Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

J.M. Rosen's Review

Monday, September 27th

2021 Cheesecake Club Reviews

J.M. Rosen's Review 1 Star Rating

J.M. Rosen's

1 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting from $180 for a 3-month subscription
  • $30 overnight delivery fee per shipment

J.M. Rosen's is a cheesecake company with many names. Under the Dessert Cheesecakes URL, the business has been under the management of Fernando Casillas for over a decade. Fun fact: Mr. Casillas was the head baker for the Rosens from 1987 onward, eventually buying the business when the original owners moved on to other business ventures.

Cheesecake club options

If you're looking for a Cheesecake Club, J.M. Rosen's has a couple of options:

  • 3-month subscription: New York, Chocolate Fantasy, Neapolitan
  • 6-month subscription: New York, Chocolate Fantasy, Neapolitan, Snickers/ Mocha/Cappuccino, Original Old Fashioned Chocolate Cake

Pretty expensive

With either plan, you choose the size of cheesecake you want: 6" (8-10 slices) or 9" (16 slices). The smaller 3-month plan costs $180, while the larger cheesecake subscription will be $240. If you're looking for the 6-month subscription, it'll cost you $360 for the 6" desserts and $440 for the 9" cheesecakes. Plus, tack on a $30 delivery fee each month. That's a pretty expensive cheesecake club, especially compared with other services we evaluated.

Best Cheesecake Clubs

Rave reviews

Is it worth it? Looking at customer reviews from people who've had these cheesecakes from a restaurant (especially ones in California that serve J.M. Rosen's desserts), they're definitely a hit. Flavor, texture, and overall impression get rave reviews across-the-board.

Ordering issues

While it looks like J.M. Rosen's does a great job with in-person fulfillment of cheesecake orders, the e-commerce end of the business comes up really short. While we were put off by some of the typos we found on the site ("flate rate shipping"?), the real issues came when we tried to subscribe to their Cheesecake of the Month Club. When we tried to fill out the form for the 3-month cheesecake club, it wouldn't let us submit the form unless we also made a selection for the 6-month club! In other words, the ordering process is broken and you'll have to order a 3-month and 6-month plan to get your order to go through.

Waited over a week for a response

What's worse is that we filled out the contact form to let J.M. Rosen's know about the problem and ask what we needed to do to place the order we actually wanted - and over a week later, during a prime gift-giving season, we received no response.

Website experience leaves us disappointed

No matter where you get your cheesecake club, it's probably going to be an investment - and you want it to be a tasty, consistent experience that is worth the money. Unfortunately, there's nothing about J.M. Rosen's online store that will make you think that it's going to deliver what you're looking for, especially since you may not even be able to get past the online order form. You've got many other options to choose from, and we're pretty sure you'll have a better experience with any of the higher-rated cheesecake clubs in our review.

Where Can You Find the Best Cheesecake Club?

Whether you prefer the traditional flavors like plain and strawberry or love to go for more unique combinations like carrot cake and pumpkin, cheesecake is one of the world's most decadent, sought-after desserts.

But, unless you have a great restaurant near you that carries a wide range of flavor options, you might find it hard to get a near-perfect slice of cheesecake. The selection at your local supermarket is probably disappointing at best, and so many places for eating out just don't have what it takes to make it worth it to bring a piece - or a whole dessert - home to share or to give as a gift.

The Best Cheesecake Clubs Compare Cheesecake Clubs Compare Cheesecake Club Reviews What are the best Cheesecake Clubs Best Cheesecake Club Reviews

Cheesecake Club FAQ

Depending on the club you select, your cheesecakes could come from the world-famous kitchens of your favorite dessert brand or from small bakeries around the nation. No matter where your cheesecakes are made, you can count on them to be delicious month after month!
You choose! While most cheesecake clubs offer monthly shipments, some allow you to spread out the deliveries to every other month or even once every three months.
On average, you can expect the monthly price of a cheesecake club to be around $40. The size of the dessert varies from club to club, ranging from 8 to 16 servings, so keep that in mind as you look at prices from one provider to another.
That also depends on the cheesecake club company you select. Some include the cost of delivery with the membership fee, others tack on shipping charges from $5 to $30 for each shipment.
Yes, most of the time. You might need to send in a photo if your cheesecake was damaged in transit, but most cheesecake clubs prioritize their customers' satisfaction and will make it right if your dessert isn't fresh and in perfect condition.
Most of the time, it's like your mom used to say: "you get what you get (and you don't have a fit)" . Fortunately, you can usually see which cheesecake flavors are scheduled for each month; if there's one that you really dislike (or maybe even are allergic to!), you can often contact the customer service department and ask for that month's delivery to be skipped, adding on a different flavor to the end of your membership term.
Most cheesecake clubs want you to have fun with your treats, so they send out a newsletter with each shipment. From details about your cheesecake's origin to recommendations for pairings with beverages - and maybe even a joke or two! - you'll be able to take your enjoyment of cheesecake to the next level.
Absolutely! Can you imagine how happy it would make YOU to find out you would be getting monthly deliveries of your favorite dessert? Cheesecake clubs are so popular as a gift that most membership plans have easy gift-giving features, like being able to include a personalized message and a fun announcement letting your lucky recipient know that there are tasty things on the horizon.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

That's where Cheesecake Clubs come in! Why settle for boring, lumpy desserts when you can have the nation's best cheesecakes delivered right to your doorstep? These subscriptions range from 3-12 months and often include seasonal flavors you may not find at any restaurants or stores near you: blackberry, peppermint and more. Carefully packaged to arrive in flawless condition, these desserts are sure to impress even the pickiest recipients - or to satisfy your own sweet tooth.

Of course, pricing and options vary, so it's important to look for the Cheesecake Club that will best meet your needs. The top providers offer excellent satisfaction guarantees, ensuring that you or your lucky recipient are completely satisfied with each and every delivery - or they'll give you a replacement or refund.

As you consider all of the delicious options out there, here are several criteria to pick the best Cheesecake Club:

  • Variety. What kinds of flavors will you get in your subscription? You can find plain, strawberry and chocolate chip just about anywhere, so will you get to try flavors that may become a new favorite? Will the plan repeat any of the flavors over the course of the membership?
  • Subscription Length: most clubs offer 3-, 6- and 12-month plans. Can you also get a seasonal plan that comes every 3 months?
  • Delivery Fees. Some Cheesecake Clubs include shipping costs in the fees, while others charge up to a hefty $30 extra per month. Be sure to add up those costs when determining what you'll pay for your subscription.
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about the Cheesecake Club? Is there a solid satisfaction guarantee in place? Can you expect a well-packaged delivery of a fresh-tasting cheesecake every month?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Cheesecake Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you pick the sweetest, richest treats for your next gift-giving occasion - or for your own delight!

The Best Reviews of Cheesecake Clubs