Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Catholic Dating Sites

What is the Best Online Dating Site for Catholics?

Dating can be a real rollercoaster of emotions. Trying to be at the right place at the right time to meet your dream man or woman can feel like a ton of pressure. But with the revolution of online dating, websites and apps are popping up to bring people together in the most unexpected ways including through important life philosophies or religious beliefs.

With online dating, you're always in the "right place" and can let go of any worries of missing out on a chance encounter with your perfect match by choosing the wrong meetup. If you're a person who values your Catholic faith or want to find a partner who shares those beliefs, you're in luck. There are tons of dedicated online dating sites out there that cater specifically to Catholic singles.

Thursday, June 20th

2024 Catholic Dating Site Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award CatholicMatch Review 5 Star Rating

CatholicMatch

5 Star Rating
  • $9.99 to $29.99 per month for membership
  • Matching algorithm
  • Article and activity database
  • Limited free trial option
  • Focus on marriage as the dating goal
  • "A+" rating and accreditation with the BBB
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

CatholicMatch is a renowned online platform that combines the art and science of matchmaking to help individuals find their perfect match. CatholicMatch's success speaks for itself, with thousands of confirmed marriages resulting from their services. If you're searching for a meaningful relationship with someone who shares your faith, CatholicMatch is the go-to destination. With a focus on "finding your forever," the site is geared most toward individuals who want to find a Catholic spouse, and offers thousands of success and marriage stories, CatholicMatch can deliver on its goals.

Free accounts are limited

Getting started with CatholicMatch is a breeze, taking minimal time and effort. Plus, you can take advantage of a free trial to explore potential matches. However, it's important to note a couple of drawbacks. Free accounts on CatholicMatch cannot respond to messages, limiting communication options and encouraging users to pay for a membership. Moreover, users in smaller towns and rural areas may encounter a smaller pool of potential matches.

Matching algorithm based on science

If you're wondering how they match you up, CatholicMatch has an impressive proprietary algorithm based on science. Their innovative "Match Portrait" system provides advanced search features and temperament profiling, to ensure that you're shown matches that are best suited to your wants and needs. CatholicMatch takes a comprehensive approach to understanding the deep connections between two people, which is why they have so many marriage success stories.

Media library for relationship help

The platform also offers CM+, a remarkable media library containing thousands of articles, in-depth courses, and training videos exclusively designed for single Catholics. There are fun things like trivia as well as a collection of articles and ideas to help you understand dating a Catholic partner and how to make marriages work. Catering to a diverse range of interests, CM+ is available to premium members, providing them with valuable resources.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Pricing starts high but is competitive for 12 months

Speaking of the premium membership, the cost goes down depending on how many months you subscribe for. For example, one month with CatholicMatch costs $29.99 while the 6-month membership only costs $14.99 per month, and the 12-month membership only costs $9.99 per month. So if you sign up for a year, you're getting a much better deal. However, $29.99 for a single month is quite a high price compared to other sites in our review. And given that you can't chat with singles unless you subscribe, free account users don't have a lot of options when trying out CatholicMatch.

Top rated with the BBB

In terms of user feedback, CatholicMatch stands out as a high performer with the Better Business Bureau. The site has a stellar "A+" rating as well as accreditation with the BBB. Additionally, the mobile app for CatholicMatch has been rated 3.5 stars at the Google Play store and 4 stars at the Apple store, showing a high satisfaction rate with users in terms of the site design and usability. In terms of third-party reviews, there aren't many available, with just over 100 individual reviews on sites like Sitejabber and Trustpilot, and the overall consensus there is that the customer service at CatholicMatch has some room for improvement. On the other hand, the 5-star reviews note that subscribers were happy with the dating pool, and multiple 5-star reviews said that the CatholicMatch experience ended up in marriages.

Top option for your forever person

CatholicMatch stands out as one of the top choices for Catholic dating sites, offering a well-designed platform packed with features to connect you with fellow Catholic singles. The site's extensive success stories and impressive marriage record showcase its effectiveness in helping individuals find long-lasting relationships rooted in faith. The free trial allows you to explore potential matches, and the site's strong rating with the Better Business Bureau and positive user feedback on the mobile app's design and usability highlight its quality. Many members have reported finding their lifelong partners through CatholicMatch, which makes it the best Catholic dating site for those who are looking to tie the knot - and ranks it as our top-performing site overall.

