Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Stonehouse Bakery Review

Thursday, December 5th

2024 Cake Club Reviews

Stonehouse Bakery Review 4 Star Rating

Stonehouse Bakery

4 Star Rating
  • Variety of pound cakes included
  • Memberships can last 3, 6, or 12 months
  • Priced at $110 for 3 months, $220 for 6 months, $440 for 12 months
  • Shipping is included at no extra cost
  • Can specify desired flavors and preferred shipping dates

If you're a big fan of pound cake and love supporting small women-owned businesses, you'll want to check out Stonehouse Bakery's cake club. The company was started by Dorothy Rackley back in 2011 after spending a year testing pound cake recipes in the kitchens at Utah State University. Since then, Dorothy's bakery has developed quite the local following in Logan - and across the nation via delivery.

You choose the pound cake flavors you want

Every cake you receive from Stonehouse Bakery will be pound cake - because that's the specialty here. But, unlike some cake clubs that don't tell you what you'll be getting or let you make any requests, Stonehouse Bakery puts all of the power in your hands. They offer a list of suggested flavors that you can indicate in your order notes - or you can customize your very own subscription. That's what you get when you work with a small business like this one.

Recommended cake flavors

Here's the list of recommended flavors you can start with, to get an idea of the tasty possibilities in this cake club:

  • Cinnamon Swirl
  • Milk Chocolate Truffle
  • Orange Glazed
  • Classic Vanilla
  • Lemon Glazed
  • Lemon Blueberry
  • Pineapple Chunk
  • Lime Glazed
  • Apple Pie
  • Pumpkin Chocolate Chunk
  • Gingerbread Spice
  • Dark Chocolate Truffle

You can choose which months to get cake

Stonehouse Bakery offers memberships lasting three, six, or twelve months, priced at $110, $220, and $440, respectively. FedEx 2-Day shipping is included at no extra cost. But, another way this cake club offers unmatched flexibility is by letting you decide which months you'd like your treats to arrive. So, for example, if you're trying to make Mom feel special on Mother's Day, her birthday, and Christmas, you can choose a three-month subscription with deliveries in those three months.

Best Cake Clubs

Personalized greeting

Your delivery will also include a personalized greeting as specified during checkout. Just don't forget to make all of those requests (cake flavors, delivery months, gift note) in the little box that says "Order notes (optional)” on the order page before you click "Place order”.

Your sweet tooth will be happy here

As you might expect with a small business like Stonehouse Bakery, there isn't a pile of customer feedback to consider on this cake club - but what you'll find is unfailingly positive. Even when traveling a few days in the mail, people say that these pound cakes taste like they're fresh from the oven. You can also check out the bakery's posts on social media and actually see some of those cakes... fresh from the oven. We love how one customer likened it to eating a tomato from the grocery store and then comparing it with one straight from the garden: absolutely no contest which one tastes better.

Perfect for pound cake fans

Stonehouse Bakery is one of our newest favorites among cake clubs. True, you'll have to choose a different company if you want desserts that are more like a birthday cake or coffee cake, but this one should be a top pick if the three Fs - freshness, flavor, flexibility - are what matter most to you. Whether for yourself or for someone you love, Stonehouse Bakery's Pound Cake of the Month Club will be a delight.

Which Cake Club is the Best?

Cake clubs offer an enticing opportunity for people to indulge in their favorite treat every month. Whether you want to treat yourself or give a cake club membership as a gift, you can depend on something delicious to arrive at your doorstep every month. While some people may be hesitant to receive cake deliveries, many cake club companies have addressed these concerns by ensuring quality control during the logistics of shipping and by offering a variety of flavors and experiences.

Compared to mass-produced cake boxes and supermarket bakery aisles, cake clubs provide a wider range of quality and selection. Many cake clubs even operate with particular values and ethics that appeal not only to customers' taste buds but also to their character. With cakes delivered from all over the country, you could taste a whole new world of flavors.

The Best Cake Clubs Compare Cake Clubs Compare Cake Club Reviews What are the best Cake Clubs Best Cake Club Reviews

Cake Club FAQ

Not from a supermarket chain assembly line, that's for sure! Cake clubs go out of their way to bring you the most mouth-watering goodies, often from small bakeries around the nation.
The real question is, how often would you like to get a fresh cake on your doorstep? Select among monthly, bi-monthly and quarterly cake clubs, with plans lasting anywhere from three months to a year.
You'll pay anywhere from $20 to $70 per delivery, depending on the cake club provider you choose. Considering what you'd spend at a local grocery store to get a cake, or how much it costs to buy a cake from a specialty bakery, those prices are right on the money.
Sometimes. You'll want to read the terms of each cake club membership to see if delivery fees are part of your monthly price: over the course of a year-long plan, paying $5 to $10 for each shipment will really add up. Fortunately, some cake clubs include your shipping fees in their monthly pricing.
Almost always. No reputable business wants to get negative customer feedback for making deliveries that don't arrive in good condition or that taste bad. You should be able to get a refund or replacement if anything isn't quite right with your cake.
Of course! While there are always new cake clubs popping up, some subscription plans have been around for ten years or more. It's helpful to check out customer reviews of both new and established businesses, to ensure that the cake club you select will be a winner.
You'll likely get a newsletter with your cake club shipment each month. They usually have fun articles about cake, details about where your cake was made, and maybe even recommended pairings with fruit or beverages. A few providers of cake club memberships let you add on items like stuffed animals or flowers for an extra fee.
Yes! Wouldn't you love it if someone surprised YOU with a cake subscription? Cake clubs are a wonderfully unique gift-giving option, and you can usually include a personalized message with your delivery. You may even be able to have a gift announcement sent to your lucky recipient via email on
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Cake is a beloved dessert that has been around for centuries. With its simple ingredients, including flour, sugar, eggs, and butter, it has a rich history dating back to Ancient Greek and Roman times, and its namesake comes from Viking origin. Cake has become an art form, with the decorating process considered a valuable and beautiful artistic expression. Many cultures have embraced cake as a symbol of their most revered customs, from weddings to birthdays.

