Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

AutoTrader vs Sell My Car

Tuesday, January 26th

2021 Car Selling Site Reviews

AutoTrader Review 3.5 Star Rating

AutoTrader

3.5 Star Rating

Autotrader offers two ways to sell your used car: getting an Instant Cash Offer based on a calculated Kelley Blue Book value, or creating a listing to sell it yourself on the Autotrader site. This business does have an "A+" rating with the Better Business Bureau, but customer reviews across the board indicate that, at least for the "sell your car" portion of their services, Autotrader may be an expensive way to generate fewer potential customers than some seller found acceptable.

Sell My Car Review 1 Star Rating

Sell My Car

1 Star Rating

Sell My Car has a no-frills website offering to list your used car by posting it in the Auto section of Google Base. Because of numerous typos and grammatical mistakes on the website, the lack of any way to contact the business other than a contact form, and numerous complaints from people who were scammed on the buying end of using Sell My Car, we cannot recommend that you trust this service for selling your used vehicle.

The 6 Best Car Selling Sites

Who Has the Best Car Selling Site?

When the time comes to sell your car - maybe you're downsizing, or you'd like to get a better price for it than what you were offered by your local dealership - what's the best way to find a buyer? In the past, most people had to rely on ads in the newspaper or even posting a sign in the window of the vehicle itself. Of course, these methods limited sellers to a small number of prospective buyers.

In today's market, the obvious choice for selling a vehicle is by using the Internet. It's not uncommon for buyers to travel long distances, even to other states, if it means getting the vehicle with the features and price they're looking for. In order to reach the widest number of people, choosing the right online service is essential to selling your used car quickly and for a fair price.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

How do you know which website will provide the best experience for you as a seller? Consider these four criteria:

  • Visibility. How many cars are typically listed on the site? Will your vehicle be lost among many others, or are there so few cars listed that the site doesn't get enough visitors? Is your listing shown only to dealerships, or will private buyers also be able to find your vehicle?
  • Cost. Does the site charge you a fee for using their service? If so, is it a flat fee or a percentage of the final sales price of the vehicle?
  • Reputability. Does the service have a solid reputation as a business? Are previous sellers happy with the results of using the site?
  • Extra Services. Can the site connect you with resources for offering inspections for prospective buyers, tools to estimate your car's value, or any other helpful features?

Whichever site you choose, you'll want to do everything possible to make your car appealing to its future owner. Make sure to clean the exterior and interior: vacuum the floor mats and between the seats, remove any bumper stickers if it can be done without damaging the paint, and consider adding an air freshener to give the car a pleasant smell. Also, as with any sales transaction that begins online, take the appropriate safety precautions to protect yourself; some people choose to meet in a well-lit parking lot at a busy supermarket or even outside of a local police station, to give both buyer and seller some extra peace of mind.

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best sites for selling cars available today. We hope these reviews help you find the right buyer and sell your car right away!

The Best Reviews of Car Selling Sites