EliteSingles Review 4 Star Rating

EliteSingles

4 Star Rating
  • $16.95 to $44.95 per month
  • Free to join
  • 3-day refund policy
  • Sister sites for other dating options
  • Mobile apps available
  • "A+" rating from the BBB

When it comes to dating, EliteSingles stands out as a platform committed to connecting like-minded singles who are looking to build a serious relationship together. The site claims every user on the site shares the same goal: finding long-lasting love. If you're single and Catholic, you can register for free and take their in-depth personality test to start your journey to meeting fellow singles.

Quiz to get started

In order to get started with EliteSingles, you first take a personality test that asks a variety of questions about your level of education, income, location, partner preferences, ideal partner age, and desire to have children to match you with compatible singles. While you have the option to search through their entire member database for free, their matchmaking system takes the hard work out of it for you.

Daily matches

EliteSingles sends you 3-7 matches daily, connecting you with people they believe you'll have a genuine connection with. In terms of the expected user base, the site caters to professional, mature singles seeking long-term serious relationships. The majority of their users fall between the ages of 30 and 55, and 85% have a high level of education. Just keep in mind that as a broad-reaching online dating platform that doesn't focus strictly on Catholic partners, you might get some matches that don't share your faith background.

UI is well-designed

The website design for EliteSingles is a refreshingly modern approach. While still stylized with its own flair, EliteSingles is easy to navigate and has a smooth user interface on the website. However, some users complain about glitches in the app in particular or occasionally on the site, but when we browsed we had zero issues, so it's possible the devs have already updated the site to address glitches or bugs.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Targeted dating site

Users like that EliteSingles does the matching for them by targeted marketing towards professionals seeking serious relationships, and the removal of inactive profiles, which keeps the site feeling much more secure than some other options in our review. Further, if you want a different kind of dating, all of the sister sites of EliteSingles like Over 50 Dating are available for you to browse at the bottom of the site.

Expensive, but might be worth it

In terms of customer experience, the "free" membership on EliteSingles has limited functionality, with messages and matches being inaccessible. Upgrading to a premium membership unlocks additional features. The cost to upgrade with EliteSingles isn't cheap. The cost is $44.95 for one month or $16.95 per month for a six-month commitment, which is on the higher end of pricing in our review. It's important to note that individuals who opt for a Premium membership have a three-day window to cancel for a full refund. Memberships auto-renew at the end of each term, and canceling after the three-day period results in continued charges. However, since most of the people on this site are looking for partners with high salaries or high levels of education, the price point may not be an issue for most potential members seeking a partner in this crowd.

Good standing with the BBB

Overall, EliteSingles offers a strong option according to its business reputation. EliteSingles' parent company, Spark Networks, has a stellar "A+" rating with the BBB and a 3-star average rating on the Apple app store. Unfortunately, the site isn't as popular with users from the Google Play store who only rated the service 2 out of 5 stars. Customers complain that the app and the website are two very different experiences. Some features are missing on the mobile app, as well as reported problems with "fake" listings for users that don't actually exist. Further, some members have reported technical glitches on both the website and the app. Match suggestions may not align with stated preferences, resulting in matches outside of the desired age range or residing far away.

Top option for educated or wealthy matches

Ultimately, personal experiences vary, and while some individuals find success on EliteSingles, others may prefer alternative dating sites. Canceling subscriptions within the three-day grace period allows for a refund which is a definite bonus for EliteSingles, but with its high price point and some complaints about usability on the mobile apps, this site still could stand for a little improvement. However, it's still one of the higher-performing Catholic dating sites despite these issues. And, if you're looking for a place to find people with specific education or salary requirements, EliteSingles may be a great option for you.

Ave Maria Singles Review 4 Star Rating

Ave Maria Singles

4 Star Rating
  • $97 for a lifetime membership
  • Anonymous profiles
  • Match test to get started
  • Standard features for a dating site
  • European dating options
  • "A+ rating from the BBB

Ave Maria Singles caters specifically to devout Catholics who are seeking a partner who shares their strong religious beliefs. The site acknowledges that finding someone who fully embraces the teachings of the Church can be a challenging task. Simplicity is at the core of Ave Maria Singles' approach, and they specifically highlight their site as being ideal for those who are devout believers in Catholicism. Navigating the site is user-friendly, ensuring ease of use for individuals with limited computer or internet experience.

Match test to get started

To get started, you have access to reading profiles, searching based on specific criteria, and exploring informative posts and videos related to dating and relationships. The Christian-focused match test assists in identifying potential matches who align well with your preferences. If someone you're interested in reciprocates, you'll be discreetly notified.

