The Best Cake Delivery

Wednesday, January 15th

2025 Cake Delivery Reviews

Bake Me a Wish!

Bake Me a Wish! has been a go-to for cake delivery since 2004, and it's easy to see why. With nearly 60 options, including classic layer cakes, cheesecakes, coffee cakes, and even gluten-free treats, there's something for everyone. Prices range from $40 to $130, and overnight, weekend delivery is just $23. You can even personalize some cakes or add fun extras like cookies, candles, or a teddy bear for that extra-special touch. Customers rave about the delicious flavors, reliable service, and on-time delivery, which is backed by a freshness guarantee. With an "A-” rating from the BBB and glowing reviews across the board, Bake Me a Wish! is a sweet choice for any celebration. It's no surprise they earned our 5-star rating - once you try them, you'll see why they're such a favorite.

David's Cookies

David's Cookies has been a staple of sweet treats since 1979, earning rave reviews for its cakes, cookies, and more, all certified kosher by the Orthodox Union and baked in an SQF-certified facility. Their selection includes 10 cakes, from classics like carrot and red velvet to colorful options like rainbow layers and a deep-dish cookie "cake”, though there are no gluten-free or vegan choices. Cakes serve about 14 people and are priced affordably at $59.95 to $67.95. Standard delivery is just $6.95, with expedited shipping available for $39.95. Backed by an "A” BBB rating and thousands of 5-star reviews, David's Cookies is a trustworthy option for delicious cake delivery, though its limited variety keeps it just shy of top-tier status.

Caroline's Cakes

When it comes to monthly cake subscriptions, there's no beating Amazing Clubs. They're a top-notch company that's all about providing the best possible experience for their customers. Not only do they deliver mouth-watering cakes from all over the country, but they also throw in free shipping and a "They'll Love It!" guarantee to make sure you're completely satisfied with your order. With so many perks, you can't go wrong with Amazing Clubs. So go ahead and treat yourself to a slice of the good life.

Harry & David

Harry & David is known for gift-giving, in business for over 100 years. They offer a wide selection of gourmet cakes, with about 50 choices that range from classic layer cakes to fun ice cream cakes. Prices range from $24.99 to $105+, and shipping fees are generally around $19.99. Most cakes get great reviews for their taste, though there aren't any gluten-free options available. While many of the cakes are sourced from other brands, the company has earned a solid reputation over the years with an "A+” BBB rating. That said, customer reviews can be a bit hit-or-miss, especially when it comes to timely arrival. Overall, while Harry & David's products are delicious, you might want to check other options first for more reliable delivery.

We Take the Cake

We Take the Cake, based in South Florida since 1997, is a well-known mail-order bakery featured on the Food Network and in publications like InStyle and The Miami Herald. They offer about 20 made-from-scratch cakes, including gluten-free and vegan options, with prices ranging from $45.95 to $93.95 - and most come with free shipping. While their partnership with Goldbelly initially raised some concerns, We Take the Cake assures customers that all baking and fulfillment is handled directly from their Ft. Lauderdale location. Delivery can be fast, but issues like damaged cakes and mixed customer service reviews make this a cautious option for nationwide cake delivery - not the best on our list, but a reasonable backup if other bakeries don't meet your needs.

Edible Arrangements

Edible Arrangements offers a unique twist on cake delivery, featuring over 20 mini-sized cakes paired with extras like fruit bouquets and balloons. Prices range from $34.99 to $187.98, with options for free next-day delivery, weekend delivery without surcharges, and same-day delivery for just $9.99. You can also pick up your order in-store for free and add upgrades like flowers or personalized cards at checkout. While the company's delivery timeframe is one of the fastest available, its reputation varies widely depending on the location fulfilling your order. Edible Arrangements is a good option for last-minute cake delivery if your local storefront has solid reviews.

Send a Cake

Send a Cake may have come across your social media feed as a fun way to jump scare someone with a tasty treat: their surprise boxes can "explode” with confetti, music, even little butterflies, revealing a mini cake. This cake retailer also has full-size cakes on the menu, but they seem to hide the fact that those bigger sweets are actually fulfilled by another cake company on our list. We have mixed feelings about Send a Cake, largely because of that lack of transparency, but over 100,000 people have given this cake shop a top-shelf rating. Circle back if you don't find what you're looking for somewhere else, but for now we can only give Send a Cake a lower rating of our own.

Magnolia Bakery

Magnolia Bakery, founded in 1996 in NYC's West Village, is famous for its cakes, cookies, pies, and iconic banana pudding. While their cakes are available for nationwide delivery, the selection is limited to four flavors - confetti, chocolate, carrot, and red velvet - with prices starting at $54 plus $35 for priority overnight shipping. Customization options are a nice touch, but some are restricted for shipped cakes. Unfortunately, their cake delivery reputation is mixed, with complaints about taste and shipping reliability, and their case-by-case satisfaction policy doesn't inspire our confidence. Magnolia Bakery shines in-store but falls short for dependable cake delivery.

Milk Bar

Milk Bar is one of the more trendy online cake vendors on our list, with plenty of likes and shares on social media. They've been around since 2008 and are best known for their cookies, but you've also got 6 different cakes to consider - even gluten-free ones. Expect to pay nearly $100 for a smaller cake and $140 for a larger one, by the time all is said and done with shipping fees. Worth it? Customers would say no: many of them described their cakes as "too crumbly”, and over 30% of this store's ratings are just 1 or 2 stars. Milk Bar only gets a lower rating from us too.

Williams Sonoma

Williams Sonoma has a cake selection that's beautifully bougie - as you'd expect from a retailer known for gourmet food and top-shelf home goods. There are around 50 options to choose from, and Williams Sonoma's holiday/seasonal cakes are particularly on point. Unfortunately, though, their customer service isn't. The biggest complaint? Nothing arrives on time (if at all), which is why this company gets thousands of rants and an "F” from the BBB. We wanted to love the cakes here, but Williams Sonoma just doesn't deliver (literally).