself or a loved one, and get your fork ready to bite into exquisiteness.

Amazing Clubs Review 4.5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

4.5 Star Rating
  • Cost: From $27.95 per month

Amazing Clubs continues to maintain a superior reputation for monthly club services with their Cake of the Month Club. Rated the #1 cake club 7 years in a row by the Wall Street Journal, customers have learned they can trust and rely on Amazing Clubs to seek out and deliver gourmet cakes from top bakeries all throughout the country.

Never repeated

Previous cakes delivered have ranged from Cranberry Bliss, to Cinnamon Walnut, to Double Chocolate Chip, and Pumpkin Apple - and no, we won't judge if you've already started to drool a bit. Cakes delivered by Amazing Clubs are advertised as containing all-natural ingredients, and are never repeated throughout the recipient's duration of club membership. In fact, the cakes are even delivered in special packaging to ensure both freshness and safety of delivery.

Satisfaction guarantee

The high-quality cakes, combined with Amazing Clubs' "They'll Love It!" Guarantee, provides customers with a fantastic subscription service experience. With the guarantee, customers are able to cancel their subscription and receive a full refund with no questions asked. That's an offer not many companies are willing to extend.

Best Cake Clubs

Many club options

Amazing Clubs will also include a newsletter with each shipment to the recipient, entitled "A Piece of Heaven", including information on that month's selection, fun cake facts, and serving suggestions - a thoughtful bonus no other company on our list includes. Plus, Amazing Clubs customers are able to choose from a wide variety of delivery duration and frequency options, that even allow the customer to choose between pre-paying in full or as shipments are delivered. Shopping Amazing Clubs affords customers incredible flexibility at extremely reasonable prices.

Cake Club Membership Overview

  • Cake Selection: 1 specialty cake per shipment including 8-10 servings.
  • Duration: 3mo, 6mo, 12mo, seasonal (4 total deliveries). Pre-pay or pay as you go.
  • Frequency: Monthly or every other month
  • Shipping: Free - international shipping unavailable at this time

Great choice

Ordering a monthly cake subscription through Amazing Clubs is one of the best investments on our reviewed list. Boasting an impressive reputation, and additional positive reviews, we find Amazing Clubs to be a trustworthy experience. Between their premium quality, outstanding prices, and a flexibility customers deserve, you are bound to have one amazing experience.

Daisy Cakes Review 4.5 Star Rating

Daisy Cakes

4.5 Star Rating
  • Cost: From $67.50 per month

With Daisy Cakes, customers are provided true Southern hospitality in every delicate and delightful bite of cake. Cakes are designed, mixed, baked, and decorated by hand in the Pauline, South Carolina bakery; and made with only the freshest premium ingredients. Looking for that home-made, baked-with-love style in your cake delivery service? Daisy Cakes doesn't have that mass-produced; money-gimmick feel. With Daisy Cakes, you can trust exceptional quality and professionalism from the first order to the last bite.

Generational cake recipes

Even the very cake recipes themselves have been passed down for generations, until reaching current owner, Kim. As the savvy and friendly website describes: three southern belles, referred to as the "Misses", passed down all ingredients and recipes throughout Kim's family tree, utilizing farm fresh eggs, vegetables, and hand-churned butter to create mouth-watering masterpieces.

Higher price

Daisy Cakes does rank on the higher end of price ranges for customers, but for the remarkable product delivered, we think customers will find Daisy Cakes well worth the price. Additionally, there are a few unique characteristics to Daisy Cakes, which we think could appeal to customers. For instance, each month corresponds with a type of cake, from which customers are able to choose from.

Best Cake Clubs

Free shipping

Dislike the cake planned to ship this month? Place your order for starting next month if it suits your taste buds better! Cakes can be kept frozen for up to 2 months, ensuring longevity with each cake delivered; and have ability to be shipping - FREE - to all 50 states. There is evening overnight shipping available for products, although this service may come with an additional fee. A cake from Daisy Cakes will also include more servings than any other cake service reviewed on our list (16-20 slices).

Cake Club Membership Overview

  • Cake Selection: 1 specialty cake per shipment including 16-20 servings.
  • Duration: 3mo, 6mo, 12mo (pre-pay only)
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: Free - international shipping unavailable at this time

Keeping customers happy

Daisy Cakes does their best to make and keep customers happy. Need to change, cancel, or postpone your order? Make sure to give 48 hours notice, and they will automatically give you a full refund. Depending on circumstances of delivery, they may also be able to accommodate a refund or replace your order after shipment, although this is handled on a case by case basis, as no changes can be made after an order has already shipped.