Single-purchase membership

Ave Maria Singles provides two membership options with their respective prices. The first membership is the Unlimited Lifetime membership, available for a one-time fee of $97, granting unrestricted access to the site for as long as desired. Alternatively, there is the 6-Month Trial membership, offered at a cost of $80, allowing six months of access to Ave Maria Singles. Payments can be conveniently made using credit or debit cards, as well as through PayPal. It's important to note that membership does not automatically extend, giving individuals the freedom to decide whether or not to continue after their chosen duration. Additionally, even after membership expires, profiles are securely saved for one year, allowing easy resumption of membership without the need for re-creating a profile.

Security and anonymity

Anonymity and seriousness are key aspects of Ave Maria Singles. By providing a self-selected username and personal inbox, members have control over when and if they choose to share personal information. This commitment to privacy ensures a secure and confidential environment for individuals seeking meaningful connections. However, some users may find it frustrating not to know who they are talking to right away. Additionally, only those who can prove they are over 18 and only those who are practicing Catholics are welcome on the site, which ensures you are only interacting with potential matches who are serious about a relationship based on your mutual beliefs.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

European love story

As an added benefit, Ave Maria Singles offers opportunities to connect with Catholic singles from various European countries through their sister sites. This way you can ensure that you have access to the widest pool of potential dates regardless of location with something that brings you both together. And who knows - maybe a European romance is just the thing for the next step in your life.

Features include standard buttons

To enhance the online experience, Ave Maria Singles offers several premium features. These include the ability to upload unlimited photos (as the basic membership restricts users to only two photos), the "Make an Exception" option which enables users to request an exception to profile restrictions for connecting with someone, the "Not Interested" button to easily reject potential matches, one-on-one live chat for real-time conversations, and the ability to save and quickly search using specific parameters. These seem like fairly standard features across the board, which doesn't make this platform stand out in particular among Catholic dating sites.

No previews available

While these premium features are presented as optional, they appear to be integral to a fulfilling dating experience on Ave Maria Singles. It would be beneficial for the site to provide demos or visual examples of these features in action to assist potential customers in understanding their value and functionality before committing to a membership that costs $97. In fact, there are no images exploring the actual usability of the app or website before you buy, which may be a downside for many customers who are looking to feel comfortable with a new dating site.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Low user-count

One place Ave Maria didn't stand out as well as some of the competing dating sites is its member-base. There aren't as many users on Ave Maria Singles compared to other options in our review. Though the European members increase the dating pool, you may still find more users on a rival dating site, making it a little harder to find your perfect match with Ave Maria Singles.

Mixed reviews, but top marks from BBB

Feedback on Ave Maria Singles is mixed. The site shares around 40 pages of success stories of couples who met and married through their platform. However, like any dating site, there are individuals who may find limited matches or experience discouragement, leading them to give up on their search. On a positive note, Ave Maria Singles' reputation has gotten better recently. The company received an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, which has risen significantly from its former "D-" rating. On the other hand, the feedback on third-party dating sites averages around 2.5 stars out of 5, which isn't great, but with only a handful of reviews (just under 20), this may not be an accurate reflection of Ave Maria Singles.

A good option for very devout Catholics

Overall, Ave Maria Singles is considered a basic online dating site for devout Catholic singles. However, some members have found that not all users on the site share their level of commitment to the Catholic faith and the desire for a lifelong commitment through marriage. Additionally, the site's membership numbers are lower compared to some competitors, potentially reducing the likelihood of finding a suitable spouse. However, many customers like the marriage-focused model here, and it's definitely worth checking out if that's your level of commitment too.

Catholic Chemistry Review 3.5 Star Rating

Catholic Chemistry

3.5 Star Rating
  • $9.98 to $19.99 per month
  • Free use available
  • Dating advice pages
  • Endorsed by church leaders
  • Mobile app available

Catholic Chemistry presents itself as a dating platform that brings together faith and chemistry in a meaningful way. Designed to cater to a variety of users including young Millennials as well as Gen-X and Baby Boomers, this service seeks to prioritize the Catholic faith in a modern, user-focused dating site. The site has three payment plans for 1, 3, and 6 months as well as a modern-design mobile app available on the Apple App Store and Google Play.

Detailed Catholic questionnaire

Getting started at Catholic Chemistry is easy. Users are prompted to answer a series of questions that delve into their beliefs and perspectives on Christian-focused love, the sanctity of life and marriage, the priesthood, premarital sex, the real presence, and papal infallibility, as well as one's favorite saints. Personal profile details include education, political views, occupation, pets, ethnicity, children, and an "about me" section. By gathering comprehensive information, the site aims to provide users with the best chances of being matched with individuals who share similar backgrounds.

