Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Sunday, February 16th
Milk Bar is the creation of Christina Tosi, an award-winning pastry chef profiled on the Netflix documentary series "Chef's Table”. Both her in-person Milk Bar locations and her online store are a representation of her professional training and her personal love of the home baking vibe, ranging from her signature "Compost Cookie” to Milk Bar's layer cakes with unfrosted sides. In business since 2008, this cake company delivers nationwide.
Cakes and shipping are costly
When you first visit the Milk Bar website, you might get a special offer. We found a pop-up discount of $15 off $80+ when we gave them our email address. You'll want that discount, because the cakes here are priced from $62 to $140. And, since shipping will cost you $15 if your order isn't at least $100+ (or $30 to $65 if you want to send the cake express), it's a good idea to grab any savings you can.
Limited flavors, but gluten-free available
You won't have to scroll through dozens of cakes to decide which one you'd like to send: Milk Bar only offers six or so to choose from. Good news, though: among those are some gluten-free choices if you've got someone with sensitivities. At the time of our most recent visit to the Milk Bar online store, the cake selection included Birthday Cake flavor (in both regular and gluten-free), Quadruple Chocolate, and a seasonal Pumpkin Coffee-Cake cake. That wasn't really the flavor panorama we like to see from an online cake company, if we're being honest.
Too many complaints
We're sorry to report that Milk Bar has earned an "F” rating from the Better Business Bureau for failing to respond to 6 of the complaints left there. That's not a ton, but we were also unhappy to see that 30% of the 200 reviews on Google were only 1- and 2-star ratings. People complained about customer service not responding to phone calls during regular business hours (we too were sent to voicemail), cakes that didn't arrive on the day of the celebration even after paying $36 for two-day delivery, and treats that arrived dry and crumbly and seemed overpriced.
Cakes aren't worth the money
Even on the reviews posted to the Milk Bar site itself, sentiment is lukewarm at best. That 6” Quadruple Chocolate Cake we mentioned? It only had a 3.2-star average across 23 reviews; again, people complained that the cake crumbled too much when it was sliced, and one person described it as "not remarkable at all”.
Mediocre for cake delivery
Given that Milk Bar only has 6 cakes, with maybe 3-4 flavors to choose from, and they're all pretty spendy, we're not super excited about ordering here. It's not the worst cake store on the market, but it's not even close to the best.
Do you have a milestone birthday coming up and you just can't bear the thought of another supermarket cake? Or you want to surprise your college student with a finals week celebration treat? Believe it or not, you can get some of the most amazing cakes shipped right to your doorstep (or theirs).
Ordering cakes online can revolutionize how you enjoy this timeless dessert. Who says you need to scour local recommendations on Facebook to get a treat crafted by an expert? Whether you're eyeing a decadent chocolate layer cake or a vegan carrot cake topped with silky cream cheese frosting, the internet makes it easier than ever to indulge.
Cakes are one of life's sweetest traditions, symbolizing celebration and indulgence in cultures worldwide. Going as far back as history can tell, cakes started out as simple honey-sweetened breads in ancient Egypt. In medieval Europe, cakes were dense and spiced, evolving over time with the addition of refined sugar and leavening agents to become lighter, fluffier treats.
From cutesy Pinterest-worthy birthday cakes covered in fondant to the multi-tiered masterpieces of modern weddings, cakes have come a long way since then. Today, they're not just desserts but edible works of art, reflecting trends like naked cakes, drip designs, and inventive flavors such as matcha, churro, and ube. Cakes are synonymous with special occasions, but they've also found their way into everyday moments - because sometimes, you don't need a reason to treat yourself.
Which online cake shop should you trust to deliver on its promises? That's a great question, because the last thing you want is to get your hopes up and have your treat fall flat (or not arrive at all). Here are some criteria we'd recommend as you decide where to order your cake:
To help you find the right bakery to order a delicious cake for delivery, the sweet-toothed experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked some of today's most popular options. With so many creative bakeries offering nationwide delivery, it's easier than ever to make any day a little sweeter. Just remember to order in advance when possible - good cake is worth the wait!
Select any 2 Cake Delivery to compare them head to head