Cake Delivery Reviews

Who's better?

Bake Me a Wish! vs Milk Bar

We've analyzed the best Cake Delivery to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Cake Delivery Reviews

Here you can see how Bake Me a Wish! and Milk Bar match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Cake Delivery in 2026.

Winner

Bake Me a Wish!

  • About 60 cakes to choose from
  • Options include traditional layer cakes, cheesecake, coffee cake, sheet cakes, and more
  • Gluten-free options available

Bake Me a Wish! has been a go-to for cake delivery since 2004, and it's easy to see why. With nearly 60 options, including classic layer cakes, cheesecakes, coffee cakes, and even gluten-free treats, there's something for everyone. Prices range from $40 to $130, and overnight, weekend delivery is just $23. You can even personalize some cakes or add fun extras like cookies, candles, or a teddy bear for that extra-special touch. Customers rave about the delicious flavors, reliable service, and on-time delivery, which is backed by a freshness guarantee. With an "A-" rating from the BBB and glowing reviews across the board, Bake Me a Wish! is a sweet choice for any celebration. It's no surprise they earned our 5-star rating - once you try them, you'll see why they're such a favorite.

Milk Bar

  • 6 cakes to choose from
  • Options include layer cakes in several flavors
  • Gluten-free options available

Milk Bar is one of the more trendy online cake vendors on our list, with plenty of likes and shares on social media. They've been around since 2008 and are best known for their cookies, but you've also got 6 different cakes to consider - even gluten-free ones. Expect to pay nearly $100 for a smaller cake and $140 for a larger one, by the time all is said and done with shipping fees. Worth it? Customers would say no: many of them described their cakes as "too crumbly", and over 30% of this store's ratings are just 1 or 2 stars. Milk Bar only gets a lower rating from us too.

If a milestone birthday's coming up and the thought of another grocery-store cake makes you groan, or you're hoping to surprise your college student with a finals-week pick-me-up, there's good news - incredible cakes can be shipped straight to your door or theirs. Many bakeries deliver nationwide and pack their creations to arrive fresh and photo-ready, with options that suit different tastes and diets. It's an easy way to turn any day into a celebration.

Ordering cakes online has changed how we treat ourselves to this classic dessert. No more chasing Facebook threads for recommendations - you can go straight to the pros and order exactly what you're craving. From a towering chocolate layer cake to a vegan carrot cake crowned with silky cream cheese frosting, it's never been simpler to indulge. You can compare bakeries, browse photos and reviews, customize flavors, and schedule doorstep delivery in just a few clicks.

Few traditions are as sweet - or as universal - as cake, a symbol of celebration and indulgence across cultures. Long before buttercream and fondant, early versions were little more than honey-sweetened breads in ancient Egypt. By medieval Europe, bakers packed dense loaves with spices, and over time the arrival of refined sugar and leavening turned them into the lighter, fluffier cakes we know today. Now, cakes anchor birthdays and weddings worldwide, with styles that range from humble tea loaves to elaborate showpieces.

Once a simple party centerpiece, cake has evolved into everything from fondant-covered, Pinterest-ready birthday confections to the multi-tiered showstoppers of modern weddings. These days it's less dessert than design - edible art that reflects trends like naked finishes, glossy drip details, and flavors as adventurous as matcha, churro, and ube. Social media and baking shows have only raised the bar, pushing bakers to experiment with new techniques and textures. Cakes still anchor our biggest celebrations, but they've also slipped into everyday life - because sometimes you don't need an occasion to treat yourself.

