AutoTrader Review: Car Selling Sites

We've analyzed the best Car Selling Sites to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Car Selling Site Reviews

What's the Best Way to Sell Your Car?  When many of us consider selling a car, we often think first of the traditional methods. In the past, inputting your car's details on a site like Kelley Blue Book for a sale value and heading to a dealership (and hoping they match the KBB price) was the standard way to handle car sales. But with the growth of online sites for buying and selling cars, the traditional methods of selling a car are a thing of the past.

3.5

GOOD

5

Good

  • $49 to list your car for sale
  • KBB Instant Cash Offer
  • Include up to 30 photos at no extra charge
  • No-cost ad renewals every 30 days for up to a year
  • Free vehicle history report included in your ad
  • Payment via Stripe in 1-2 business days
  • "A+" rated and accredited by the BBB

GOOD

3.5

On the AutoTrader website

Whether you're in the market for selling or buying a new set of wheels, Autotrader is a great place to start your search. This popular automotive website brings together vehicles from dealers and private sellers, making it a great platform to sell directly to dealers or create private listings. Every month, millions of people visit Autotrader to research, buy, or sell a car, providing a huge potential customer base if you're looking to get a fair price for your vehicle.

Get instant offers or list privately

Autotrader offers two ways to sell your car: you can get an instant offer from a participating dealer or list your car privately on Autotrader's platform starting at a $49 fee. The instant quote route is the fastest way to sell your car - simply enter your license plate or VIN, provide details about your vehicle's condition, and receive cash or trade-in credit offers from a nearby dealer. These offers are valid for seven days, after which you'll need to bring your car to the dealer for an inspection to verify the information provided during the quote process. You then have one day to redeem the cash offer.

Dealership's prices are guaranteed

If you're worried about getting a quote and then dealers changing the price later, don't be. Any dealership that participates in this program is required to honor the instant cash offer unless they find that you misrepresented your vehicle's condition or drove more than 50 miles after the inspection. This way, you won't face any surprises when trying to sell your car to a dealership through Autotrader.

Lots of listing tools + KBB

While Autotrader is well-known for its private listing service, it does come with a fee of $49. However, you can renew your ad at no charge every 30 days for up to a year if it takes that long to sell your car. Your ad will be listed on both Autotrader and Kelley Blue Book, exposing it to millions of active shoppers. You'll have the ability to include up to 30 photos and receive a free vehicle history report. You'll also have access to the KBB Private Party Value tool, which helps you determine a fair price for your vehicle. When potential buyers contact you through the contact form on your ad, Autotrader will forward their information to the email address you specify, keeping your identity anonymous until you choose to respond.

Best Car Selling Sites

Autotrader manages secure payments through any method

When you sell your car through Autotrader's Private Seller Exchange, you can rest assured that the transaction will be secure and hassle-free. The company charges a small fee of 0.99% (as little as $99) of the final sale price. The platform offers financing options to buyers. It also handles secure payment through the Stripe platform and title transfer, accepting various payment methods such as wire transfer, ACH electronic payment transfer, debit card, or credit card. The company verifies funds instantly for cash payments via ACH or CC, while wire transfers take 2-48 hours to verify. Once a buyer is approved, the company may request additional information to complete the sale, which typically takes 1-2 business days. Regardless of the buyer's payment method, you'll receive your payment promptly.

Reviewers are happier with instant offers

Although Autotrader has an impressive "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and accreditation, we found mixed reviews outside of the BBB. Many people who have sold cars through Autotrader reported receiving an overwhelming number of spam and scam emails after posting their listings, making it difficult to find legitimate buyers. This has led many people to describe their experience as a waste of time and money. The positive reviews usually revolve around the speed and fairness of instant cash offers from dealerships, so that may be a more recommended route.

A competitive option for instant cash

We appreciate that Autotrader offers both options - instant quotes and private listings - giving you control over how you want to sell your car. The company has been around for a long time and has a good reputation with the BBB. However, we do have concerns about the self-listing part of the site due to negative user experiences. We recommend exercising caution when using this feature and considering the instant cash offer as an alternative.

On the AutoTrader website

Continued from above...

What's the Best Way to Sell Your Car?

When many of us consider selling a car, we often think first of the traditional methods. In the past, inputting your car's details on a site like Kelley Blue Book for a sale value and heading to a dealership (and hoping they match the KBB price) was the standard way to handle car sales. But with the growth of online sites for buying and selling cars, the traditional methods of selling a car are a thing of the past.