We were quite impressed by Daisy Cake's commitment to put customers first, showcased by their impressive top-quality, premium ingredients, and thoughtful considerations of the customers' anticipated needs. Enjoy your order from Daisy Cakes - just don't forget to save us a bite!

Goldbelly Review 3.5 Star Rating

Goldbelly

3.5 Star Rating
  • Cost: $69 per month

Goldbelly delivers exceptionally unique, delicious, and just plain fun cakes for consumers from some of the country's most esteemed bakeries. Launched in 2013 as an online marketplace for regional and artisanal foods, Goldbelly handpicks and delivers only the most exquisite products for customers. One look at their website, and you are sure to enjoy their quirky, celebratory vibes - almost as much as you're bound to enjoy the cakes delivered.

Variety of cakes

In the mood for a 7-layer Caramel Cake from South Carolina's "'Caroline's Cakes"? Or how about "Ovenly's" Brooklyn Blackout Cake? Or even a scrumptious Neapolitan Torte, courtesy of Nebraska's own Lithuanian Bakery? These are just a few of the heavenly creations from all over the country that Goldbelly will link you to. Distributed cakes will even range from traditional cakes, to cupcakes, to cheesecakes, to crispy cakes - serving you with variety and pleasure each shipment.

Best Cake Clubs

Most expensive

Goldbelly is much appreciated for their fun, 21st-century feel, and professionalism that also bursts with personality. They have numerous good reviews, and have received tons of positive press. Unfortunately, this quality comes at a steep, steep price. Goldbelly ranks the highest on our list in cost to customers by far - which isn't necessarily what you want to be ranked #1 for. If Goldbelly's product quality was vastly superior to its competitors, we may see the justification for their high prices; but we think there are other exceptional organizations that don't place such a financial burden on customers. If you're looking to splurge, go for Goldbelly. If you're looking for high quality at a fair price, you might find a better choice higher on our list.

Cake Club Membership Overview

  • Cake Selection: 1 specialty cake per shipment including 8-12 servings.
  • Duration: 3mo, 6mo, 9mo, 12mo. Pre-pay in full.
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: Free

Customer service questions

Goldbelly specifies that they do not allow returns, refunds, or cancellations on any orders which have shipped, and all items are final sale. Customers are encouraged to reach out to customer service, upon receipt of any damaged or spoiled goods. We do feel this draws a rather hard line for customers, and establishes a customer service tone that isn't quite as friendly as competitors. We think customers deserve both amazing products, and amazing customer care in their cake club subscription. Still, Goldbelly provides customers access to high quality cakes that are trusted to delight with each bite.

We Take the Cake Review 3 Star Rating

We Take the Cake

3 Star Rating
  • Cost: From $19.95 per month

We Take the Cake, is a great option for individuals looking to fully appreciate cakes - particularly Bundt Cakes. Originally founded as a modest mail-order company, Lori Karmel serendipitously happened upon one of their cakes in 1997, and fell in love at first bite. Almost immediately she bought the company, and equipped it with a brand new makeover that better reflected their fun and whimsical personality - and, above all, she was sure to retain all their delicious, wholesome, and homemade recipes.

World famous bundt cakes

For We Take the Cake, cake is a symbol of celebration, happiness, friends, and family. The organization is led by a small team of passionate employees, who take pride and passion in what their work. While their commitment to creating, baking, and delivering bunt cakes may limit their consumer base in some regards, their Bundt Cake has also become world famous. The Gourmet Key Lime Bundt Cake was even named one of Oprah's "Favorite Things", and appeared on 3 different food network shows!

Made fom scratch

Previous Bundt flavors delivered have included Sour Cream Coffee Bundt cake, Triple Chocolate Bundt cake, Carrot Bundt Cake, Butter Pound Bundt Cake, Strawberry Bundt Cake, and more. So, while the style of cake may be monotone, the flavor certainly is not. The cakes are made from scratch and can be refrigerated for up to 2 weeks, or even frozen for up to 1 year; and they are delivered to the recipient in unique, signature packing to ensure professionalism and safe delivery.

Best Cake Clubs

Limited cake club options

The Bundt cake theme is unique and niche, which comes with various pros and cons of appeal to customers. Unfortunately, though, We Take the Cake only offers 6 month or 12 month subscription plans, and does not include free shipping - this all combines to limit the customer service experience in several ways. Additionally, all items are final sale. Customers are instructed to reach out to customer service if they experience delivery of damaged or spoiled goods.