Which online cake shop should you trust to deliver on its promises? That's a great question, because the last thing you want is to get your hopes up and have your treat fall flat (or not arrive at all). Here are some criteria we'd recommend as you decide where to order your cake:

To help you find the right bakery to order a delicious cake for delivery, the sweet-toothed experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked some of today's most popular options. With so many creative bakeries offering nationwide delivery, it's easier than ever to make any day a little sweeter. Just remember to order in advance when possible - good cake is worth the wait!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Cake Delivery FAQ

Why should I buy a cake online?
Buying a cake online gives you access to a wide variety of flavors, designs, and specialty options that may not be available locally. Whether you're sending a cake across the country or need a custom design for an event at home, online bakeries offer convenience, flexibility, and nationwide delivery.
Will the cake stay fresh during shipping?
Yes, most online bakeries use specialized packaging to keep cakes fresh during transit. This can include insulated boxes, ice packs, or even dry ice for more delicate cakes like cheesecakes. They also package the cake with enough padding to make sure that your lovely treat doesn't arrive squished!
Can I order a cake for same-day or next-day delivery?
Some online bakeries offer same-day or next-day delivery, especially in major metro areas. However, most cakes you'll see online will require more lead time, so it's best to plan ahead when possible.
How do I customize a cake when ordering online?
A few online cake vendors allow you to personalize your order with custom messages, but don't expect anything overly fancy or bespoke. And, be aware that customizations may require extra processing time.
What if I have dietary restrictions?
Many online bakeries cater to dietary needs, offering options like gluten-free or vegan cakes. Be sure to read product descriptions carefully and contact customer service if you have specific allergy concerns or ingredient questions.
What happens if the cake arrives damaged?
Reputable cake shops have solid satisfaction guarantees, including refunds or replacements if the cake arrives damaged. Be sure to take photos immediately upon receiving the order and contact the bakery's support team to resolve any issues quickly.
How much does it cost to have a cake delivered?
Delivery costs vary based on factors like location, shipping speed, and whether special handling (refrigeration) is required. Expect to pay anywhere from $10 to $60 in shipping fees.
Can I send a cake as a gift?
Absolutely! Online cake delivery is a fantastic way to celebrate from afar. Most bakeries let you include a personalized message with your order, and some let you tack on extras like balloons or chocolate-covered strawberries - making it a thoughtful and delicious present for any occasion.

