Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Old Time Candy Review

Sunday, October 2nd

2022 Candy Club Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Old Time Candy Review 5 Star Rating

Old Time Candy

5 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting at $19.99, plus $9.95 shipping
  • Candy Club Selection: 3 clubs to choose from, large (120+ pieces) or small (65+ pieces)
  • Duration: Auto-renews until you cancel
  • Frequency: From once a month to once a year
  • Shipping: $9.95 per delivery
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Old Time Candy Company is on a mission "to provide childhood candy memories". Owners Karen and Donny Ray started selling some of their favorite treats from the 50s and 60s in 2000, and for more than 20 years they've been delighting customers with candy that takes them down memory lane. Their inventory comes from 80+ different manufacturers of "candy you ate as a kid".

Three Plans Available

There are three candy clubs to choose from with Old Time Candy:

  • Decade Candy Gift Box: for a trip down a specific memory lane, you can choose a decade from the 50s to the 90s. Options include a 2- or 4-lb. assortment of candies, priced at $27.99 and $39.99, respectively. As an added touch, you can choose a "Remember When" booklet for a specific year. Many customers buy this candy club to honor a milestone birthday or anniversary.
  • Retro Candy Gift Box: for $19.99 (65+ pieces) or $29.99 (120+ pieces), you'll get a fun assortment of treats from the last 70 years. Every month's selection will be different, but some of the commonly-included candies are Charleston Chews Minis, Pop Rocks, Wax Bottles, Atomic Fireballs, Razzles, Root Beer Barrels, and Lik-M-Aid Fun Dip.
  • Retro Candy Assortment: offering the same basic selection as the Retro Candy Gift Box but packaged in a reusable plastic tub (like you might find in a candy store display), this club gives you 175 pieces of candy for $23.12.

Most Flexible Candy Club

This provider offers the most flexibility of any candy club we evaluated. You can set up deliveries to happen every month, every two months, or quarterly; some clubs even have options for shipments just once or twice a year. You can also change the requested delivery date right from your online account. There are no long-term commitments with Old Time Candy either: cancel at any time.

Discounts Only For A La Carte Purchases

You might even be able to score a discount. While we browsed the Old Time Candy site, we got a pop-up offering us 10% off our first order with a coupon code. We liked the fact that we didn't have to sign up for an email list in order to get the savings. However, coupon codes aren't able to be used on subscription boxes, only on regular purchases. You can save that coupon for going back and buying more of the candies that wind up being your favorites!

Best Candy Clubs

Free Rewards Program

Another way to save at Old Time Candy is with their rewards program. Earn "Candy Coins" with every purchase, plus get 200 coins just for signing up and another 1000 every year on your birthday. You can redeem points for a discount on future orders, with $1 off for every 100 coins used.

Hand-written Gift Announcements

Old Time Candy makes it easy to give their candy club as a gift. Look for the option to include a gift card during checkout. We think it's a particularly nice touch that the gift enclosure cards are "hand-written by actual people": no generic printed message on a packing slip here!

Stellar Satisfaction Guarantee

The company offers a fantastic satisfaction guarantee. If you're not happy with your candy club for any reason, you can get a refund of your purchase price - including the shipping fees.

Customers Love This Candy Club

But, chances are good that you'll never need to ask for a refund. Old Time Candy has a great reputation, including an "A+" rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau. Out of more than 2000 shopper reviews, an impressive 96% give the store a rating of 4 or 5 stars, citing excellent customer service and delicious candy as their reason for giving Old Time Candy such high marks. Many of the reviews were from repeat customers, who return to the online store time and again to get all of their sweet favorites.

First-place Winner Among Candy Clubs

Old Time Candy is our favorite pick for candy club subscriptions, with classic favorites that are sure to delight candy lovers of all ages. Their memberships are affordable and flexible, and the company's gift-giving options make it an easy choice for that hard-to-please person on your list. You won't be disappointed if you choose Old Time Candy for your candy club membership.

Where Can You Find the Best Candy Club?

If you've got a sweet tooth that needs to be satisfied on the regular, subscribing to a candy club is a fun way to do it. What could be more entertaining and tasty than getting a fresh assortment of candies delivered to your home or office every month?

