Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Whether you prefer the traditional flavors like plain and strawberry or love to go for more unique combinations like carrot cake and pumpkin, cheesecake is one of the world's most decadent, sought-after desserts.
But, unless you have a great restaurant near you that carries a wide range of flavor options, you might find it hard to get a near-perfect slice of cheesecake. The selection at your local supermarket is probably disappointing at best, and so many places for eating out just don't have what it takes to make it worth it to bring a piece - or a whole dessert - home to share or to give as a gift.
Sunday, October 17th
Amazing Clubs takes the cake (pun intended) when it comes to Cheesecake Clubs. Whether you subscribe to a 3-, 6-, or 12-month plan, you'll get some of the world's most unique flavors at affordable prices - and the most flexible payment and delivery options available anywhere. Amazing Clubs blows away the competition when it comes to customer satisfaction too, backing every shipment with an unparalleled guarantee and friendly customer service reps who'll make it right if anything goes awry. For gift-giving or for your own sweet tooth, this is the best Cheesecake Club on the market.
Eli's is one of Chicago's favorite dessert-makers, and their Cheesecake Club offers some delicious options you won't find with other providers (like a sampler option that gives you several flavors of cheesecake with each delivery). Like some of their competitors, delivery fees aren't included in the price of the membership, so keep that in mind when considering the total cost of each plan.
Cheesecake wants you to have choices when it comes to your Cheesecake Club plan. They offer two different dessert sizes and four different subscription lengths - along with 12 different flavors over the course of a year, so your recipient will never get the same treat twice. Although their gift-giving features aren't as strong as some of their rivals, Cheesecake's competitive pricing and brand reputation make them a provider to consider if you're looking for a high-quality Cheesecake Club.
When it comes to food as a gift-giving option, Harry & David is one of the experts. So, it shouldn't be a surprise that they team up with world-famous restaurant The Cheesecake Factory to deliver mouth-watering sweets on monthly plans ranging from 3 to 12 months. However, this club will cost more than some of the higher-rated retailers in our review, and you may get a flavor or two repeated in the longer Cheesecake Club plans.
David's Cookies has a total of four Cheesecake Club plans - and all of their desserts are certified kosher. This dessert club has prices that are comparable to other stores, and you can expect the same quality you might already be familiar with from their cookies. Gift-giving options aren't as impressive as some of the higher-rated retailers, and you may need to contact the company to get clarification on their delivery policies.
Who wouldn't love a Cheesecake Club with a fun name like Flying Noodle (and a fun story behind it)? If you love all things Italian, you'll enjoy shopping at this online store. Their Cheesecake Clubs have four different delivery options, all priced competitively and with shipping included at no extra charge. But, unlike most similar memberships, this company doesn't tell you what flavors you can expect with each delivery - making it a less-than-ideal choice for recipients with food allergies/sensitivities or for shoppers who prefer to know what they're getting/sending in advance.
J.M. Rosen's offers cheesecakes hand-crafted under the direction of Fernando Casillas for over 30 years. This is the most expensive cheesecake club in our review, with a 3-month plan coming in at $180 plus $30 in monthly shipping fees. While local customers say these cheesecakes are worth every penny, the online store makes it hard to actually subscribe, and the customer service response was nonexistent when we tried to get help. We recommend you choose a cheesecake club from a more responsive - and less spendy - provider.
That's where Cheesecake Clubs come in! Why settle for boring, lumpy desserts when you can have the nation's best cheesecakes delivered right to your doorstep? These subscriptions range from 3-12 months and often include seasonal flavors you may not find at any restaurants or stores near you: blackberry, peppermint and more. Carefully packaged to arrive in flawless condition, these desserts are sure to impress even the pickiest recipients - or to satisfy your own sweet tooth.
Of course, pricing and options vary, so it's important to look for the Cheesecake Club that will best meet your needs. The top providers offer excellent satisfaction guarantees, ensuring that you or your lucky recipient are completely satisfied with each and every delivery - or they'll give you a replacement or refund.
As you consider all of the delicious options out there, here are several criteria to pick the best Cheesecake Club:
TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Cheesecake Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you pick the sweetest, richest treats for your next gift-giving occasion - or for your own delight!
Select any 2 Cheesecake Clubs to compare them head to head