Compare Any 2 Products

Bake Me a Wish!
David's Cookies
Caroline's Cakes
Harry & David
We Take the Cake
Edible Arrangements
Send a Cake
Magnolia Bakery
Milk Bar
Williams Sonoma
vs
Bake Me a Wish! vs David's CookiesBake Me a Wish! vs Caroline's CakesBake Me a Wish! vs Harry & DavidBake Me a Wish! vs We Take the CakeBake Me a Wish! vs Edible ArrangementsBake Me a Wish! vs Send a CakeBake Me a Wish! vs Magnolia BakeryBake Me a Wish! vs Milk BarBake Me a Wish! vs Williams SonomaDavid's Cookies vs Caroline's CakesDavid's Cookies vs Harry & DavidDavid's Cookies vs We Take the CakeDavid's Cookies vs Edible ArrangementsDavid's Cookies vs Send a CakeDavid's Cookies vs Magnolia BakeryDavid's Cookies vs Milk BarDavid's Cookies vs Williams SonomaCaroline's Cakes vs Harry & DavidCaroline's Cakes vs We Take the CakeCaroline's Cakes vs Edible ArrangementsCaroline's Cakes vs Send a CakeCaroline's Cakes vs Magnolia BakeryCaroline's Cakes vs Milk BarCaroline's Cakes vs Williams SonomaHarry & David vs We Take the CakeHarry & David vs Edible ArrangementsHarry & David vs Send a CakeHarry & David vs Magnolia BakeryHarry & David vs Milk BarHarry & David vs Williams SonomaWe Take the Cake vs Edible ArrangementsWe Take the Cake vs Send a CakeWe Take the Cake vs Magnolia BakeryWe Take the Cake vs Milk BarWe Take the Cake vs Williams SonomaEdible Arrangements vs Send a CakeEdible Arrangements vs Magnolia BakeryEdible Arrangements vs Milk BarEdible Arrangements vs Williams SonomaSend a Cake vs Magnolia BakerySend a Cake vs Milk BarSend a Cake vs Williams SonomaMagnolia Bakery vs Milk BarMagnolia Bakery vs Williams SonomaMilk Bar vs Williams Sonoma Williams Sonoma vs Milk BarWilliams Sonoma vs Magnolia BakeryWilliams Sonoma vs Send a CakeWilliams Sonoma vs Edible ArrangementsWilliams Sonoma vs We Take the CakeWilliams Sonoma vs Harry & DavidWilliams Sonoma vs Caroline's CakesWilliams Sonoma vs David's CookiesWilliams Sonoma vs Bake Me a Wish!Milk Bar vs Magnolia BakeryMilk Bar vs Send a CakeMilk Bar vs Edible ArrangementsMilk Bar vs We Take the CakeMilk Bar vs Harry & DavidMilk Bar vs Caroline's CakesMilk Bar vs David's CookiesMilk Bar vs Bake Me a Wish!Magnolia Bakery vs Send a CakeMagnolia Bakery vs Edible ArrangementsMagnolia Bakery vs We Take the CakeMagnolia Bakery vs Harry & DavidMagnolia Bakery vs Caroline's CakesMagnolia Bakery vs David's CookiesMagnolia Bakery vs Bake Me a Wish!Send a Cake vs Edible ArrangementsSend a Cake vs We Take the CakeSend a Cake vs Harry & DavidSend a Cake vs Caroline's CakesSend a Cake vs David's CookiesSend a Cake vs Bake Me a Wish!Edible Arrangements vs We Take the CakeEdible Arrangements vs Harry & DavidEdible Arrangements vs Caroline's CakesEdible Arrangements vs David's CookiesEdible Arrangements vs Bake Me a Wish!We Take the Cake vs Harry & DavidWe Take the Cake vs Caroline's CakesWe Take the Cake vs David's CookiesWe Take the Cake vs Bake Me a Wish!Harry & David vs Caroline's CakesHarry & David vs David's CookiesHarry & David vs Bake Me a Wish!Caroline's Cakes vs David's CookiesCaroline's Cakes vs Bake Me a Wish!David's Cookies vs Bake Me a Wish!
See the Best Cake Delivery in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Qfc #0850 Bky | 22833 Bothell

Qfc #0850 Bky | 22833 Bothell Everett Hwy, Bothell, WA, 98021 | ...

Visit Qfc #0850 Bky in Bothell, WA. Find the perfect cake to celebrate any event, occasion or birthday

Wed, 22 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Cakes.com | Personalized Onlin

Cakes.com | Personalized Online Cake Ordering with Local Bakeries

Personalize your perfect decorated cake to celebrate every event and occasion at Cakes.com. Order and pick up from a local bakery, supermarket or ice cream shop and enjoy.

Fri, 06 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

20617 Bothell Everett Hwy, Bot

20617 Bothell Everett Hwy, Bothell, WA, 98012 - Cakes.com

Visit Mayuri Foods in Bothell, WA. Find the perfect cake to celebrate any event, occasion or birthday

Sun, 01 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Cakes.com | Personalized Onlin

Cakes.com | Personalized Online Cake Ordering

This is a 3rd party website, used by Albertsons Companies, to help design and process your custom cake orders. For details about data collection and rights, please refer to DecoPac's Privacy Policy.

Thu, 29 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Order Cakes Online and Pick-up

Order Cakes Online and Pick-up from Safeway #458 Bky | 16304 Bothell ...

Order a personalized cake and pick-up from Safeway #458 Bky at 16304 Bothell Hwy, Mill Creek, WA. Find the perfect cake to celebrate any event or occasion at Cakes.com

Mon, 02 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Find a Bakery Near Me | Cakes.

Find a Bakery Near Me | Cakes.com

Search for a bakery near you and order a cake from local bakeries, supermarkets and ice cream shops. Order a cake online or phone call through Cakes.com.

Fri, 06 Feb 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.