Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Sunday, February 16th
We Take the Cake is a mail order bakery based in South Florida, in business since 1997. They've been featured on three Food Network shows (including Unwrapped, Road Tasted, and Challenge), and mentioned in The Miami Herald, CNN Money, Entrepreneur Magazine, and InStyle. This is one of the only cake delivery options on our list that will ship a hand-decorated, hand-mixed cake anywhere in the country.
20 flavors to choose from, including gluten-free and vegan options
So, what kinds of cakes do you have to choose from here? First off, we're happy to say that if you need a gluten-free or vegan treat, We Take the Cake has you covered. Just click on the tab for Gluten-Free and you'll find two chocolate layer cakes and a golden/vanilla layer cake, each priced at $89.95. Next, in the "regular” section (labeled "Cakes & Cupcakes”), you'll be tempted by Oprah's Favorite (yes, THAT Oprah) Key Lime Bundt Cake and several other bundt flavors for $45.95, a multitude of 4-layer cakes including Fresh Strawberry and Peanut Butter Cup for $89.95, and possibly some seasonal favorites like Christmas Ornament for $93.95. The only one that wasn't available during our visit was the Luscious Lemon 4-Layer Cake: it was sold out.
High-quality ingredients
It's very reassuring reading the ingredient lists on We Take the Cake, too. Their cakes are always made from scratch, using real butter, fresh eggs, whole milk, and so on. In other words, there won't be anything you can't pronounce. Most cakes serve about 8-10 people.
Goldbelly is just the order-taker
You may notice this bakery's affiliation with Goldbelly, a company that specializes in delivering local, gourmet goods nationwide. We weren't particularly excited to see that relationship, because we've found not-so-great things said about Goldbelly in other categories we've evaluated. So, we were very glad to get a prompt response via email from We Take the Cake: the rep explained that Goldbelly simply is the order processor for their cake orders, but they're baked and fulfilled in-house in their Ft. Lauderdale location. Whew!
Free shipping in the continental US
Another bit of good news? We Take the Cake ships just about everything for free, though you'll have a surcharge if you're sending a treat to Hawaii or Alaska. That makes these cakes very competitively-priced, given that many rivals charge an extra $10 to $60 for delivery.
Pay attention to the delivery calendar
While you can check possible delivery dates right on each cake's product page, you'll have to wait until the checkout to confirm the one you prefer. That's because orders with multiple products may not have the same availability, and you'll be given the corresponding open dates when you finalize your cart. On the triple chocolate cake that caught our eye, our recipient could get it in just two days, or on Tuesdays through Fridays in future weeks. You'll see a surcharge of $20 on Saturday deliveries, just FYI.
Gift message via email only
Also during checkout, you can add a gift message, including your recipient's email. No pricing info will be displayed on their message, and they'll only reach out if there's a delivery issue.
Customer sentiment is hot and cold
We Take the Cake has an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau, with no complaints filed there. Fantastic! But, we're a bit surprised not to see anything negative on the BBB site, because this bakery's reputation in other places (like Yelp, TripAdvisor, even its own Facebook page) has taken a few hits. We saw several photos of cakes with smashed sides, reviews describing delivered cakes that didn't taste so great, and some overall complaints about how the customer service team handled the issue (offering another delivery or a store credit instead of a refund). On the other hand, there were also quite a few compliments for these cakes, praising the taste, the on-time and damage-free delivery, and the experience of working with the bakery. It's a bit of a mixed bag for We Take the Cake, reputation-wise.
Just average among cake delivery options
All told, this bakery earns a middle-of-the-road rating for its cake delivery service. The flavor selection isn't the broadest or the narrowest we've seen out there, the customer service isn't the best or the worst, you get the idea. We Take the Cake could be an option if you don't find the dessert you're looking for from a higher-ranked cake shop on our list, but this isn't our first choice for having a treat delivered and being reasonably sure it's going to arrive in perfect condition.
Do you have a milestone birthday coming up and you just can't bear the thought of another supermarket cake? Or you want to surprise your college student with a finals week celebration treat? Believe it or not, you can get some of the most amazing cakes shipped right to your doorstep (or theirs).
Ordering cakes online can revolutionize how you enjoy this timeless dessert. Who says you need to scour local recommendations on Facebook to get a treat crafted by an expert? Whether you're eyeing a decadent chocolate layer cake or a vegan carrot cake topped with silky cream cheese frosting, the internet makes it easier than ever to indulge.
Cakes are one of life's sweetest traditions, symbolizing celebration and indulgence in cultures worldwide. Going as far back as history can tell, cakes started out as simple honey-sweetened breads in ancient Egypt. In medieval Europe, cakes were dense and spiced, evolving over time with the addition of refined sugar and leavening agents to become lighter, fluffier treats.
From cutesy Pinterest-worthy birthday cakes covered in fondant to the multi-tiered masterpieces of modern weddings, cakes have come a long way since then. Today, they're not just desserts but edible works of art, reflecting trends like naked cakes, drip designs, and inventive flavors such as matcha, churro, and ube. Cakes are synonymous with special occasions, but they've also found their way into everyday moments - because sometimes, you don't need a reason to treat yourself.
Which online cake shop should you trust to deliver on its promises? That's a great question, because the last thing you want is to get your hopes up and have your treat fall flat (or not arrive at all). Here are some criteria we'd recommend as you decide where to order your cake:
To help you find the right bakery to order a delicious cake for delivery, the sweet-toothed experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked some of today's most popular options. With so many creative bakeries offering nationwide delivery, it's easier than ever to make any day a little sweeter. Just remember to order in advance when possible - good cake is worth the wait!
Select any 2 Cake Delivery to compare them head to head