Cake Club Membership Overview

  • Cake Selection: 1 specialty cake per shipment including 8-10 servings.
  • Duration: 6mo, 12mo. Pre-pay in full.
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: Not included

Niche market

We Take the Cake offers a very good cake club in a niche market, and their prices are the lowest of any other site on our list. However, their lack of variety offered, both in cake style and flexibility in customer experience, leaves something to be desired. We are excited to see how We Take the Cake can learn, grow, and expand its horizons to deliver the best quality and the best experience for customers all throughout the nation.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

With such considerable fascination of cake, individuals have never so easily been able to access their favorite treat through cake club memberships, which can cater to the customer's every wish.

Cake clubs provide an enticing opportunity for dessert lovers everywhere to revel in sweet decadence. You can gift a cake club to a loved one, treat yourself to a mouthwatering bite - or both! With a cake club, each month will bring something delicious that you can depend on and look forward to.

You may have concerns receiving cake as a delivery each month: perhaps you question how the company manages quality control amidst the logistics of a traveling shipment? Maybe you feel skeptical subscribing to a club where you've never before tasted the product? Possibly, you're looking for a particular kind of cake or experience? Or, you could just be excited to anticipate the surprise of a sinfully rich chocolate cake, a light and zesty lemon cream cake, or seasonally inviting pumpkin cream cheese cake. No matter what your particular position may be in, many cake club companies are more than able to address your questions, anticipate your concerns, and deliver to your desires.

Mass-produced cake boxes, and supermarket bakery aisles won't begin to offer the same quality and selection as cake clubs. Many of the cake clubs we've reviewed even operate with particular values and ethics that appeal not only to your taste buds, but may even appeal to your very character. Delivering cakes that range from all over the country, your taste is bound to be opened to so much more than what store bought or local shops have to offer.

With such high demand, and a broad and expansive marketplace to choose from, it's no wonder cake clubs are considered a popular option for many folks. However, the cake clubs themselves are likely to vary in style, flexibility, focus, and price point. It's important to research what cake club features are most important to you:

  • Price. What is the subscription cost and will you need to pay for shipping? Does the club offer any discounts or membership-only exclusives? Will the company refund your order, if they don't deliver to satisfaction?
  • Duration. What length of plan best suits your needs? Are you confident in the product your purchasing? Are you simply hoping to test it out? Can you cancel any time?
  • Frequency. Is there variety in frequency of delivery? Can you choose how often you'd like to receive a shipment?
  • Selection. What comes in each shipment? Is it the same kind of cake each time? How many servings are included with each cake delivery? How is the cake chosen each month?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Cake Clubs available today. We hope these reviews help you find the right Cake Club membership to suit your needs!

The Best Cake Clubs Compare Cake Clubs Compare Cake Club Reviews What are the best Cake Clubs Best Cake Club Reviews

Cake Club FAQ

Not from a supermarket chain assembly line, that's for sure! Cake clubs go out of their way to bring you the most mouth-watering goodies, often from small bakeries around the nation.
The real question is, how often would you like to get a fresh cake on your doorstep? Select among monthly, bi-monthly and quarterly cake clubs, with plans lasting anywhere from three months to a year.
You'll pay anywhere from $20 to $70 per delivery, depending on the cake club provider you choose. Considering what you'd spend at a local grocery store to get a cake, or how much it costs to buy a cake from a specialty bakery, those prices are right on the money.
Sometimes. You'll want to read the terms of each cake club membership to see if delivery fees are part of your monthly price: over the course of a year-long plan, paying $5 to $10 for each shipment will really add up. Fortunately, some cake clubs include your shipping fees in their monthly pricing.
Almost always. No reputable business wants to get negative customer feedback for making deliveries that don't arrive in good condition or that taste bad. You should be able to get a refund or replacement if anything isn't quite right with your cake.
Of course! While there are always new cake clubs popping up, some subscription plans have been around for ten years or more. It's helpful to check out customer reviews of both new and established businesses, to ensure that the cake club you select will be a winner.
You'll likely get a newsletter with your cake club shipment each month. They usually have fun articles about cake, details about where your cake was made, and maybe even recommended pairings with fruit or beverages. A few providers of cake club memberships let you add on items like stuffed animals or flowers for an extra fee.
Yes! Wouldn't you love it if someone surprised YOU with a cake subscription? Cake clubs are a wonderfully unique gift-giving option, and you can usually include a personalized message with your delivery. You may even be able to have a gift announcement sent to your lucky recipient via email on
The Best Reviews of Cake Clubs