9 Best Catholic Dating Sites of 2026

We've analyzed the best Catholic Dating Sites to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Catholic Dating Site Reviews

Which Catholic Dating Service is the Best?  Many Catholic singles have turned to online dating sites to find their like-minded spouse. Dating sites are popping up everywhere, changing the way millions of Catholic singles meet. With so many choices, how do you know which Catholic dating site is for you, especially if you're looking for someone with a specific belief system?

5.0

EXCELLENT

1

Best Option

  • Limited free access
  • Premium membership for about $15 to $20 per month
  • Over a million registered members
  • Free content including articles and videos
  • Additional paid courses available on both dating and Catholicism

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the CatholicMatch website

CatholicMatch calls itself the "largest and most successful website for single Catholics." Co-founders Jason and Brian take pride in hearing success stories, including marriages, babies, and always appreciate the thank-you notes for fostering a genuine community. Their three promises are: to respect and care for your experience, connect you with great matches and helpful content, and provide excellent service with privacy and security.

Test out the site with a free account

The basic account is the default option on CatholicMatch. You can display your profile, view and "like" other profiles, receive messages, and participate in matching. This option is an excellent way to see how many Catholic singles are available in your area, and to check out the tools they provide for finding you a match.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

You'll want a subscription if you're looking for a match

Once you've explored the site and assessed potential matches for free, consider purchasing a subscription. This unlocks full communication features, including sending and reading messages without delay. Subscription fees support free coaching for subscribers, religious education to nourish marriages, safety features, and more. What does it cost? CatholicMatch doesn't put that out there until you create a profile, but our research suggests you should expect it to be $15 to $20 per month.

Take your time to fill out the questionnaire

CatholicMatch has created a detailed Match Portrait, a questionnaire that covers key areas where successful couples typically complement each other, such as values, personality, and outlook on life. Each Portrait is scored and compared with other profiles to suggest potential matches based on compatibility. Don't worry if the questions seem a bit personal - no one will see (or judge) your answers. Just be honest, so the best matches are sent your way.

Are you free to marry in the Catholic Church?

For consistency and in keeping with their mission, CatholicMatch only suggests matches to those who are free and able to marry in the Catholic church.

There's a lot of help on this site

CatholicMatch's CM+ offers thousands of articles, both in print and video, covering Catholic topics as well as dating and marriage advice. These articles are free to access, even if you don't have a subscription or profile with CatholicMatch.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Looking for tips on dating, marriage, holidays, and more?

CatholicMatch has thought of it all. There are more than five courses you can take, for a fee, to learn about all things dating, plus Lent and Advent. If you need to give your dating life a boost, consider signing up for one of these courses.

It's our #1

With over a million registered members, a high success rate, reasonable membership prices, an "A+" Better Business Bureau rating, plus free articles on dating, marriage and more, CatholicMatch is your best bet for finding a spiritually-compatible partner. We give this Catholic dating service five stars and our highest ranking.

On the CatholicMatch website

4.5

GREAT

2

Great

  • Limited free membership
  • 1 month for $49.99
  • 3 months for $104.97 ($34.99 per month)
  • 6 months for $149.94 ($24.99 per month)
  • Large dating pool
  • Focus on long-term relationships
  • Christian site with a Catholic filter
  • Free articles on Christian dating

GREAT

4.5

On the Christian Mingle website

Spark Networks launched Christian Mingle in 2001, and it has grown to quite a large community of over 16 million members, all of whom are connected by their shared Christian faith and goal of finding a partner with similar beliefs. Christian Mingle has been honored with recognitions in the Religion & Spirituality category at the Webby Awards and they've been the Editor's Top Pick Christian Award by DatingSiteReviews.

Christian focus with Catholic options

Christian Mingle has a large dating pool of Christians, and in their questionnaire, you can select your denomination from 23 options, including Catholic. It also asks if you have a religious preference for your matches. Choosing Catholic for both yourself and potential matches may narrow the results, but it ensures you'll be connected with like-minded individuals.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Free membership to test out the site

See if Christian Mingle is for you before you become a paid member. Create a profile, use your Catholic preference filters, and see how many singles are in your area. This is about all you can do without paying for the membership, but it should be enough to find out if Christian Mingle is worth signing up for.

Paid membership has more benefits

The paid membership allows you full access to the site, meaning to message other users and begin conversation with those people you find interesting as a potential match. You can also hide your online status and browse anonymously. How much does it cost? Expect to get 1 month for $49.99, 3 months for $104.97 ($34.99 per month), or 6 months for $149.94 ($24.99 per month).

Swipe feature

If you like swiping through profiles, Christian Mingle's LookBook feature lets you look at profiles one at a time, allowing you to "heart" them or skip them. If you "heart" a person, they will know that an anonymous person "hearted" them. If you both "heart" each other, you'll be included in each other's Mutual Like list.