Pricing is available on the app store

Catholic Chemistry's pricing is a little hard to find. In order to get a clear idea, we had to check out the app for Catholic Chemistry on the App Store. According to Apple, Catholic Chemistry is a paid service that offers 1, 3, or 6-month payment options. The price starts at $19.99 per month and goes down depending on if you choose to pay every 3 months for $44.99 or every 6 months for $59.99. This offers a monthly cost range of $9.98 to $19.99. While Catholic Chemistry does offer free browsing, allowing users to create their profiles and explore others without any cost, members say it is more effective to upgrade for the benefits of viewing who's seen your profile and other perks.

Dating advice and blogs

One place that Catholic Chemistry offers a little extra is its dating advice page. This resource offers a range of posts covering topics such as the #MeToo movement, relationship challenges, summer date ideas, and tips for staying safe on dates. The advice articles are conveniently organized into discernment, relationship, and Catholic and Single categories, allowing users to find relevant content easily. The site also incorporates humorous videos that highlight the importance of matching with individuals who share similar tastes, providing a glimpse into the overall vibe and philosophy of the platform.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Mid-rated mobile app may need updates

Like many options in this review, Catholic Chemistry offers an app experience on top of the website. This is one of the only places that Catholic Chemistry is rated by users, as the company has zero presence on the Better Business Bureau or on third-party review sites such as Trustpilot. The Catholic Chemistry app is rated 3.5 stars out of 5, making it a mid-ground dating platform overall. There are just under 150 total reviews, indicating that this may not be one of the most widely-used dating services. Since the app is new, this is to be expected; however, in terms of looking at the membership base and likelihood of meeting a fellow Catholic match, you might struggle to find a wide dating pool at Catholic Chemistry.

Endorsed by church leaders

One interesting thing about the reviews for Catholic Chemistry includes a "What are the Catholic leaders saying" with quotes from well-known Catholic speakers or leaders. Overall app reviews and online testimonials from the Catholic Chemistry website point out that users do love the clean and modern feel of the app and site experience. However, some members complain that there are some bugs with the app like being unable to change email and password after signing up, location settings are too broad, and the filters don't always work. So, while the app is modern, it could use a few tune-ups to be up to the popular dating app standard. Additionally, while the reviews for the app are acceptable, we would prefer to be able to see a preview of the site and app functionality, which isn't offered for Catholic Chemistry.

Middle-ground option

Catholic Chemistry offers a middle-ground option for those seeking a Catholic dating site that combines faith and romantic compatibility. With a focus on the Catholic faith and a modern user experience, the platform aims to connect individuals with similar backgrounds and beliefs. While the pricing structure is not easily accessible and is a little higher than some monthly subscriptions, clients have reported that upgrading to a paid membership provides more effective browsing and viewing.

Could use some updates

However, the limited number of reviews and possibly low membership base means that this site definitely isn't one of the top performers for Catholic dating sites - yet. Overall, Catholic Chemistry presents itself as a decent site and may be worth checking out, especially since you can start using it for free initially, but keep in mind you may find more dates elsewhere.

Catholic Dating Club Review 2.5 Star Rating

Catholic Dating Club

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing unknown for membership
  • Free option is limited
  • Same-sex relationship searches

The Catholic Dating Club is an online platform dedicated to bringing together individuals who share the Catholic faith and values. Whether seeking friendships, conversations, romance, or love, Catholic Dating Club provides a welcoming space to meet fellow Catholics who understand and appreciate your religious beliefs. This dating website offers an extensive range of features. It provides various options to personalize and customize your profile, such as adding photos and videos. Additionally, you can keep track of who has viewed or liked your profile and create your own list of matches and likes.

Free to start, but limited access

To get started at the Catholic Dating Club, you just need to create a free personal profile and add a photo. Members gain access to an extensive collection of Catholic personals, making it easier to connect with compatible individuals who share similar outlooks on life. One feature that stood out from the Catholic Dating Club is their initial questionnaire includes same-gender relationship options, which was different from most of the other sites in this review. It's important to note that you can start using Catholic Dating Club for free, though you are limited in the number of flirts you can send to other members as a free member.

