The Best Cake Clubs

Thursday, May 22nd

2025 Cake Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs

• $35.95 to $37.95 per month, depending on club duration
• Variety of cakes in every subscription (past selections include Cranberry Walnut, Cinnamon Streusel, Cherry Chocolate Chip, and more)
• 8-10 servings per cake
• Deliveries can be monthly, every other month, or quarterly
• Shipping included in the club price
• Ideal for gift-giving
• "A Piece of Heaven” newsletter with each cake
• Company and cake club get rave reviews
• Phenomenal satisfaction guarantee
• "A-” rated by the BBB
• In business since 2003

We're huge fans of Amazing Clubs. Look at any "Blank”-of-the-Month subscription involving food and you'll almost always find this company at the top of our list - and with good reason. And, every time we do the oh-so-tasty research on the Cake of the Month Club, we come to the same conclusion: Amazing Clubs is the best. With this subscription, you'll receive a gourmet cake each month from some of the finest bakeries across the country, carefully chosen to keep things fresh and exciting.

8-10 servings of fantastic cake flavors

Amazing Clubs takes pride in offering a wide variety of flavors, so you'll never get the same cake twice during your membership. Think rich Cherry Chocolate Chip, tart-and-sweet Granny Smith Apple, and seasonal favorites like Cranberry Walnut - all made with natural ingredients. Each cake provides 8-10 servings, making it easy to share (or not).

Monthly newsletter takes you behind the scenes

This club isn't just about the cakes - each shipment includes "A Piece of Heaven," a fun newsletter packed with facts about that month's cake and the bakery that made it, and serving suggestions to make it even better.

Oh-so-affordable

Amazing Clubs' is one of the most affordable cake subscriptions out there. You'll pay anywhere from $35.95 to $37.95 per delivery, depending on whether you choose a 3-month, 4-month (seasonal), 6-month, or year-long plan. Pay upfront for all of the deliveries or pay as you go: it's the same price either way. And, shipping is always free, which makes this cake club even sweeter. Finally, it won't take much time before you find ways to get a discount here: visit the website and wait for a pop-up, abandon the cart and peep your inbox for some savings, you get the idea. (And once Amazing Clubs has your number, so to speak, you'll get lots and lots of offers. You may need to unsubscribe...)

You're the boss

This company always makes it simple to manage your membership. While you can't pick the cake flavors, you'll get a heads-up a few weeks before each shipment. If you don't love the upcoming flavor, just contact customer service to skip that month - your subscription will be extended to make up for it.

Gift-giving made simple

And, if you're gifting the club, Amazing Clubs makes it easy too: you can send a gift announcement via email or regular mail on a date you choose, or you can print it out to deliver in person. Your recipient will have the same ability to get the monthly flavor bulletin and skip any cake that's not quite one that they'd like to eat (for example, one of our giftees absolutely hates peanut butter, so that's always a "skip it” for her). It's a thoughtful, delicious gift that keeps on giving.

Customer service can't be beat

The icing on the cake (see what we did there?) is Amazing Clubs' reputation, both for this cake subscription and for the company as a whole. People rave about the moist cakes in a never-repeated array of flavors, the on-time and perfectly-packaged delivery, and the exceptionally attentive customer service team. Amazing Clubs guarantees that you'll love everything you get - that's literally in the name of their satisfaction policy - and in our experience on the few times we've had one of their club deliveries go a little sideways, we've been offered a myriad of options for them to make it right. You could get a refund for one of the deliveries, get a replacement shipped, cancel your subscription and get a prorated refund for the remaining deliveries, or even apply your "credit” to a completely different club. Yes, Amazing Clubs is really that awesome.

Best cake club for yet another year

Once again, Amazing Clubs stands out as our top pick among cake clubs. From the high-quality treats to the thoughtful customer service and flexible options, it's hard to find a better cake subscription. Whether you're treating yourself or giving a gift, this is a club that's sure to impress. And maybe save us a piece?

Zingerman's

• $145 for 3 months, $275 for 6 months
• Variety of coffee cakes (selections include Sour Cream, Lemon Poppy Seed, and Sweet Butter Tea Cake, among others)
• Cakes delivered monthly
• Shipping included in the club price
• Exceptional satisfaction guarantee
• "A+” rated by the BBB
• In business since 1982

Zingerman's, located in Ann Arbor, is a legendary name among food lovers - and for good reason. This collection of specialty stores is famous for its mouthwatering treats, including fresh bread, rich brownies, and, of course, their signature coffee cakes. Their website proudly calls itself "the online shop for food lovers,” and once you've tasted their coffee cake, you'll understand why.