Boost your profile

Christian Mingle's Spotlight feature boosts your profile to the top of the search results so you can get more attention. Choose the Spotlight feature time period from one day ($2.99) to 30 days ($14.99). Spotlight's a nice way to be assured that people are seeing you.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Encourage and enhance your Christian dating experience

When you're looking for a little encouragement or advice, there are more than 275 free articles you can peruse to find motivation or direction. Take a break from your search, or while you're waiting for a reply from your match, and read an article or two to lift your spirits.

Love story successes?

Click on Success Stories, and you'll see more than 100 pages of people who have posted their Christian Mingle success stories, some including photos of their weddings. It's inspirational to get yourself out there on Christian Mingle and see what they can do for you.

An excellent option for all types of Catholics

Although Christian Mingle isn't specifically focused on Catholicism, it's a well-known Christian dating site. Set your profile and search parameters to Catholic, and ask potential matches about their faith. Whether you're a devout Catholic or Catholic by tradition or baptism, you can find matches with similar beliefs. The pricing is fair, and there are many Christian singles to connect with. Christian Mingle isn't our #1 Catholic dating site because it's not exclusively for Catholics, but it's still an excellent option.

On the Christian Mingle website

4.0

VERY GOOD

3

Very Good

  • 6 months for $60
  • Lifetime membership for $97
  • For members who believe in the Catholic teachings
  • Anonymous profiles
  • European dating options
  • Encourages prayer to help in your search for a spouse

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the Ave Maria Singles website

Ave Maria Singles has been around since 1998 and is not your typical dating site. If you're looking for casual dating, this isn't the place. Their motto, "Where Devout Catholics Meet," is right on their homepage, reflecting their focus on connecting like-minded Catholics seeking a spouse who shares the depth of their faith.

Christian-inspired match test

You'll fill out a survey to help Ave Maria Singles understand more about you and what you're looking for in a match. If someone shares similar interests and values, they'll discreetly notify you, and you can take it from there.

They value your anonymity

You'll choose a username for the website and decide when, or if, you want to share your personal information with others. Of course, some users find it frustrating that they can only communicate with someone who has an anonymous username.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Serious Catholics only

If you are serious about your Catholic faith, beliefs, and practices and are looking for someone similar, you'll find that at Ave Maria Singles. This site isn't for those who are Catholic in name only. Also, members must prove that they are 18 years of age or older.

No previewing the site

It's always nice to preview a site for a feel of what membership would be like, but Ave Maria Singles doesn't allow it. You'll need to become a member to check out the site, members, and group meet-up offerings.

One-time payment, no monthly subscriptions

We love that Ave Maria Singles offers only two choices for membership: six months for $60 or $97 for a lifetime. For less than $100, the lifetime subscription is perfect and a great investment. And, you might be able to get it at an even lower price: when we reached out to Ave Maria Singles' customer service team, they offered us a membership at $39 for 6 months or just $57 for lifetime access.

Few members

One common complaint about Ave Maria Singles is the limited number of members to choose from. With about half of them likely not being the gender that you're looking for, the pool becomes even smaller. However, users who have found their spouse through the site often say patience is key- the right person will come along when it's meant to happen. Despite the smaller member base, many happy users agree that while there may not be quantity, there is certainly quality here.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Be open to longer distance

Because you may find only a few members in your state, many members have opened themselves up to either cross-country relationships or international relationships and haven't been disappointed. They communicated with video chat, and several of these couples have married.

European choices

If you're overseas or are open to meeting someone overseas, there are about seven sister sites that can help you meet people in Europe. You never know.

Singles have found success

Ave Maria Singles claims over 250 marriages have resulted from their site, a statement made in the early 2000's. On their website, about 40 couples have shared their success stories. As with many dating sites, reviews are mixed. Some users have found the love of their life, while others have noted too few members and a few reported that profiles didn't match the actual person.

A very good, inexpensive option for devout Catholics with patience and trust

The motto of Ave Maria Singles is "Where Devout Catholics Meet," which narrows the membership pool due to its focus on serious commitment to Catholic practices and beliefs. While this results in a smaller dating pool, particularly in your area, it ensures that you won't have to sift through hundreds of profiles looking for casual daters or those with beliefs far from your own. If your priority is your Catholic faith, this site helps you find like-minded individuals. Ave Maria Singles earns a high rating from us.

On the Ave Maria Singles website

3.9

VERY GOOD

4

Very Good

  • Limited free membership
  • 3 months for $173.85 ($57.95 per month)
  • 6 months for $269.70 ($44.95 per month)
  • 12 months for $383.40 ($31.95 per month)
  • 5 Factor personality questionnaire
  • Elite singles
  • Spark Networks as parent company
  • Online magazine

VERY GOOD

3.9

On the EliteSingles website

EliteSingles calls themselves a partnership service rather than a dating service, as they maintain the highest standards to help foster long-term commitment matches with American singles. They're not a Catholic dating service per se, but have filters where you can search for (elite) Catholics.

