Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Eli's Cheesecake vs Cakes by Jeff the Chef

Friday, June 21st

2024 Cheesecake Club Reviews

Eli's Cheesecake Review 4 Star Rating

Eli's Cheesecake

4 Star Rating
  • $165 for a 3-month club
  • $329 for a 6-month club
  • $639 for a 12-month club
  • Each delivery serves 14-16
  • Shipping costs are not included in the club price
  • Schedule first delivery for the week of your choice
  • 15-day refund/replacement policy

Eli's holds a special place in the hearts of Chicagoans as a beloved dessert-maker, and their Cheesecake Club brings forth a delectable array of flavors you're sure to love too. You'll know exactly which flavors are scheduled each month, no surprises. But, this club is more expensive than many of its rivals, and Eli's no longer offers a sampler that delivers multiple flavors within a single delivery. Eli's Cheesecake Club is definitely worth checking out - just make sure you know exactly what you'll be spending before you sign up.

Cakes by Jeff the Chef Review 1.5 Star Rating

Cakes by Jeff the Chef

1.5 Star Rating
  • Four 4" cheesecakes delivered every month: three flavors of your choice plus one seasonal selection chosen for you
  • Novel flavors
  • $39.97/month + $25 shipping per delivery
  • Extras include a silicone baking mat and a 10" cheesecake in your birthday month

Cakes by Jeff the Chef starts out looking like a great cheesecake club if you like supporting small businesses and trying really unique dessert flavors. It's priced affordably at under $40/month, and you get four different cheesecakes in each delivery. But will those deliveries actually come? Customer feedback says "not very likely" , and we weren't able to reach anyone at this bakery either. You'll want to go with a better-established, more consistent cheesecake club instead.

Which Cheesecake Club is the Best?

Cheesecake, with its wide array of flavors ranging from the classic plain and strawberry to more adventurous combinations like German chocolate and coconut cream, stands as one of the most indulgent, popular desserts worldwide.

Yet, for those who don't have the fortune of living near a top-notch restaurant offering a diverse selection of cheesecakes, obtaining a near-perfect slice can be quite challenging. Local supermarkets often disappoint with their limited choices, and many eateries lack the necessary finesse to make it worthwhile to bring home a delectable piece or even an entire cheesecake as a gift or for sharing.

The Best Cheesecake Clubs Compare Cheesecake Clubs Compare Cheesecake Club Reviews What are the best Cheesecake Clubs Best Cheesecake Club Reviews

Cheesecake Club FAQ

Depending on the club you select, your cheesecakes could come from the world-famous kitchens of your favorite dessert brand or from small bakeries around the nation. No matter where your cheesecakes are made, you can count on them to be delicious month after month!
You choose! While most cheesecake clubs offer monthly shipments, some allow you to spread out the deliveries to every other month or even once every three months.
On average, you can expect the monthly price of a cheesecake club to be around $40. The size of the dessert varies from club to club, ranging from 8 to 16 servings, so keep that in mind as you look at prices from one provider to another.
That also depends on the cheesecake club company you select. Some include the cost of delivery with the membership fee, others tack on shipping charges from $5 to $30 for each shipment.
Yes, most of the time. You might need to send in a photo if your cheesecake was damaged in transit, but most cheesecake clubs prioritize their customers' satisfaction and will make it right if your dessert isn't fresh and in perfect condition.
Most of the time, it's like your mom used to say: "you get what you get (and you don't have a fit)" . Fortunately, you can usually see which cheesecake flavors are scheduled for each month; if there's one that you really dislike (or maybe even are allergic to!), you can often contact the customer service department and ask for that month's delivery to be skipped, adding on a different flavor to the end of your membership term.
Most cheesecake clubs want you to have fun with your treats, so they send out a newsletter with each shipment. From details about your cheesecake's origin to recommendations for pairings with beverages - and maybe even a joke or two! - you'll be able to take your enjoyment of cheesecake to the next level.
Absolutely! Can you imagine how happy it would make YOU to find out you would be getting monthly deliveries of your favorite dessert? Cheesecake clubs are so popular as a gift that most membership plans have easy gift-giving features, like being able to include a personalized message and a fun announcement letting your lucky recipient know that there are tasty things on the horizon.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Fortunately, Cheesecake Clubs have emerged as the solution to this predicament, bringing the finest cheesecakes directly to you. These subscription services typically span a duration of 3 to 12 months and frequently feature seasonal flavors that might be unavailable near you. Imagine relishing the exquisite taste of apple walnut or tropical mango cheesecakes, packaged with care to arrive at your doorstep in perfect condition. These treats will impress even the most discerning palates and satisfy your craving for something sweet.

One of the key attractions of cheesecake clubs is the opportunity to explore a wide variety of flavors and styles. Members can indulge in a diverse selection of flavors, ranging from classic options like New York-style or strawberry cheesecake to more adventurous and unique combinations. This variety ensures that subscribers never get bored and constantly have something new and interesting to look forward to. It also caters to different tastes and preferences, appealing to a wide range of cheesecake lovers.

Furthermore, the convenience of monthly delivery allows for hassle-free gifting options. Many people choose to subscribe to cheesecake clubs as a thoughtful and unique gift for their loved ones. Whether it's for birthdays, anniversaries, or special occasions, sending a monthly cheesecake delivery is a delightful surprise that shows care and consideration. It eliminates the need to search for presents and offers a memorable and delicious treat that can be enjoyed throughout the year.

Naturally, the pricing and options for Cheesecake Clubs vary, so it's crucial to find the one that best suits your needs. The leading providers in this industry go the extra mile by offering exceptional satisfaction guarantees, ensuring that you or your fortunate recipient will be completely content with each and every delivery. In the rare event that something doesn't go quite right, most clubs are prepared to provide replacements or refunds, demonstrating their commitment to delivering excellent customer service.

So, how can you choose the right cheesecake club for you or as a gift for that special occasion? You can use these criteria to help make your decision:

  • Flavor Selection. What can you expect from the cheesecake club? Is it mostly traditional flavors like plain NY cheesecake and strawberry, or do you get to try varieties you've never had before?
  • Satisfaction Guarantee. What will the company do if your cheesecake arrives in poor condition? Or if it tastes bad? Look for a cheesecake club that gives you a no-hassle refund or replacement.
  • Flexibility. Are you locked into a traditional "cheesecakes every month" schedule, or can you opt into an every-other-month plan? Do you have to pay upfront or can you pay as you go? Will you know in advance what you're getting, and can you skip a month if it's something you don't like (or that you're allergic to)?
  • Gift-Giving Options. Is it easy to set the club up as a surprise for a friend or family member? Will you get any extras with the membership, like a fun newsletter? Can you set up the cheesecake club well in advance and then have the gift announcement sent on the date of your choice?

Whether you're looking to surprise a loved one with a delectable cheesecake gift or seeking to indulge in the finest flavors yourself, Cheesecake Clubs offer a convenient and delightful solution. Top Consumer Reviews has done the research to let you know which clubs bring the epitome of cheesecake excellence directly to your doorstep - and which ones might be a disappointment! Get ready to elevate your dessert experience, impress your loved ones, and indulge in the sweetest and most decadent cheesecakes available today.

The Best Reviews of Cheesecake Clubs