Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Wednesday, February 12th
Bake Me A Wish! got its start in 2005 to fill the gap in New York: there weren't any bakeries that shipped out of state. Bake Me A Wish! started out as a cake shop, but now offers a variety of bakery treats like cookies, brownies, cupcakes, pies, and cheesecakes. Bake Me A Wish!'s future goal is to become the go-to source for customers who want high-quality bakery gifts. This sweet shop is also highly popular with TV spots and articles from major outlets like Oprah Daily, The Sun, Windy City Times, Forbes, and more.
Easy to find the cheesecake
Browsing Bake Me A Wish! is a simple process, with all the major treats you could want listed across the top navigation window. You just need to click on "cheesecakes” at the top to start browsing. The cheesecakes are all pictured in a scrolling window, and the individual treat listings include names, reviews from individuals for each cheesecake, and the price. When you click through to a particular cheesecake, you'll see a brief description, including allergy information for those with dietary restrictions. You can choose a delivery date and a gifting occasion. You can also choose upgrades like adding a teddy bear, birthday candles, or cookies to your order before you check out.
Choose from 10 flavors
There are 10 flavors of cheesecake to choose from at Bake Me A Wish!. You'll find flavor staples like New York Cheesecake (plain) and Chocolate Chip Cheesecake as well as unique selections like Vesuvius Cake, Mango Cheesecake, and some seasonal favorites like Pumpkin or Eggnog. All of these are New York-style. While we expect these cheesecakes will change out as seasonal selections, the total number of flavors is smaller than some competitors.
Pricing from $52 to $58 for one cheesecake
The prices for cheesecakes at Bake Me A Wish! are all around the same cost. The least expensive options start at $52 and the highest cost is $58. For example, the Peanut Butter Cup is $52 for a full-size cheesecake and the Vesuvius Cake is the only cheesecake at $58. However, shipping is somewhat costly, and you don't get to choose your shipping date. For our area, shipping costs $22.99, but this may update depending on where you're located. Shipping is only visible when you complete the checkout details. This means the final cost may be closer to $74.99 to $80.99 for one cheesecake.
Delivery guarantee with some options for refunds
Bake Me A Wish! promises to offer quality gift delivery and has an "On Time Guarantee”. All of the cheesecakes are shipped through UPS, and if your delivery is not completed on time, you will be refunded the cost of shipping. Bake Me A Wish! also offers recourse in case your chosen treat isn't satisfactory. The policy states you may be able to receive a full or partial refund, store credit, or overnight re-delivery depending on the issue.
Extremely slow shipping on most orders
Bake Me A Wish! holds an "A-” rating from the Better Business Bureau, and it has impressive reviews from customers on its website. Testimonials for most of the cheesecakes average 5 stars. On third-party review sites, the feedback is a little more balanced. Trustpilot shows that Bake Me A Wish! holds a 3.4-star average. In general, customers claim that the quick delivery policy doesn't hold true. Even reviews with 5-star ratings claim that the shipping from Bake Me A Wish! was extremely slow. There are many complaints too that cakes and treats have been "lost” in the mail or there is zero communication about delivery times. While foodies love the flavors in general, the shipping frustrations seem to disagree with Bake Me A Wish!'s standing delivery guarantee.
Good for treats in general, but needs more cheesecake
While the flavors look great and this is a fun site to gift treats to yourself or loved ones, it has a few drawbacks. If you're not too worried about when you'll get your cheesecake, you might be happy, but with limited flavors, this isn't going to be your top pick for exotic cheesecakes. Overall, Bake Me A Wish! earns a solid rating for its bake quality and one-stop-shop treat offerings, but it doesn't score as high as our favorite cheesecake services due to more limited flavors and the shipping concerns.
Imagine this: you're curled up on the couch after a long day, dinner is done, your favorite show is on, and all you can think about is sinking your fork into a slice of rich, creamy cheesecake. Sounds like a dream, right? But where do you get your delectable treat?
While you can run to your local grocery store for a decent cheesecake, if you're looking for that top-tier smooth and creamy experience, you want to go to the experts. Whether you're a die-hard fan of classic New York-style cheesecake or looking for a brand new flavor to try, there are plenty of services online that deliver cheesecakes right to your door.
Cheesecake is a baked custard, and its origins trace back to ancient Greece. Modern cheesecake has four main "styles”: New York, which relies on cream cheese for its rich texture, Italian, which uses cottage cheese or ricotta as its base, German cheesecakes which are made with quark (a soft dairy), and French, which is unbaked and served chilled. Most of the sites in our review cover New York cheesecake, which is considered the creamiest and most decadent of the four.
From classic vanilla bean to red velvet, or unique flavors like holiday hot cocoa, there are hundreds of flavors you can try. Whether you're hunting for a specific cheesecake for your holiday get-together or you just want to try new cheesecakes you can't get at your local shops, choosing a bakery that offers delivery services is a great way to expand your cheesecake horizons. These businesses bring gourmet-quality bakes straight to your door so you can enjoy your favorite dessert without the hassle.
Back in the day, if you wanted high-quality baked goods, you'd have to hope that a decent bakery opened in your area. Now, online bake stores make it easier than ever to enjoy cheesecake without needing to drive for hours (or rely on your local Cheesecake Factory location to have an open table). With just a few clicks, you'll have rich, creamy, professionally-made cheesecakes delivered fresh to your door. What could be better than that?
If you're ready to stock your fridge with cheesecake but aren't sure where to start, we've got you covered. Here are some factors that can help you pick the best cheesecake service:
There's no better time to dive into the world of delicious cheesecakes than right now. To help you satisfy your sweet tooth, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top cheesecake services out there today. From classic flavors to creative new twists, you're sure to discover your next creamy favorite. Bon appetit!
Select any 2 Cheesecake Delivery to compare them head to head