The personality test

EliteSingles' personality test is based on the Five Factor Model theory of personality traits established by McCrae and Costa (1972). You'll answer questions regarding your attitude towards relationships, your personality traits, and your communication skills. In addition to the personality test, they'll take into consideration your level of education, income, location, ideal age of partner, desire to have children, and more.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Basic membership is just to peruse

Start by taking the personality test, and you're allowed access with the limited, basic membership. You can view your own profile, look through partner suggestions and start a conversation with other EliteSingles members.

Premium membership has its privileges

What will it cost you to sign up here? When searching for pricing on EliteSingles, the site directs you to "click here," but all you'll find is information on how to purchase or cancel a subscription. There's no clear pricing until you go through the payment process. At the time of our review, research indicated that 3 months would be $173.85 ($57.95 per month), 6 months' access was $269.70 ($44.95 per month), and 12 months would cost $383.40 ($31.95 per month). Once you pay for a subscription, you can have unlimited communication with other Premium members and you can view all of everyone's photos.

Online magazine for dating ideas

EliteSingles' online magazine has a selection of great advice from their dating experts, including flirting online, selecting the right profile picture, and even fun date ideas. And, their customer care team is always ready if you need a little help.

Catholic(?) professionals looking for professionals

If you're looking for a dating match who's also a professional, EliteSingles is catered to you. You'll see that their home page, via our link, has the word Catholic sprinkled on it, as our search was for Catholic dating. EliteSingles does assure that they can be your Catholic dating site "with a country-wide reputation for matchmaking couples with shared faith, beliefs, and ambitions," but of course you'll find more elite singles here than just Catholics.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

We'd give them a chance

If you're looking to find like-minded professionals with your desired level of education and income, that's what EliteSingles is all about. They assure you that they can help you find elite Catholic matches as well. We like that their parent company is Spark Networks, with a family of reputable dating sites. EliteSingles is a bit pricey, but that encourages those in a higher income bracket to join. When you choose Catholicism for your filters, you can be presented with Catholic matches. If you're looking for a dating site for devout Catholics only, though, try one of our other highly recommended dating sites.

On the EliteSingles website

3.5

GOOD

5

Good

  • Limited free access
  • 1 month for $19.99
  • 3 months for $14.99/month
  • 6 months for $9.99/month
  • Founded in 2018
  • One of the first Catholic dating services to offer an app
  • Adds fun questions to pique interest
  • Auto-renewing subscriptions

GOOD

3.5

On the Catholic Chemistry website

Catholic Chemistry's founder Chuck Gallucci noticed a lack of options for singles who took their Catholic faith seriously after using dating sites to find his spouse. After marrying and having three children, he still felt for others seeking a partner with similar faith. He created Catholic Chemistry, designing both the website and app, to help people deepen their faith and devotion. What sets Catholic Chemistry apart is its mix of thoughtful faith-based questions and fun, quirky prompts that encourage follow-up conversations.

Lengthy but important questionnaire

Catholics come in many forms: some are Catholic by name, others attend Mass regularly, and some may choose how strictly they follow Church teachings on issues like abortion, confession, or sex outside marriage. To help find a match, Catholic Chemistry's questionnaire asks tough, faith-based questions. It also includes compatibility questions about political views, profession, pets, hobbies, and more. You can filter by age, location, Mass attendance, liturgy preference, and more, allowing the algorithm to find your best matches.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Let's add a little fun

To keep things light, there are funny videos about dates gone wrong. You'll also find fun icebreakers in your questionnaire, like "Which is more you: soda or kombucha?" Not only does this give a better idea of who someone is, but you can click on their answer, like kombucha, and ask more - like their favorite flavor or if they make it themselves. If you forget who the kombucha person was later, you can simply search for "kombucha" to jog your memory.

You'll be happier with a paid subscription

Once you sign up for the free version of Catholic Chemistry, you can create a profile and browse others' profiles; but if you want unlimited messaging, seeing who likes or views your profiles, or have access to more features, you'll want to pay for a subscription. 1 month's access to Catholic Chemistry goes for $19.99, 3 months for $14.99/month, or 6 months for $9.99/month. Remember that whichever paid subscription you choose, it will renew automatically, and you'll end up paying until you unsubscribe.

The site is meant to be fun and easy to use, but is it?

Catholic Chemistry's mission was to make the site easy to use and have fun features to make online dating more desirable with a more entertaining website. Some users haven't found this to be the case, complaining that this Catholic dating platform is just plain clunky. Others have said it starts out that way until you get used to it, then it's easy and appealing. Still others have said that the website is doable but the app still needs to be worked out. Sounds like Catholic Chemistry is an acquired taste, and we recommend you try the free version before you subscribe.