No skimping on the ingredients

The secret behind Zingerman's standout coffee cakes lies in their top-tier ingredients. They don't cut corners - you're getting Grassland butter (never shortening), Belgian chocolate, real maple syrup, fresh eggs, and Indonesian cinnamon. Other high-quality ingredients include organic, unbleached, unbromated flour, Red Flame raisins, toasted nuts, and real vanilla. And the final ingredient? Love. That's what Zingerman's actually lists last, and honestly, you can taste it.

A new flavor of coffee cake every month

One of the best things about Zingerman's coffee cake club is the rotating selection of flavors. Depending on the length of your subscription - three or six months - you'll receive a carefully curated lineup of seasonal cakes:

• Three-month club: Sour Cream, Gingerbread, Hot Cocoa Chocolate
• Six-month club: Sour Cream, Gingerbread, Hot Cocoa Chocolate, Sweet Butter Tea, Lemon Poppy Seed, Jumbleberry

Sign up for 3 or 6 months

We do want to point out that Zingerman's used to offer a 12-month subscription - and the Coffee Cake Club page even references it - but at the time of our most recent visit, they were only displaying the 3- and 6-month options.

Under $50 per delivery

Zingerman's cake club offers a terrific value, especially considering the premium quality of the cakes. It's priced at $145 for three months (same cost as our earlier review) and $275 for six months (a $15 increase over last time, boo to inflation). Shipping is included, but it's considered "relaxed” shipping, which means your cakes will arrive within four business days - plenty of time to enjoy them fresh.

Be the star in the gift-giving game

Setting up the cake club as a gift couldn't be simpler. Zingerman's makes the process smooth and stress-free with an interactive calendar that lets you select the delivery date. You can include a personalized gift message at checkout, and if you want to give a physical or digital gift announcement, there's a downloadable card available directly on the Coffee Cake Club page. Plus, you have the option to share tracking information with the recipient - no more wondering if the gift arrived on time.

Customer service is on point

Zingerman's commitment to customer satisfaction is legendary. They hold an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau with zero complaints - an impressive feat. Their "Unbeatable Guarantee” means that if something goes wrong with your order, they'll make it right - no questions asked, no need to send anything back. Their customer service team is responsive, helpful, and truly passionate about making sure you're happy. And, when we reached out via live chat (to ask about that "no 12-month club now” issue), we got a rep -not an AI bot - who said she would be glad to customize a year-long subscription with any combination of the 8 coffee cake flavors in their overall inventory. Now THAT is service.

One of our favorite cake clubs

Zingerman's coffee cake club isn't just about the cake - it's about the experience. The anticipation of a new flavor each month, the high-quality ingredients, and the stellar customer service all add up to a club that's truly a treat. While you won't find individual reviews for the Coffee Cake Club itself, Zingerman's overall reputation is fantastic - and it's clear why. Whether you're signing up for yourself or giving it as a gift, this is one cake club we can whole-heartedly recommend.

Sweet Diplomacy

• $89/month
• 5 signature cake-in-a-jar flavors + 1 surprise flavor in each delivery (past selections have included red velvet, brown sugar cake with vanilla frosting, chocolate cake with chocolate frosting and gold sugar sprinkles, and more)
• All cake-in-a-jar selections are vegan, and dairy-/gluten-/nut-free
• Monthly deliveries; pause or cancel anytime
• Can set cake club up as a gift, with a hand-written message on a postcard with the first box
• Extra gifts with every third delivery
• Shipping included in the club price
• In business since 2017

Sweet Diplomacy has been delivering delicious treats since 2017, specializing in gourmet, allergen-friendly desserts. This is a company you can feel good about supporting, with 1% of profits donated to World Central Kitchen's global work as a nod to the bakery's philosophy of "Delicious knows no borders”. If you want a feel-good origin story, be sure to check out the "About Us page” on the Sweet Diplomacy website. And, we'll let the cat out of the bag early and say that this is the only company on our list that makes cakes that are gluten-, dairy-, and nut-free.

