Cheesecake Delivery Reviews

Who's better?

Muddy Paws Cheesecake vs Carnegie Deli

We've analyzed the best Cheesecake Delivery to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Cheesecake Delivery Reviews

Here you can see how Muddy Paws Cheesecake and Carnegie Deli match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Cheesecake Delivery in 2026.

Winner

Muddy Paws Cheesecake

  • Prices from $95.95 to $105 per cheesecake
  • 7 cheesecake flavors for nationwide shipping
  • Free shipping included

Muddy Paws Cheesecake is a charming Minnesota bakery that brings a homemade touch to its cheesecake. While the bakery has a massive menu for locals, its nationwide shipping only offers 7 of the claimed 200+ flavors (and we only saw around 40 during our research). One of the best perks is that the price you see already includes free two-day shipping, so there are no hidden surprises at checkout. However, with fewer reviews on the cheesecake delivery part of the service, it doesn't rank quite as high as more established shipping options, but we'll definitely give Muddy Paws Cheesecake the chance to move up in the future.

Carnegie Deli

  • Prices from $99.95 to $130 per cheesecake
  • 4 flavors to choose from
  • Heirloom and family recipes

Carnegie Deli is a historic New York deli that offers a small selection of traditional, family-recipe cheesecakes for its cheesecake delivery service. However, costs are significantly higher than competitors once shipping fees are added to the base price. Although in-person reviews rave about the authentic flavor, the absence of recent feedback regarding their delivery service makes this a more cautious choice for long-distance cheesecake delivery. But if you're in NYC, you'll definitely want to stop in.

Picture this: you've finally sunk into the couch after a long day; dinner's done, your favorite show is on, and all you can think about is sliding a fork into a slice of rich, creamy cheesecake. It sounds like a dream, doesn't it? The craving hits fast - and hard - and your sweet tooth isn't taking no for an answer. So where are you getting that decadent treat - the corner bakery, a delivery app, or a surprise slice hiding in the freezer?

You can grab a decent cheesecake at the grocery store, but if you're after that top-tier, smooth and creamy bite, you'll want the specialists. Whether you crave a classic New York slice or feel like exploring something new, specialty bakeries - many with nationwide shipping - deliver straight to your door. Most ship in insulated packaging with dry ice so the texture stays pristine, and many offer seasonal flavors and gift-ready boxes for birthdays and holidays.

Long before it became a diner staple, cheesecake started in ancient Greece as a baked custard. Today you'll find four main styles: New York - dense and rich from cream cheese -; Italian, built on ricotta or cottage cheese; German, made with quark (a soft dairy); and French, which skips the bake and is served chilled. That range of bases is what gives each style its distinct texture and personality. Most of the sites in our review zero in on New York cheesecake, widely considered the creamiest and most indulgent of the lot.

From timeless vanilla bean and red velvet to playful picks like holiday hot cocoa, the flavor options seem endless. If you're searching for a specific cheesecake for your holiday get-together - or you just want to try varieties you can't get at local shops - pick a bakery that delivers. Many also offer sampler boxes, so you can taste a lineup of slices before committing to a whole cake. These businesses ship gourmet-quality bakes straight to your door, letting you enjoy your favorite dessert without the hassle.

Not long ago, getting great baked goods meant crossing your fingers for a decent bakery in town. Today, online bake shops put bakery-quality cheesecake just a few clicks away - no long drives, no waiting for a table at the local Cheesecake Factory. Place an order and you'll get rich, creamy, professionally made cheesecakes shipped fresh to your doorstep. You can even schedule a delivery for birthdays, holidays, or a treat-yourself Friday. It's convenience, quality, and indulgence in one box, delivered right when you want it.

To make sure you satisfy your sweet tooth with the best possible cheesecake delivery service, we've put together a few tips to consider as you narrow down the tastiest options:

So, if you can't kick that cheesecake craving, don't worry - we've got your back. Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top cheesecake delivery services out there, so you don't have to run to the grocery store: you can get top-notch cheesecakes sent right to your door. Now you can relax and enjoy a sweet treat (or a surprise cheesecake every month). Save a piece for us!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Cheesecake Delivery FAQ

How does ordering cheesecake online work?
Online cheesecake shops and bakeries make it easy to order tasty treats and have them delivered right to your door - or someone else's, if you're feeling generous. It works like any other shopping spree (just tastier!), and in as little as two days, you'll have cheesecake on your doorstep. Ordering cheesecake online is a great way to satisfy your cravings or spice up a special occasion.
How does the cheesecake stay fresh during shipping?
Most bakeries use insulated packaging and fast shipping (which can get expensive). This keeps the cheesecake chilled during transit. Some bakeries will flash-freeze your cheesecake before shipping it to make extra sure it doesn't go bad if you live in a warmer climate.
Can I customize the cheesecake flavors or toppings?
Definitely! While this depends on the site you buy from, most bakeries allow you to choose extra add-ons or toppings for your cheesecake. Some sites have pre-made designs, but others have drizzles, crumbles, and different crusts you can change out. A few bakeries even offer a "design your own cheesecake" option.
Are there options for dietary restrictions?
Yes! Many cheesecake services offer gluten-free, sugar-free, or keto-friendly cheesecakes. Just check your favorite cheesecake bakery's website to see what accommodations they have. Not all bakeries are the same, so it's always best to dive into the ingredients.
What if you want to send cheesecake as a gift?
Go right ahead! Most bakery sites make gifting easy with options to include a personalized message or extras to make your cheesecake gift special. Some sites are even designed for gifting or offer clubs that you can use to send multiple cheesecakes per year to a loved one's door.
How long does it take to get my cheesecake?
Delivery times may vary from bakery to bakery. Some allow you to schedule your shipping date, so you know exactly when it will arrive. Standard shipping for most bakeries is 2-5 days. However, the shipping is generally expedited to make sure your treats don't spoil in the mail. This can make it extra costly, though.
Is it expensive to order cheesecake online?
The final cost of your cheesecake will depend on the size, flavor, and where you buy from. In general, most cheesecakes cost between $30-$100. Shipping is generally where the price goes up, so keep an eye out for bakeries that offer lower-cost shipping to keep your cheesecake treat within budget.
Will you need to thaw the cheesecake before eating it?
Most cheesecakes arrive frozen or semi-frozen, so you'll want to thaw them in the fridge for a few hours before serving. If you get multiple, you can put the ones you don't want directly in the freezer to keep for months if you need to. The packaging usually includes clear instructions for the best thawing results.

