The Best Cake Clubs

Tuesday, October 8th

2024 Cake Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs

When it comes to monthly cake subscriptions, there's no beating Amazing Clubs. They're a top-notch company that's all about providing the best possible experience for their customers. Not only do they deliver mouth-watering cakes from all over the country, but they also throw in free shipping and a "They'll Love It!" guarantee to make sure you're completely satisfied with your order. With so many perks, you can't go wrong with Amazing Clubs. So go ahead and treat yourself to a slice of the good life.

Zingerman's

If you're a fan of coffee cakes made with premium ingredients, we highly recommend that you consider the cake club at Zingerman's. Their three memberships are super-easy to give as a gift (or treat yourself), and Zingerman's coffee cakes are their most-gifted item across their inventory of tasty baked goods. Zingerman's also provides an exceptional satisfaction guarantee, with the added assurance that your delivery will arrive on or before the promised date and zero hassles if anything doesn't quite live up to your expectations. Be sure to give Zingerman's a long look when choosing a cake club.

Stonehouse Bakery

Stonehouse Bakery is a small woman-owned business that's big on flavor and customer service. You'll love this cake club if you're all about pound cake that tastes like it just came out of the oven at Grandma's. Stonehouse Bakery also gets high marks for being extremely flexible: choose your flavors from the suggested list (or request something you don't see), decide which months you'd like your treats to arrive, and presto! Put this cake club on your list of top options.

Daisy Cakes

Daisy Cakes offers an exceptional cake delivery service that will make you feel like you're receiving a homemade cake from your very own grandmother. This family-owned business uses tried-and-true recipes passed down through generations to ensure the highest quality and taste for their customers. Not only that, but their commitment to customer service is exceptional, with thoughtful touches that make every order a delight. From the moment you place your order to the first delicious bite, you'll feel the warmth of southern hospitality and charm like never before.

Luscious Little Desserts

Luscious Little Desserts will bring the taste of Grandma's home in the South to your table, with up to twelve different flavors of pound cake that will have you asking for more. You can choose between medium- and large-size plans, depending on how many servings you want, and you'll know exactly what you're getting from month to month. Just "beware” the sweet potato pound cake: we hear that one bite and it's all over because you'll instantly crave more. We love supporting women- and minority-owned small businesses like Luscious Little Desserts, but that's just the icing on the cake for this fantastic cake club.

Goldbelly

Goldbelly is an online food marketplace that connects consumers with a wide variety of iconic and artisanal foods from all across the United States. The platform allows customers to order specialty food items and meals, including regular deliveries of cakes. Although Goldbelly gets lots of five-star reviews from delighted customers, the $75-per-cake cost might keep this cake club off the table for some customers.

Pemberton Farms

Cambridge-based Pemberton Farms has been in business for nearly 100 years, offering an interesting mix of grocery and garden items. They offer a Coffee Cake of the Month Club with at least six different flavors, but you might have a hard time placing your order online. The customer service here is excellent and can help you set up your plan over the phone, but the site glitches and the lack of details about the club itself keep Pemberton Farms from earning our highest recommendation.

Flying Noodle

For nearly three decades, Flying Noodle has been a purveyor of Italian delicacies such as pasta, sauces, and confectioneries. Their monthly cake club subscription is priced affordably and comes with 8-12 servings of various types of cakes. However, despite the gift-giving possibilities here, the lack of information on the desserts and scarce feedback from other members of the club make it difficult to gauge what to expect. As a result, Flying Noodle falls short compared to most of its competitors.

Jarva Cakes

Jarva Cakes' Lava Cake Club is about as different as you can get from the other subscriptions we evaluated: your deliveries here will include four different flavors of lava cake, packaged in a single serving size and ready to be mixed with water and microwaved. This could be a nice treat for anyone who doesn't have a ton of fridge space or likes an element of portion control with their desserts. That's not necessarily what most people are looking for in a cake club, but don't hesitate to try this small Maine company if a cake-in-a-cup is perfect for you.

The Black Cake Company

Get the sweet flavors of the Caribbean with The Black Cake Company - if you know, you know - when it comes to memories of special occasions with this beloved dessert. There are four plans to choose from, all with monthly payments, but don't miss the little detail that your cake club might not have monthly deliveries. There's so much feeling that goes into the rum cakes, Dundee cakes, and black cakes you can get here - but this club's appeal probably won't extend to customers who prefer a more American-style cake each month.