How do candy clubs work? It's easy: you choose the type of candy you want and how often you'd like to get deliveries, and voila! Options range from old-fashioned favorites like Bit O Honey and Blow Pops to global novelties from Japan and the UK.

The Best Candy Clubs Compare Candy Clubs Compare Candy Club Reviews What are the best Candy Clubs Best Candy Club Reviews

Candy Club FAQ

Great question! Most chocolate based candies, like candy bars can be frozen. The shelf life for frozen candy, if stored in an airtight container or bag, can last anywhere from 12 to 18 months.
There are many kinds of memberships such as the Fun Box, Party Box, Signature Sweets, or a chocolate-only collection. Each package will contain anywhere from 3 to 6 full size products. Candy types can range from sweet and sour to spicy to even indulgent chocolates.
The shelf life of hard sweets can be stored at room temperature or dry, cool conditions up to one year. Whereas the shelf life of hard candy can vary. Typically candy bars and concession candy can last up to one month. Bubblegum, candy corn, dark chocolate, Jordan almonds, and licorice have a shelf life of 2 months. Milk or white chocolates tend to last 3 months and jellybeans last up to 6 months. Longer shelf-life candy that lasts up to 12 months include caramel, gummy candy, hard candy, lollipops, and novelty candy. The longest shelf life is 24 months and is typically limited to mints. In general, the temperature the candy is stored at is important to the overall quality of the sweet.
Great question! Nut-free means that the candy has been made without a trace of nuts. In fact, Nut-free candies are generally created and packaged in a nut-free facility. If you still have questions, feel free to reach out to the company's customer service.
When looking at the package, unless stated, there should be the letter K or U with a circle around it. There are more kosher symbols, but those two are the most popular. If you still are uncertain, feel free to contact customer service or visit oukosher.org and search the product name and brand to see if it is on the approved kosher food list.
Dark chocolate, also known as semi-sweet, has 4 main differences from milk chocolate. Dark chocolate contains no more than 12% milk fat, less cocoa butter, contains at least 15% chocolate liquor, and has a more intense chocolate flavor. The only other difference is that milk chocolate uses fresh whole milk rather than milk fat.
It all depends on the number of guests you have, but a good rule of thumb is to estimate that each guest will eat about 4 oz. of candy. The formula to calculate this is the total number of guests multiplied by (four ounces) = total. For conversion to pounds, 4 ounces is equal to 1/4 of a pound. So, if you had 200 guests, you would have 50 pounds of candy.
Of course, this whitish powder is called chocolate bloom and is not white mold. Chocolate bloom does not affect the quality of the product and occurs when there is a temperature change. Keep in mind, if the chocolate is older than the recommended shelf life and contains white stuff on it, we recommend you discard the product and purchase fresh and delicious new candy.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Subscription options vary by provider: some allow you to choose a timeframe in advance - say, 3 months or a year - and your membership will stop at the end of that time. Others automatically renew your membership from month to month, until you cancel your candy club. You will also find a few candy subscriptions that let you space out your deliveries to once every three months or longer (if you need to pace yourself!).

Candy clubs are also a terrific choice for gift-giving. Many companies let you enter a gift message for your lucky recipient, to personalize the sweet surprise they're receiving. Wouldn't you rather get candy in the mail every month, instead of a sweater you won't wear or a gift card to a store you don't like? Of course you would - and so would the people on your list!

No two candy clubs are alike, so how can you decide which one should get your business? Here are several factors to consider:

  • Selection. Does the candy club offer the types of treats that you or your gift recipient like best? How much is included in each shipment? Some clubs send just 10 treats per delivery, while others have dozens - or hundreds! - of candies in each box. Are you looking for traditional sweets or novelties from around the world?
  • Price. What will you spend each month for the candy club? Be sure to factor in shipping costs: a few providers include it at no extra charge, while others have fees that almost double the price of the membership.
  • Reputation. What do other candy fans say about the club? Does the company have a positive track record for on-time deliveries and helpful customer service? Has the Better Business Bureau given the club a good rating?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best candy clubs available today. We're sure this information will help you pick the right monthly subscription to satisfy your sweet tooth!

The Best Reviews of Candy Clubs