Compare Any 2 Products

The New York Cheesecake Company
Cheesy Eddie's
Muddy Paws Cheesecake
Eli's Cheesecake
Junior's Cheesecake
Carnegie Deli
Bake Me a Wish
David's Cookies
Harry & David
vs
The New York Cheesecake Company vs Cheesy Eddie'sThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Eli's CheesecakeThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Junior's CheesecakeThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Carnegie DeliThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Bake Me a WishThe New York Cheesecake Company vs David's CookiesThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Harry & DavidCheesy Eddie's vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeCheesy Eddie's vs Eli's CheesecakeCheesy Eddie's vs Junior's CheesecakeCheesy Eddie's vs Carnegie DeliCheesy Eddie's vs Bake Me a WishCheesy Eddie's vs David's CookiesCheesy Eddie's vs Harry & DavidMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Eli's CheesecakeMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Junior's CheesecakeMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Carnegie DeliMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Bake Me a WishMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs David's CookiesMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Harry & DavidEli's Cheesecake vs Junior's CheesecakeEli's Cheesecake vs Carnegie DeliEli's Cheesecake vs Bake Me a WishEli's Cheesecake vs David's CookiesEli's Cheesecake vs Harry & DavidJunior's Cheesecake vs Carnegie DeliJunior's Cheesecake vs Bake Me a WishJunior's Cheesecake vs David's CookiesJunior's Cheesecake vs Harry & DavidCarnegie Deli vs Bake Me a WishCarnegie Deli vs David's CookiesCarnegie Deli vs Harry & DavidBake Me a Wish vs David's CookiesBake Me a Wish vs Harry & DavidDavid's Cookies vs Harry & David Harry & David vs David's CookiesHarry & David vs Bake Me a WishHarry & David vs Carnegie DeliHarry & David vs Junior's CheesecakeHarry & David vs Eli's CheesecakeHarry & David vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeHarry & David vs Cheesy Eddie'sHarry & David vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyDavid's Cookies vs Bake Me a WishDavid's Cookies vs Carnegie DeliDavid's Cookies vs Junior's CheesecakeDavid's Cookies vs Eli's CheesecakeDavid's Cookies vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeDavid's Cookies vs Cheesy Eddie'sDavid's Cookies vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyBake Me a Wish vs Carnegie DeliBake Me a Wish vs Junior's CheesecakeBake Me a Wish vs Eli's CheesecakeBake Me a Wish vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeBake Me a Wish vs Cheesy Eddie'sBake Me a Wish vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyCarnegie Deli vs Junior's CheesecakeCarnegie Deli vs Eli's CheesecakeCarnegie Deli vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeCarnegie Deli vs Cheesy Eddie'sCarnegie Deli vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyJunior's Cheesecake vs Eli's CheesecakeJunior's Cheesecake vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeJunior's Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie'sJunior's Cheesecake vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyEli's Cheesecake vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeEli's Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie'sEli's Cheesecake vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie'sMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyCheesy Eddie's vs The New York Cheesecake Company
See the Best Cheesecake Delivery in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Insider on MSN

How The Cheesecake Factory turned a family recipe into a global ...

Before The Cheesecake Factory had a 250-item menu, it was a family bakery. David Overton opened the first restaurant in 1978 to sell his mom's cheesecakes.

Tue, 12 May 2026

Only the Best Reviews

London Evening ...

Best cheesecakes in London to order for delivery online

The Standard's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Calling all Londoners: stop what you’re doing, grab a plate and ...

Mon, 30 Jan 2023

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo News Australia

Best cheesecakes in London to order for delivery online

Calling all Londoners: stop what you’re doing, grab a plate and a fork as you’re about to taste some of the best cheesecakes the capital has to offer. The perfect pudding, a cheesecake can be ...

Thu, 18 Aug 2022

Only the Best Reviews

Cambridge News

Cambridge's delicious cheesecake emporium is now delivering straight ...

This new sweet treat delivery service may just be the perfect answer to combating your lockdown blues. After almost eight weeks in lockdown it's fair to say that people across not only the county, but ...

Fri, 15 May 2020

Only the Best Reviews

CBS News

Cheesecake Factory Promises Free Cheesecake Delivered For Free

(CBS Local) — The Cheesecake Factory is celebrating its 40th anniversary in a delicious way. On Wednesday, Dec. 5, the restaurant will be giving away 40,000 free slices of cheesecake. They have ...

Tue, 04 Dec 2018

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo Finance

Harry & David Now Delivering the Cheesecake Factory(R) Cheesecakes ...

MEDFORD, OR--(Marketwired - Nov 12, 2013) - Harry & David, America's iconic gourmet gifting curator, announces its agreement with The Cheesecake Factory Bakery Inc. to be the exclusive online seller ...

Tue, 12 Nov 2013

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.