No pricing available till you're already in

Speaking of cost, the payment options on Catholic Dating Club are hard to find. The Catholic Dating Club states that they provide a range of prices for their Premium membership, including the ability to accept different foreign currencies. However, the exact pricing details are not readily available on the site. To view the current pricing, users are required to log into their account and navigate to the Upgrade section. It is important to note that the subscription will auto-renew until canceled, but users can reach out to the customer support team if they wish to stop their subscription.

Paid membership benefits

The benefits of paying for the membership include:

  • Show your profile on the front page.
  • 10x more messages
  • You are displayed first and highlighted in searches

Outdated design doesn't inspire confidence

One area where Catholic Dating Club didn't quite stand out is its website design. The site was started in 1999, and unfortunately, the site styling looks like it. All of the text on the front page is written in one block, and there is only one button to join the site. All other information is in links at the bottom of the site as there is no navigation header. Further, the site does not appear to have a mobile app, which sets them below the bar compared to other more competitive dating sites in our review.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

No review presence

In addition to no mobile app, there simply aren't any user reviews for Catholic Dating Club. The site has no presence on the Better Business Bureau and has almost no presence on other third-party review sites. We could only find 6 individual user reviews. However, these reviews offered high praise for Catholic Dating Club, so this may still indicate the site is worth exploring. Users noted that not only were they able to find dates but also friends on the site who shared their beliefs.

Free basic membership

Overall, Catholic Dating Club provides a range of methods to personalize profiles, track profile interactions, and create lists of matches and likes. While the site lacks a modern design and mobile app, it offers a free basic membership with limited features and a paid Premium membership with additional benefits. Since pricing details are not readily available on the site, customers may feel that they don't have a clear idea of what they're signing up for, which could be frustrating.

An option for LGBTQ+ Catholics

With these things in mind and the addition of the lack of review presence for Catholic Dating Club, we can't give this service a very high rating. However, it may still be useful for its features, and especially interesting to Catholics looking to find a same-sex partner, as that is one of the options at Catholic Dating Club. If this sounds like a feature you might enjoy, it may be worth checking out Catholic Dating Club, at least in the free capacity to see if it's for you.

Catholic People Meet Review 1.5 Star Rating

Catholic People Meet

1.5 Star Rating
  • Free to sign up
  • Articles available
  • Find friends as well as partners
  • "B" rated by the BBB

Catholic People Meet presents itself as a platform where like-minded Catholics can connect with each other. Owned by People Meet Media Inc, Catholic People Meet claims to be a "Catholic dating site where online dating is simple for the faithful." However, it is important to note that once you create a profile and start interacting with others, there is minimal emphasis on Catholicism. Member profiles lack information about one's devotion to their faith, making it challenging to find individuals who are genuinely serious about their Catholic beliefs. But, with free browsing, it does offer some dating searches without charging you right away.

Website looks ancient

However, like a few other options in this review, Catholic People Meet is unbelievably outdated. The site design is clunky, hard to navigate, and looks like it was designed in the internet stone age. The use of generic stock photos that are not only small .png files but blurry makes this feel like a site that doesn't have any maintenance or quality control: definitely not ideal for a site where you're trying to find your perfect Catholic partner. Even the profiles themselves appear basic and fail to provide substantial insights into each person's character.

Friendship options available

Interestingly, Catholic People Meet extends beyond the realm of dating and also aims to foster friendships and casual relationships. While this inclusivity is commendable, it does make it more difficult to navigate the platform in search of a potential romantic partner, especially when members are there for various reasons.

Free to sign up

Similar to its competitors, Catholic People Meet offers free sign-up and browsing of member profiles. However, to access essential features that facilitate meaningful connections, a subscription fee is required - and that pricing was hard to find on the site. For example, under the billing link at the bottom of the site, you can choose billing and subscription, but from that page, it only tells you there is a rate page with no way to access it. Since the search bar only works in the FAQ section of the site, it's almost impossible to find the upgrade prices unless you're already a member.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Articles for Catholic dating

Despite being a low performer overall, Catholic People Meet has a few bonuses. For example, the site has a bunch of articles to help you gain a deeper understanding of dating while Catholic. Some of the topics include articles about how to create a good profile, how to cope with modern dating, and "premarital intercourse" . The goal of these articles is to support Catholics in their search for a relationship that aligns with their beliefs.

Parent company is "B" rated

Like the other low-performing sites in our review, Catholic People Meet has no review presence either on the BBB or on third-party review sites. However, the parent company, People Meet Media, does have a page on the BBB. This company has a decent rating of a "B" from the Bureau, but only has 67 total reviews and an average star rating of 1.5 out of 5 stars. So, even though they are listed and have decent customer service, this still doesn't make us feel confident about Catholic People Meet as a whole.

