Thursday, December 5th
2024 Cake Club Reviews
Pemberton Farms
- Variety of coffee cakes included
- Priced from $124.95 for a 3-month subscription up to $469.95 for a 12-month subscription
- Shipping is included at no extra cost
- Memberships can last 3, 6, 9, or 12 months
In 1930, the Pemberton Farms Marketplace originated as a family-owned retail store for fruits and vegetables in Massachusetts. As of today, the business has transformed into a specialty grocery store, garden center, and provider of high-quality gifts. One such gift is Pemberton Farms' Coffee Cake of the Month Club.
Just coffee cake
What will you get with this cake club? Pemberton Farms is noticeably light on details. Here's what you can know for sure: all of the cakes you'll get with this membership are, as you'd guess from the name, coffee cakes. That means no pound cake, no birthday-type cake, just coffee cakes typically in a Bundt style.
Several cake club lengths to choose from
Memberships here can last for 3, 6, 9, or 12 months. When you set up your membership, you'll choose which month you'd like the deliveries to start. The Coffee Cake of the Month Club will cost you $124.95 for a 3-month plan, $239.95 for a 6-month plan, $349.95 for a 9-month plan, and $469.95 for a full year. Shipping is included in those prices, though deliveries can only be made within the continental US.
More information, please?
...and that's about all you'll know in advance. Which flavors can you expect? How many servings are in each coffee cake? Is it a set schedule (Pumpkin Coffee Cake every November, Peach Coffee Cake every June) or random? Are they seasonal? These are all terrific questions that many cake clubs are happy to answer, but Pemberton Farms seems to prefer a little mystery in theirs.
Online ordering was broken
The mystery deepened when we went to add the cake club to our online cart: it just wouldn't work. We reached out to Pemberton Farms' customer service and were pleased to get a prompt response. Unfortunately there was no way to actually start a cake membership online at the time of this review, but the customer support rep was more than happy to take our order over the phone.
Typically coffee cakes
He also explained that typically they just choose coffee cakes from among the flavors listed in the general store (Lemon Burst, Applicious Walnut, Blueberry Blizzard, Triple Chocolate, Cinnamon Walnut, and Caramel Apple Harvest) with no repeats, but we're not sure how that's possible with a 12-month membership and only six flavors in the lineup. But, if you decide to go with Pemberton Farms and the online order process still isn't working, you can reach out via phone and they'll actually let you specify which flavor you'd like to start with.
Good reputation
The majority of reviews for Pemberton Farms are centered around their physical grocery store rather than their shippable products, such as their Coffee Cake Club. Customers generally give high praise to this retailer, whether shopping in-store or receiving deliveries. They often say that they appreciate the family-owned atmosphere that pervades everything sold there.
We wish there were more customer reviews
We would like to see more reviews specifically focused on the cake club. There was just one on the club's page on the Pemberton Farms website (dated all the way back in 2016) - but we're not overly concerned about the quality of the cakes you'll get here or the customer service aspect of the membership. The company enjoys an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau and is very active on social media. You should have no trouble reaching a representative if you have questions about the club or have issues with any deliveries.
Good cake but difficult-to-use website
While Pemberton Farms has a lot of room for improvement in their online shopping experience, we give them points for having responsive customer service and for a solid reputation as a small business. You're probably going to have to jump through a few extra hoops to set up your cake club here, so we suggest looking at some of our higher-ranked options and circle back to Pemberton Farms if you don't find what you need there.
More Cake Club Reviews
Which Cake Club is the Best?
Cake clubs offer an enticing opportunity for people to indulge in their favorite treat every month. Whether you want to treat yourself or give a cake club membership as a gift, you can depend on something delicious to arrive at your doorstep every month. While some people may be hesitant to receive cake deliveries, many cake club companies have addressed these concerns by ensuring quality control during the logistics of shipping and by offering a variety of flavors and experiences.
Compared to mass-produced cake boxes and supermarket bakery aisles, cake clubs provide a wider range of quality and selection. Many cake clubs even operate with particular values and ethics that appeal not only to customers' taste buds but also to their character. With cakes delivered from all over the country, you could taste a whole new world of flavors.
Cake Club FAQ
Continued from above...
Cake is a beloved dessert that has been around for centuries. With its simple ingredients, including flour, sugar, eggs, and butter, it has a rich history dating back to Ancient Greek and Roman times, and its namesake comes from Viking origin. Cake has become an art form, with the decorating process considered a valuable and beautiful artistic expression. Many cultures have embraced cake as a symbol of their most revered customs, from weddings to birthdays.
Cake comes in a variety of styles, shapes, sizes, and occasions, and it's enjoyed by many all around the world. The art and science of cake baking and decorating has captured the fascination of many individuals, with shows like The Great British Bake-Off showcasing the skill and creativity that goes into making a perfect cake. With high demand for this treat, cake clubs have become a popular option for dessert lovers everywhere to enjoy sweet decadence.
Cake clubs come in different styles, flexibility, focus, and price points. Therefore, it's good to think about which cake club features are most important to you. Some clubs may focus on providing seasonal flavors, while others may offer a wider variety of year-round favorites. Here are a few ways you can narrow down the tasty options available in today's cake clubs:
- Cost. What will you spend for each delivery? Is shipping included?
- Duration. How long would you like your cake subscription to last? Are you looking for something that gives you a year's worth of cakes or just something during the entertaining holidays (such as Thanksgiving, Christmas, Hanukkah, and New Year's)?
- Selection. What will you get in each delivery? Is there a lot of variety from one month to the next? Can you opt out if there's something scheduled that you'd rather not try?
- Customer satisfaction. Does the cake club have a refund policy if something arrives in less-than-perfect condition? What if you just don't like the taste? Check out what other customers have said about the overall experience with any cake club you're considering.
- Gift-giving options. If you're looking to send a cake club as a sweet surprise for a special occasion, choose a cake club that makes it easy to include a gift message and set up the membership for your lucky recipient. Some cake clubs go the extra mile to make it fun, with newsletters that describe each cake's origin and maybe even some interesting facts about this popular dessert.
Indulging in delicious cakes is one of life's greatest pleasures, but with so many cake clubs out there, it can be tough to decide which one to join. The experts here at Top Consumer Reviews have done the hard work and reviewed and ranked the best Cake Clubs available today. From decadent chocolate cakes to fruity delights, we've got you covered. Our reviews can help you find the perfect Cake Club membership to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings!
Compare Cake Clubs
Select any 2 Cake Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Cake Club News
Related Cake Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Cake Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