Choose from the website or the app

The website seems to be easier to use, and some critics suggest that the apps really need to be worked on to be user-friendly. If you prefer an app, you'll find it in Apple's App Store, and there you can choose between 1, 3, and 6-month subscriptions. Catholic Chemistry is not available in Google's Play Store.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Extra support

There's a page with articles about your favorite saints, dating in a post #MeToo world, Catholic date ideas, and more. And if you do find your dating or relationship match, Catholic Chemistry will send you articles about how to support your couplehood as you continue on the dating or courtship path.

Great concept but lacking in user-friendly technology

We love that all types of Catholics can feel comfortable with the variety of Catholics welcome on this site, along with the filters where you can select people who are similar in practice as you are. We are fascinated with the ice-breaker questions and that you're encouraged to click on an ice-breaker response and easily start a conversation. We're perplexed, though, that the creator is a long-time website designer, yet makes a product that people find clunky, awkward, and challenging to use. Catholic Chemistry comes in at an above-average rating: not the best or the worst out there, with some compelling features (and some frustrating ones).

On the Catholic Chemistry website

2.0

SUBPAR

6

Subpar

  • 1 month for $16.99
  • 3 months for $26.97 ($8.99 per month)
  • 6 months for $38.94 ($6.49 per month)
  • Possible dating site co-op
  • Loosely addresses the concept of Catholic dating
  • Catholic dating advice articles

SUBPAR

2.0

On the Catholic People Meet website

CatholicPeopleMeet's mission is "Creating Relationships. Connecting Lives." Their home page is filled with the word Catholic, saying it's the best place to meet Catholic singles; yet, there's nothing Catholic or religious at all in their mission statement.

This site is a dinosaur

Navigating CatholicPeopleMeet feels like time travel back to the inception of public use of the internet - listen carefully for the old-school dial up screech. CatholicPeopleMeet is challenging to navigate, and it's quite unattractive.

Dating site co-op?

CatholicPeopleMeet lists partnerships with five dating sites, raising concerns about whether most of their users come from these sites and if your information will be shared. While site partnerships can be useful, none of the five sites are explicitly Catholic or Christian. Are there filters for Catholics, perhaps, on these partnered sites? We just don't know.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Pricing is invisible

Unless you sign up for a paid membership, you won't find pricing. In fact, there's a link at the bottom of their page for billing. Unfortunately, when you click on it, it takes you to a message that the IP address could not be found. We did some research and think we can safely say that paid memberships at CatholicPeopleMeet will be in the neighborhood of 1 month for $16.99, 3 months for $26.97 ($8.99 per month), or 6 months for $38.94 ($6.49 per month).

Dating articles, but they're not Catholic- or even Christian-focused

If you're looking for dating advice, the articles on CatholicPeopleMeet aren't what you'd expect of an authentic, official, Catholic-focused service. For example, there's an intriguing article called "Pre-Marital Intercourse." There is a quite vividly descriptive story of a woman debating on whether she should have premarital intercourse or not. Their conclusion is that one should do whatever you think God would want you to do. Another article, called Coping with Modern Dating, talks about compromise, but in an odd fashion. It tosses around the word "confess", but the use of the word is quite out of the Catholic context. And it says that love "can be difficult and complicated (like technology)." The articles on CatholicPeopleMeet are awkward and, we would say, inconsistent with articles we've seen on our more highly-rated Catholic dating sites.

Not Catholic enough for us

If you're seeking a devout Catholic for sacramental marriage, this isn't the site we'd recommend. CatholicPeopleMeet appears to be a co-op with other major dating sites. The articles lack a deep connection to Catholic faith and practices, and the site's navigation is awkward. For these reasons, we can't give CatholicPeopleMeet a higher rating.

On the Catholic People Meet website

1.5

WEAK

7

Weak

  • Limited free access
  • Price not disclosed
  • It's a cooperative, not their own database

WEAK

1.5

On the Catholic Dating Club website

Catholic Dating Club says they are the fastest growing cooperative of online dating sites in the world. Being a cooperative, they help new or existing dating sites to gain access to a larger database of members. They also help these sites with administration, registration, payments, and more. When you join Catholic Dating Club, you'll have access to profiles of not only their members, but also the members in the co-op.

Free access is pretty much a free trial

With basic, free access, you can create an account, upload a photo, create your profile, and send up to 10 different "flirts" to up to 10 different members. You can also do a location search to see how many members are in your geographical area or are interesting to you.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Benefits to paying for membership

Right when you pay for a Catholic Dating Club membership, your profile will show up on the front page, so it's probable you'll get more visits to your profile page and more messages. The other benefits of a paid subscription are being able to send and receive messages from people you're interested in chatting with.