6 cakes in a jar each month

Sweet Diplomacy's Cake-in-a-Jar subscription is a delightful addition to this bakery's offerings, perfect for anyone who loves indulging in delicious vegan cake without gluten, dairy, or nuts. For $89 per month (which includes shipping), you'll get 6 flavors in every delivery. Each box comes with 5 signature recipes - like red velvet, brown sugar cake with vanilla frosting, chocolate cake with chocolate frosting and gold sugar sprinkles, and more, often named for US cities- and one surprise flavor, often seasonally-themed.

Thaw and enjoy

Before you think this cake club is going to take up your time in the kitchen because it comes in a jar, let's clear up a common misconception. These cakes are baked, frosted, and then frozen for freshness. When they arrive, all you have to do is either pop them back into the freezer for another time, or let them get to room temperature and enjoy.

Even cake can be eco-friendly

And, as you'd expect from such a "green” company, all of the cake jars come with compostable packaging and biodegradable ice packs. See what we mean about this being a company you can feel super-happy about using for monthly cake deliveries?

Hand-written postcard when you send as a gift

Thinking about sending the Cake-in-a-Jar Monthly Subscription as a gift? Sweet Diplomacy makes it easy. You can include a hand-written message on a postcard with the first box, adding a personal touch to your thoughtful gift.

Just under $90/month

Are you bracing yourself for the price? No need for that. You'll pay $89 for 6 cakes-in-a-jar; while that's a bit on the expensive side for just a half-dozen servings (or a dozen, if you're willing to share each jar), the price includes shipping. And, remember as the only cake club on our list that is suitable for vegetarians or people with dairy, wheat, or nut allergies, Sweet Diplomacy's slightly higher per-serving cost is well worth it.

Super-flexible, and surprise gifts too

There are some extra benefits for subscribers to this cake club. First off, you'll get a limited edition tote bag (perfect for the farmer's market) with your third box, and a surprise every three boxes after that. Plus, you can pause or cancel the subscription anytime: there's no long-term commitment or prepayments required here.

Bakery has tons of fans

While we can't tell you much about the reputation of this cake-in-a-jar subscription (because there are no reviews on the website), Sweet Diplomacy's brick-and-mortar location gets lots of love in places like Yelp. Averaging 4.5 stars out of nearly 250 ratings on that platform, this bakery has plenty of fans. We do want to point out that one of the lower ratings was specifically related to the online ordering and delivery process; that customer said that communication on large shipped orders could be a little better. Still, on the whole, Sweet Diplomacy fans are hugely appreciative of being able to get excellent baked treats that don't have any of the allergens common to cakes, cookies, and everything else this company makes.

Have your cake and eat it too - allergy-free

On the whole, if you count yourself among those who absolutely adore cake but rarely find any that won't trigger an allergic reaction, Sweet Diplomacy's cake club is going to feel like the sun breaking through the clouds on a once rainy, dessert-less day. It might not be exactly what everyone else is going for, but it's pretty risk-free to give it a one-month try and put six flavors to the test. We give Sweet Diplomacy a good spot on our list of cake clubs.

Flying Noodle

• $35.95 to $37.95 per month, depending on club duration (3, 4, 6, or 12 months), paid upfront (can call about month-to-month payment plan)
• Variety of cake types (past selections have included tiramisu, lemon-raspberry, and more)
• Cakes delivered monthly or every other month
• Shipping included in the club price
• Easy gift-giving features
• Fun monthly newsletter
• 100% satisfaction guarantee
• In business since 1995

Since 1995, Flying Noodle has been delivering gourmet gifts to individuals and businesses alike, offering a wide range of monthly clubs featuring everything from wine to cheese and beyond. Their Cake of the Month Club is a sweet addition to their lineup, perfect for anyone who loves indulging in delicious baked treats. While Flying Noodle's website could still use a little more transparency - including customer reviews or third-party ratings - we went straight to the source to get the full scoop on their cake club. What we learned makes this subscription sound like a winner.