Cake comes in a variety of styles, shapes, sizes, and occasions, and it's enjoyed by many all around the world. The art and science of cake baking and decorating has captured the fascination of many individuals, with shows like The Great British Bake-Off showcasing the skill and creativity that goes into making a perfect cake. With high demand for this treat, cake clubs have become a popular option for dessert lovers everywhere to enjoy sweet decadence.

Cake clubs come in different styles, flexibility, focus, and price points. Therefore, it's good to think about which cake club features are most important to you. Some clubs may focus on providing seasonal flavors, while others may offer a wider variety of year-round favorites. Here are a few ways you can narrow down the tasty options available in today's cake clubs:

  • Cost. What will you spend for each delivery? Is shipping included?
  • Duration. How long would you like your cake subscription to last? Are you looking for something that gives you a year's worth of cakes or just something during the entertaining holidays (such as Thanksgiving, Christmas, Hanukkah, and New Year's)?
  • Selection. What will you get in each delivery? Is there a lot of variety from one month to the next? Can you opt out if there's something scheduled that you'd rather not try?
  • Customer satisfaction. Does the cake club have a refund policy if something arrives in less-than-perfect condition? What if you just don't like the taste? Check out what other customers have said about the overall experience with any cake club you're considering.
  • Gift-giving options. If you're looking to send a cake club as a sweet surprise for a special occasion, choose a cake club that makes it easy to include a gift message and set up the membership for your lucky recipient. Some cake clubs go the extra mile to make it fun, with newsletters that describe each cake's origin and maybe even some interesting facts about this popular dessert.

Indulging in delicious cakes is one of life's greatest pleasures, but with so many cake clubs out there, it can be tough to decide which one to join. The experts here at Top Consumer Reviews have done the hard work and reviewed and ranked the best Cake Clubs available today. From decadent chocolate cakes to fruity delights, we've got you covered. Our reviews can help you find the perfect Cake Club membership to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings!

Compare Cake Clubs

Select any 2 Cake Clubs to compare them head to head

best-cake-clubs
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Zingerman's
  • Stonehouse Bakery
  • Daisy Cakes
  • Luscious Little Desserts
  • Goldbelly
  • Pemberton Farms
  • Flying Noodle
  • Jarva Cakes
  • The Black Cake Company
Amazing Clubs vs Zingerman's Amazing Clubs vs Stonehouse Bakery Amazing Clubs vs Daisy Cakes Amazing Clubs vs Luscious Little Desserts Amazing Clubs vs Goldbelly Amazing Clubs vs Pemberton Farms Amazing Clubs vs Flying Noodle Amazing Clubs vs Jarva Cakes Amazing Clubs vs The Black Cake Company Zingerman's vs Stonehouse Bakery Zingerman's vs Daisy Cakes Zingerman's vs Luscious Little Desserts Zingerman's vs Goldbelly Zingerman's vs Pemberton Farms Zingerman's vs Flying Noodle Zingerman's vs Jarva Cakes Zingerman's vs The Black Cake Company Stonehouse Bakery vs Daisy Cakes Stonehouse Bakery vs Luscious Little Desserts Stonehouse Bakery vs Goldbelly Stonehouse Bakery vs Pemberton Farms Stonehouse Bakery vs Flying Noodle Stonehouse Bakery vs Jarva Cakes Stonehouse Bakery vs The Black Cake Company Daisy Cakes vs Luscious Little Desserts Daisy Cakes vs Goldbelly Daisy Cakes vs Pemberton Farms Daisy Cakes vs Flying Noodle Daisy Cakes vs Jarva Cakes Daisy Cakes vs The Black Cake Company Luscious Little Desserts vs Goldbelly Luscious Little Desserts vs Pemberton Farms Luscious Little Desserts vs Flying Noodle Luscious Little Desserts vs Jarva Cakes Luscious Little Desserts vs The Black Cake Company Goldbelly vs Pemberton Farms Goldbelly vs Flying Noodle Goldbelly vs Jarva Cakes Goldbelly vs The Black Cake Company Pemberton Farms vs Flying Noodle Pemberton Farms vs Jarva Cakes Pemberton Farms vs The Black Cake Company Flying Noodle vs Jarva Cakes Flying Noodle vs The Black Cake Company Jarva Cakes vs The Black Cake Company
Compare the Best Cake Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Cake Clubs
The Best Reviews of Cake Clubs