Where is the Best Place to Find Cheesecake?
Imagine this: you're curled up on the couch after a long day, dinner is done, your favorite show is on, and all you can think about is sinking your fork into a slice of rich, creamy cheesecake. Sounds like a dream, right? But where do you get your delectable treat?
While you can run to your local grocery store for a decent cheesecake, if you're looking for that top-tier smooth and creamy experience, you want to go to the experts. Whether you're a die-hard fan of classic New York-style cheesecake or looking for a brand new flavor to try, there are plenty of services online that deliver cheesecakes right to your door.
Thursday, January 16th
2025 Cheesecake Delivery Reviews
New York Cheesecake Company
New York Cheesecake Company is a standout bakery offering award-winning cheesecakes made fresh daily. With 47 different cheesecakes to buy (including gluten-free styles), you can find a range of flavors that beats almost every bakery in our review. With unique creations (and tasty alcohol add-ins), there's something for everyone at New York Cheesecake Company. While external reviews are sparse, the affordable prices, competitive shipping costs, and solid in-house reviews make this our top pick for cheesecake lovers.
Juniors Cheesecake
Juniors Cheesecake, a New York icon since 1950, offers 17 flavors and an authentic taste of NYC. With prices that don't break the bank, a 100% satisfaction guarantee, and rave reviews on Tripadvisor, you'll definitely want to score some cheesecake from Juniors Cheesecake. While the "F” rating from the BBB brought it down from being our top pick, the reviews back up its solid reputation, so Juniors Cheesecake remains a highly competitive service and a must-try for New York cheesecake fans.
Bake Me a Wish!
Bake Me A Wish! is a New York-based bakery that's been shipping treats nationwide since 2005. The bakery offers everything from cakes and cookies to cheesecakes that come in 10 fun flavors. While Bake Me A Wish! receives high praise for flavor and quality on its website, third-party review sites show that shipping can be slow and costly. For this reason, Bake Me A Wish! is a top-notch service overall, though it may not be your first pick if you're an exotic cheesecake fan.
Muddy Paws Cheesecake
Muddy Paws Cheesecake has been serving handmade cheesecakes for over 30 years to its loyal locals in St. Louis Park, MN. While there are 22 flavors to choose from in person, the online shipping experience is a little more limited (and costly). There are only 7 flavors, and shipping makes each cheesecake almost twice the price. But despite the costs, customers rave about quality and customer service, earning Muddy Paws Cheesecake a goodrating with the option to move up in the future.
Carnegie Deli
Carnegie Deli is a legendary New York restaurant offering classic deli meals and traditional New York Cheesecake. With 80+ years in business, it has a solid reputation as a mom-and-pop location right in downtown New York. However, since this isn't a cheesecake-specific bakery, the flavor selection is somewhat limited. But free shipping makes it more competitive than many services in our review.
Eli's Cheesecake
Eli's Cheesecake is a Chicago-based bakery that offers an impressive range of cheesecake flavors including vegan and gluten-free options. Prices are competitive, and the bakery provides plenty of detailed information for those with allergy concerns. While Eli's Cheesecake has solid reviews on Yelp for its texture and flavor, the "C+” rating from the BBB prevents it from ranking higher in our review. But it's still a great choice for fans of Chicago-style cheesecake.
Cheesy Eddie's
Cheesy Eddie's in Rochester, New York has been a delight for local fans of cheesecake since 1976. With 21 different cheesecake flavors to choose from, customers rave about the bakery's rich, flavorful treats. However, while it's a #1 stop for locals, the extremely high cost of shipping makes Cheesy Eddie's less appealing for those ordering online. For this reason, it earns a middle-of-the-road rating from us.
David's Cookies
David's Cookies, founded in 1979, is known for its classic desserts and its New York-style cheesecakes. With reasonable prices for cheesecakes and shipping, the bakery should be a competitive choice. However, despite a 100% satisfaction guarantee, its poor reputation with customers on Trustpilot raises some questions about cheesecake quality and customer service.
Harry & David
Harry and David, a gourmet gift shop that's been around since 1934, offers a wide variety of cheesecake flavors including official flavors from the Cheesecake Factory. Their cheesecakes have a range of prices from affordable to over $100 per cheesecake, but given the concerns from reviewers, you may not want to spend too much at Harry and David. According to Trustpilot, many shoppers have experienced poor customer service and delivery problems, which can make ordering from Harry and David a hassle, especially if you don't like the final treat.
The Swiss Colony
The Swiss Colony is a food gifting company best known for its cheese, sausages, and holiday-themed treats. However, when it comes to cheesecakes, The Swiss Colony falls behind the pack. The selection of flavors is limited, and with widespread complaints about poor quality, shipping delays, and disappointing portion sizes, The Swiss Colony doesn't stand up against the competition, earning it one of the lowest ratings in our review.
Continued from above...
Cheesecake is a baked custard, and its origins trace back to ancient Greece. Modern cheesecake has four main "styles”: New York, which relies on cream cheese for its rich texture, Italian, which uses cottage cheese or ricotta as its base, German cheesecakes which are made with quark (a soft dairy), and French, which is unbaked and served chilled. Most of the sites in our review cover New York cheesecake, which is considered the creamiest and most decadent of the four.
From classic vanilla bean to red velvet, or unique flavors like holiday hot cocoa, there are hundreds of flavors you can try. Whether you're hunting for a specific cheesecake for your holiday get-together or you just want to try new cheesecakes you can't get at your local shops, choosing a bakery that offers delivery services is a great way to expand your cheesecake horizons. These businesses bring gourmet-quality bakes straight to your door so you can enjoy your favorite dessert without the hassle.
Back in the day, if you wanted high-quality baked goods, you'd have to hope that a decent bakery opened in your area. Now, online bake stores make it easier than ever to enjoy cheesecake without needing to drive for hours (or rely on your local Cheesecake Factory location to have an open table). With just a few clicks, you'll have rich, creamy, professionally-made cheesecakes delivered fresh to your door. What could be better than that?
If you're ready to stock your fridge with cheesecake but aren't sure where to start, we've got you covered. Here are some factors that can help you pick the best cheesecake service:
- Cost. Cheesecake is a world-class treat, and you'll want to get your money's worth. See if the service you're shopping with offers bundles or deals to get as much cheesecake as you need without breaking the bank. Make sure you take into account things like shipping to make sure you're getting a good deal for the cheesecake you order.
- Variety. There are so many cheesecake flavors to try, and you don't want to miss out. Make sure you pick a cheesecake bakery with plenty of styles and flavors, so when you want to try something new, you can stay with a baker you already trust.
- Dietary restrictions. If you're on a special diet, don't worry. Plenty of cheesecake services offer gluten-free, keto, or sugar-free options. There are even a few vegan desserts depending on where you buy. Make sure your chosen bakery offers the right type of cheesecake for you.
- Reputation. Check your preferred cheesecake bakery and delivery service with trusted third-party review sites like Trustpilot or the Better Business Bureau. Other cheesecake lovers can help you decide if a site is worth your time and money or if you want to stay away from high prices and low-quality treats.
There's no better time to dive into the world of delicious cheesecakes than right now. To help you satisfy your sweet tooth, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top cheesecake services out there today. From classic flavors to creative new twists, you're sure to discover your next creamy favorite. Bon appetit!
Cheesecake Delivery FAQ
Compare Cheesecake Delivery
Select any 2 Cheesecake Delivery to compare them head to head
Trending Cheesecake Delivery News
Related Cheesecake Delivery Reviews
Since you're interested in Cheesecake Delivery, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