More than meets the eye

While Flying Noodle's website doesn't offer much detail about the Cake of the Month Club, their customer service team was more than happy to fill in the gaps. We asked what kinds of cakes subscribers have received in the past, and here are some of the mouth-watering options they shared:

• Cinnamon Walnut Cake
• Tiramisu
• Blueberry Burst
• Lemon-Raspberry
• Coffee Crumble

Affordable and available monthly or every other month

Pricing for this Cake of the Month Club is quite reasonable, especially considering that shipping is included. You can sign up for 3 months for $113.85, 4 seasonal deliveries for $151.80, 6 months for $$221.70, or a full year for $431.40. When you choose your subscription length, you'll also decide whether you want deliveries every month or every other month.

Easy to manage your cake club deliveries

One of the things we love about Flying Noodle's clubs is the monthly email preview. Around the 10th-13th of the month, you'll get a sneak peek at what's coming in your next shipment. If you see a flavor you'd rather pass on, no problem - just contact Flying Noodle by the 15th and ask to skip that delivery. Your subscription will then be extended by a month to make up for the skipped shipment. Keep in mind that your very first shipment will be a surprise unless you call to ask, but after that, you'll always know what's coming next.

Gift-giving features make life easier

Thinking about sending the Cake of the Month Club as a gift? It's easy. Just select the gift option when you're signing up. You can have the gift announcement sent by email or regular mail, or print it out yourself if you want to hand it over in person. Flying Noodle also lets you choose when the announcement goes out, so you can time it perfectly for a birthday or other special occasion.

"Let Them Eat Cake” newsletter gives you the inside scoop

And, whether you're sending this cake club as a gift or treating yourself, it comes with a fun monthly newsletter called "Let Them Eat Cake”. You can read all about each month's cake flavor, get some serving suggestions, and so on.

Pay upfront or call for other arrangements

Flying Noodle seems to prefer that you pay for the whole cake subscription upfront, but the customer service rep suggested that there might be a month-to-month option available. If paying upfront isn't ideal for you, it's worth giving them a call to see if you can arrange a different setup.

Satisfaction guaranteed

Flying Noodle stands behind their Cake Club. If you're not 100% happy with your delivery, just reach out to their customer service team, and they'll work to make it right. That's a pretty sweet deal.

A cake club worth trying

While Flying Noodle could definitely benefit from adding some customer reviews and third-party ratings to give new subscribers more confidence, the combination of delicious cakes, flexible delivery options, and solid customer service makes their Cake of the Month Club a tempting choice. We're happy to move Flying Noodle's Cake Club up in our rankings, thanks to the tasty variety and reasonable pricing. Now, if they could just spruce up that website a little...

Stonehouse Bakery

• $110 for 3 months, $220 for 6 months, $440 for 12 months
• All pound cakes (you choose flavors at checkout)
• Monthly deliveries
• Shipping included in the club price
• Extremely customizable
• Friendly customer service from the owner herself
• In business since 2011

Stonehouse Bakery's Pound Cake Club is a hidden gem for pound cake lovers. Founded by Dorothy Rackley in 2011 after spending a year perfecting recipes at Utah State University, this small, women-owned business has built a loyal following in Logan, Utah, and beyond.

You get to pick all the cake flavors

Unlike many cake clubs where you get whatever the bakery chooses each month, Stonehouse Bakery gives you full control over your subscription. Every cake you receive will be a pound cake - that's their specialty - but you can choose which flavors you'd like to try. You'll find an enticing list of options, including classics like Cinnamon Swirl, Classic Vanilla, and Lemon Blueberry, alongside more creative flavors like Lime Glazed and Pineapple Chunk. If you have a particular flavor in mind that's not on the list, you can even request a custom creation. That's the benefit of working with a small business that's committed to making each order feel personal.

Ordering process requires some extra steps

But, this ordering process is not quite as polished as we usually see with rival cake clubs. To choose the flavors of your cake club, you'll have to go back-and-forth between the main Shop link to see what's available, then type the ones you want into the order notes in the checkout. We imagine that if you were to place your order for any of the 3 clubs (3 months for $110, 6 months for $220, 12 months for $440, all of which include shipping) without specifying the flavors, you'd get a reach-out from Stonehouse Bakery's customer service team.

Pick-and-choose which months you get cake

Unlike many subscription services that send shipments on a fixed schedule, Stonehouse Bakery lets you select the specific months you'd like to receive your cakes. Want to treat your bestie to a cake on her birthday, her anniversary, and Thanksgiving? No problem - just indicate your preferred delivery months when you place your order. However, once again, you'll have to put that into the order notes or reach out to the customer service team to get that done.