No mention of pricing

Pricing is nowhere to be found on the Catholic Dating Club webpage. There is a FAQ page, and a link to pricing, but all that does is tell you that you'll get pricing once you complete a profile, and that your subscription will automatically renew unless you cancel it yourself.

Pretty generic

Catholic Dating Club doesn't have much information on their site to attract a potential user. The home page tells you that Catholic Dating Club is for Catholics, but because they're a co-op, they present more like they've filtered "Catholic" from other company members, and that's that. There's no mention of a Catholic questionnaire so you can find someone similar to you: whether or not people attend Mass regularly, receive the sacraments, abstain from sex before marriage, and so much more. Catholic Dating Club seems Catholic only as a browsing filter, nothing deeper than that.

Same-sex browsing features

Contrary to what we've seen in other Catholic dating sites, at the foot of the Catholic Dating Club home page, where you can click to find single Catholic gay men and Catholic lesbians. This may be one Catholic dating site that the LGBTQ+ community can use to find non-cis matches.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Finding fans is frustrating

We'd expect to find success stories of happy Catholic marriages on Catholic Dating Club's site, but there aren't, at least as far as we could find. Delving out into the interwebs, there aren't positive reviews from those thrilled with their experience, and not even those who have had a less-than-pleasant experience with the service. There's no rating on Trustpilot and they're not rated by the Better Business Bureau. Our research into Catholic Dating Club's reputation came up as empty as the feeling of Catholicism from this dating website.

Just not enough

We don't see evidence of Catholic Dating Club providing any real focus on Catholics and their specific desires for a potential Catholic spouse. It's a lovely idea to be a cooperative and join forces with other dating sites, but so much more work and research must be done on their part for us to consider this an authentic, Catholic dating service. Catholic Dating Club gets one of our lowest ratings (and even that feels generous).

On the Catholic Dating Club website

1.0

POOR

8

Poor

  • Limited free membership
  • $29.99 per month
  • Choose among 17 languages
  • Catholic senior dating

POOR

1.0

On the Catholic Mates website

Catholic Mates has been around since 2004, but its outdated design makes it feel like it was created a decade earlier. While the site claims to cater to Catholic singles, it doesn't seem to truly embrace Catholic values. Instead of promoting sacramental marriage or Catholic dating principles, it feels more like a generic dating site with the word "Catholic" thrown in to be more appealing. The description Catholic Mates gives of itself leans more toward casual dating than serious, faith-based relationships.

Free access allows quite limited access

With a free account, you can create a profile, upload photos, and look for singles in your area. You can also send up to 30 "flirts" to those who might interest you. Catholic Mates claims to expand and add new features all the time, but they do not mention even one feature that they are planning to add.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Paid access lets you contact users

When you have an active, paid membership, you can send and receive messages. And how much will it cost? That's a great question. In the past, we found Catholic Mates charging $29.99 per month. Our more recent research turned up at least one user who got a 5-day trial membership for $5, then month-to-month access for $34.95 or 3 months' access for $54.98. What will you pay? It's anyone's guess.

Antiquated site features

Just looking at the home page of Catholic Mates might bring you back to your 1990s computer class or a B-rated 1990s movie where the computer geek needs to save the girl from impending cyber doom. That and the typos send a pretty bad vibe here.

Catholic in name only?

There's little Catholic focus at this dating service, beyond the name. The site doesn't promote sacramental marriage, include a questionnaire about religious practices, or offer anything with a true Catholic feel.

Catering to seniors?

The photos and brief profiles we've seen at Catholic Mates are mostly singles over 40. The photos of younger people, and only women at that, look like they might be planted, like stock photos. We're not sure about the photos being stock, but they just don't seem consistent with the real-looking photos of those with profiles. And, we didn't see any photos of men.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Unusual "Catholic" browsing features

You can browse Catholic Chicks, Catholic Babes, Catholic Dudes, Catholic Studs, Catholic Hunks, or "Catholic Gay." You can also browse Catholic BBW (Big, Beautiful Women), or Catholic Chubby (men). Really, we didn't make this up. Most of these filters are more commonly found on specialty sites instead (and questionable ones at that).

No user feedback out there

The feedback for this Catholic dating platform, positive or negative, doesn't exist. Catholic Mates isn't rated by the Better Business Bureau, there are no ratings on Trustpilot, and when you search for reviews of Catholic Mates, you'll be lucky if you find one.

We can't rate this any lower

We rate Catholic Mates as low as the feeling we get when perusing this site. The site's design is antiquated, typos run amok, pricing can't be found unless you become a member, and they promote themselves as offering a "special dating service." We're not sure what they mean by that, but it doesn't scream Catholic-dating-then-sacramental-marriage to us. The more we browse this site, the more slimy we feel, and it clearly doesn't measure up as a "Catholic" dating service. Take a peek for laughs, but otherwise avoid Catholic Mates.

