Tuesday, January 21st
2025 Candy Club Reviews
Old Time Candy
- Candy Club Selection: 4 clubs to choose from, all with "retro” candies
- Cost: From $19.99 to $26.59/month, depending on the selected club
- Duration: Until you cancel
- Frequency: Every 1, 2, 3, 6, 9, or 12 months
- Shipping: $9.99 + $0.98 shipping insurance for each delivery
Old Time Candy Company is on a mission to bring back childhood candy memories, offering a nostalgic journey through time with treats from the 50s to the 90s. Owners Karen and Donny Ray have been curating delightful assortments for over 20 years, drawing from 100+ different manufacturers of "candy you ate as a kid."
Take a walk down one decade's memory lane
There are four candy club options here, and all of them get rave reviews from Old Time Candy's customers. First, the Decade Candy Gift Box offers a specific trip down memory lane by allowing you to choose candies from a specific decade from the 50s to the 90s. Priced at $26.59 and $37.99 for 2- and 4-lb. assortments, respectively, this club is ideal for commemorating milestone birthdays or anniversaries. You can even add a "Remember When” booklet for just $6.99, featuring the specific year you'd like to highlight. This box comes with up to 65 pieces of candy (in the 4-lb size), including at least 20 full-size treats.
Get treats from all the years
Next, the Retro Candy Gift Box, priced at $19.99, features a fun assortment of 65+ treats spanning the last 70 years, including favorites like Mallo Cups and Root Beer Barrels.
Sweets in a refillable jar
Third on the list, the Retro Candy Assortment provides 175 pieces of candy for $27.54, packaged in a reusable plastic tub. If you just want the refill on subsequent deliveries, it'll only cost $21.84 (and you can just put it right in the plastic tub you got the first time). Some of the candies in this assortment include Cow Tales Minis, Caramel Creams, Now & Laters, and many more.
Every month is a surprise
And fourth, a new addition since our last evaluation of Old Time Candy is the generically-named Candy Box Subscription. For $24.69 per box, every month is a surprise. Only described as "different decades to crazy flavors”, each box has a new theme with everyone's favorite childhood candies. To be frank, this sounds like a catch-all for us (along the lines of "here's what we bought too much of, so in the box it goes”), but that doesn't mean it's not worth trying. And, if you like surprises, it might be the perfect option here.
Shipping and insurance are extra
Bear in mind that shipping fees aren't included with those prices. You'll pay $9.99 per box, plus an extra $0.98 for "shipping insurance”. Don't skip that under-$1 add-on, because it's what protects you if your package gets lost or your candies are a little melted upon unboxing.
Makes gift-giving a treat
Gift-giving with Old Time Candy is a breeze, with the option to include a hand-written gift card during checkout (and even some suggested messages if you're not sure what to say). And, whether you're buying for yourself or someone else, there's plenty of flexibility in the deliveries too: you can have your candy come every month, every other month, or just a few times a year. Finally, you can select a delayed delivery date for your order, usually about three months into the future (you could place your order in September for a gift that arrives in December).
Reputation is on point
The company's reputation speaks volumes, with an "A+" rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau. Across almost 500 customer reviews beyond the BBB, Old Time Candy has an impressive average of 4.8 stars. Customers praise the store for excellent customer service and delicious candies, especially for those who want a taste that brings them back to their childhood. The Decade Candy Gift Box is the show-stopper here, with almost 200 5-star reviews. Time and again (no pun intended), people say that this box delivers a sweet way to relive old memories and make new ones.
Still our #1 choice among candy clubs
Old Time Candy is our top choice among candy club subscriptions. With affordable memberships, flexible options, and an array of classic favorites, Old Time Candy is sure to satisfy candy lovers of all ages, making it a delightful pick for your candy club membership.
More Candy Club Reviews
The 10 Best Candy Clubs
Where Can You Find the Best Candy Club?
Do you, or someone you know, have a craving for sugary treats that just won't quit? If you're looking for a delightful way to satisfy your sweet tooth on a regular basis, you might want to consider joining a candy club - or giving one as a gift. These delectable subscriptions offer a wide variety of candies, from classic favorites to exotic treasures sourced from around the globe.
Imagine the joy of receiving a fresh assortment of candies at your doorstep every month or having them sent to your office. It's a treat everyone would eagerly anticipate. But with so many candy clubs to choose from, how do you find the best one for your sweet cravings?
Candy Club FAQ
Continued from above...
The process is simple: you get to select the type of candy you love and how frequently you want to receive your candy deliveries. Each candy club has its own unique subscription options. Some allow you to pre-select a fixed timeframe, like 3 months or a year, after which your membership ends. Others offer automatic renewals on a monthly basis until you decide to cancel your subscription. There are also candy clubs that give you the flexibility to space out your deliveries, perhaps receiving them once every three months or even less often, in case you want to pace yourself.
Candy clubs also make an excellent choice for gift-giving. Many of these clubs offer you the opportunity to include a personalized gift message for your lucky recipient, making the sweet surprise even more special. Who wouldn't prefer a monthly candy delivery over an outfit that doesn't quite fit or a gift card to a store they may never visit? The answer is simple - candy clubs make for thoughtful and delightful presents, sure to bring smiles to the faces of those you care about.
With numerous candy clubs available, it can be challenging to determine which one will suit your preferences. Here are some factors to consider when making your decision:
- Candy type and quantity. What types of candies does the candy club offer? Make sure they have your favorite treats: traditional, retro, international, or something else? Also consider the quantity included in each shipment. Some clubs provide just a handful of candies, while others deliver dozens or even hundreds.
- Cost. How much will you pay each month for your candy club subscription? Keep in mind that some providers include shipping in the membership cost, while others may have additional fees that can significantly increase what you spend.
- Reputation. Research the candy club's reputation, like feedback from other candy enthusiasts, to ensure you are making the right choice. Check if the company has a history of on-time deliveries and responsive customer service. Finally, look for ratings and reviews from organizations like the Better Business Bureau to gauge the club's overall reliability.
If you're struggling to decide which candy club to choose, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best ones available today. So why wait? Explore the world of candy clubs and indulge in a monthly experience that brings delight straight to your doorstep. Whether it's for yourself or a loved one, a candy club subscription is sure to add a little extra sweetness to your life!
Compare Candy Clubs
Select any 2 Candy Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Candy Club News
Related Candy Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Candy Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