More than meets the eye

At first, some signs suggested that the bakery's online presence and customer engagement aren't as sharp as they once were. During our most recent visit, the website felt a bit outdated, social media hadn't been updated since December 2024, and when we called the listed phone number, all we could do was leave a message. All of that changed when the owner of Stonehouse Bakery called us back personally. She thanked us for pointing out that the site copyright was a couple of years old ("I knew we were forgetting something. I called our web developer and he's going to take care of that right away!”), and she confirmed that yes, this cake club is exactly as customizable as it sounds. Dorothy clarified that any flavor is on the table, but the bakery prefers not to ship chocolate pound cake in the summer months - because it's hard to get them to arrive in good condition when it's roasting out nationwide.

Far better than average among cake clubs

We're huge fans of the customizations in this cake club and thought it was delightful to get a reach-out from Dorothy herself. But, even with the ability to specify the flavors of the pound cake, there's not quite as much variety month-to-month for treat-lovers who might like a different kind of cake once in a while (like coffee cake or birthday cake). We're also hoping that, between now and our next update on this cake club, Stonehouse Bakery's socials show more feedback so that we can bump our rating up even more.

Pemberton Farms

• $129.95 for 3 months, $249.95 for 6 months, $369.95 for 9 months, $489.95 for 12 months
• All coffee cakes (flavors include Lemon Burst, Triple Chocolate, Caramel Apple, and more)
• Cakes delivered monthly
• Shipping included in the club price
• "A+” rated by the BBB
• In business since 1930

Pemberton Farms has been a Massachusetts staple since 1930, starting as a family-run produce market and growing into a specialty grocery store, garden center, and gift shop. Among their offerings is their monthly cake club: if you're craving rich, delicious Bundt-style coffee cakes delivered straight to your door, this could be the club for you. But, be prepared for some hiccups along the way.

You might get some repeat flavors

This club keeps it simple: you're getting coffee cake and nothing else. No pound cakes, no birthday-style confections here - just coffee cakes in a variety of flavors. You can see exactly which flavors go out in which months: Lemon Burst in January and July, Triple Chocolate in February and August, Caramel Apple in March and September, and so on. But, you're going to get repeats in any subscription longer than 3 months, so manage your expectations about the variety (or lack thereof) in this cake club.

3 clubs to choose from, you decide when to start deliveries

Pemberton Farms offers four membership lengths to fit your cake cravings: 3 months ($129.95), 6 months ($249.95), 9 months ($369.95), or a full year ($489.95). You can also choose when you'd like the club to start - a nice touch if you're planning it as a gift for a future occasion. Shipping is included in the cost, but deliveries are limited to the continental US.

Company is well-liked overall

This business still maintains an "A+” rating with the Better Business Bureau. Just be aware, if you decide to see for yourself, that you'll find it under the parent company's name (Pemberton Garden Services, Inc.). And there, you'll see exactly what we always love to read: "No complaints to display.” All right! Pemberton Farms has a solid reputation overall, especially for their in-store shopping experience. Most reviews focus on their physical store rather than the cake club, but customers consistently praise the quality of their products and the attentive customer service. Pemberton Farms is really active on their social media channels, making it easy to keep your finger on the pulse of this business, so to speak.

Online ordering system is (still) broken

However, here's where things get frustrating. Even in the months elapsed since our last review, the online ordering system for Pemberton Farms' cake subscription is still unreliable. At the time of this review, adding the Coffee Cake Club to the cart simply didn't work (again). And, the solution now is the same: you'll probably need to place your order over the phone. While it's nice to know you'll probably get a friendly, helpful voice at the other end of the line, it's disappointing that the online store hasn't been fixed after all this time. That could also be why there's only one review for the cake club on the product listing, dating all the way back to 2016.

Great cakes, mediocre website

There's no doubt that Pemberton Farms delivers tasty coffee cakes with a personal touch. But, the broken online ordering process is a major inconvenience - especially when other cake clubs make it so easy to subscribe with just a few clicks. If you're willing to go the extra mile and pick up the phone, their Coffee Cake of the Month Club could still be worth it. But if you're awake in the middle of the night and just remembered you were going to order a cake subscription as a gift, you might want to explore other, more "online” options first.