Now there is no waiting with a "for sale" sign on your windshield and waiting for interested buyers to come knocking on your door. Today, most people sell their cars totally online, and it's often a quick and easy process. With the numerous tools available, you can set a competitive asking price and attract potential buyers from all over.

When deciding how to sell your car, you have two main options on car sales websites: accepting a cash offer from a dealership, either online or with a physical location near you, or creating a listing to sell it privately. Each method has its advantages and disadvantages. Dealership offers can be convenient because they eliminate the need to screen potential buyers, schedule multiple viewings, and verify payment methods. Some online services will even pick up the vehicle from your specified address at no extra cost.

However, this convenience may come at a cost. Not all services that offer cash for cars will accept vehicles in any condition, and you may be able to get more money for your car if you sell it privately. This is because private buyers are often trying to avoid the markup that dealerships put on used cars before selling them to customers. As a result, you may be able to start with a higher asking price when selling privately. Many people choose to do both: shop around for the best cash offer while also creating a private listing to test the market.

Regardless of which method you choose, there are certain documents you'll need to have ready. In most cases, you'll need to provide current and valid registration papers, any available key fobs and manuals, a valid state-issued photo ID, and have any owners named on the title present at the time of sale. The specific requirements may vary depending on the state where you live and the terms of the car-selling service you choose.

With so many sites to help you sell your car online, it can be hard to know where to start. To help you make an informed decision about which one is best for you, consider the following criteria:

To help you simplify selling your car, TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked the most popular sites available online today. We hope this helps you sell your car quickly and get the most money possible out of your sale. Happy listing!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Car Selling Site FAQ

Can I really sell my car online?
Yes! The days of taking out an ad in the classifieds are gone - most private sellers sell their cars by listing them online. The process is simple and makes it possible for thousands of prospective buyers to see your vehicle.
How much does it cost to sell my car online?
Nothing! There are several sites that allow you to list your car for free. Of course, most of these sites offer upgraded listings for a fee, if you'd like to put up more photos, have your ad up for longer than 30 days, or include your vehicle's CARFAX report.
How can I get the most money for my vehicle?
Start by determining a fair market value for your car: most people use Kelley Blue Book to do that. Then, make sure your vehicle is reasonably clean - you don't have to spend a lot of money for a professional detailing, but at least make sure to wash it well and do a thorough job of cleaning out the inside (no crumbs, fast food wrappers, or unpleasant odors!). Finally, set up your online listing for maximum visibility: the more information you provide, including photos, the more prospective buyers you'll get.
What paperwork do I need to sell my car?
At the very least, you'll need to have the vehicle's title in hand (or available for electronic transfer at your DMV). If you still owe money on your car, contact your lender to find out their process for getting the title. Other paperwork that can help you sell your car includes documentation of the service history (e.g. oil changes, tire rotations), initial purchase documents if you bought the car new, and a vehicle history report from a service like CARFAX.
Someone wants to see the car. What do I do now?
For safety reasons, you may want to arrange to meet at a neutral public location like a parking lot or even outside of the police station. If the buyer wants to take a test drive - as they should! - you should get a photo of their driver's license and be sure to ride along with them.
Can I sell my car directly to a dealer?
Absolutely! While you may not get as much money for your vehicle this way, it eliminates a lot of the hassle you'll experience when selling to a private buyer. There are online services that specialize in advertising your car only to dealerships. You could get an instant cash offer, or a dealer might ask to do an in-person appraisal first.
Should I pay for an inspection before I sell my car?
That's up to you, but a smart buyer will probably request one from a mechanic they trust instead of taking yours at face value. It might be better to wait until you have a buyer and let them choose if and where to have an inspection done.
I've sold my car. When can I cancel my car insurance?
Call your insurer! If you're planning on getting a new car, you may have to keep your policy in place so that there's no lapse in coverage.