Might want to keep searching

Overall, Catholic People Meet falls short of expectations. While the site offers additional resources such as online and in-person dating tips, these extras alone do not justify investing time and money in the platform. We recommend opting for higher-rated sites that provide a larger member base and attract individuals who are genuinely committed to dating and devoted to their Catholic beliefs - because Catholic People Meet isn't a perfect match.

Online Catholic Dating Review 1.5 Star Rating

Online Catholic Dating

1.5 Star Rating
  • 5-day trial for $6.59
  • $46.19 per month
  • Options for multiple genders and sexualities
  • Video and photo features
  • Live chat

Online Catholic Dating is a dating platform that caters to individuals with diverse sexual orientations, including straight, gay, and lesbian. With its establishment in 2019, the site has become a part of a network of dating sites sharing a common user profile database. Online Catholic Dating employs a matching algorithm that takes compatibility into account. Studies have shown that couples with shared interests tend to stay together longer, and this dating site aims to identify members who are most like you, though it doesn't say what this algorithm is.

High prices for few rewards

In terms of pricing, Online Catholic Dating offers different membership plans, including a trial plan, a recurring plan, and a premium subscription.

  • The Trial Subscription plan provides a five-day membership at a cost of $6.59. If you do not cancel before the trial period ends, you will be automatically enrolled in the recurring plan.
  • The Recurring Subscription plan costs $46.19 per month,
  • The Premium Subscription offers flexible options of $40.69 for one month, $62.67 for three months, and $131.87 for twelve months.

This pricing is unusually high compared to competitors - and with no mobile app, this seems to be lacking benefits for such a high price. If you decide to cancel your membership to Online Catholic Dating, you can do so online. The site allows members to terminate recurring memberships and allows all users to deactivate or close their accounts.

Wide range of search parameters

When it comes to searching for potential matches on Online Catholic Dating, the site provides basic search criteria such as gender, age, photo availability, and online status. Furthermore, you can perform extended searches using more specialized filters to narrow down your options. However, to enhance your visibility and stand out among other members, Online Catholic Dating offers a paid Priority Listing feature, ensuring your profile appears prominently in search results. Additionally, you have the option to create a profile video, further distinguishing yourself from other users.

Group and single chat options

Engaging with other members is made easy on Online Catholic Dating with features such as Group Chat, where you can chat with multiple members simultaneously, and private chats for more intimate conversations. The site also offers webcam chat, providing a safe and convenient way to connect before meeting in person.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Your information is public here

One feature that wasn't ideal about Online Catholic Dating is its low commitment to user privacy. One third-party review site noted that if you choose to use this site, your information, including profile images, will be publicly available. If privacy is a priority for you, it might be smarter to explore alternative dating sites that offer comprehensive privacy protection.

No review presence

While Online Catholic Dating has its advantages, such as live chat functionality and the ability to report spam profiles, it's important to consider the site's limitations. The absence of a mobile app, no proof of identity verification, and the fact that profiles are public are some of the disadvantages to be aware of. Furthermore, the site has almost no presence online either with the Better Business Bureau or with most third-party review sites. So, with no app or review site data, there aren't any customer testimonials to back up the claimed benefits of this site.

Search for something more secure

While there are some decent Catholic dating sites out there, Online Catholic Dating just isn't the one. With no customer reviews or testimonials to go off of, there's no way to know if the site is really trustworthy. Further, with one third-party site noting that your information may not be secure (and no other reviews to counter that claim), we don't feel safe suggesting this site, especially if protecting your data and information is a priority. So, check out some of the other safer and higher-rated options in this review instead.

Catholic Mates Review 1 Star Rating

Catholic Mates

1 Star Rating
  • $29.99 per month
  • Free option during sign up
  • Older users

If you're looking for a modern and visually appealing dating site, Catholic Mates isn't it. The site looks like it's stuck in the 90s, with outdated patterns and tiny text. It lacks subpages for policies and has an old-school vibe that may make you hesitate to share personal info. Plus, it's pretty expensive for a site with a small user base and limited features. The profiles are crowded and overwhelming, and the whole site gives off scam vibes.

Built in 2004, but feels like it's from the 90s

If a modern feel is a must-have for your next dating site experience, Catholic Mates won't impress you. In fact, the landing site is so out of date that it looks like the webpage might have been built in the 90s and completely forgotten about. With busy patterns, too-small text, and an aspect ratio that feels like it's meant to serve computers from a bygone era, there's almost nothing good to say about the design and digital footprint of Catholic Mates.