Jarva Cakes

• $76.50 for 3 months, $150 for 6 months, $288 for 12 months
• 4 different lava cakes each month (previous flavors include chocolate peanut butter cup, birthday cake, dark velvet chocolate, sea salt caramel, and more)
• Deliveries come monthly
• One-time shipping fee of $18 on all subscription durations
• In business since 2013

Jarva Cakes is a charming mother/daughter-owned business from Maine that first won hearts at farmers' markets and craft fairs - and now you can have their delicious single-serving lava cakes delivered straight to your door. And, if you love the idea of a gooey, indulgent dessert without the hassle of baking, the Lava Cake Club might be exactly what you're looking for.

Single-serving cakes that you heat in the microwave

With the Lava Cake Club, you'll receive four surprise flavors every month, all designed to be quick and easy to prepare. Flavors might include sea salt caramel, chocolate peanut butter cup, dark velvet chocolate, and so on. These shelf-stable cakes come in single-serving cups - just add water and pop them in the microwave for a warm, gooey treat in minutes. While you won't be getting a full-sized cake to share, these four personal portions are perfect for a cozy night in or a quick dessert fix. Plus, club members get the bonus of being the first to try any newly-released seasonal flavors.

Pretty spendy per serving

However, you're going to pay more per serving with the Lava Cake Club than with most of Jarva Cakes' rivals on our list. At $76.50 for 3 months, $150 for 6 months, or $288 for 12 months, you're looking at a per-serving price of at least $6. Then, tack on a one-time shipping fee of $18 (regardless of the club length) and that per-portion cost goes up a bit more. Consider placing a one-time à la carte order, then deciding if the portions and flavors are what you had in mind for a cake club subscription.

Website needs some touch-ups

While Jarva Cakes' products are delightful, the ordering experience could be smoother. The website feels a bit outdated (with a copyright that's 12+ years old), and it's clunky to have to click into the store and look for the Lava Cake Club. Once you get there, the information is a bit hard to follow, and even the free shipping code (cakeclub2016) had us wondering if the subscription details were up-to-date. Plus, in contrast to one part of the site that explains that you get 4 different flavors in each box, the more detailed listing says you'll receive one each of Dark Velvet Chocolate and Sea Salt Caramel each month, plus two mystery flavors. These are small sticking points, but ones worth noting if you're expecting a more polished shopping experience.

Reputation is solid

Despite the website hiccups, customers rave about Jarva Cakes overall. Reviews on social media mention delicious flavors, fantastic customer service, and just-right portions. Fortunately, Jarva Cakes' socials are just active enough for us to trust that the 2010s copyright date isn't any indicator that this business is equally behind the times.

Good enough

Jarva Cakes' Lava Cake Club isn't trying to compete with larger cake clubs - and that's part of its charm. The single-serving size also makes this club a good fit for anyone who likes a bit of help with portion control or who doesn't have a houseful of people who can sit down together and eat a cake in one dessert sitting. But, it's a little spendy compared with some of the cake clubs in our review, the website could use a glow-up, and there isn't much recent customer feedback to let us know if the subscription itself is as successful as the farmer's market-fresh cakes-in-a-cup. We still give Jarva Cakes a "good enough” rating: not the best or the worst, but a cake club we'd mostly think about trying if we were looking for a small indulgence that doesn't take up much space or time.

The Black Cake Company

• $29.41 to $34.50 per month, depending on selected club
• 3 clubs to choose from, all Caribbean favorites: Black Cake, Miniature, and Rum Cake
• Cakes delivered every month
• Shipping included in the club price
• In business since 1987

The Black Cake Company, founded in 1987 by Barbadian native Angela Price, specializes in traditional Caribbean black cakes and rum cakes. These rich cakes are deeply tied to Caribbean celebrations and culture. If you're a fan of these distinctive flavors, the Black Cake Company's cake club could be a hit - but if you're not already familiar with black cake, this might not be the right subscription for you.