Compare Any 2 Products

We Buy Any Car
CarVIO
Wheelzy
Car Gurus
AutoTrader
CarMax
Carvana
Driveway
True Car
Facebook Marketplace
vs
We Buy Any Car vs CarVIOWe Buy Any Car vs WheelzyWe Buy Any Car vs Car GurusWe Buy Any Car vs AutoTraderWe Buy Any Car vs CarMaxWe Buy Any Car vs CarvanaWe Buy Any Car vs DrivewayWe Buy Any Car vs True CarWe Buy Any Car vs Facebook Marketplace CarVIO vs WheelzyCarVIO vs Car GurusCarVIO vs AutoTraderCarVIO vs CarMaxCarVIO vs CarvanaCarVIO vs DrivewayCarVIO vs True CarCarVIO vs Facebook Marketplace Wheelzy vs Car GurusWheelzy vs AutoTraderWheelzy vs CarMaxWheelzy vs CarvanaWheelzy vs DrivewayWheelzy vs True CarWheelzy vs Facebook Marketplace Car Gurus vs AutoTraderCar Gurus vs CarMaxCar Gurus vs CarvanaCar Gurus vs DrivewayCar Gurus vs True CarCar Gurus vs Facebook Marketplace AutoTrader vs CarMaxAutoTrader vs CarvanaAutoTrader vs DrivewayAutoTrader vs True CarAutoTrader vs Facebook Marketplace CarMax vs CarvanaCarMax vs DrivewayCarMax vs True CarCarMax vs Facebook Marketplace Carvana vs DrivewayCarvana vs True CarCarvana vs Facebook Marketplace Driveway vs True CarDriveway vs Facebook Marketplace True Car vs Facebook Marketplace Facebook Marketplace vs True CarFacebook Marketplace vs DrivewayFacebook Marketplace vs CarvanaFacebook Marketplace vs CarMaxFacebook Marketplace vs AutoTraderFacebook Marketplace vs Car GurusFacebook Marketplace vs WheelzyFacebook Marketplace vs CarVIOFacebook Marketplace vs We Buy Any Car True Car vs DrivewayTrue Car vs CarvanaTrue Car vs CarMaxTrue Car vs AutoTraderTrue Car vs Car GurusTrue Car vs WheelzyTrue Car vs CarVIOTrue Car vs We Buy Any Car Driveway vs CarvanaDriveway vs CarMaxDriveway vs AutoTraderDriveway vs Car GurusDriveway vs WheelzyDriveway vs CarVIODriveway vs We Buy Any Car Carvana vs CarMaxCarvana vs AutoTraderCarvana vs Car GurusCarvana vs WheelzyCarvana vs CarVIOCarvana vs We Buy Any Car CarMax vs AutoTraderCarMax vs Car GurusCarMax vs WheelzyCarMax vs CarVIOCarMax vs We Buy Any Car AutoTrader vs Car GurusAutoTrader vs WheelzyAutoTrader vs CarVIOAutoTrader vs We Buy Any Car Car Gurus vs WheelzyCar Gurus vs CarVIOCar Gurus vs We Buy Any Car Wheelzy vs CarVIOWheelzy vs We Buy Any Car CarVIO vs We Buy Any Car
See the Best Car Selling Sites in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

USA TODAY

How to sell your car privately and avoid common mistakes

Selling your vehicle privately can be a daunting task, especially if you’re unsure about the different state-by-state requirements.

Tue, 09 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

24/7 Wall St

The Slowest-Selling New Cars in 2024

The Ford F-Series is the best selling car so far this year, with 352,406 units sold in the first half, according to Car and Driver, though sales declined by 8% compared to the same period the previous ...

Wed, 17 Jul 2024

Only the Best Reviews

MSN

Why Some Used Cars Are Selling for More Than New Ones

The post-pandemic era has flipped the car market on its head, with used cars often selling for higher prices than their brand-new counterparts. This unexpected trend is the result of various factors, ...

Sat, 11 Jan 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Autoblog

How to Sell a Classic Car Online Without Wasting Your Time

Selling a classic car online isn’t about casting the widest net, it’s about putting your car in front of the right people. Selling a classic car online isn’t about casting the widest net; it’s about ...

Wed, 23 Jul 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Jalopnik

Online Car Salesman Shares Secrets Of Successfully Selling A Car ...

So it's time to sell your car. Maybe you already have a new car and just need to get rid of the old one. Maybe not. But there's more to selling a car than simply throwing an ad up online with a few ...

Sat, 06 Sep 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Telegraph

Understanding taxes when buying and selling a car

When it comes to buying and selling a car, cutting out the middleman has plenty of perks. Buying a car from a private seller will usually result in a lower price tag. Selling your car yourself will ...

Tue, 29 Oct 2024

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.