Won't give you any info until you sign up

To access the pricing information and select a subscription plan, you'll need to provide some demographic details, your email address, birthday, and a username. There are no subpages to check policies or even learn more about the platform on the Catholic Mates site, and the antiquated appearance of the website Catholic Mates doesn't inspire confidence for new users to share their personal details. It's unlikely that a large membership base would choose their services when there are more affordable and modern dating sites available.

No younger users

In terms of signing up, Catholic Mates offers users various options to select their religion, including non-religious and non-Christian, which seems counterintuitive for a Catholic dating site. The user base tends to be older, with many individuals in their 40s and 50s. While free users have some limited features like viewing profiles, adding them to lists and sending pre-programmed messages, engaging in conversations with other users requires a paid account. It's worth noting that many users on the site have not uploaded a photo, which can make it challenging to gauge their appearance.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Expensive for what you get

Catholic Mates offers two payment options as of the time of this review, which include a 1-month membership fee of $29.99 and a 3-month membership fee of $39.99. The only way to access this information is to sign up. Although the site does offer a free option for Catholics seeking relationships, the features are pared down. Either way, for a site this poorly designed and with such a low user base, the price isn't anywhere near fair. If you're looking for good deals and a good Catholic dating service, Catholic Mates won't be anywhere near the top of your list.

Scam vibes from page design

While there aren't any screenshots on the site itself, we found a few users who posted images of Catholic Mates' internal platform, and what we can see is almost cringe-worthy. The profile page on Catholic Mates is overloaded with text, photos, and external links, giving it an overwhelming and busy appearance. Additionally, everything about the site from the low-quality photos to the site composition looks like a scam site that you'd be navigated to if you clicked an unsafe link. There's nothing about the red and yellow site motif and outdated styling that makes this place seem like a safe site to start your dating adventure.

No buzz for Catholic Mates

While we'd love to give you the rundown on reviews, the truth is that beyond a few dating bloggers, there just aren't any reviews out there. Not only does this site not have a presence on the BBB, but sites like Trustpilot and Sitejabber don't have any reviews for Catholic Mates. This raises a red flag for us since even some of the less popular sites in our review have some kind of feedback. Overall, Catholic Mates may not be the safest option for you.

Find any other option

If you haven't already gathered, Catholic Mates is a subpar option for online dating. Not only does it appear to have little relevance to Catholic-specific dating beyond its name, as they allow plenty of non-Catholic and even non-religious members, but it is also priced very high for a site with a specific age range and low user base. Choosing any of the other available options for online Catholic dating would undoubtedly be a better choice than using Catholic Mates. For these reasons, this site is clearly our lowest-ranked option among Catholic dating sites.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

These dating sites and apps are designed to provide you with a specific dating pool to help you connect with someone who shares your commitment to the Catholic way of life, beliefs, and values. Instead of having to rely solely on chance encounters at school, church, or work, you can scroll through profiles and find hundreds of like-minded men and women who tick all the right boxes.

The best part is, signing up and creating your online dating profile is super easy. Just a few clicks and taps, and you're in the Catholic dating game. With questions about age, interests, and educational background, you can narrow down potential matches as well as help your future first date get a sneak peek into who you are and what you love.

A great dating site will likely ask you for specifics about your ideal partner, so they can work their magic and help match you with profiles that align with your interests and romantic desires. So, with just a few swipes, you might just find that special someone who's a perfect match for you.

If it's your first time embracing the convenience and excitement of online dating and letting the virtual Cupid work its magic, don't worry: the apps and websites are built with safety and security in mind. The goal is to connect with like-minded folks looking for faith-based relationships while prioritizing your comfort and safety. Who knows, your Catholic soulmate might be just a few clicks away!

With so many different dating sites available for Catholic romantics, it can be hard to decide where to start your journey. We totally understand. So, we've put together this checklist to help you narrow down your options:

