Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Old Time Candy vs Treatsbox

Friday, May 14th

2021 Candy Club Reviews

Old Time Candy Review 5 Star Rating

Old Time Candy

5 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting at $19.99, plus $9.95 shipping
  • Candy Club Selection: 3 clubs to choose from, large (120+ pieces) or small (65+ pieces)
  • Duration: Auto-renews until you cancel
  • Frequency: From once a month to once a year
  • Shipping: $9.95 per delivery
TopConsumerReviews.com Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Old Time Candy has been delighting customers since 2000. They focus on sweet favorites from the 1950s to now, so that everyone can enjoy the candy they loved as a child. With three candy club membership options, a fantastic satisfaction guarantee, and personalized gift-giving options, Old Time Candy is the obvious choice for your monthly package of sweets.

Treatsbox Review 4 Star Rating

Treatsbox

4 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting at $20/month, plus shipping fees up to $25
  • Candy Club Selection: An assortment of lollipops, hard candies, gum, salty snacks and chocolate, with options for Regular (10-12 treats), Epic (20-24 treats) or Colossal (32-36 treats) sizes
  • Duration: Auto-renews every month until you cancel
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: Up to $25 per delivery

Canada's contribution to the candy club marketplace is Treatsbox. Your monthly deliveries will include a fun assortment of traditional candies, plus salty snacks and unique items you may have never tried before. The only decision you have to make is how big you want each box to be! Shipping fees are fairly expensive if you live in the US, so keep an eye out for any discounts on subscription boxes posted at the top of the Treatsbox site. While the pricing stops Treatsbox from earning a first-place finish, their top-notch customer service team and exciting variety of goodies make this candy club worth a look.

Where Can You Find the Best Candy Club?

If you've got a sweet tooth that needs to be satisfied on the regular, subscribing to a candy club is a fun way to do it. What could be more entertaining and tasty than getting a fresh assortment of candies delivered to your home or office every month?

How do candy clubs work? It's easy: you choose the type of candy you want and how often you'd like to get deliveries, and voila! Options range from old-fashioned favorites like Bit O Honey and Blow Pops to global novelties from Japan and the UK.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Subscription options vary by provider: some allow you to choose a timeframe in advance - say, 3 months or a year - and your membership will stop at the end of that time. Others automatically renew your membership from month to month, until you cancel your candy club. You will also find a few candy subscriptions that let you space out your deliveries to once every three months or longer (if you need to pace yourself!).

Candy clubs are also a terrific choice for gift-giving. Many companies let you enter a gift message for your lucky recipient, to personalize the sweet surprise they're receiving. Wouldn't you rather get candy in the mail every month, instead of a sweater you won't wear or a gift card to a store you don't like? Of course you would - and so would the people on your list!

No two candy clubs are alike, so how can you decide which one should get your business? Here are several factors to consider:

  • Selection. Does the candy club offer the types of treats that you or your gift recipient like best? How much is included in each shipment? Some clubs send just 10 treats per delivery, while others have dozens - or hundreds! - of candies in each box. Are you looking for traditional sweets or novelties from around the world?
  • Price. What will you spend each month for the candy club? Be sure to factor in shipping costs: a few providers include it at no extra charge, while others have fees that almost double the price of the membership.
  • Reputation. What do other candy fans say about the club? Does the company have a positive track record for on-time deliveries and helpful customer service? Has the Better Business Bureau given the club a good rating?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best candy clubs available today. We're sure this information will help you pick the right monthly subscription to satisfy your sweet tooth!

The Best Reviews of Candy Clubs