3 monthly cake clubs to choose from

The company now offers three subscription plans - Black Cake, Miniature, and Rum Cake - all of which deliver a cake every month. (We point that out because, at the time of our previous evaluation, subscriptions had monthly charges but didn't necessarily include a cake every month.) Let's take a look:

• The Black Cake Lover plan includes full-size and miniature black cakes, priced at $32.86/month. It's a nice variety of cake flavors and shapes: for example, in February, you'll get a set of heart-shaped cakes; May's delivery is a 2-lb. black cake; November brings you a 2-lb. brown cake.
• The Miniature Lover club features a variety of smaller cakes like rum cake and Dundee cake. You'll get the original set in both December and January, but all other deliveries will be unique with no repeats. You'll pay $34.50/month for this subscription.
• The Rum Cake plan focuses on different flavors of rum cake, such as banana and coconut. It comes in the same flavors as the Miniature Lover club, but in bigger sizes. This is the most affordable cake club here, at $29.41/month.

Watch out for auto-renewals and early cancellation penalties

Shipping costs are included in the monthly fee, making this a pretty reasonably-priced cake club. But, the catch is that if you cancel early, you'll be charged the full retail value of any cakes you've already received (typically $45 per cake). Also, the subscriptions automatically renew unless you cancel, so you'll want to keep an eye on that if you're not planning to continue.

Rave reviews

From those who've been looking for a "taste of the islands” or for nostalgic cakes that make them feel like they're back home in the Caribbean, the reviews of The Black Cake Company are enthusiastic. One Jamaican born-and-raised customer raved about how authentic (and delicious) her regular black cake and mini hearts were. Another described these cakes as "as authentic as it comes” and said she gives the mini loaves every year as holiday gifts. And, one review we really loved was from a customer who had read Charlene Wilkerson's book "Black Cake” for her book club and ordered treats from The Black Cake Company to share with her fellow readers (who loved it, as you would imagine).

Rich tradition but niche appeal

While the cakes themselves are well-made and rich in tradition, this cake club is pretty niche. Black cake and rum cake are bold, complex flavors that won't appeal to everyone, especially if you're more into classic American-style cakes. Plus, the early cancellation penalty and automatic renewal policy could be a downside for some buyers. If you have a taste for Caribbean treats or want to explore something different, The Black Cake Company delivers a unique experience - but for most people, a more traditional cake club might be a better fit.

Zana Cakes

• Prices range from $115 to $280, depending on cake size and club duration
• Choose small or large pound cakes and 3-month or 6-month duration
• Choose the flavors in checkout (previous selections have included Brandy Carrot, Chocolate Marble, Key Lime, Pecan Island Rum, and more)
• Cakes delivered monthly
• One-time shipping fees of up to $90
• In business since 1998

Since 1998, Zana Cakes has been delivering delectable pound cakes to dessert enthusiasts. Creator and owner Zana Billue started out by baking pound cakes for friends and family after attending The Culinary Institute of America, and launched Zana Cakes as a way of sharing her delectable, memorable desserts with even more people. The company's Cake of the Month Club, introduced in February 2025, is a sweet addition to their lineup, perfect for anyone who loves indulging in homemade-style pound cakes.

Choose your own adventure

When signing up for the Cake of the Month Club here, you have the flexibility to customize your experience. First, choose 6 flavors and specify the order in which you'd like them delivered. Some of the delicious options include Chocolate Marble, Key Lime, Pecan Island Rum, and Brandy Carrot. Next, select the cake size (small or large) and subscription duration (3 or 6 months). After that, you'll indicate if it's a gift by checking a box and entering a message and recipient address. Finally, add any special notes or instructions you'd like Zana Cakes to consider before sending out your treats.

Pretty affordable... until you add in shipping costs

So, what does it cost? These are your options:

• Small pound cakes: $115 for 3 months, $230 for 6 months
• Large pound cakes: $140 for 3 months, $280 for 6 months

That's pretty reasonable and comparable to many of the rival cake clubs we reviewed. But, you'll only see the shipping cost disclosed at checkout; when we looked, that was an additional $90 on a 6-month large-cake club. That may put Zana Cakes' monthly club out of reach for people who are shopping on a tighter budget.

Cake club is so new, there aren't any reviews

Because this cake club is so new, there's not a lot of feedback. We didn't spot any listing for Zana Cakes with the Better Business Bureau, social media reviews are pretty light, and so on - which makes it more challenging to confidently say that you're going to have a great experience if you go for this subscription.

Will easily climb in rank with more feedback

We're hopeful to see amazing things from Zana Cakes in the near future. There's no reason not to think that this small business' subscription option isn't going to become widely popular and bring in tons of glowing reviews from happy customers. However, until then, we've got to put their cake club at the bottom of our list.