On the Catholic Mates website

0.9

POOR

9

Poor

  • Limited free access
  • 5-day trial for $4.95
  • 1 month for $32.99
  • 3 months for $43.98 ($14.66 per month)
  • Option to save 25%
  • Option to join affiliate dating site

POOR

0.9

On the Online Catholic Dating website

OnlineCatholicDating is a website-only dating site, without an option for an app. The home page has no suggestions about how to date in the Catholic world, how to find a partner with your beliefs or practices, and there's no religious questionnaire to help their algorithm find your best Catholic matches. In fact, we found that OnlineCatholicDating seems to be Catholic in name only.

Get started

There's no information about OnlineCatholicDating on their homepage, and the only way you'll find out anything is to complete your profile. Right away, you're encouraged to pay the membership fee, and immediately start typing your message to send out to anyone who matches your profile.

Too little information

There's basically no information on the OnlineCatholicDating homepage, and you can't find tabs or a menu to get any "about us," pricing, success stories, or membership features - and that's a big turn-off.

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Too much pressure

As you create your brief, free profile here, it's "in your face" to quickly pay to join, and if you do, you can receive 25% off of whichever plan you choose. At this point, you still have no information about what free or paid membership entails, or anything about the company, but there's pressure to pay.

Free access doesn't allow much

You can create your profile here and receive some messages when you browse for free, but OnlineCatholicDating keeps sending you "sutble" messages to upgrade.

Quick "sell" to join affiliated partners

Right away, when giving your email and profile statement, you are encouraged to "click here" to also join their affiliated site.

Premium gives you full access

You'll unlock all the premium features when you pay for a membership to OnlineCatholicDating. You can see your matches, see who viewed your profile, browse, change your settings, see who's online, and choose your favorites. You can also get Quick Matches, which is where you see one profile at a time and "like" or "pass" them, one at a time. And how much will that membership cost? You can get a 5-day trial for $4.95, 1 month of access for $32.99, or 3 months for $43.98 ($14.66 per month).

Best Catholic Dating Sites

Who are these people? And where are the Catholics?

The site has "Catholic" in its name, but none of the matches that came up for us with our free profile had anything Catholic mentioned, nor did they ask us about our religious affiliation. The profile messages for two of the people offered to us were, "I love sexy," and "Am good in bed." Thanks, but... One said that Jesus is #1 in his life and his wife is his #2. (Glad you're devoted to your wife, but you're on a dating site.) And a few of the profile messages were challenging to understand and had no punctuation or complete thoughts.

It feels slimy

From start to finish, this Catholic dating site just feels off. There's no introduction to what OnlineCatholicDating is, and you're just "lured" into creating a profile and clicking for the affiliated dating site. After that you get people's "interesting" profile messages: a few religious, some sexy, some incomprehensible, and more.

We'd "swipe left" on OnlineCatholicDating

OnlineCatholicDating's website gives you no information, and there's high pressure to pay for a subscription. Immediately you're offered an affiliate-site membership. Plus, you're presented with all age groups, not just the ones you've requested; the profile messages are cringe-worthy; and there's nothing Catholic about this site except its name. We need a long cleansing shower after doing research on OnlineCatholicDating, and give it our lowest rating.

On the Online Catholic Dating website

Continued from above...

Which Catholic Dating Service is the Best?

Many Catholic singles have turned to online dating sites to find their like-minded spouse. Dating sites are popping up everywhere, changing the way millions of Catholic singles meet. With so many choices, how do you know which Catholic dating site is for you, especially if you're looking for someone with a specific belief system?

Online Catholic dating sites are helpful because they bring people together who share the same faith and values. For Catholics who want God to be a big part of their relationship, these websites make it easier to talk about important topics like church, prayer, and marriage. This can lead to stronger and more meaningful connections because both people are starting from the same spiritual foundation.

Another good thing about these sites is that they make it easier to meet more people. It can be hard to find someone special just through your local church or social group, especially if you live in a small town. Online dating lets you meet Catholics from all over the country or even the world, giving you more chances to find someone who's right for you.

Online dating sites have expanded to include platforms just for Catholics. Whether you're a cradle Catholic, a convert, or someone who attends Mass on the Holy Days of Obligation, there are Catholic dating sites that match you with compatible Catholics.

These sites also often offer helpful tools and advice to support healthy, faith-based relationships. Some have quizzes, conversation starters, or articles that talk about love and marriage from a Catholic point of view. These extras can guide people in building strong, lasting relationships that honor their beliefs and help them grow closer to God and each other.