  • Price. Love is priceless, they say. But let's be real: if you're shelling out your hard-earned cash every month for a dating site, it can be a buzzkill. When it comes to Catholic dating sites, the payment options can vary. Some sites offer the flexibility of month-to-month payments, while others might nudge you towards longer membership commitments. Keep in mind how much you want to spend and what finding your special someone is worth.
  • Membership. When it comes to dating sites, it's a numbers game. The larger the user base, the greater the pool of potential dates at your fingertips. It's simple math: more people equals more opportunities to find that special someone. Keep in mind that more options increase your opportunity to find the love of your life, so looking at how many people have membership on a particular Catholic dating site may help choose where to make your next profile.
  • Features. Consider the level of detail in the dating profiles and the ability to specify your location preferences. Look for a site that provides accurate and relevant results, while also being user-friendly and offering plenty of options. Also, look at the features: how many search filters are there? Can you send photos or voice chat? Some features can help you connect better with your future special someone, so make sure the site you choose has the features you want.
  • Security. When deciding on a Catholic dating app, considering the level of security it offers is crucial. A reliable and secure app prioritizes the safety of personal information, implements robust privacy measures, and provides tools for managing privacy settings. By choosing a secure app, like one that requires photo authentication, users can have peace of mind and enjoy a positive and trustworthy online dating experience.

To help you find the best place to start your Catholic online dating ventures, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best online dating sites that cater specifically to romantics who want Catholic beliefs to be a part of their next relationship. We hope this helps you get started and focus on finding your special someone who shares your beliefs and your life philosophy!

The Best Catholic Dating Sites Compare Catholic Dating Sites Compare Catholic Dating Site Reviews What are the best Catholic Dating Sites Best Catholic Dating Site Reviews

Catholic Dating Site FAQ

Absolutely! While new services are popping up every year, some of the most well-known Catholic dating sites have been around for more than 20 years.
For most devout Catholics, it's a must for their partner to share their faith. Although you might find singles who check the "Catholic" box on a general dating website, they may not be as orthodox or active as you're expecting. Catholic dating sites make it easier to find someone with the same beliefs and practices.
Tens of thousands of people create profiles every year. Some sites even have page after page of "success stories": couples who have met through the service and found their "happily ever after."
That depends on the site you select. Most offer subscriptions that range from $9.95 to $29.95/month.
Most dating sites let you create a profile and view possible matches without paying for a membership. But, once you find someone you'd like to contact, you'll probably have to choose a paid plan.
Just like any other dating situation, you should be careful as you get to know people. Some Catholic dating services have helpful articles with advice on navigating the process safely.
Sometimes. A site might offer a "match guarantee", extending your membership at no extra cost if you don't find a good fit in the first six months. But, most services let you cancel your plan at any time, so you're not locked into your dating service if you don't like it - you just won't get a refund for the time you've already used it.
Is the Pope Catholic? Yes, there are many happy couples that got their start through a Catholic dating site. While YMMV ("your mileage may vary"), these services are worth taking a chance. You could be just a few clicks away from true love!

Dating Profiles that Work

Most of us know people who have had great success using a dating website while other friends see little or no dating action. Often the reason between the two stories is simply their profile and what impression it gave off to potential suitors. Writing about yourself doesn't come natural and putting relationship needs and wants into a one page summary takes practice so it's easy for people to make mistakes.

Spend time figuring out what you want in a potential mate and then focus on the following attributes of your profile to improve your chances of attracting the right person.

Tone. The tone of your profile is one of the biggest aspects of the impression you give off. Do you sound confident and upbeat or lacking self confidence. Do you spend more time explaining what you don't want or more time talking about your interests in a positive light? A negative Nelly or a selfish Sally are big turn offs. A nice balance of what you can bring to the table as well as what you're looking for will attract attention from others.

Username. The username is often the first thing someone sees about your profile and will create an initial first impression. A user name that uses profane language or sexual content is likely to turn off many quality singles. In turn, a boring or meaningless username can also have the same effect. Spend time coming up with a username that favorably depicts you and will grab someone's attention.

Mistakes. Bad grammar and spelling can be a huge turn-off for most. This can give the impression that you're lacking brain power and wouldn't put much effort into a relationship. If the website doesn't offer spell check, cut and paste your writing into a word document and search for errors.

Pictures. A profile with no pictures typically receives very few inquiries if any. Appearance is an important aspect of finding someone you have a chemical response to and people tend to avoid those profiles lacking photos. Be sure to include at least one picture but adding various shots of you from face to full body is ideal.

Honesty. Be honest in what you write in your profile. If you really don't want to date anyone older than you than make sure you indicate an accurate age range, height, body shape, religion or any other aspect of a potential mate you find critical. Also be honest about yourself. Lying about your age, income, kids or anything else will eventually lead to failure.

Ask for Feedback. While it may seem a little awkward, ask a close friend that knows you to give you honest feedback regarding your profile. How does it sound? Does it send the wrong message. What would they change?

See the Best Catholic Dating Site
The Best Reviews of Catholic Dating Sites