You have choices. You can choose a general public dating site, then put Catholic in your profile, and filter for Catholic potential matches. Some of these sites can be hit or miss when it comes to matching you with like-minded church members. Or, you can choose a site specifically for Catholic singles, which often include features like articles on dating with Catholic ideals or highlighting saints and feast days.

Whichever way you choose to search, here are points to consider when selecting the right Catholic dating site:

To help you find your Catholic partner or spouse, Top Consumer Reviews has carefully reviewed Catholic dating sites to help you find the best one and avoid the worst. Whether you choose a general site and use filters to find people who share your Catholic beliefs, or work directly with a Catholic site, we're confident you'll meet someone special.

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Catholic Dating Site FAQ

Are Catholic dating websites legitimate?
Absolutely! While new services are popping up every year, some of the most well-known Catholic dating sites have been around for more than 20 years.
Why would I use a Catholic-focused site instead of a general dating service?
For most devout Catholics, it's a must for their partner to share their faith. Although you might find singles who check the "Catholic" box on a general dating website, they may not be as orthodox or active as you're expecting. Catholic dating sites make it easier to find someone with the same beliefs and practices.
How many people use these sites?
Tens of thousands of people create profiles every year. Some sites even have page after page of "success stories": couples who have met through the service and found their "happily ever after."
How much does it cost to use a Catholic dating site?
That depends on the site you select. Most offer subscriptions that range from $9.95 to $29.95/month.
Are there any features I can use for free?
Most dating sites let you create a profile and view possible matches without paying for a membership. But, once you find someone you'd like to contact, you'll probably have to choose a paid plan.
Is it safe to use an online dating website?
Just like any other dating situation, you should be careful as you get to know people. Some Catholic dating services have helpful articles with advice on navigating the process safely.
Is there a satisfaction guarantee?
Sometimes. A site might offer a "match guarantee", extending your membership at no extra cost if you don't find a good fit in the first six months. But, most services let you cancel your plan at any time, so you're not locked into your dating service if you don't like it - you just won't get a refund for the time you've already used it.
Do people really find love on Catholic dating sites?
Is the Pope Catholic? Yes, there are many happy couples that got their start through a Catholic dating site. While YMMV ("your mileage may vary"), these services are worth taking a chance. You could be just a few clicks away from true love!

Compare Any 2 Products

CatholicMatch
Christian Mingle
Ave Maria Singles
EliteSingles
Catholic Chemistry
Catholic People Meet
Catholic Dating Club
Catholic Mates
Online Catholic Dating
vs
CatholicMatch vs Christian MingleCatholicMatch vs Ave Maria SinglesCatholicMatch vs EliteSinglesCatholicMatch vs Catholic ChemistryCatholicMatch vs Catholic People MeetCatholicMatch vs Catholic Dating ClubCatholicMatch vs Catholic MatesCatholicMatch vs Online Catholic DatingChristian Mingle vs Ave Maria SinglesChristian Mingle vs EliteSinglesChristian Mingle vs Catholic ChemistryChristian Mingle vs Catholic People MeetChristian Mingle vs Catholic Dating ClubChristian Mingle vs Catholic MatesChristian Mingle vs Online Catholic DatingAve Maria Singles vs EliteSinglesAve Maria Singles vs Catholic ChemistryAve Maria Singles vs Catholic People MeetAve Maria Singles vs Catholic Dating ClubAve Maria Singles vs Catholic MatesAve Maria Singles vs Online Catholic DatingEliteSingles vs Catholic ChemistryEliteSingles vs Catholic People MeetEliteSingles vs Catholic Dating ClubEliteSingles vs Catholic MatesEliteSingles vs Online Catholic DatingCatholic Chemistry vs Catholic People MeetCatholic Chemistry vs Catholic Dating ClubCatholic Chemistry vs Catholic MatesCatholic Chemistry vs Online Catholic DatingCatholic People Meet vs Catholic Dating ClubCatholic People Meet vs Catholic MatesCatholic People Meet vs Online Catholic DatingCatholic Dating Club vs Catholic MatesCatholic Dating Club vs Online Catholic DatingCatholic Mates vs Online Catholic Dating Online Catholic Dating vs Catholic MatesOnline Catholic Dating vs Catholic Dating ClubOnline Catholic Dating vs Catholic People MeetOnline Catholic Dating vs Catholic ChemistryOnline Catholic Dating vs EliteSinglesOnline Catholic Dating vs Ave Maria SinglesOnline Catholic Dating vs Christian MingleOnline Catholic Dating vs CatholicMatchCatholic Mates vs Catholic Dating ClubCatholic Mates vs Catholic People MeetCatholic Mates vs Catholic ChemistryCatholic Mates vs EliteSinglesCatholic Mates vs Ave Maria SinglesCatholic Mates vs Christian MingleCatholic Mates vs CatholicMatchCatholic Dating Club vs Catholic People MeetCatholic Dating Club vs Catholic ChemistryCatholic Dating Club vs EliteSinglesCatholic Dating Club vs Ave Maria SinglesCatholic Dating Club vs Christian MingleCatholic Dating Club vs CatholicMatchCatholic People Meet vs Catholic ChemistryCatholic People Meet vs EliteSinglesCatholic People Meet vs Ave Maria SinglesCatholic People Meet vs Christian MingleCatholic People Meet vs CatholicMatchCatholic Chemistry vs EliteSinglesCatholic Chemistry vs Ave Maria SinglesCatholic Chemistry vs Christian MingleCatholic Chemistry vs CatholicMatchEliteSingles vs Ave Maria SinglesEliteSingles vs Christian MingleEliteSingles vs CatholicMatchAve Maria Singles vs Christian MingleAve Maria Singles vs CatholicMatchChristian Mingle vs CatholicMatch
See the Best Catholic Dating Sites in Your State

Dating Profiles That Work

Most of us know people who have had great success using a dating website while other friends see little or no dating action. Often the reason between the two stories is simply their profile and what impression it gave off to potential suitors. Writing about yourself doesn't come natural and putting relationship needs and wants into a one page summary takes practice so it's easy for people to make mistakes.

Spend time figuring out what you want in a potential mate and then focus on the following attributes of your profile to improve your chances of attracting the right person.

Tone.  The tone of your profile is one of the biggest aspects of the impression you give off. Do you sound confident and upbeat or lacking self confidence. Do you spend more time explaining what you don't want or more time talking about your interests in a positive light? A negative Nelly or a selfish Sally are big turn offs. A nice balance of what you can bring to the table as well as what you're looking for will attract attention from others.

Username. The username is often the first thing someone sees about your profile and will create an initial first impression. A user name that uses profane language or sexual content is likely to turn off many quality singles. In turn, a boring or meaningless username can also have the same effect. Spend time coming up with a username that favorably depicts you and will grab someone's attention.

Mistakes. Bad grammar and spelling can be a huge turn-off for most. This can give the impression that you're lacking brain power and wouldn't put much effort into a relationship. If the website doesn't offer spell check, cut and paste your writing into a word document and search for errors.

Pictures. A profile with no pictures typically receives very few inquiries if any. Appearance is an important aspect of finding someone you have a chemical response to and people tend to avoid those profiles lacking photos. Be sure to include at least one picture but adding various shots of you from face to full body is ideal.

Honesty. Be honest in what you write in your profile. If you really don't want to date anyone older than you than make sure you indicate an accurate age range, height, body shape, religion or any other aspect of a potential mate you find critical. Also be honest about yourself. Lying about your age, income, kids or anything else will eventually lead to failure.

Ask for Feedback. While it may seem a little awkward, ask a close friend that knows you to give you honest feedback regarding your profile. How does it sound? Does it send the wrong message. What would they change?

Only the Best Reviews

The Catholic Spirit

Catholic influencer’s matchmaking social media posts lead to new ...

Jerome and Jessie Jumawan studied at the same Catholic university and, years later, attended the same wedding of a mutual friend. But it wasn't until they joined a matchmaking post on social media ...

Fri, 06 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Catholic News Agency

Catholic courtship is not a mini-marriage, expert says

Pep Borrell, born in Barcelona, Spain, in 1963, is a dentist by profession, but his passion is to know and spread profound countercultural truths about dating and marriage according to the teachings ...

Mon, 06 Jan 2025

Only the Best Reviews

National Catholic ...

Catholic Singles Please the Lord

Bishop James Conley, auxiliary bishop of the Denver Archdiocese, spoke to the concerns of Catholic singles at the 2012 National Catholic Singles Conference held in the archdiocese recently. He said, ...

Thu, 02 Aug 2012

Only the Best Reviews

Orlando Weekly

15 Best Christian Dating Sites and Apps for Love, Marriage and More

Let’s face it: faith-based dating sites make up a fraction of the online dating industry. And, yeah, it can be challenging finding the right Christian corners to do your thing. Even if you’re ...

Wed, 12 Feb 2025

Only the Best Reviews

National Catholic ...

New Catholic App Hopes to ‘Relight the Hope of Catholic Dating’

When Emily Wilson-Hussem began sharing “matchmaking” posts on Instagram, inviting Catholic singles to share their names and locations to connect with others, she wasn’t expecting that her lighthearted ...

Wed, 08 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Cleveland Scene

Free 10 Catholic Dating Sites for Catholic Singles to Find Spouse

There are many millions of Catholics worldwide and for those looking to find a partner with the same faith, there are thankfully many catholic dating sites. We’ve listed some of the more well-known ...

Tue, 29 Jun 2021

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.